Last updated: 12 November 2026
Short answer: You can say true things, honest opinions on matters of public interest, and fair reports of court proceedings on social media. You take a real legal risk when you attach a damaging factual claim to a named or easily identifiable person without being able to back it up. Defamation is both a crime under section 356 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), which replaced IPC sections 499 and 500 from 1 July 2024, and a civil wrong for which the person can sue for damages. A forward, a repost or a comment can count as publication in the same way as an original post.
Learn your everyday legal rights step by step. Everyday Law for Every Indian: Know Your Rights is a self-paced certificate course on everyday legal rights. Price: Rs 349.
What the law means by defamation
Section 356(1) BNS covers anyone who, by words spoken or intended to be read, by signs or by visible representations, makes or publishes an imputation about a person intending to harm that person’s reputation, or knowing or having reason to believe that it will. The explanations to the section add that an imputation is only harmful to reputation if it lowers the person in the eyes of others, for example by attacking his character, credit, standing in his calling or caste, or by suggesting a loathsome condition. Imputations against a company, an association or a group can also qualify.
Four practical points follow:
- A third person must see it. A message sent privately only to the person it is about is not publication. A post, a story, a comment, a review or a WhatsApp group message is.
- The person must be identifiable. You need not use the name. A photograph, a nickname everyone knows, or details that point to one person are enough.
- It must be an imputation, not just rudeness. Abuse and insults may attract other laws but are not always defamation. A false claim that someone is a thief, a cheat or a molester is the classic case.
- Intent or knowledge matters for the crime. The prosecution must show you meant to harm the reputation or had reason to believe you would. In a civil suit, courts look mainly at whether the statement was false and damaging and whether you have a defence.
Legal, grey and risky: a quick guide to posts
| Kind of post | Usual position | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Your own honest experience, stated factually, with proof (for example a billing dispute with a shop, with the receipt) | Generally safe | Truth stated in good faith for a legitimate purpose is protected, and it stays factual |
| Fair criticism of a public servant’s conduct in public duties, or of a public question | Generally safe if in good faith | Exceptions 2 and 3 to section 356 protect good faith opinion on these |
| A review of a book, film, speech or performance | Generally safe if in good faith | Exception 6 protects honest opinion on a performance placed before the public |
| A substantially true report of what happened in court | Generally safe | Exception 4 protects substantially true court reports |
| A true but private fact about a person, posted to shame him | Grey | Truth alone is not enough. The exception for truth applies only if publication is for the public good |
| A forwarded video or message accusing a named person of a crime, which you have not checked | Risky | You may be treated as publishing it, and you must be able to show good faith |
| Calling a named person a fraud, thief or abuser without proof | Risky | This is the core of the offence |
The table is a guide, not a guarantee. Courts look at the exact words and the context, and good faith means real care and attention, not a casual belief.
The statutory exceptions, in plain words
Section 356 lists ten exceptions where an imputation is not defamation. In short, they cover: (1) a true statement made for the public good; (2) good faith opinion on a public servant’s conduct in his public functions; (3) good faith opinion on any person’s conduct on a public question; (4) a substantially true report of court proceedings; (5) good faith opinion on a decided case or on the conduct of the people in it; (6) good faith opinion on a performance submitted to the public; (7) good faith censure by a person with lawful authority over another, such as an employer or parent; (8) a good faith accusation made to a person with lawful authority over the accused; (9) good faith imputation made to protect your own interest or another’s, or the public good; and (10) a good faith caution to a person for his own or others’ good. The words “good faith” run through most of them. Exceptions 8 and 9 fit a complaint to the right authority better than a post to the whole internet.
What happens if someone takes action
| Criminal route | Civil route | |
|---|---|---|
| Law | Section 356 BNS | Law of torts; suit for damages and an injunction |
| Punishment or relief | Simple imprisonment up to two years, or fine, or both, or community service | Compensation, and orders to take down the post or stop repeating it |
| Who starts it | The injured person files a complaint before a Magistrate. The offence is classed as non-cognizable and bailable, so police do not ordinarily arrest or investigate without a Magistrate’s order | The injured person files a suit in the civil court |
| Time limit | Three years from the offence under section 514 BNSS, since the maximum punishment is two years. A court may take cognizance later only if the delay is explained | Generally one year under the Limitation Act, 1963 for libel or slander, so check the date of publication |
| Notable procedure | Under the proviso to section 223(1) BNSS the Magistrate must give the accused a chance to be heard before taking cognizance of a complaint | The court can grant interim orders, so a quick takedown is possible |
In Subramanian Swamy v. Union of India (2016), the Supreme Court upheld the constitutional validity of criminal defamation. In September 2025, while issuing notice in a defamation case brought against a news portal, Justice M.M. Sundresh orally remarked that the time had come to decriminalise defamation. That was a remark during a hearing, not a ruling, and section 356 remains in force.
Also remember that section 66A of the Information Technology Act, 2000, which punished “offensive” messages, was struck down by the Supreme Court in Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015). Police may still use other provisions if the facts fit.
Three illustrations
Illustration 1: the shop review
Meera buys a mixer that stops working in a week. The shop refuses a refund. She posts: “Bought on 3 March, bill number attached, stopped working on 10 March, shop refused refund despite three visits.” Every line is true and provable, so the risk is low. Had she added “the owner is a fraud”, she would have added an unprovable accusation.
Illustration 2: the housing society group
Ravi forwards a message in the society group saying that a named tenant was arrested for theft. He did not check it. The arrest never happened. Ravi did not write the message, but he published it to the group. Deleting it and apologising quickly helps, but it does not erase the risk.
Illustration 3: the political comment
Sana posts that a local officer awarded a road contract to a relative, citing the tender documents she obtained and a news report. She says the decision “looks wrong to me” and asks for an inquiry. Opinion on a public servant’s conduct, based on facts she can show and offered in good faith, falls within the protected area. If the documents were fabricated or she knew the claim was untrue, the protection would be lost.
Group admins, shares and comments
In Kishor Tarone v. State of Maharashtra (2021), the Nagpur Bench of the Bombay High Court held that a WhatsApp group administrator is not vicariously liable for objectionable content posted by a member, because he cannot moderate or censor messages before they are posted. That is one High Court’s view and it does not protect an admin who posts or endorses the content himself. A comment endorsing the accusation can also be treated as publication.
If someone defames you: steps
- Preserve evidence. Take screenshots showing the full post, the username, the date and the URL. Note who saw it. If you will rely on these in court, a certificate for electronic records is needed under section 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023.
- Report the content to the platform’s grievance channel. For serious online harassment you can also report on cybercrime.gov.in.
- Send a written demand asking for deletion and an apology within a stated time. A notice is not a legal requirement, but it shows reasonableness and can end the matter.
- Decide the route. A criminal complaint before the Magistrate, a civil suit for damages and an injunction, or both. Keep the time limits above in mind.
- Consider settlement. The offence is compoundable, so a public clarification can end it.
If you receive a notice or summons
- Take your own copy of the post before deleting anything, and ask a lawyer whether to remove it.
- Do not reply with fresh accusations. A heated reply can create a second defamation.
- Gather your proof of truth or good faith: documents, messages, the news report you relied on.
- Attend the date given in a summons.
Common mistakes and myths
- “It is true, so I am safe.” Truth helps, but the first exception also needs public good, and you must be able to prove it.
- “I only forwarded it.” Forwarding is publishing. Check before you share.
- “I did not name him.” If people can tell who it is, that is enough.
- “Deleting ends the matter.” Deletion may reduce damages but screenshots remain.
What not to do
- Do not post accusations about a crime that you have not verified.
- Do not threaten to expose someone unless he pays. That can amount to extortion or criminal intimidation, which are separate offences.
- Do not ignore a legal notice.
Frequently asked questions
Is truth a complete defence to defamation in India?
Not automatically. The first exception to section 356 protects an imputation of truth only if making or publishing it is for the public good, and that is a question of fact for the court.
Can I be arrested straight away for a defamatory post?
Defamation under section 356 is classed as non-cognizable and bailable, so the police ordinarily need a Magistrate’s order to investigate. Other offences, if they are also alleged, can change the position.
Can I write a negative review of a doctor, shop or service?
Yes, if it is honest, factual, based on your own experience and not exaggerated. Stick to what happened and keep the proof. Avoid labelling the person with crimes or character insults.
Is a WhatsApp group admin responsible for what members post?
The Bombay High Court (Nagpur Bench) held in 2021 that an admin is not vicariously liable merely for being admin. This is not a rule from the Supreme Court, and an admin who posts or encourages the content may be treated differently.
How long do I have to file a case for defamation?
For a criminal complaint, three years from the offence under section 514 BNSS. For a civil suit for compensation, generally one year from publication. Dates can be argued in online cases, so act early.
Learn your everyday legal rights step by step. Everyday Law for Every Indian: Know Your Rights is a self-paced certificate course on everyday legal rights. Price: Rs 349.
This article is general information, not legal advice for any specific case. Laws, limits, fees and procedures can change and some depend on your state, so check the current position before you act. Lexfolio is a learning resource.