LLexfolio

Co-Founder Quits, Investor Offers Money: 6 Startup Legal Scenarios in India

Last updated: 12 November 2026

Short answer: the legal problems that hurt young companies are rarely exotic. A co-founder leaves, an investor offers money on a few lines of email, an overseas friend wants to invest, a hire is promised options, a designer claims the logo, and a deadline passes unnoticed. Below are six illustrations, each invented to show how the law applies, with the position and a practical next step. They are not real cases and the names are made up.

Learn the whole path. This is a self-paced certificate course on startup legal basics, from incorporation to funding, aimed at founders who want to handle these situations before they become disputes. The course is Startup Legal Basics: From Incorporation to Funding, priced at Rs 499.

How to read these illustrations. Each one is a made up situation. Facts matter in law, so a small change in the facts (a written clause, a date, a signature) can change the result. Use them to spot the issue, not to predict your own outcome.

Illustration 1: A co-founder leaves after six months

Illustration. Meera and Arjun incorporate a software company with 50 per cent each. There is no founders’ agreement. Six months later Arjun takes a job elsewhere and stops working on the product, but he is still a 50 per cent shareholder and a director.

Position. Shares allotted to Arjun are his property. Without vesting terms or a leaver clause, the company has no automatic right to take them back, and he can still vote and block decisions that need a special resolution. Meera cannot simply remove him from the register of members. The company can buy back shares only through a process set out in the Companies Act, with conditions, and any transfer to Meera needs a proper instrument of transfer, stamp duty and compliance with the articles.

What to do. Negotiate a written exit: Arjun sells all or part of his shares to Meera at an agreed price, resigns as director, and signs an assignment of any code or designs he wrote. Check the articles for pre emption rules and board approval for transfers. The lesson for the next company: vesting and leaver terms signed on day one.

Illustration 2: An angel investor offers Rs 50 lakh on an email

Illustration. An investor emails a founder: “I will put in Rs 50 lakh for 10 per cent. Share your account number.” The money arrives. Nothing else is signed.

Position. Money received without an agreed instrument is a legal grey area: is it a loan, an advance against shares, or a gift? A private company can issue shares by private placement under section 42 of the Companies Act, 2013, but only to persons it has identified before the offer, with an offer letter addressed to each, payment through banking channels, and allotment within 60 days of receiving the money. If allotment is not made in that window, the money must be repaid, with interest if the delay continues. The shareholding of 10 per cent exists only once shares are allotted and recorded.

What to do. Convert the email into a subscription agreement and, if the investor wants rights such as board seat, information or anti dilution, a shareholders’ agreement. Hold a board meeting, pass the required resolutions, allot the shares on time and file the return of allotment. Share valuation is also a tax question, so ask your accountant.

Illustration 3: A friend in the United States wants to invest

Illustration. Kabir, a software engineer in California, offers to put in Rs 30 lakh in a friend’s Pune startup, asking to be repaid if the startup does not work out.

Position. Because Kabir is a non-resident, the inflow is governed by the Foreign Exchange Management (Non-debt Instruments) Rules, 2019. A private company that is a recognised startup can issue a convertible note: an instrument that acknowledges money received initially as debt and that can be repaid or converted into equity within the period the rules allow (stated as not exceeding ten years). The rules set a minimum of Rs 25 lakh in a single tranche for a non-resident buyer, and the issue has to be reported to the Reserve Bank through its portal, generally within 30 days. An informal loan arrangement outside these rules can create a foreign exchange compliance problem for both sides. Also remember the resident director requirement under section 149(3).

What to do. Decide whether Kabir wants equity or a note, document it under the foreign investment framework, send the money through a bank, collect the bank’s inward remittance advice, and have the filing made on time. Confirm with an authorised dealer bank which forms apply.

Illustration 4: A new hire is “promised options”

Illustration. A startup’s offer letter to a senior engineer says she will get “0.5 per cent ESOPs”. There is no plan, no grant letter and no vesting schedule.

Position. Options are issued under a scheme approved by the company’s members, within section 62(1)(b) of the Companies Act, 2013 and Rule 12 of the Companies (Share Capital and Debentures) Rules, 2014. Rule 12 requires a minimum one year between grant and vesting. A sentence in an offer letter is not a scheme. If the company never creates one, the engineer holds an unclear promise, and a dispute over what “0.5 per cent” meant (of which share count, diluted or not) is likely. Each allotment when options are exercised is filed on Form PAS-3 within 30 days.

What to do. Adopt a plan with a member resolution, issue a grant letter stating the number of options, exercise price, vesting schedule and leaver rules, and tell the employee that tax arises at exercise and sale and that she should take advice.

Illustration 5: The freelance designer claims the logo

Illustration. A company pays a freelance designer Rs 15,000 for a logo. A year later, after the brand becomes popular, the designer asks for a licence fee, saying the logo was never transferred.

Position. Under the Copyright Act, 1957, the author is generally the first owner of the work, except in situations the Act lists, such as work made in the course of employment under a contract of service. A freelancer is not an employee. A transfer of copyright must be in writing and signed (section 19(1)), and must state the rights, duration and territory (section 19(2)). If the duration is missing, the law presumes five years, and if the territory is missing, India (section 19(5) and 19(6)). The company may therefore find that even a paid for logo is only partly its own.

What to do. Ask the designer for a signed assignment with the full term and worldwide territory, and a waiver or acknowledgment about the design files. Apply for a trademark in the company’s name. For future work, use a written services agreement that includes an IP clause before work starts.

Illustration 6: The company is incorporated but the declaration is never filed

Illustration. A founder incorporates a company in January, signs customer contracts in March, but never files the declaration of commencement of business after the shareholders pay in their capital.

Position. The Companies Act requires a declaration that every subscriber has paid for the shares agreed, to be filed within 180 days of incorporation. Until it is filed, the company cannot commence business or exercise borrowing powers, and if the Registrar has reason to believe the company is not carrying on business, the Registrar can start the process of removing its name from the register. The founder faces penalties and, more practically, a company that may be struck off while holding customer contracts.

What to do. Make sure the subscribers’ money is in the bank, file INC-20A at once with any late fee, and diarise the other deadlines: office verification (30 days), the first auditor (30 days from registration, section 139(6)) and annual filings.

The pattern behind the six illustrations

  • Write it down and sign it: equity, IP, services, investment.
  • Fix the instrument before the money moves, not after.
  • Know the clock: 30, 60 and 180 day periods run whether or not you noticed them.
  • Check who is on the other side of the table: a resident, a non-resident, an employee or a freelancer, because the rules differ.

Prepare before it happens. The Lexfolio course on startup legal basics covers incorporation to funding as a self-paced certificate course. The course is Startup Legal Basics: From Incorporation to Funding, priced at Rs 499.

Frequently asked questions

Can a co-founder be removed from the company without his consent?

Not automatically. A director can be removed by an ordinary resolution of members under the Companies Act, but shares cannot be taken back without a contractual right or a buyback. Vesting and leaver clauses give that right.

Is a convertible note better than a share allotment for early funding?

Neither is better in every case. A note postpones valuation, while shares fix it. For non-resident investors, the foreign exchange rules set conditions for notes. Ask a professional to model both.

Does the company own the code written by an employee?

Generally yes, when the work is made in the course of employment under a contract of service, unless the parties agreed otherwise. Contractors and freelancers need a written assignment.

Are ESOPs taxed when granted?

Tax arises at later stages such as exercise and sale. The rules differ for DPIIT recognised startups on timing of tax on exercise, so check the provision applicable to the year in question.

What if an investor wants their money back after sending it?

If shares have not been allotted within 60 days of receiving the application money, a private placement requires the money to be repaid. If the arrangement is a loan, the loan terms apply. A written agreement avoids this uncertainty.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice for a specific case. The illustrations are invented and facts change outcomes, so consult a qualified professional before acting. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

Useful books for this topic

As an Amazon Associate, Lexfolio earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are shown on Amazon.

Free CLAT PG 2027 sample: exam guide + 2 judgment passages

Get our 16 page CLAT PG starter free: the 2027 pattern, how to read judgment passages fast, the 25 key Supreme Court judgments of 2026, and two practice passages with 10 explained questions. Plus new free guides and law updates by email. Unsubscribe any time.

Learn this properly, with a certificate. Police and FIRs, consumer and bank fraud complaints, property, wills and inheritance, work rights, family law, cyber fraud and RTI, in plain English. Certificate Course in Everyday Law for Every Indian, ₹349: self-paced lessons, module quizzes and a final test; pass at 60% for a verifiable Lexfolio certificate.

See all Lexfolio certificate courses

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *