LLexfolio

Tag: queer couples

  • Supriyo Chakraborty Same-Sex Marriage Judgment Explained

    Last updated: 22 November 2026

    On 17 October 2023, the Supreme Court delivered its judgment in Supriyo @ Supriya Chakraborty v. Union of India, the marriage equality case. Many people remember it only as “the Court said no”. The reality is more layered: five judges, four separate opinions, some points of unanimity, and a set of statements that still shape rights for queer couples. This guide explains what was asked, what was decided, and what remains open.

    What the petitioners asked for

    A group of same-sex couples and others asked the Court to declare that the Special Marriage Act, 1954 must allow marriage between two persons regardless of sex, or that the Act’s language be read to include same-sex couples. Their argument was that being unable to marry denies equality and dignity, and blocks a long list of benefits tied to marital status, from joint bank accounts to inheritance and medical decisions.

    Course: LGBTQ+ Legal Rights in India, Rs. 299. A self-paced certificate course with 6 modules, 18 lessons, quizzes and a final test, and a certificate on passing. View the course

    The Union government opposed the petitions. Its position, in summary, was that marriage is a matter for Parliament, and that courts should not create a new institution.

    The Bench and the result

    The Constitution Bench was made up of Chief Justice D. Y. Chandrachud and Justices Sanjay Kishan Kaul, S. Ravindra Bhat, Hima Kohli and P. S. Narasimha. The Court delivered four opinions: the Chief Justice, Justice Kaul, Justice Bhat (for himself and Justice Kohli) and Justice Narasimha.

    Where all five judges agreed

    • There is no fundamental right to marry under the Constitution.
    • The Special Marriage Act cannot be read to include same-sex couples, and the Court would not strike it down or rewrite it.
    • The decision to create a legal framework for same-sex unions lies with Parliament and State legislatures.
    • Queer persons have the right to choose a partner and to be free from coercion and violence.

    Where the Bench divided

    The major split was about whether queer couples should have some form of legal union recognition and about adoption.

    IssueChief Justice (with Kaul on some points)Majority (Bhat, Kohli, Narasimha)
    Right to a unionRecognised a right to enter into unions as part of autonomy, dignity and association. Said it was for the legislature to give the framework.Did not accept a constitutional right to a union.
    Adoption by queer couplesRead down the rule that requires a “stable marital relationship” so unmarried and queer couples could adopt jointly.Upheld the adoption regulation as it stood. Said the wider legal framework around adoption assumes marriage, and reform is for policy makers.
    Directions to the StateGave detailed directions to police and governments.Accepted some directions but not all.

    On adoption, the result was a 3 to 2 outcome against recognising a right of queer couples to adopt jointly. Coverage of the judgment consistently reports this as the majority position, with the Chief Justice and Justice Kaul in the minority on that point.

    What the Court said or recorded that still matters

    • The Solicitor General’s statement. The Union told the Court that a committee headed by the Cabinet Secretary would examine problems faced by queer couples, such as treatment as a “family” or “spouse” for benefits. The judgment records and relies on that assurance. Reports in 2024 indicated that the Union later constituted the committee. Check current news for any outcome.
    • Protection from police and family interference. The Court said queer couples should not be harassed for living together and that the State must protect them from violence. It also said that people should not be forced into medical procedures or “conversion” attempts based on their orientation.
    • Transgender persons in heterosexual relationships can marry. A transgender man marrying a woman, or a transgender woman marrying a man, can marry under existing law, including the Special Marriage Act and personal laws, as the law treats them as persons of the respective gender.
    • Queer persons are not an “elite” or “urban” group. The Chief Justice’s opinion rejected the Union’s suggestion that queerness is an urban or elite idea, noting that queer persons exist across caste, class and region.

    Review petitions

    Petitioners asked the Court to reconsider the decision. On 9 January 2025, the Supreme Court dismissed the review petitions, saying there was no error apparent on the face of the record. The October 2023 judgment therefore stands as it was delivered.

    What this means for couples today

    There is no legal marriage for same-sex couples in India at present, and no civil union. But couples are not without options. Many of the practical consequences of marriage can be approached through other documents and rules.

    • Wills and nominations. A person can leave property to a partner by a registered or properly attested will and can nominate a partner in insurance, provident funds, bank accounts and mutual funds, subject to the rules of each scheme.
    • Joint bank accounts. In August 2024, the Department of Financial Services issued an advisory saying there is no restriction on queer persons opening joint accounts or nominating a partner. Individual banks may still ask questions, so carry a copy of the advisory when you apply.
    • Powers of attorney and advance directives. These let you name a partner to handle finances or medical decisions if you cannot. The next guide in this series covers healthcare and housing in more detail.
    • Cohabitation. Adults can live together. Where a family or others try to separate a couple by force, remedies like habeas corpus petitions and police protection requests exist.

    The open questions

    • Will Parliament or State legislatures legislate on civil unions or marriage?
    • Will the Cabinet Secretary committee’s work lead to concrete changes in laws on benefits, adoption or succession?
    • Will challenges to the adoption regulation be taken up again in a different form?

    None of these has a definitive answer yet. The Certificate Course in LGBTQ+ Legal Rights in India on Lexfolio (Rs. 299) has a full module on marriage, the Supriyo judgment and protection from family coercion, with plain language summaries.

    This guide is general information, not legal advice.

    Frequently asked questions

    Is same-sex marriage legal in India?

    No. The Supreme Court held in 2023 that there is no fundamental right to marry and left the question to the legislature. There is no marriage or civil union available to same-sex couples at present.

    Did the Court say anything in favour of queer couples?

    Yes. All judges accepted that queer persons can choose a partner and must be protected from coercion and violence, and the Court recorded the Union’s assurance about a committee to examine benefits and rights.

    Can same-sex couples adopt a child together?

    The majority upheld the existing adoption regulation, so joint adoption by unmarried or queer couples is not recognised. A single person may adopt under the rules, subject to conditions.

    Can a transgender person marry?

    The Court said transgender persons in heterosexual relationships can marry under existing laws, so a transgender woman can marry a man and a transgender man can marry a woman.

    Was the judgment reviewed?

    Review petitions were dismissed in January 2025, so the original judgment remains the law.

    Where can I read the judgment?

    It is available on the Supreme Court of India website as Supriyo @ Supriya Chakraborty v. Union of India, 2023 INSC 920.

    Course: LGBTQ+ Legal Rights in India, Rs. 299. A self-paced certificate course with 6 modules, 18 lessons, quizzes and a final test, and a certificate on passing. View the course

    More guides on this topic

    This article is general information, not legal advice. Lexfolio is not affiliated with any government body, exam board or institution. For your own situation, consult a qualified advocate.