LLexfolio

Tag: drafting

  • How to Draft an Arbitration Clause That Works in India

    Last updated: 22 November 2026

    An arbitration clause is usually two or three lines at the end of a contract, and it is often copied from the last agreement without a second look. That habit is expensive. A badly drafted clause can lead to months of argument over whether arbitration applies, who the arbitrator is, or which court supervises it, all before the real dispute is even heard.

    This guide shows how to build a clause that works under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, piece by piece, with sample wording, the mistakes courts keep seeing, and a checklist you can use before you sign.

    What the law needs from an arbitration agreement

    Course: Arbitration and Mediation, Rs. 399. A self-paced certificate course with 6 modules, 18 lessons, quizzes and a final test, and a certificate on passing. View the course

    Section 7 of the Act defines an arbitration agreement as an agreement to submit to arbitration all or certain disputes that have arisen or may arise in respect of a defined legal relationship, contractual or not. It must be in writing. Writing can mean a signed document, an exchange of letters, emails or other telecommunication that provides a record of the agreement, or an exchange of statements of claim and defence where one side alleges an agreement and the other does not deny it. A clause in a contract can also arise by reference, if the contract incorporates another document containing it and the reference makes that clause part of the contract.

    Courts look for a clear intention to refer disputes to arbitration and to be bound by the result. Wording that only says the parties will try to resolve matters amicably, or that a dispute “can be referred” to arbitration if they later both agree, has been treated as an agreement to agree rather than an arbitration agreement. That is the first lesson of drafting: use words that commit.

    Part 1: the commitment and the scope

    Start with a firm promise and a wide net.

    Sample: “All disputes, differences or claims arising out of or in connection with this Agreement, including any question about its existence, validity, interpretation, performance, breach or termination, shall be finally resolved by arbitration in accordance with the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.”

    • Use “shall”, not “may”. “May” invites an argument that arbitration is optional.
    • Use “arising out of or in connection with”. A narrow clause covering only “disputes about payment” can split one fight between a tribunal and a court.
    • Say “finally resolved”. This signals a binding award, not a recommendation.

    Remember separability under section 16(1): the arbitration clause is treated as independent of the rest of the contract, so a claim that the main contract is void does not by itself kill the clause. Drafting the scope to include validity questions makes this protection explicit.

    Part 2: the seat, the venue and the governing law

    These three are different things, and mixing them up is a classic source of litigation.

    TermMeaningWhy it matters
    SeatThe legal home of the arbitrationDecides which courts supervise it, hear section 9 applications and section 34 challenges
    VenueWhere hearings take placePractical convenience; can differ from the seat
    Governing lawLaw that governs the contractDecides rights and obligations on the merits

    The Supreme Court has dealt with seat and venue repeatedly, including in BALCO v Kaiser Aluminium (2012) and BGS SGS Soma JV v NHPC (2019), where it held that naming a place as the venue, together with other indications, can make it the seat. The safe approach is to say it plainly: “The seat of arbitration shall be Lucknow. Hearings may be held at Lucknow or virtually.” Choose a seat that is convenient and whose courts you trust, and do not leave the point to inference.

    Part 3: the arbitrators and how they are appointed

    Decide the number first. The number must not be even, and if the agreement is silent the default is a sole arbitrator under section 10. For most commercial disputes below very high values, a sole arbitrator keeps cost and delay down. Three suit large or technical disputes.

    Then state the appointment route. A workable pattern for a sole arbitrator: “The parties shall jointly appoint a sole arbitrator within 30 days of a written notice invoking arbitration. Failing agreement, either party may apply under section 11 of the Act.” For three arbitrators: each side names one and the two choose the presiding arbitrator.

    A warning here. Clauses letting one party alone choose the sole arbitrator, or hand its own employee or a panel of its own choosing to the other side, have been struck down. In Perkins Eastman Architects v HSCC (2019) the Supreme Court held that a person who is ineligible under section 12(5) and the Seventh Schedule cannot appoint an arbitrator either. Later decisions have kept the focus on equal treatment in appointment. For a business signing a standard-form contract, this means you should look closely at any clause that gives the other party control over the tribunal, and negotiate it, because that kind of clause invites a challenge that wastes time.

    Part 4: language, rules and institution

    • Language: fix English or Hindi so no one argues about translation.
    • Ad hoc or institutional: ad hoc means you run it with the arbitrator; institutional means a body administers it under published rules and a fee schedule. If you name an institution, confirm it exists and is active, and copy its model clause exactly. Pathological clauses naming dead or wrong bodies are a known source of trouble.
    • Timeline and fees: you can build in the fast track under section 29B or agree the arbitrator’s fee basis. Section 29A sets a general 12-month period for the award after pleadings are complete, and the Fourth Schedule offers a model fee scale as a reference point.

    Part 5: tiers, with realistic time limits

    A step clause moves from negotiation to mediation to arbitration. It works only if each step has a clock.

    Sample: “The parties shall first attempt to resolve the dispute by senior management discussion within 15 days of a written dispute notice. Failing that, the dispute shall be referred to mediation under the Mediation Act, 2023 or an agreed mediation centre, to be concluded within 45 days. Failing that, either party may commence arbitration.”

    Without time limits, one side can stall at the first step and say arbitration cannot start. Courts have also differed on whether skipping a pre-arbitral step defeats a reference, so write the tier clearly and say what happens on expiry. Add that interim relief from a court or tribunal under sections 9 and 17 is not blocked by the tiers, so urgent protection is always available.

    A complete sample clause

    “Any dispute arising out of or in connection with this Agreement, including any question about its validity, shall first be referred to good faith negotiation between senior representatives for 15 days from written notice, and if unresolved, to mediation for a further 30 days. If still unresolved, it shall be finally settled by arbitration under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 by a sole arbitrator appointed jointly by the parties, or failing agreement within 30 days, appointed under section 11. The seat of arbitration is Lucknow and the language is English. This Agreement is governed by Indian law. Nothing here stops either party from seeking interim relief from a competent court or the tribunal.”

    Adapt every blank to your deal. Do not copy it blindly, and have a lawyer review any high-value contract.

    Common mistakes to avoid

    1. Contradictory clauses. A jurisdiction clause giving a named court exclusive power over “all disputes” next to an arbitration clause creates a clash. Say that the jurisdiction clause applies only for supervisory and interim matters at the seat.
    2. No seat. It sends the first fight to court.
    3. Optional language. “Parties may refer” is not a commitment.
    4. Naming a non-existent institution.
    5. Even number of arbitrators.
    6. Forgetting stamping. An unstamped agreement does not make the arbitration clause void, as a seven-judge bench held in 2023, but it must be stamped before it can be acted on, so keep your originals in order.
    7. Silence on costs. Say that the tribunal may allocate costs under section 31A.

    Pre-signing checklist

    • Is the commitment firm and in writing?
    • Is the scope wide enough to catch a realistic dispute?
    • Are seat, venue, language and governing law each named?
    • Is the number of arbitrators odd, and is appointment fair to both sides?
    • Do tiers have time limits and an exit?
    • Does anything else in the contract contradict it?

    The course Certificate Course in Arbitration and Mediation: Resolving Disputes Outside Court includes a lesson on reading and shaping these clauses with worked examples. This guide is general legal information, not advice for a specific contract.

    Frequently asked questions

    Does an arbitration clause have to be a separate agreement?

    No. It can be a clause inside the main contract. Under the separability principle in section 16, it is treated as an independent agreement even when it sits inside the contract.

    Can an email exchange create an arbitration agreement?

    Section 7(4) allows an agreement to be in writing through emails or other communication that provides a record of the agreement. A signed clause is still far safer than relying on a trail of messages.

    What happens if my clause names no arbitrator?

    If the parties cannot agree, a party can apply under section 11 to the High Court, the Supreme Court or an institution designated by them, to appoint one. A sole arbitrator is the default number when the clause is silent.

    Should the seat be where I live?

    Often yes, because the seat’s courts handle interim applications and challenges, and a nearby seat lowers cost. But a neutral seat may be a fair compromise in a negotiation, so weigh convenience against fairness.

    Is a tiered clause safe?

    It is useful if each step has a clear time limit and an exit to the next step. Vague tiers with no deadlines can be used to stall. Keep them short and specific.

    Can I use one clause for several related contracts?

    You can, but make sure each contract either contains the clause or clearly incorporates it by reference, otherwise a related agreement may fall outside it.

    Course: Arbitration and Mediation, Rs. 399. A self-paced certificate course with 6 modules, 18 lessons, quizzes and a final test, and a certificate on passing. View the course

    This article is general information, not legal advice. Lexfolio is not affiliated with any government body, exam board or institution. For your own situation, consult a qualified advocate.