LLexfolio

Tag: corporate governance

  • Private Limited Company Compliance in India: 9 Common Mistakes and Myths

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: most compliance trouble in private companies does not come from fraud. It comes from a handful of wrong beliefs: that a quiet company has no duties, that directors who do not manage the business carry no risk, and that board paperwork can be done after the event. Each belief below is followed by the correct position under the Companies Act, 2013.

    These nine points apply mainly to private limited companies. Listed companies carry additional duties under SEBI regulations that are not covered here.

    Want to understand governance end to end? The Lexfolio Corporate Governance, Compliance and Risk Management is a self-paced certificate course on corporate governance, compliance and risk management. Price: Rs 599.

    Myth 1: A company with no business needs no filings

    This is the most expensive myth in practice. The Act requires every company to prepare financial statements and to file them with the Registrar of Companies, together with an annual return, whether or not it traded. Section 164(2) then disqualifies a person who is or was a director of a company that has not filed financial statements or annual returns for any continuous period of three financial years. The disqualification runs for five years and also bars the person from being appointed as a director of other companies in that period.

    Separately, the Registrar has power under section 248 to strike off a company that has not carried on business or operations for two immediately preceding financial years and has not applied for dormant status. If a company is truly inactive, the cleaner routes are dormant status or a voluntary strike off, not silence.

    Myth 2: One board meeting a year is enough

    Section 173 requires a first board meeting within 30 days of incorporation and, after that, at least four meetings every calendar year with no more than 120 days between two consecutive meetings. There is a genuine relaxation: one person companies, small companies, dormant companies and start-up private companies need to hold only one meeting in each half of the calendar year, with a gap of at least 90 days between them. Many companies assume they qualify for the relaxation without checking the definition. Check your company’s category first.

    Myth 3: Short notice is fine because it is a small family company

    Section 173(3) requires at least seven days’ notice in writing to every director, and notice can go by hand, post or electronic means. A shorter notice is allowed for urgent business, but then at least one independent director, if the company has one, should attend, and if none attends the decisions are circulated and need ratification by at least one independent director. In a company with no independent director the safest course is to obtain written consent to shorter notice from all directors. Proxies are not allowed at board meetings: a director must attend personally or through video conference.

    Myth 4: Minutes can be written whenever convenient

    Secretarial Standard 1 (board meetings) and Secretarial Standard 2 (general meetings) are not optional. Section 118(10) requires every company to observe them. In practice, draft minutes should reach the directors within 15 days of the meeting, directors should respond within seven days, and the minutes should be entered into the minute book within 30 days of the meeting. Minutes written months later, or copied from a template with the wrong date, are exactly the documents that hurt a company in a dispute or an inspection.

    A resolution passed by circulation under section 175 is also not a casual WhatsApp reply. The draft must be sent to all directors and approved by a majority of those entitled to vote, and the resolution must be noted at the next meeting.

    Myth 5: Director KYC must be filed every September

    This was true for years and is now out of date. The Companies (Appointment and Qualification of Directors) Amendment Rules, 2025, notified on 31 December 2025, move routine KYC to a three-year cycle from 31 March 2026. A director holding a DIN on 31 March of a financial year files a single consolidated online form, DIR-3-KYC-Web, once after every three consecutive financial years, by 30 June of the following financial year. Changes in mobile number, e-mail or residential address must be reported within 30 days. Do not rely on an old compliance calendar that still shows an annual 30 September date.

    Myth 6: A non-executive or family director carries no risk

    The Act defines an officer in default, and a director who is aware of a contravention, or who did not act diligently, can be proceeded against. Section 149(12) gives some protection to independent directors and non-executive directors who are not promoters or key managerial personnel: they are liable only for acts of omission or commission that occurred with their knowledge, attributable through board processes, and with their consent or connivance or where they did not act diligently. That is a protection earned by attending meetings, reading papers and recording dissent, not a blanket immunity. A director who never attends and never asks questions will find the protection hard to rely on.

    Myth 7: Deals with family companies need no approval

    Related party transactions are one of the most reviewed areas. Under section 184, every director must disclose their interest in other firms and companies at the first board meeting in which they participate and at the first meeting of every financial year, and an interested director generally does not take part in the discussion or vote. Section 188 then requires board approval, and in some cases shareholder approval, for specified related party contracts such as sale, purchase or leasing of property, supply of goods or services and appointment to an office of profit, subject to the prescribed thresholds and exemptions. Both sections have conditions that depend on the type of company, so a one line board note saying ‘approved’ is not enough.

    Myth 8: A compliance calendar is a one time setup

    Compliance is a cycle. A basic annual cycle for a private company usually covers the board meetings, the annual general meeting (generally within six months of the financial year end), the AOC-4 within 30 days of the AGM, the MGT-7 or MGT-7A within 60 days of the AGM, director disclosures, auditor related filings, statutory registers and any event based filings such as a change of address or directors. Late filing carries an additional fee of Rs 100 per day, per form, with no upper limit, and the Registrar can also prosecute and levy penalties. The sensible approach is a calendar owned by a named person, reviewed at every board meeting.

    ItemWho it applies toCore rule
    Board meetingsAll companies, with relaxations for small, one person, dormant and start-up private companiesFour a year, 120 day gap; relaxed categories twice a year with 90 day gap
    AOC-4Companies filing financial statementsWithin 30 days of the AGM
    MGT-7 or MGT-7AAnnual returnWithin 60 days of the AGM
    DIR-3-KYC-WebEvery individual holding a DINOnce after three consecutive financial years, by 30 June of the next financial year

    Myth 9: Risk management is only for listed companies

    Section 134(3)(n) requires the board report to state how a risk management policy has been developed and implemented, including the risks that in the board’s opinion may threaten the company’s existence. Larger listed entities have additional duties such as a risk management committee under SEBI regulations, but even a small private company faces contract risk, tax risk, labour law risk and cyber risk. A short written risk register reviewed twice a year is better than none, and it shows the board is doing the work the law expects.

    A short self-check for founders

    1. Is the company’s category (small, one person, start-up, dormant) correctly identified, and do the board meeting numbers match it?
    2. Are minutes signed, dated and entered in the minute book within the Secretarial Standard timelines?
    3. Do all directors have an active DIN, current contact details and a valid KYC status?
    4. Has every director filed a fresh disclosure of interest this financial year?
    5. Are the AGM, AOC-4 and MGT-7 dates written on a calendar with a named owner?
    6. Are related party contracts approved and recorded before performance begins?

    If two or more answers are no, fix them before the next filing season. The additional fee grows daily and disqualification under section 164(2) is far harder to undo than a late fee is to pay.

    Build a compliance system that survives staff changes. The Lexfolio Corporate Governance, Compliance and Risk Management is a self-paced certificate course on corporate governance, compliance and risk management. Price: Rs 599.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is the due date for AOC-4 and MGT-7?

    AOC-4 (financial statements) is due within 30 days of the annual general meeting and MGT-7 (annual return) within 60 days of it. Small companies and one person companies file the abridged MGT-7A. An additional fee of Rs 100 per day, per form, applies to late filing.

    Do I have to file returns if my company earned nothing this year?

    Yes. A company with no turnover must still prepare financial statements, hold its meetings and file with the Registrar. The Act has no exemption for inactive companies, though a company can apply for dormant status in the prescribed manner.

    Can a director resign to escape liability for past defaults?

    Resignation ends future responsibility but does not wipe out liability for defaults that happened while the person was a director. The director should file the resignation with the Registrar and keep proof.

    Is every private company required to have an audit committee?

    No. The audit committee requirement applies to listed companies and to public companies crossing the prescribed paid-up capital, turnover or borrowing limits. A private company usually does not need one, but good practice still calls for someone to review the accounts independently.

    How often must directors file KYC now?

    From 31 March 2026, routine director KYC moves to a cycle of once after every three consecutive financial years, filed through DIR-3-KYC-Web by 30 June of the following financial year. Changes to mobile number, e-mail or residential address must be reported within 30 days.

    This article is general information, not legal or professional advice for a specific case. Dates, fees and forms can change, so confirm them on the MCA portal or with a company secretary before acting. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • How to Hold a Board Meeting Under the Companies Act: Step by Step Checklist

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: a valid board meeting has six parts: a proper call (at least seven days’ written notice with agenda), a quorum present throughout, a chairman who runs the agenda, disclosures of interest handled before voting, minutes circulated in draft within 15 days, and the signed minutes entered in the minute book within 30 days. The steps below take you through them in order.

    This guide is written for a private company with a board of two to six directors, which is where most informal habits grow. The same sequence applies to larger companies, with more formal committees and SEBI rules added for listed ones.

    Governance made practical. The Lexfolio Corporate Governance, Compliance and Risk Management is a self-paced certificate course on corporate governance, compliance and risk management. Price: Rs 599.

    Step 1: Decide whether a meeting is even the right tool

    Some decisions can be taken by a resolution passed by circulation under section 175. The draft must be circulated to all directors, and the resolution is passed if it is approved by a majority of the directors entitled to vote. It must then be noted at the next board meeting and recorded in the minutes. A few matters cannot be dealt with by circulation, such as those the Act requires to be decided at a meeting, for example approving the financial statements and the board’s report. If the matter is significant or contested, call a meeting.

    Step 2: Check how many meetings the company owes

    • First meeting: within 30 days of incorporation.
    • Ordinary companies: at least four meetings in each calendar year, with a gap of no more than 120 days between two consecutive meetings.
    • One person companies, small companies, dormant companies and start-up private companies: at least one meeting in each half of the calendar year, with a gap of at least 90 days.
    • Section 8 companies: at least one meeting in every six calendar months.

    Put the dates on a calendar at the beginning of the year. A fixed pattern, say the second week of each quarter, makes the 120 day gap almost impossible to miss.

    Step 3: Send the notice and agenda

    Section 173(3) requires at least seven days’ notice in writing to every director at the address registered with the company. Notice can be delivered by hand, by post or by electronic means. Secretarial Standard 1 expects the agenda and notes on each agenda item to go with the notice. Include the date, time, venue, and, if the meeting allows participation by video, the link and the procedure for joining.

    Short notice is allowed for urgent business, but at least one independent director, if the company has one, should be present. If no independent director attends, the decisions taken must be circulated to all directors and become final only after ratification by at least one independent director. Record the urgency in the minutes. Do not use short notice routinely, because it can become evidence that the board was not given time to apply its mind.

    Step 4: Prepare the director papers

    The notes on agenda items are the heart of good governance. For each item, state what decision is sought, why, what the alternatives are and what the law requires. For a loan to another company, for example, the note would set out the lender, borrower, amount, rate, purpose, whether any restriction under the Act applies and who is interested. Directors who cannot rely on a note cannot easily show that they acted with due and reasonable care, which is a duty under section 166.

    Step 5: Open the meeting properly

    1. The chairman is identified (the Articles or the directors present decide if there is no standing chairman).
    2. The company secretary or the person acting as secretary records who is present, who is attending by video conference, and the time the meeting begins.
    3. The chairman confirms that quorum is present. Under section 174 it is one third of the total strength or two directors, whichever is higher, and it must be present throughout, not only at the start.
    4. Leave of absence is noted for directors who could not attend.
    5. Any disclosure of interest is taken up before the item concerned.

    On disclosures: under section 184 each director must disclose their interest in other companies, firms and bodies at the first meeting in which they participate and at the first meeting of every financial year, and an interested director generally does not take part in discussion or voting on the contract concerned. Interested directors are generally excluded when counting quorum for that item, subject to exceptions notified by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs.

    Step 6: Run the agenda in the order sent

    Take items in the sequence of the notice. A matter outside the agenda can be taken up only with the chairman’s permission and with the consent of a majority of directors present, including at least one independent director where the company has one. Statutory items that must not be left off include approval of the previous minutes, noting of disclosures, review of compliance, and approval of financial statements at the relevant meeting.

    Matters that cannot be approved by video conference

    Under the 2014 meeting rules, the following cannot be dealt with through a meeting held on video conference: approval of the annual financial statements and the board’s report, approval of the prospectus, the audit committee’s consideration of financial statements including consolidated statements, and approval of amalgamation, merger, demerger, acquisition or takeover. If one of these items is on the agenda, ask directors to attend physically. Check the current text of the rules at the time of the meeting, because the list has been amended in the past.

    Step 7: Record decisions as resolutions

    A board decision should be worded as a resolution so that a bank, the Registrar or an auditor can rely on it. A usable pattern is: the recital of the background, the decision in operative words, the authority given to a named director or officer, and the limit of that authority. For a bank account, for instance, name the bank, the signatories and whether signing is joint or single. For a loan, state the maximum amount.

    The mover and seconder are optional. What must be recorded is how the resolution was passed, any dissent and the names of directors who did not vote because of interest.

    Step 8: Write, circulate and sign the minutes

    StageTimelineSource
    Draft minutes sent to all directorsWithin 15 days of the meetingSecretarial Standard 1
    Directors confirm or commentWithin 7 days of receiving the draft, or a reasonable period set by the boardSecretarial Standard 1
    Minutes entered in the minute bookWithin 30 days of the conclusion of the meetingSection 118(1)
    Signed by the chairmanAt the same or the next meeting, as the standard providesSection 118(10) and SS-1

    Minutes should record what was decided and why it was reasonable, not a transcript. Use numbered pages, avoid blank spaces that can be filled later, and keep the signed copy together with the attendance register and the notice. Minutes kept in the form of a loose paper file are easy to lose; follow the minute book rules of the standard.

    Step 9: Follow up the decisions

    Each decision needs an owner and a date. If the board authorised a director to sign an agreement, file a charge, appoint an auditor or open an account, track the filing deadlines that follow. For appointment of an auditor, for example, the intimation form to the Registrar must be filed within the prescribed period. A tracker at the end of the minutes, reviewed at the next meeting, closes the loop.

    Common pitfalls to avoid

    • Holding four meetings in the calendar year but leaving a gap of more than 120 days between two of them.
    • Treating quorum as a start of meeting check only.
    • Taking approval of the financial statements on video conference when the rules require a physical meeting for it.
    • Having an interested director vote on his own related party contract.
    • Writing minutes months later without a draft circulation.
    • Sending a notice by an informal chat message with no record of delivery.

    The Companies Act and Secretarial Standard 1 should be read together. If you are unsure whether a company is a small company or a start-up private company, check the definitions first because they decide how many meetings you owe.

    Go beyond the checklist. The Lexfolio Corporate Governance, Compliance and Risk Management is a self-paced certificate course on corporate governance, compliance and risk management. Price: Rs 599.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can a board meeting be held entirely on video conference?

    Yes, for most business. Directors joining by video conference count towards the quorum, and the company must record their participation and store the proceedings. Certain matters are excluded under the Companies (Meetings of Board and its Powers) Rules, 2014, including approval of the annual financial statements and the board’s report, approval of the prospectus, and approval of amalgamations, mergers, demergers, acquisitions and takeovers.

    What is the quorum for a board meeting?

    Under section 174 the quorum is one third of the total strength of directors, or two directors, whichever is higher. Any fraction in counting one third is rounded up to one. Interested directors are generally not counted for the item in which they are interested.

    What happens if the quorum is not present?

    The meeting stands adjourned to the same day in the next week, at the same time and place, unless the Articles say otherwise. If that day is a national holiday, the meeting moves to the next day that is not a holiday.

    Does a board meeting need a written agenda?

    The Act does not make an agenda compulsory, but Secretarial Standard 1 expects notice with an agenda and notes on each item. Items outside the agenda can be taken up with the chairman’s permission and the consent of a majority, including at least one independent director if the company has one.

    Is a director allowed to attend through a proxy?

    No. Section 173(2) requires a director to attend personally or through video conference or other audio visual means, and proxies are not permitted at board meetings.

    This article is general information, not legal or professional advice for a specific case. The Articles of your company, your category of company and later rule changes can alter the steps, so confirm with a company secretary where the decision matters. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • ESG Compliance in India: Real Scenarios When a Buyer, Lender or Regulator Asks

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: ESG obligations reach a business from four directions: securities regulation (BRSR), company law (CSR and directors’ duties), consumer law (misleading environmental claims) and contracts (buyer and lender questionnaires). The six situations below are illustrations invented to show how those four directions interact. The names, numbers and companies are made up.

    Understand the framework behind these situations. The Lexfolio ESG and BRSR Reporting in India is a self-paced certificate course on ESG and BRSR reporting in India. Price: Rs 599.

    Illustration 1: A mid cap manufacturer facing assessment for the first time

    Situation. A listed engineering company ranks in the 700s by market capitalisation. For two years it filed a BRSR but never had its numbers independently reviewed. Its finance head hears that this year will be different.

    Legal position. BRSR is mandatory for the top 1000 listed entities by market capitalisation. BRSR Core, the subset of key indicators across nine attributes, was phased in for the top 150 from FY 2023-24, the top 250 from FY 2024-25 and the top 500 from FY 2025-26, and reaches the top 1000 in FY 2026-27. A company ranked 700 therefore faces independent assessment or assurance of those indicators for the first time in FY 2026-27, subject to any later SEBI change.

    What to do. Choose the route (assurance or the third party assessment route allowed by the March 2025 circular), pick a provider independent of the firm that helped compile the data, build the evidence file for each Core indicator now, and run a trial review before the year closes.

    Illustration 2: The supplier with a ten page questionnaire

    Situation. A small unlisted packaging firm receives a long ESG questionnaire from a listed customer. It asks for emissions, water use, safety incidents and worker welfare, and says that future orders depend on the answers.

    Legal position. The listed customer’s duties come from SEBI’s framework, which asks the largest listed entities to look at value chain partners that individually account for 2 per cent or more of purchases or sales, with an option to cover 75 per cent in total. A March 2025 circular made value chain disclosure and the related assessment voluntary. The supplier is not directly bound by BRSR, but the customer may impose a contractual duty through purchase terms. Giving false data to a customer can also create civil and, in extreme cases, criminal exposure.

    What to do. Answer what the firm can prove, mark the rest as not measured, ask for a reasonable time, and keep a copy. Read the purchase terms for audit rights, termination for non-disclosure and confidentiality of the data.

    Illustration 3: The carbon neutral label

    Situation. A consumer goods start-up wants to print “carbon neutral” and “eco friendly” on its packs because it buys small offsets and uses recycled cartons for part of its packaging.

    Legal position. An environmental claim is a statement of fact. Misleading advertisements fall under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, and the Central Consumer Protection Authority issued guidelines on greenwashing and misleading environmental claims in October 2024. In general, claims must be specific, truthful and supported by evidence, and broad words used without qualification are risky. The Advertising Standards Council of India has guidelines on the subject too.

    What to do. Replace the slogan with a precise, provable statement, for example the percentage of recycled material in the carton, and keep the test reports on file. Do not claim carbon neutrality unless you can show what was measured, what was offset and how.

    Illustration 4: The CSR shortfall

    Situation. A company with a net profit of Rs 8 crore in the previous year approved a CSR plan for a two year school project. By year end it has spent only part of the amount.

    Legal position. Section 135 applies to a company with net worth of Rs 500 crore or more, turnover of Rs 1,000 crore or more, or net profit of Rs 5 crore or more in the preceding financial year, so this company is covered. It must spend at least 2 per cent of its average net profit of the three preceding financial years. If the unspent amount relates to an ongoing project, it must be transferred to an Unspent CSR Account within 30 days from the end of the financial year. If it relates to other projects, it must be transferred to a fund specified in Schedule VII within six months of the end of the financial year. The board’s report must explain the shortfall. For default, the company can be penalised with twice the unspent amount or Rs 1 crore, whichever is less, and each officer in default with one tenth of the unspent amount or Rs 2 lakh, whichever is less.

    What to do. Confirm whether the school project qualifies as an ongoing project under the rules, make the transfer on time, record the reasons in the board’s report and revise the annual action plan.

    Illustration 5: The same firm compiles and assures

    Situation. A listed company asks the consulting firm that built its ESG data system to also give the assessment report on BRSR Core.

    Legal position. The 2025 changes allow a third party assessment route, but the provider is expected to be independent of conflicts of interest, including consulting ties with the company on the same data. A firm reviewing its own work is not independent in any ordinary sense, and the assessment report may be questioned by investors and by the stock exchange.

    What to do. Keep consulting and verification with different firms, document the reasons for choosing the provider and obtain a written confirmation of independence before engagement.

    Illustration 6: Board papers with gaps

    Situation. Two days before the board meeting, the sustainability head tells the managing director that waste data for two plants is estimated and the water figures for one plant could not be verified. The MD wants the BRSR approved anyway.

    Legal position. Directors owe duties under section 166 of the Companies Act, 2013, including to act in good faith in the best interests of the company, its employees, shareholders, the community and for the protection of the environment, and to exercise due and reasonable care, skill and diligence. Approving a report that the board knows contains unverified numbers, without saying so, is hard to defend. Where data is truly unavailable, an honest statement that it is not available, with the plan to build it, is better than a precise looking guess.

    What to do. Disclose the data limitation in the report in plain words, record the board’s discussion, ask for a corrective timeline and have the audit committee follow it up.

    Patterns to remember

    • Know which rule applies to you before you answer anyone’s request.
    • Disclose what you can prove and say clearly what you cannot.
    • Keep marketing claims, filings and questionnaire answers consistent with each other.
    • Keep the evidence file for every number, because someone will ask for it.

    Get fluent in the rules behind ESG reporting. The Lexfolio ESG and BRSR Reporting in India is a self-paced certificate course on ESG and BRSR reporting in India. Price: Rs 599.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can a listed company be penalised for not filing a BRSR?

    Non-compliance with the listing regulations can attract action from the stock exchanges and SEBI, including monetary penalties under the framework applicable to listed entities. The consequences depend on the nature and duration of the default, so treat the filing as a hard deadline.

    Is a carbon neutral claim safe if we buy offsets?

    Not automatically. The claim must be truthful, specific and supported by evidence of what was offset and how. Guidelines on greenwashing issued by the Central Consumer Protection Authority in October 2024 expect advertisers to substantiate environmental claims and not to use vague terms in a misleading way.

    What happens if a company misses its CSR spending target?

    The board’s report must state the reasons. Unspent amounts must be moved to the specified account or fund within the time the section allows, and default can lead to a penalty on the company and its officers in default under section 135.

    Do ESG ratings matter legally?

    Ratings are not a legal requirement, but lenders and investors use them, and statements made to raters are statements made to the market. Treat the information you provide with the same care as a regulatory filing.

    Where should a small business start on ESG?

    Start with the basic data the BRSR asks for: energy, water, waste, employees, safety and compliance record. Then read the questionnaires your customers send, and build one set of answers you can reuse.

    The scenarios are invented illustrations, not reports of real cases or real companies. This article is general information, not legal or professional advice for a specific case. SEBI and the Ministry of Corporate Affairs revise ESG requirements often, so check the latest circulars. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • Director Duties and Compliance Problems in India: Real Scenarios and What to Do

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: a director’s exposure depends on what the director knew, what the director did about it, and what the records show. The six scenarios below are illustrations invented to show how the Companies Act, 2013 treats common situations. Names and figures are made up.

    Read each as a pattern. The legal position is stated first, then the sensible next step. If your own facts are close to one of these, get advice before you act.

    Learn to handle these situations with a framework. The Lexfolio Corporate Governance, Compliance and Risk Management is a self-paced certificate course on corporate governance, compliance and risk management. Price: Rs 599.

    Illustration 1: Three years of silence

    Situation. Rhea joined a friend’s start-up as a director in 2022 and signed nothing after incorporation. The company never held an annual general meeting and never filed its financial statements or annual returns for three financial years. A notice from the Registrar arrives.

    Legal position. Section 164(2) disqualifies a person who is or was a director of a company that has not filed financial statements or annual returns for any continuous period of three financial years. The disqualification is for five years and covers appointment in other companies too. How it affects an existing directorship has been argued in commentary, so take advice on the date from which it runs and the consequences for your other boards.

    What to do. Establish exactly which years are overdue. Have the company file the pending financial statements and returns, with the additional fees. Check whether your DIN appears on the published list of disqualified directors. Pause signing any new filings until a company secretary or lawyer has confirmed your status.

    Illustration 2: The cousin’s supplier

    Situation. Karan, a director of a manufacturing company, wants the company to buy packaging from a firm run by his cousin. The price looks market competitive. He asks the other directors to approve it by a quick message.

    Legal position. Section 184 requires Karan to disclose his interest in the cousin’s firm to the board, and an interested director generally does not take part in discussion or vote on the contract. Section 188 requires board approval, and in some cases approval of the members, for specified related party contracts above the prescribed thresholds, unless a statutory exemption applies, such as transactions in the ordinary course of business at arm’s length. Whether a cousin’s firm is a related party depends on the definitions of relative and related party in the Act, so check these.

    What to do. Record Karan’s disclosure, have the independent or disinterested directors review the pricing against quotes from other suppliers, pass the approval at a meeting with Karan out of the discussion, and keep the comparison in the file.

    Illustration 3: The anonymous complaint

    Situation. An employee of a mid sized company writes to the chairman alleging that purchase invoices are being inflated. The writer asks that the name be kept confidential.

    Legal position. Section 177(9) requires a vigil mechanism for listed companies, for companies that accept deposits from the public and for companies that have borrowed money from banks and public financial institutions in excess of Rs 50 crore. Where it applies, the mechanism must give adequate safeguards against victimisation and allow direct access to the chairperson of the audit committee in appropriate cases. A company that is outside those classes still has to deal with the allegation, because an inflated invoice can be a misstatement in the accounts.

    What to do. Acknowledge the complaint, restrict the circle of people who know the name, give the investigation to someone independent of the department concerned, preserve the documents, and record the outcome in a note to the board.

    Illustration 4: Minutes written a year later

    Situation. A lender asks for a certified board resolution approving a loan taken eleven months ago. No such resolution exists. A senior manager suggests preparing minutes now, bearing the earlier date.

    Legal position. A resolution that was not passed cannot be created later with an old date. Creating backdated records can amount to making a false statement or document, and the Act punishes fraud and false statements in the course of its provisions, including sections 447 and 448. The correct route is to put the matter before the board now and ratify the borrowing, recording honestly that the decision is being ratified on the new date and why.

    What to do. Call a meeting with proper notice, place the loan terms and the explanation before the directors, and ratify with the actual date. Tell the lender the true position if asked. Ask whether any statutory filing about the borrowing was missed and file it with additional fees.

    Illustration 5: The auditor’s fraud report

    Situation. During the audit, the statutory auditor finds that a store manager has diverted goods worth about Rs 40 lakh over a year.

    Legal position. Section 143(12) requires an auditor who has reason to believe that an offence involving fraud is being or has been committed against the company by officers or employees to report it. Under the rules made under the section, where the amount involved is Rs 1 crore or more the report goes to the Central Government after informing the board, and for smaller amounts the report goes to the audit committee or the board, and the matter must be disclosed in the board’s report. The amount here is below Rs 1 crore, so the route is to the board or audit committee.

    What to do. Convene the board, take the report on record, give the auditor a reasoned reply within the rule’s time limit, act against the employee through a proper inquiry, and disclose the details in the board’s report as the rules require. The board should not pressure the auditor to drop the matter.

    Illustration 6: A deactivated DIN

    Situation. Meera, a director of two companies, learns that a bank refuses her signature on a form because her DIN shows as deactivated for non filing of KYC.

    Legal position. Director KYC rules changed with effect from 31 March 2026. Routine KYC is now filed once after every three consecutive financial years through the consolidated form DIR-3-KYC-Web, by 30 June of the following financial year, and the form is also used for DIN reactivation. Some cases, such as reactivation, need a certification by a chartered accountant, cost accountant or company secretary. Check which window applies to your DIN, because the transition from the old annual cycle can produce confusion.

    What to do. File the form, pay any fee applicable for reactivation, update the company records, and re-file any document that was rejected because of the status. Set a reminder for the next window and for the 30 day duty to report a change in mobile, e-mail or residential address.

    Illustration 7: The meeting that never happened

    Situation. A company’s last board meeting was in January. It is now September and no meeting has been held. The directors assume that an annual general meeting in September will count.

    Legal position. An annual general meeting is a meeting of members, not of the board. Section 173 requires board meetings at least four times a year with no more than 120 days between two consecutive meetings, unless the company falls in a relaxed category such as a small company, one person company, dormant company or start-up private company, which must meet once in each half of the calendar year with a gap of at least 90 days.

    What to do. Hold a board meeting at once, record the lapse candidly, and fix the calendar for the remaining months. Check whether the company is eligible for the relaxed pattern and document the basis.

    What the illustrations have in common

    • Each problem became serious because nobody acted when the first sign appeared.
    • Each can be solved through honest records: disclosure, a meeting, a filing with fees, or a ratification dated truthfully.
    • A director’s best protection is a paper trail showing questions asked and decisions taken with care.

    Turn these patterns into a working governance routine. The Lexfolio Corporate Governance, Compliance and Risk Management is a self-paced certificate course on corporate governance, compliance and risk management. Price: Rs 599.

    Frequently asked questions

    Is a director personally liable for a company’s debts?

    Generally no. A company is a separate legal person and its debts are its own. Personal liability arises where the Act says so, for example for fraud under section 447, for acts done with consent or connivance, for specific defaults as an officer in default, or where a director gave a personal guarantee.

    What is an officer in default?

    Section 2(60) lists the persons who are treated as officers in default for the purposes of penalties, including whole time directors, key managerial personnel and, where there are none, directors specified by the board. It also reaches a director who knew of the default through board proceedings and did not object, or who consented or connived.

    Can a disqualified director continue to sign filings?

    A person disqualified under section 164 should not act as a director or sign documents as one. The Ministry of Corporate Affairs publishes lists of disqualified directors. Take advice immediately if you find your DIN on such a list.

    Do I need a vigil mechanism in a small private company?

    The Act makes it mandatory for listed companies, for companies accepting deposits from the public and for companies with borrowings from banks and public financial institutions above the prescribed limit. A company outside those classes is not required to have one but a simple written process to receive complaints is good practice.

    When should a director seek independent legal advice?

    When a decision may expose the director to a personal claim, when the board is divided, when a regulator has issued a notice, or when a record seems to have been altered. The company’s lawyer acts for the company, not for each director.

    The scenarios are invented illustrations, not reports of real cases, and every real situation turns on its own facts. This article is general information, not legal or professional advice for a specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource.