LLexfolio

Tag: transgender rights

  • 10 Myths About LGBTQ+ Rights in India, Answered

    Last updated: 22 November 2026

    Few areas of law attract as many half-truths as LGBTQ+ rights. Some myths say that everything is legal now, others say that nothing is. This guide goes through ten common claims and gives a short, sourced answer to each, based on what Indian courts and statutes actually say.

    Myth 1: “Homosexuality is still a crime in India”

    Reality. Since the Supreme Court’s decision in Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India on 6 September 2018, consensual sexual conduct between adults, including same-sex conduct, is not a crime. Section 377 was kept only for non-consensual acts, acts with minors and bestiality, and the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita that replaced the Indian Penal Code in July 2024 is reported to contain no matching provision at all.

    Course: LGBTQ+ Legal Rights in India, Rs. 299. A self-paced certificate course with 6 modules, 18 lessons, quizzes and a final test, and a certificate on passing. View the course

    Myth 2: “Same-sex marriage is legal now”

    Reality. It is not. In Supriyo v. Union of India (17 October 2023) the Supreme Court held there is no fundamental right to marry and left the matter to the legislature. Review petitions were dismissed in January 2025. Couples can live together and use wills, nominations and other documents, but they cannot register a marriage or civil union.

    Myth 3: “Navtej legalised same-sex marriage, adoption and inheritance”

    Reality. Navtej was about criminal law. It removed the offence but did not create civil rights such as marriage, adoption or succession. Those questions were taken up in Supriyo, and the answers there were mostly no, with some important protective statements.

    Myth 4: “Transgender persons need surgery to be legally recognised”

    Reality. The 2014 NALSA judgment held that gender identity is for the person to decide and that surgery cannot be a precondition. The 2019 Act spoke of a self-perceived gender identity and its definition expressly covered trans men and women whether or not they had surgery. The 2026 amendment, passed by Parliament in March 2026 and under challenge in the Supreme Court, is reported to introduce medical board screening and to narrow the definition. Whether and how it operates depends on its notification and on the Court. Check the current position before applying for a certificate.

    Myth 5: “The Transgender Persons Act protects all LGBTQ+ people”

    Reality. The Act is about gender identity. It does not cover lesbian, gay or bisexual people as such, and the 2026 amendment, according to the PRS summary of the Bill, expressly excludes persons whose difference is only one of sexual orientation or self-perceived sexual identity. Protection for sexual orientation rests mostly on the Constitution as interpreted in Navtej.

    Myth 6: “A same-sex couple can adopt a child jointly”

    Reality. In Supriyo, the minority view was that unmarried and queer couples should be allowed to adopt jointly, but the majority upheld the existing adoption regulation. A single adult may adopt under the rules, but joint adoption by a same-sex couple is not recognised at present.

    Myth 7: “Employers cannot discriminate against LGBTQ+ people, full stop”

    Reality. The picture is mixed. Government employers are bound by Articles 14, 15 and 16. The 2019 Act covers transgender persons in establishments. But India has no general statute banning private-sector discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation. Many companies have their own inclusion policies, which employees can invoke, and courts treat constitutional values as a guide.

    Myth 8: “Conversion therapy is an accepted treatment”

    Reality. Courts and medical authorities have moved away from it. The Supreme Court recorded in Supriyo that individuals should not be forced into medical procedures or conversion efforts over their orientation, and some High Court orders, including from the Madras High Court in 2021, have directed authorities to act against such practices. It is not a recognised cure, because orientation is not an illness.

    Myth 9: “Same-sex partners are legal strangers to each other in every way”

    Reality. They lack the automatic status that marriage provides, but they are not without tools.

    • A will can leave property to a partner.
    • Nomination is possible in bank accounts, insurance, provident funds and similar assets, subject to scheme rules.
    • The Department of Financial Services issued an advisory in August 2024 stating there is no restriction on queer persons opening joint bank accounts or nominating a partner.
    • Powers of attorney and advance directives can name a partner to act for you.

    What a partner does not get automatically is the status of “spouse” or “next of kin”, which matters for hospital decisions, family pensions and intestate succession.

    Myth 10: “If police harass you, there is nothing you can do”

    Reality. A consensual relationship is not a crime, so a threat to arrest on that basis has no legal footing. You can ask for the police officer’s name and the section invoked, make a written complaint to a senior officer, approach the State Human Rights Commission, or file a writ in the High Court. Courts have also protected consenting adult couples from harassment by relatives and police in cases where families tried to separate them.

    A few more things worth knowing

    • “Queer” is not just an urban idea. The Supreme Court in Supriyo specifically rejected the suggestion that queerness is urban or elite.
    • Courts decide cases, not trends. A High Court order may protect a couple in one State and not bind another. Supreme Court judgments bind all courts, but they only decide what was argued.
    • Law changes. The 2026 transgender amendment, the Cabinet Secretary committee announced in the Supriyo case, and court challenges are all still developing.

    If you want a structured guide to the judgments behind these answers, the Certificate Course in LGBTQ+ Legal Rights in India on Lexfolio (Rs. 299) walks through the Constitution, NALSA, Navtej, Puttaswamy and Supriyo in plain language.

    This guide is general information, not legal advice.

    Frequently asked questions

    Is being LGBTQ+ legal in India?

    Yes. Being LGBTQ+ is not an offence, and consensual same-sex conduct between adults has been lawful since 2018. Legal recognition of marriage is a separate question that remains open.

    Can two men or two women live together in India?

    Yes. Adults have the right to choose a partner and live together. The Supreme Court said in 2023 that queer couples must not be harassed for cohabiting.

    Do I have to prove my gender identity to a doctor to be recognised?

    Under the 2019 Act and NALSA, recognition does not depend on surgery. The 2026 amendment is reported to add a medical board step, so check the current rules.

    Can my family force me into marriage or treatment?

    No. Forcing an adult into marriage or medical treatment against their will can be challenged, and courts have granted protection to adults in such cases.

    Where can I read about all this in one place?

    Primary sources are the judgments on the Supreme Court website, the statutes on India Code, and bill summaries on PRS Legislative Research.

    Course: LGBTQ+ Legal Rights in India, Rs. 299. A self-paced certificate course with 6 modules, 18 lessons, quizzes and a final test, and a certificate on passing. View the course

    More guides on this topic

    This article is general information, not legal advice. Lexfolio is not affiliated with any government body, exam board or institution. For your own situation, consult a qualified advocate.