LLexfolio

Tag: SMC

  • Parents’ Rights in School Under the RTE Act: 8 Myths

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: The Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009 (RTE Act) gives every child aged 6 to 14 a right to free and compulsory elementary education in a neighbourhood school, and several of its rules answer questions parents ask at the school gate every year: Can the school refuse admission without a transfer certificate? Can it charge a donation? Can a teacher cane a child? Many of the beliefs parents hold, and many that schools repeat, are wrong. Here are eight of them, with the correct position and the section of the Act that supports it. Rules for fees, quotas and complaint portals vary by State, so check your own State’s notifications for those.

    Want the full picture of a parent’s legal rights? The Lexfolio Legal Rights of Parents: Education, Safety, Custody and Family Law is a self-paced certificate course on the legal rights of parents in India, covering education, child safety, custody and family law. Price: Rs 349.

    Myth 1: “No transfer certificate, no admission”

    Section 5 of the RTE Act gives a child the right to seek transfer to another school, and requires the head-teacher of the earlier school to issue the transfer certificate immediately. It also says that delay in producing the certificate shall not be a ground for delaying or denying admission to the new school, and a head-teacher who delays it is liable to disciplinary action. So a school cannot hold a child out of class because the old school has not yet released the papers. Keep copies of your written requests for the certificate, since they show who caused the delay.

    Myth 2: “Without a birth certificate the school can refuse”

    Section 14(2) says that no child shall be denied admission in a school for lack of age proof. Age is normally determined from a birth certificate issued under the Births, Deaths and Marriages Registration Act, 1886, or any other document prescribed, but a missing document is not a ground for refusal. Section 4 adds that a child above six years who has never been admitted, or has not completed elementary education, must be admitted to a class appropriate to his or her age. The school may arrange extra support for the child to catch up, but it cannot turn the child away.

    Myth 3: “Donations and admission tests are normal”

    Section 13(1) says that no school or person shall, while admitting a child, collect any capitation fee, and no child or parent may be subjected to any screening procedure. Section 13(2) sets the penalties: a fine of up to ten times the capitation fee for taking one, and a fine of up to Rs 25,000 for the first screening contravention and up to Rs 50,000 for each subsequent one. This protects admission to elementary classes. Read your admission notice carefully, because the ban is about admission to elementary classes. A “voluntary donation” that is in fact required for a seat is a capitation fee in substance.

    Myth 4: “The 25 per cent quota applies to every school”

    Section 12(1)(c) requires unaided schools and schools of a specified category to admit, in Class I, at least twenty-five per cent of the strength of that class from children belonging to weaker sections and disadvantaged groups in the neighbourhood, and to provide them free education until completion of elementary education. It is a seat reservation in private schools, not a general right to enter any school. Eligibility, income limits, the lottery or selection method, the entry class and the application portal are decided by each State. If a school claims it has no seats, ask the local education office how many reserved seats it has notified. Do not assume your State’s rules are the same as another State’s.

    Myth 5: “A teacher may hit a child to keep discipline”

    Section 17(1) says that no child shall be subjected to physical punishment or mental harassment. Section 17(2) makes a person who contravenes this liable to disciplinary action under the applicable service rules. Humiliating a child before the class, withholding food or washroom access as punishment, or repeated verbal abuse can fall under mental harassment. If a child is seriously injured, the criminal law on hurt and assault can apply on top of the disciplinary route. Keep photographs, medical records and a dated note of what the child said, and give a written complaint to the principal, with a copy to the local education officer.

    Myth 6: “The school can fail and throw out a child at any time”

    Section 16 says that no child shall be expelled from a school till the completion of elementary education. Regular examinations at the end of the academic year are held in Classes 5 and 8, and a child who fails gets additional instruction and a re-examination within two months. After the 2019 amendment, the appropriate government may allow schools to hold back a child in Class 5 or Class 8 if the child fails the re-examination, so whether holding back is allowed depends on the State or the type of school. It is not an automatic right of the school, and it does not extend to expulsion. If your child is told to leave, ask for the order in writing and approach the local authority under section 32.

    Myth 7: “Parents have no say in how a school is run”

    Section 21 requires most schools to constitute a School Management Committee (SMC). At least three-fourths of its members must be parents or guardians of the children, and half of them must be women, with proportionate representation for parents of disadvantaged children. The SMC monitors the school, prepares the school development plan under section 22 and monitors the use of grants. In minority-run schools and in aided schools the SMC has only an advisory role. Ask the school for the names of SMC members and the dates of the last meetings.

    Myth 8: “The RTE Act controls how much a private school can charge”

    The Act bars capitation fees and requires free education for children admitted under the 25 per cent quota. It does not itself set a ceiling on the tuition fee of private schools. Fee regulation comes mainly from State laws and fee committees, and these differ widely. If your concern is a mid-year fee hike, read your State’s law or ask the education department which authority hears fee complaints. Collect fee receipts, circulars and the school’s fee structure, and compare them.

    Where to complain under the Act

    Section 32 allows any person with a grievance relating to a child’s right under the Act to make a written complaint to the local authority, which must decide the matter within three months after giving the parties a hearing. An appeal lies to the State Commission for Protection of Child Rights or the authority prescribed. Section 18 also prohibits a private school from operating without a certificate of recognition, with a fine up to Rs 1 lakh and Rs 10,000 for each day of continuing contravention, so it is worth checking that your child’s school is recognised.

    • Write rather than talk: date the complaint and keep a signed receipt.
    • Quote the section number, which shows that you know the rule.
    • Send the complaint to the head of the school first and then to the local education officer.
    • Keep evidence: receipts, circulars, messages, medical records.
    • Use the section 32 route if the school does not respond.

    Cover school, safety and family law in one course. The Lexfolio Legal Rights of Parents: Education, Safety, Custody and Family Law is a self-paced certificate course on the legal rights of parents in India, covering education, child safety, custody and family law. Price: Rs 349.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can a private school ask for a donation for nursery admission?

    The RTE Act’s ban on capitation fee applies to admission to elementary education. Nursery rules depend on State law and the school’s entry class, so check your State’s admission guidelines.

    Does the RTE Act apply to children above 14?

    The Act gives a right to free and compulsory education from 6 to 14 years, and section 4 allows a child older than six who was never admitted to join a class appropriate to age and continue free until elementary education is complete.

    What can I do if the school refuses the 25 per cent quota seat?

    Make a written complaint to the local authority under section 32, attach your allotment letter and any proof of eligibility, and, if needed, approach the State Commission for Protection of Child Rights on appeal.

    Is corporal punishment a crime?

    It is prohibited under section 17 of the RTE Act, which leads to disciplinary action. Serious injury can also attract criminal provisions, depending on the facts.

    Who is a “parent” for school committee purposes?

    The Act speaks of parents or guardians of children admitted to the school, and the SMC rules in your State will give the process for selecting them.

    This article is general information, not legal advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource, and a qualified lawyer should be consulted about your own situation.