LLexfolio

Investor Rights in Real Situations: 7 Illustrations from Unauthorised Trades to Ponzi Schemes

Last updated: 12 November 2026

Short answer: Investor problems usually fall into a few patterns: a trade you did not make, money stuck after an IPO, dividends that never arrived, advice from a stranger online, an account holder who dies, a scheme that promises fixed high returns, and a broker that collapses. For each, the right first step differs. The six illustrations below are invented for teaching and do not describe real people or cases.

Learn the rules behind these situations. Legal Rights of Investors (Rs 349) is a self-paced certificate course on investor rights in India, for anyone who invests or advises people who do.

Illustration 1: A trade you never placed

Situation (illustration). Meera opens her broker app on a Monday and sees a sale of 300 shares she did not order, executed the previous Thursday. Her phone shows no order confirmation message.

Position. A trade you did not authorise is a grievance against a regulated entity, the broker. SEBI’s SCORES platform accepts complaints within one year of the cause of action, so the clock started on Thursday, not Monday. Whether the broker is at fault depends on its order logs, login records and her own conduct, such as sharing a password.

What to do. Screenshot the order book and the contract note, write to the broker’s compliance contact the same day asking for the order log and a reversal, and keep a copy. If the reply is unsatisfactory or never comes, file on SCORES or on the exchanges’ Smart ODR portal, but not both for the same complaint. Change the account password and enable two factor login.

Illustration 2: IPO money still blocked after the shares were listed

Situation (illustration). Arjun applied for an IPO through his bank’s UPI based application. The shares were not allotted, but several days after listing the amount is still blocked in his account.

Position. SEBI made the T+3 listing timeline mandatory for public issues from 1 December 2023, where T is the closure date of the issue, and a news report from that date says money of bidders is unblocked in about half the earlier time. A block that continues well after listing is therefore worth raising in writing.

What to do. Note the application number, the issue closing date and the date of listing. Write to the bank that blocked the funds, quoting these details, and also to the registrar to the issue. If neither unblocks the amount in a reasonable time, a SCORES complaint against the intermediary concerned is the next step. Keep screenshots of the block entry in your bank app.

Illustration 3: Dividends from a company you forgot about

Situation (illustration). Suman finds her late father’s share certificates for a company that has paid dividends for years. No dividend has reached the family for a long time.

Position. Shares and dividends that remain unclaimed for seven consecutive years are transferred by the company to the Investor Education and Protection Fund Authority. They are not extinguished: the investor or the legal heirs can claim them under section 124 of the Companies Act, 2013 and the IEPF Authority Rules, 2016.

What to do. Check the company’s investor page for its list of unclaimed shares and dividends. If the family’s name is there, fill the web form IEPF-5, take the acknowledgement number, print the form, and send it with the original indemnity bond and supporting papers to the company’s nodal officer for IEPF, marked as a claim for refund. For heirs, the papers will include proof of succession, and a 2025 report says that for claims up to Rs 5 lakh the requirement of a succession certificate has been relaxed. Confirm the present rule in the instruction kit on the IEPFA portal.

Illustration 4: Paid stock tips from a group on a messaging app

Situation (illustration). Karan pays Rs 15,000 to join a group whose admin sends “sure shot” calls and shows screenshots of profits. After three losing weeks, the admin stops replying.

Position. Persons giving investment advice generally need SEBI registration, with limited exemptions where the advice is incidental to another regulated activity. Registered advisers must display their registration details, and SEBI publishes a list of registered advisers. Regulated entities such as brokers are also restricted from associating with unregistered people who give securities advice or make return claims, according to reports on SEBI’s 2024 amendments. A promise of assured profit is a warning sign in any case.

What to do. Save the payment record, the group messages and the admin’s contact details. Search for the name in SEBI’s list of registered advisers to see whether registration exists. Report the matter to the police or the cyber crime authorities if you believe you were cheated, and consider whether you can complain to SEBI about the unregistered activity. Do not pay a second fee for “recovery” of the first.

Illustration 5: A demat account holder dies without a nominee

Situation (illustration). Rohit’s father held shares worth several lakh in a demat account and mutual fund folios. He never filled in a nomination.

Position. Nomination makes transmission simpler, because the nominee can approach the depository participant or fund house directly with the death certificate and forms. SEBI’s revised norms effective 1 March 2025 allow up to 10 nominees per account or folio, with a percentage share assigned to each, and let existing holders revise nominations or opt out through a secure online process. A nominee is the person to whom the holdings are transmitted for the time being; entitlement of heirs under the applicable succession law is a separate question.

What to do. Without a nominee, the heirs will need to follow the legal heir route of each institution, which usually asks for documents such as a succession certificate, a will with probate where applicable, or an indemnity. For your own accounts, add nominees now, review the shares assigned, and keep the login details and a list of holdings where your family can find them.

Illustration 6: A neighbourhood scheme promising monthly returns

Situation (illustration). Farida’s relatives deposit Rs 2 lakh each with a local firm that promises 4 per cent a month and gives handwritten receipts. After eight months the firm closes its office.

Position. The Banning of Unregulated Deposit Schemes Act, 2019 prohibits unregulated deposit schemes, meaning schemes not registered with the regulators who license deposit taking. A summary prepared by PRS Legislative Research states that running such a scheme is punishable with 2 to 7 years of imprisonment and a fine, that a Competent Authority can provisionally attach the property of the deposit taker, and that a Designated Court can finalise the list of depositors and order the sale of property and distribution of proceeds.

What to do. Gather receipts, bank transfer records, advertisements and the names of the promoters. File a police complaint without delay, and ask that the case be reported to the Competent Authority under the Act. Joint action by depositors tends to be easier to manage than scattered complaints, but each person should still keep their own papers.

Illustration 7: The broker becomes a defaulter

Situation (illustration). A small broker stops paying out funds and the exchange declares it a defaulter. Neha has Rs 4 lakh of credit balance in her trading account.

Position. Stock exchanges maintain Investor Protection Funds to compensate eligible clients of a trading member declared a defaulter or expelled. The ceiling is set by each exchange. A report from August 2024 says the NSE raised its ceiling from Rs 25 lakh to Rs 35 lakh per investor per claim. The fund does not cover market losses.

What to do. Read the defaulter section of the exchange’s website, file the claim in the prescribed form within the period announced for that defaulter, and attach the ledger, bank statements and contract notes. Keep proof of submission.

What these cases have in common

  • Dates matter: one year for SCORES, seven years before dividends move to the IEPF, and the listing day for IPO refunds.
  • Writing beats talking. A dated email is evidence; a phone call is not.
  • The first forum depends on who regulates the entity. SEBI does not handle every investment product.
  • Compensation funds and regulators do not insure against market risk.

Go beyond the examples. Legal Rights of Investors (Rs 349) is a self-paced certificate course on investor rights and remedies in India, with a certificate on completion.

Frequently asked questions

Are these illustrations real cases?

No. The names and facts are invented to show how the rules work. Real cases depend on their own documents and dates.

Which authority do I approach for a mutual fund complaint?

Start with the fund house and its registrar in writing. SCORES can be used for SEBI-regulated entities if the response is unsatisfactory and you are within the one year limit.

Can I recover money paid for stock tips?

It depends on the facts. If you were cheated, a police complaint is the usual route, and a civil claim may also be possible. Registration status of the adviser and your payment records will matter.

Does nomination decide who owns the shares after death?

Not by itself. A nominee receives the holdings for the time being, and the claim of legal heirs under the applicable succession law is a separate matter.

How do I know whether a deposit scheme is regulated?

Ask which regulator has licensed or registered it and ask for the registration details. Check with that regulator before depositing money.

This article is general information, not legal or financial advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource. Laws, rates and procedures change, so check the current rule or consult a qualified professional before you act.

Useful books for this topic

As an Amazon Associate, Lexfolio earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are shown on Amazon.

Free CLAT PG 2027 sample: exam guide + 2 judgment passages

Get our 16 page CLAT PG starter free: the 2027 pattern, how to read judgment passages fast, the 25 key Supreme Court judgments of 2026, and two practice passages with 10 explained questions. Plus new free guides and law updates by email. Unsubscribe any time.

Learn this properly, with a certificate. Police and FIRs, consumer and bank fraud complaints, property, wills and inheritance, work rights, family law, cyber fraud and RTI, in plain English. Certificate Course in Everyday Law for Every Indian, ₹349: self-paced lessons, module quizzes and a final test; pass at 60% for a verifiable Lexfolio certificate.

See all Lexfolio certificate courses

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *