LLexfolio

Tag: data breach

  • Cyber Crime Myths in India: 9 Mistakes Offices and Colleges Make

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Most offices and colleges learn cyber law the hard way: after the money has moved, the server is locked or a student’s photograph is circulating. By then the first hours have been spent on the wrong steps, because of beliefs that sound sensible but are wrong. This guide takes nine of those beliefs one by one and gives the correct position under Indian law as it stands on the date above.

    A quick note on the statutes: the main law is the Information Technology Act, 2000 (the IT Act). Ordinary offences such as cheating are now under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), and police procedure is under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), both in force since 1 July 2024.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers Cyber Crime Law for Offices and Institutions, a self-paced certificate course on cyber crime law for offices and institutions. Course price: Rs 599.

    Myth 1: “We are too small or too ordinary to be targeted”

    Phishing e-mails, fake invoices and ransomware are sent in bulk, and a small office with weak passwords and one accounts clerk who can release payments is an easy target. The law also does not shrink with the size of the entity. The reporting directions issued by CERT-In (the Indian Computer Emergency Response Team) apply to service providers, intermediaries, data centres, body corporates and government organisations alike, so a private company or a college society that runs its own systems is covered.

    Myth 2: “A cyber incident is only a police matter, so we do not need to report it anywhere else”

    There are at least two separate reporting tracks, and the police track is the one people know. Under the directions issued by CERT-In on 28 April 2022 under section 70B(6) of the IT Act, listed incidents must be reported to CERT-In within six hours of noticing them. The list includes unauthorised access to IT systems or data, data breaches and leaks, ransomware and other malicious code, phishing and identity theft, attacks on e-mail, DNS or database servers, website defacement and unauthorised access to social media accounts. Reports go to incident@cert-in.org.in or the toll free number 1800-11-4949. CERT-In itself says that failing to comply can invite action under section 70B(7), which provides for imprisonment up to one year or a fine up to Rs 1 lakh, or both.

    The police track (a complaint or FIR) is separate. Doing one does not discharge the other.

    Myth 3: “The data law will tell us what to do after a breach, and it is not in force yet, so we can wait”

    Half of this is true and half is dangerous. The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 and the DPDP Rules, 2025 (published 13 November 2025) are being phased in. Only the first rules (definitions and the provisions on the Data Protection Board) took effect on 13 November 2025. The main duties of a data fiduciary, including security safeguards and breach intimation, are set to apply from 13 May 2027, eighteen months after publication. The Rules require a breach to be intimated to affected persons and to the Data Protection Board, with a detailed report to the Board within 72 hours.

    But “not yet in force” does not mean “no rule today”. Until then section 43A of the IT Act (compensation when a body corporate is negligent in protecting sensitive personal data) continues to apply, and the CERT-In six hour direction applies now. The DPDP Act will omit section 43A only when its section 44(2) comes into force on the same 13 May 2027 date. The DPDP Act’s schedule provides penalties of up to Rs 250 crore for failure to take reasonable security safeguards and up to Rs 200 crore for failure to give intimation of a breach.

    Myth 4: “Deleting the malicious file or wiping the machine solves it”

    It destroys the evidence. Cyber cases are won on logs, headers, device images and timestamps. The CERT-In directions already require service providers, body corporates and others covered to keep logs of all ICT systems for a rolling 180 days, stored within India, and to synchronise system clocks with NIC or NPL time servers or sources traceable to them. If you rebuild a server before the logs are copied, you may lose both the proof and the ability to show compliance. Isolate the machine from the network, do not switch off or wipe it, and copy logs first.

    Myth 5: “A screenshot is enough proof in court”

    A screenshot helps you complain, but electronic records are proved in a particular way. Under section 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA), an electronic record produced as secondary evidence is admissible when accompanied by a certificate in the prescribed form, signed by the person in charge of the device or system and, in Part B, by an expert. The certificate carries a hash value of the record. In Pune Bar Association v. Union of India (22 May 2026) the Supreme Court upheld the section 63(4) certificate requirement as constitutional, describing a hash value as “synonymous with an electronic fingerprint”. The Court also read section 39 BSA as allowing a person with special skill in computer science and cyber forensics to qualify as an expert for the Part B certificate on the material before the court, and left the wider question open. So keep original files, exported logs and the device itself.

    Myth 6: “If we lose money to online fraud, the bank must refund us”

    It depends on how the money left the account. The Reserve Bank of India’s circular of 6 July 2017 on customer liability in unauthorised electronic banking transactions gives zero liability where the fault is the bank’s, and also where a third party breach occurs and the customer reports within three working days of the bank’s communication. If the customer reports after four to seven working days, liability is limited to the transaction value or a cap, whichever is lower. The caps are Rs 5,000 for BSBD accounts, Rs 10,000 for other savings accounts and for MSME and small individual current accounts (average balance or limit up to Rs 25 lakh), and Rs 25,000 for other current accounts. Beyond seven working days it depends on the bank’s board approved policy.

    The important limit: the circular deals with *unauthorised* transactions. If your own accounts officer, believing a fake invoice or a spoofed e-mail from a “vendor”, approved and released a payment, the transaction was authorised from the bank’s side and a refund right is generally much weaker. Report immediately anyway, because speed is what allows a bank to try to freeze the receiving account.

    Myth 7: “A cyber crime complaint is not an FIR, so nothing will happen”

    A complaint on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal (cybercrime.gov.in) or on the helpline 1930 is not by itself an FIR, but it can lead to one. Under section 173 of the BNSS, information about a cognizable offence can be given by electronic communication and is recorded when the informant signs it within three days. For large financial frauds, the Ministry of Home Affairs announced in May 2025 an e-Zero FIR system: complaints on the portal or 1930 with losses above Rs 10 lakh are converted automatically into a Zero FIR, which the complainant then follows up at the relevant cyber police station within three days. It was launched as a pilot in Delhi with plans for other states, so check what applies where you are. Below that threshold, do not wait for automatic conversion: file the portal complaint and also approach the local cyber cell or police station with a written complaint.

    Myth 8: “An employee who copies office data is only a disciplinary problem”

    It can be both a disciplinary and a criminal matter. Section 43 of the IT Act makes a person who, without permission of the owner, accesses, downloads, copies or extracts data from a computer liable to pay compensation. Section 66 turns the same acts into a crime where done dishonestly or fraudulently, with imprisonment up to three years or a fine up to Rs 5 lakh, or both. Section 72A punishes disclosure of personal information obtained under a lawful contract with intent to cause wrongful loss or gain, with imprisonment up to three years or a fine up to Rs 5 lakh, or both. Where an employee entrusted with data dishonestly misuses it, the offence of criminal breach of trust (section 316 BNS) may also be considered. Criminal liability depends on proof of intent, so preserve evidence and take advice before acting.

    Myth 9: “A fake account or photograph is a ‘social media problem’ that only the platform can fix”

    The platform is one route, not the only one. Identity theft using another person’s password or unique identification feature is punishable under section 66C (up to three years and a fine up to Rs 1 lakh). Cheating by personation using a computer resource is punishable under section 66D (up to three years and a fine up to Rs 1 lakh), and the personation limb of cheating also appears in section 319 BNS. Publishing a private image of a person without consent attracts section 66E (up to three years or a fine up to Rs 2 lakh, or both). Material showing children in sexually explicit acts falls under section 67B (up to five years on a first conviction). Use the platform’s grievance process, keep screenshots with URLs and dates, and file the portal complaint.

    What to do next: a one minute checklist

    • Name one person who decides what to do when something goes wrong, and keep the numbers where staff can find them.
    • Keep logs and back ups as the CERT-In directions expect, and know where they are stored.
    • Train staff on the two or three attacks that actually succeed: fake payment instructions, fake log in pages and password reuse.
    • Save the portal address (cybercrime.gov.in), the 1930 helpline and CERT-In’s reporting address in your incident plan.
    • Plan for the DPDP duties that begin on 13 May 2027.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers Cyber Crime Law for Offices and Institutions, a self-paced certificate course on cyber crime law for offices and institutions. Course price: Rs 599.

    Frequently asked questions

    Do we have to report every spam e-mail to CERT-In?

    A: No. The six hour duty relates to the listed types of cyber incidents, such as unauthorised access, data breach, ransomware or compromise of systems. An ordinary spam message that was deleted unopened is not such an incident, but a successful phishing attack that gave an outsider access is.

    Does a college or school have to follow the CERT-In directions?

    A: The directions are addressed to service providers, intermediaries, data centres, body corporates and government organisations. Whether a particular institution falls in one of those categories depends on how it is constituted and what it operates, so confirm for your own entity. Government institutions are generally covered.

    How soon after a fraud should I call 1930?

    A: As soon as you notice it. The helpline exists so that banks and platforms can be alerted quickly to hold the money, and delay reduces the chance of recovery. Also tell your own bank in writing.

    Will the DPDP Act change what we have to do after a breach?

    A: Yes, from 13 May 2027 the data fiduciary duties, including breach intimation to the Data Protection Board and to affected persons, are scheduled to apply. Until then the IT Act and the CERT-In directions are what apply.

    This article is general information, not legal, financial or tax advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services.

  • What to Do After a Cyber Attack or Data Breach at Your Office in India

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: if your office or institution has been hit by ransomware, a hacked mail account, a data leak or a payment fraud, treat the first day as a clock. Contain the problem without destroying evidence, report to CERT-In within six hours of noticing a listed incident, tell your bank at once if money moved, file a complaint with the police or the cyber crime portal, and keep a record of every step. The order below is a working checklist, not a substitute for advice on your own facts.

    This guide covers an organisation (company, firm, college, school, trust or government office) that controls its own systems. If you are an individual who lost money in a scam, the same ideas apply, but the six hour direction is aimed at organisations.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers Cyber Crime Law for Offices and Institutions, a self-paced certificate course on cyber crime law for offices and institutions. Course price: Rs 599.

    The first day at a glance

    StepDo thisRule or source
    ———
    1Contain: isolate affected devices, change credentials, do not wipeEvidence preservation
    2Note the exact time you noticed the incidentCERT-In six hour clock runs from noticing
    3Report to CERT-In if the incident is of a listed typeDirections of 28 April 2022 under section 70B(6), IT Act
    4If money moved, call your bank and the helpline 1930RBI circular of 6 July 2017; National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal
    5File a complaint or FIRSection 173, BNSS
    6Preserve and certify electronic evidenceSection 63, BSA
    7Assess data protection dutiesIT Act section 43A now; DPDP Act and Rules from 13 May 2027
    8Fix, document, learnInternal record

    Step 1: Contain, but do not destroy

    Disconnect the affected computers from the network and the internet (pull the cable or switch off Wi-Fi rather than shutting the machine down, because shutting down can erase information held in memory). Change passwords and revoke access tokens from a clean device, starting with e-mail, banking and administrator accounts. Switch on multi-factor authentication where it was missing.

    Do not reinstall, reformat or delete anything yet. Make a list of devices, accounts and servers involved. If you use a vendor or cloud provider, ask them in writing to preserve logs. The CERT-In directions already expect covered entities to keep logs of all ICT systems for a rolling 180 days, stored within India, so the logs may exist even if the machine itself is rebuilt later.

    Step 2: Write down the time you noticed

    The six hour period under the CERT-In directions runs from the moment the entity notices the incident or is told about it. Record the time, who noticed it and how, in a simple log that you keep adding to. It protects you later if anyone asks when you knew.

    Step 3: Report to CERT-In if the incident is listed

    The directions issued by CERT-In on 28 April 2022 under section 70B(6) of the Information Technology Act, 2000 list incident types in an annexure. Those most relevant to offices and institutions include:

    • unauthorised access to IT systems or data, and compromise of critical systems or information
    • data breaches and data leaks
    • malicious code such as ransomware, spyware and trojans
    • identity theft, spoofing and phishing
    • attacks on mail, DNS or database servers and on network devices
    • website defacement or intrusion
    • unauthorised access to social media accounts
    • attacks affecting digital payment systems or cloud systems

    Report within six hours by e-mail to incident@cert-in.org.in or by phone on 1800-11-4949. The directions ask for the details of the incident as far as known, so send what you have and add more later. Failure to furnish information or comply can invite action under section 70B(7), which provides for imprisonment up to one year or a fine up to Rs 1 lakh, or both.

    Two related duties in the same directions are worth checking today and not on the day of an attack: keep system logs for 180 days within India, and synchronise your system clocks with the NIC or NPL time servers (or sources traceable to them).

    Step 4: If money has moved, act within minutes

    Call your bank’s fraud line and follow up in writing, giving the transaction reference, amount, time and the receiving account. Then report on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal (cybercrime.gov.in) or call the national helpline 1930. Speed matters because the receiving bank may be able to hold the funds only while they have not been moved on.

    Under the Reserve Bank of India’s circular of 6 July 2017, a customer has zero liability for an unauthorised electronic transaction where the fault lies with the bank, or where a third party breach occurs and the customer reports within three working days of the bank’s communication. After four to seven working days the customer’s liability is capped (Rs 5,000, Rs 10,000 or Rs 25,000 depending on the account type) and beyond seven working days it follows the bank’s board approved policy. The banks must credit the disputed amount provisionally within ten working days of notification. These protections concern *unauthorised* transactions. If your own staff released the payment on a fake instruction, expect a harder dispute and tell the bank exactly what happened.

    Step 5: File a complaint or FIR

    Take a written complaint to the cyber crime police station or the local police station, with copies of the evidence. Under section 173 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, information can also be given electronically; it is taken on record when the informant signs it within three days. For large financial frauds, the Ministry of Home Affairs announced in May 2025 an e-Zero FIR process under which complaints on the portal or 1930 involving more than Rs 10 lakh are converted automatically, starting as a pilot in Delhi. Whether it operates in your state may differ, so ask the police desk.

    What to include in the complaint:

    1. A short chronology with dates and times.
    2. Names and designations of the staff involved and what each did.
    3. Account numbers, transaction IDs, phone numbers, e-mail addresses, URLs and IP addresses seen.
    4. The loss, if any, and the date you informed the bank and CERT-In.
    5. A list of the evidence you are handing over or preserving.

    The offences usually considered are in the IT Act (for example sections 43 and 66 for unauthorised access and damage, 66C for identity theft and 66D for cheating by personation using a computer resource) and in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (for example section 318 for cheating and section 319 for cheating by personation). The police decide which sections apply on the facts.

    Step 6: Preserve and certify the electronic evidence

    Copy, do not move, the originals. For each item note who copied it, when, from which device and with which tool. Keep e-mails in their original format with full headers, not only printed pages.

    In court, electronic records are proved under section 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023. A certificate in the prescribed form accompanies the record: Part A is given by the person in charge of the device or computer system and Part B by an expert, and the certificate records the hash value of the record. In Pune Bar Association v. Union of India, decided on 22 May 2026, the Supreme Court upheld the certificate requirement and described a hash value as “synonymous with an electronic fingerprint”. It also read section 39 of the BSA as allowing a person with special skill in computer science and cyber forensics to qualify as an expert for Part B on the material before the court, while leaving the wider question open. A forensic specialist engaged early can save you from a failed certificate later.

    Step 7: Check your data protection position

    Today, section 43A of the IT Act requires a body corporate that handles sensitive personal data to maintain reasonable security practices, failing which it can be liable to pay compensation to the person affected. The Digital Personal Data Protection Rules, 2025 were published on 13 November 2025 and the main obligations, including the duty to intimate a personal data breach, are scheduled to apply from 13 May 2027. Once they do, a data fiduciary will have to inform each affected person without delay, and the Data Protection Board with an initial description followed by a detailed report within 72 hours. The Act’s schedule sets maximum penalties of Rs 250 crore for failure to take reasonable security safeguards and Rs 200 crore for failure to give intimation of a breach.

    If the incident exposed personal data of students, patients, staff or customers, list what data, whose, and how many. You will need that list under any regime.

    Step 8: Close the loop

    • Reset all credentials, patch the entry point and test back ups before bringing systems back.
    • Brief staff in plain language on what happened and what to do next time.
    • Review contracts with IT vendors for incident support and log retention.
    • Keep a single folder with the incident log, reports to CERT-In, bank and police, and evidence certificates.
    • If you have cyber insurance, read the notice period in the policy and inform the insurer in time.

    What not to do: do not pay a ransom or “recovery agent” on the strength of a message alone, do not delete the attacker’s e-mails and do not contact the receiving account holder yourself. Leave contact with suspects to the police.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers Cyber Crime Law for Offices and Institutions, a self-paced certificate course on cyber crime law for offices and institutions. Course price: Rs 599.

    Frequently asked questions

    What if I am not sure whether the incident is “listed” for CERT-In?

    A: The annexure covers most incidents an office is likely to face, including unauthorised access, phishing, ransomware and data leaks. If you are unsure, reporting is the safer course, and you can supplement the report as facts emerge.

    Is a complaint on cybercrime.gov.in enough, or do I also need an FIR?

    A: The portal complaint starts the process, but an FIR is what lets investigation and prosecution proceed formally. Follow up with the cyber crime police station and ask for the FIR number or a written acknowledgement.

    Can we investigate internally before telling anyone?

    A: You can begin internal checks, but the six hour period for listed incidents runs from noticing, and delay can cost recovery of money. Report first and investigate in parallel.

    Does an employee’s mistake, such as clicking a phishing link, make the employer liable?

    A: Liability depends on the facts: what safeguards the organisation had, what the contract with the affected person says and which law applies. Training and reasonable security practices are your best protection.

    This article is general information, not legal, financial or tax advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services.