LLexfolio

Category: Guides

  • Women’s Legal Rights in India: Common Myths and the Correct Legal Position

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: Indian law gives women real rights over property, a shared home, protection from violence, free legal help and a safe workplace, but many are lost to myths: that a daughter has no share, that a complaint means leaving home, that a police station can refuse an FIR for “wrong jurisdiction”, or that a workplace complaint can be made any time. This guide corrects nine such myths, with the provision or ruling behind each.

    Where the law has been renumbered, we use the current provision. The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) and the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) replaced the Indian Penal Code and the Code of Criminal Procedure from 1 July 2024. The domestic violence, succession and workplace statutes are older Acts that still apply. General information only: your case needs your own facts examined.

    Want the full picture? The Lexfolio Women’s Legal Rights in India is a self-paced certificate course on the main legal rights of women in India, from family and property to safety and the workplace. Price: Rs 299.

    Myth 1: A daughter has no share in her father’s property

    The position: since the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, a daughter of a Hindu coparcener is a coparcener by birth, in the same way as a son, in a Hindu joint family. In Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma (2020), a three-judge bench of the Supreme Court held that the right is by birth, that the father need not have been alive on 9 September 2005, and that the Court’s earlier contrary view in Prakash v. Phulavati was overruled on that point. The Court also said that a daughter’s rights are subject to any disposition, alienation, testamentary disposition or partition that was completed before 20 December 2004, and that an oral partition is not generally accepted unless it is supported by strong public documents in exceptional cases. A father’s self-acquired property can still be left by will to anyone, but if he dies without a will, daughters are among the Class I heirs who inherit together with the sons, the widow and the mother.

    Myth 2: If a wife complains, she has to leave the marital home

    The position: section 17 of the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 gives every woman in a domestic relationship the right to reside in the shared household, whether or not she has any title or interest in it, and says she cannot be evicted or excluded except by the procedure established by law. A shared household, under section 2(s), includes a household where she lives or has lived with the respondent, owned or rented by either or both, and a joint family household of which the respondent is a member. Under section 19 a Magistrate can restrain the respondent from dispossessing her or disturbing her possession, direct him to leave the shared household (such an order cannot be made against a woman), bar entry into the portion she lives in, or order alternative accommodation of the same standard or payment of rent.

    Myth 3: The Domestic Violence Act is only for beaten wives

    The position: the Act speaks of a “domestic relationship”, which section 2(f) defines as a relationship between persons who live or have lived together in a shared household and are related by blood, marriage, a relationship in the nature of marriage, adoption, or as members of a joint family. Relief is not confined to a physically injured wife. The reliefs include protection orders (section 18), residence orders (section 19), monetary relief covering expenses, loss of earnings, medical costs and maintenance (section 20), temporary custody of children (section 21) and compensation for injuries including mental torture and emotional distress (section 22).

    Myth 4: A case must start with an FIR, and it takes years

    The position: a woman can seek these civil reliefs by an application to the Magistrate under section 12, without first lodging an FIR. The aggrieved person, a Protection Officer or anyone acting on her behalf may apply. The first hearing is ordinarily to be fixed within three days of the application being received (section 12(4)), and the Magistrate is to endeavour to dispose of the application within sixty days of the first hearing (section 12(5)). Section 23 allows interim orders, and an ex parte order may be granted if the aggrieved person’s affidavit prima facie shows that domestic violence has occurred or is likely. Courts do not always keep these time limits, but they are the statutory targets, and they can be cited when asking for early dates. Breach of a protection order is an offence under section 31, with imprisonment up to one year, a fine up to Rs 20,000, or both.

    Myth 5: The police can refuse an FIR because the crime happened elsewhere

    The position: BNSS section 173 provides for registration of information about a cognizable offence irrespective of the area where it was committed. This is what is called a zero FIR: it is registered at the police station you went to and then transferred to the station with jurisdiction. Information can also be given electronically, but an e-FIR is recorded only after the informant signs it within three days. The informant and the victim are each entitled to a copy of the FIR free of cost. If the police do not act, write to the superior police officer and consider the remedies a lawyer can advise on.

    Myth 6: A woman can be arrested at any hour

    The position: section 43(5) of the BNSS, which corresponds to section 46(4) of the old Code, provides that a woman is not to be arrested between sunset and sunrise, except in exceptional circumstances. In such a case a woman police officer must obtain the prior written permission of the jurisdictional Magistrate before making the arrest. Courts have examined breaches of this safeguard. If you or a relative face such an arrest, ask the officer to show the Magistrate’s permission and call a lawyer or the legal aid authority.

    Myth 7: Lawyers are too expensive, so there is nothing I can do

    The position: under section 12 of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, women and children are among the categories entitled to free legal services. The National Legal Services Authority’s description of eligibility says that women qualify regardless of income. Legal services authorities exist at the taluka, district, State and national levels. Section 5 of the Domestic Violence Act also requires police officers, Protection Officers, service providers and Magistrates to tell an aggrieved woman about her right to free legal services.

    Myth 8: A workplace harassment complaint can be filed whenever I feel ready

    The position: under the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013, a written complaint to the Internal Committee should be made within three months of the incident (or of the last incident in a series), and the Committee can extend this by a further three months if it is satisfied that circumstances prevented a timely complaint. Every workplace with ten or more employees must have an Internal Committee, and the Local Committee at the district level handles smaller workplaces and cases where no Internal Committee exists. The inquiry is to be completed within 90 days, the report goes to the employer within 10 days thereafter, and the employer should act on the recommendations within 60 days. An appeal can be made within 90 days of the decision. The Ministry of Women and Child Development’s SHe-Box portal (shebox.wcd.gov.in) is a single window for registering such complaints. Act early, and keep dates, messages and names of witnesses.

    Myth 9: Cruelty by in-laws is only a family matter

    The position: section 85 of the BNS makes it an offence for a husband or his relative to subject a woman to cruelty, punishable with imprisonment up to three years and a fine. It replaced section 498A of the Indian Penal Code, with the same punishment. Section 86 defines cruelty in two ways: wilful conduct likely to drive the woman to suicide or to cause grave injury or danger to her life, limb or health, physical or mental; or harassment to force her or her relatives to meet an unlawful demand for property or valuable security. Only one of these needs to be shown. The offence is cognizable and non-bailable and, as a general rule, non-compoundable, although some States have changed the compounding rule locally. Ordinary quarrels are not enough by themselves, and courts examine allegations carefully, so details of dates and incidents matter.

    Summary table

    MythCorrect positionSource
    Daughters have no shareDaughters are coparceners by birth; father need not have been alive on 9 Sept 2005Hindu Succession Act s.6; Vineeta Sharma (2020)
    Complaint means leaving homeRight to reside in the shared householdDV Act s.17, s.19
    Need an FIR firstApply to the Magistrate; first hearing ordinarily within 3 daysDV Act s.12
    FIR refused for jurisdictionZero FIR is allowed; free copy of the FIRBNSS s.173
    Women can be arrested at nightNot between sunset and sunrise except exceptionally, with Magistrate’s prior permissionBNSS s.43(5)
    Legal help costs moneyWomen are entitled to free legal servicesLegal Services Authorities Act s.12
    No time limit at workComplaint within 3 months, extendable by 3POSH Act, 2013

    Frequently asked questions

    Can a daughter ask for a share in ancestral property?

    Yes, a daughter is a coparcener by birth in a Hindu joint family after the 2005 amendment, subject to partitions and dispositions completed before 20 December 2004. Facts such as the nature of the property and earlier partitions matter, so a lawyer should see the papers.

    Do I need a lawyer to apply under the Domestic Violence Act?

    The application can be made by the aggrieved person, a Protection Officer or someone on her behalf. A lawyer helps to draft it, and free legal services are available to women under the Legal Services Authorities Act.

    What if the police refuse to register my FIR?

    Ask for the reason in writing, stress that BNSS section 173 requires registration of information on a cognizable offence irrespective of where it took place, and approach the superior police officer. A lawyer can tell you about further remedies.

    Is maintenance only available to a wife who is living with her husband?

    No. Section 144 of the BNSS covers a wife who cannot maintain herself, and the term includes a woman who has been divorced by her husband, or who obtained a divorce from him, and has not remarried. Whether you qualify depends on your facts.

    Does the three month limit in a POSH complaint ever extend?

    The Internal Committee may extend the time by up to another three months if it is satisfied that circumstances prevented the woman from complaining within the first three months.

    Go beyond this guide. Continue with the Lexfolio Women’s Legal Rights in India, a self-paced certificate course on the main legal rights of women in India, from family and property to safety and the workplace. Price: Rs 299.

    This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice for a specific case. Laws, rules and fees change and differ by state, so check the current text or consult a lawyer for your situation. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • Women’s Legal Rights in Everyday Situations: Seven Scenarios and What the Law Says

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: The right route depends on the problem. Violence or exclusion at home points to the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 and section 85 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS). Harassment at work points to the Internal Committee under the POSH Act, 2013. Stalking and online harassment are criminal offences under the BNS. A refusal of money points to maintenance under section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS). The seven illustrations below are fictional, and each one gives the legal position and a practical next step.

    Names and facts in the illustrations are invented to show how the law works. They are not real cases. The provisions cited are real. Practice differs by district and by State, so use this as a guide and not as a substitute for advice on your own facts.

    Want the full picture? The Lexfolio Women’s Legal Rights in India is a self-paced certificate course on the main legal rights of women in India, from family and property to safety and the workplace. Price: Rs 299.

    Illustration 1: Locked out after a dowry demand

    Illustration: Pooja was married eight months ago. Her husband and his parents keep demanding a car from her family and have now locked her out of the house after an argument. She has no money with her.

    Legal position: Pooja has a right to reside in the shared household under section 17 of the Domestic Violence Act, whether or not she owns any part of it, and she can be removed only by the procedure established by law. She can apply to the Magistrate under section 12 for a residence order (section 19), monetary relief (section 20) and protection (section 18). Harassment aimed at forcing her or her relatives to meet an unlawful demand for property falls within the definition of cruelty in section 86 of the BNS, and section 85 punishes a husband or his relative who subjects a woman to such cruelty with imprisonment up to three years and a fine. What to do: go to a safe place, contact the Protection Officer or the police, photograph the lock-out and keep any messages that mention the demand. Ask for an interim order and an ex parte order if needed, since section 23(2) allows one on an affidavit that prima facie shows violence is likely.

    Illustration 2: The classmate who keeps tracking her online

    Illustration: Anita told a former classmate she was not interested in a relationship. He still messages her on several platforms, shows up near her hostel and comments on her photos to show that he sees her activity.

    Legal position: section 78 of the BNS punishes stalking by a man: following a woman and contacting or trying to contact her repeatedly to foster personal interaction despite a clear indication of disinterest, and monitoring her use of the internet, email or other electronic communication. The punishment for a first conviction is imprisonment up to three years and a fine, and for a second or later conviction up to five years and a fine. The section has three exceptions, which the accused must prove: crime prevention by an authorised person, compliance with a law, or conduct that was reasonable and justified. Stalking on a first conviction is generally classed as cognizable and bailable. What to do: stop replying, take screenshots with dates, record places and times of the visits, tell the hostel warden and report to the police. You can lodge the information at any police station as a zero FIR under BNSS section 173 and ask for a free copy.

    Illustration 3: Remarks by a senior at work

    Illustration: Rekha works in a company with 40 employees. Her manager makes sexual remarks in meetings and has sent her suggestive messages. The most recent incident was last week, and the first was five months ago.

    Legal position: the POSH Act, 2013 requires an Internal Committee in a workplace with ten or more employees. A written complaint should be made within three months of the incident, or of the last incident in a series, and the Committee may extend the time by a further three months for reasons recorded. Since the last incident was a week ago, Rekha is well within time even though the first incident was five months back. Inquiry is to be completed within 90 days, the report goes to the employer within 10 days of completion, and the employer is expected to act within 60 days. An appeal lies within 90 days. Sexual remarks and unwelcome overtures can also be an offence under section 75 of the BNS, which provides imprisonment up to three years for unwelcome physical advances, demands for sexual favours or showing pornography against the woman’s will, and up to one year for sexually coloured remarks. What to do: keep the messages, write down dates and witnesses, and file a written complaint with the Internal Committee. The SHe-Box portal (shebox.wcd.gov.in) is available as a single window. Note that the Internal Committee process and the criminal route are separate.

    Illustration 4: A late night call to appear at the police station

    Illustration: At 11 pm, police come to Shabana’s home and tell her to come with them for a case involving her brother. She is not accused of an offence in the information she was given.

    Legal position: section 43(5) of the BNSS says that a woman is not to be arrested between sunset and sunrise, except in exceptional circumstances, and then only with the prior written permission of the jurisdictional Magistrate obtained by a woman police officer. Asking her to “come along” without arrest and without that permission needs scrutiny. What to do: stay calm, ask the officers for their names, ranks and the reason in writing, ask whether she is being arrested and, if so, to see the Magistrate’s permission, call a family member and a lawyer, and contact the District Legal Services Authority, since women are entitled to free legal services under section 12 of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987.

    Illustration 5: Divorced, with a child and no income

    Illustration: Meena obtained a divorce last year. She lives with her ten-year-old son and has no income. Her former husband has a stable job and refuses to pay anything.

    Legal position: section 144 of the BNSS allows a Magistrate of the first class to order a person with sufficient means who neglects or refuses to maintain his wife who cannot maintain herself, or his child, to pay a monthly allowance. The term wife includes a woman who has been divorced by her husband or has obtained a divorce from him and has not remarried. The Magistrate fixes the rate as he or she thinks fit, can order interim maintenance with the expenses of the proceedings, and an application for interim maintenance should as far as possible be disposed of within sixty days of service of notice. Where there was domestic violence, section 20 of the Domestic Violence Act also lets the Magistrate order monetary relief and section 21 temporary custody of the child. What to do: collect her expenses, the child’s school and medical bills, and whatever shows his income, such as pay slips or bank details. Apply for interim maintenance in the first filing.

    Illustration 6: A brother says the land belongs only to the sons

    Illustration: Sunita’s father died in 2018 without a will. The family holds ancestral land in a Hindu joint family. Her brothers say that the land is for sons only, and that daughters were “married off with gifts”.

    Legal position: in Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma, decided on 11 August 2020, a three-judge bench of the Supreme Court held that a daughter is a coparcener by birth under section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 as amended in 2005, with the same rights as a son, and that the father need not have been alive on 9 September 2005. The daughter’s rights are subject to any disposition, alienation, testamentary disposition or partition completed before 20 December 2004, and an oral partition is generally not accepted without a registered deed or court decree, apart from exceptions backed by public documents. What to do: obtain the revenue records and any partition papers, check whether a registered partition took place before 20 December 2004, and send a notice asking for her share. Seek legal advice before filing for partition, because the nature of the property (self-acquired or ancestral) changes the legal route.

    Illustration 7: The police station that says come back to the right area

    Illustration: Lakshmi was assaulted by her employer in another city while on a work trip. Back home, the local police tell her to go to the other city to file.

    Legal position: BNSS section 173 provides for the registration of information about a cognizable offence irrespective of the area where it was committed, which is the basis of zero FIR. The police then transfer it to the station that has jurisdiction. An e-FIR is recorded only after the informant signs it within three days, and the informant and the victim are entitled to a free copy. What to do: give written information, ask for the FIR number and the free copy, and note the date and the officer. If the police do not register it, approach the superior officer and ask a lawyer about further remedies.

    A short list to keep in your phone

    • Photos, screenshots and messages with dates, backed up outside your device.
    • Names and numbers of witnesses.
    • Copies of ID, marriage proof, children’s papers and property papers.
    • The Protection Officer’s and the District Legal Services Authority’s contact details for your district.
    • The emergency number 112.

    Frequently asked questions

    Which law do I use for harassment at home and which for harassment at work?

    Harassment at home is covered by the Domestic Violence Act, 2005 and section 85 of the BNS. Sexual harassment at work is covered by the POSH Act, 2013, through the Internal Committee, and it may also be an offence under the BNS.

    Is stalking a bailable offence?

    On a first conviction, stalking under section 78 of the BNS is generally classed as cognizable and bailable. On a second or subsequent conviction it is cognizable and non-bailable. Always check the current statute with a lawyer.

    Can I file a complaint at work after three months?

    The Internal Committee can extend the time by up to another three months if it is satisfied that circumstances prevented you from filing earlier. Do not wait for that.

    Do I need my husband’s consent to claim maintenance?

    No. Maintenance under section 144 of the BNSS is a claim against the husband and does not need his consent. You must show that you cannot maintain yourself and that he has sufficient means and neglects or refuses to maintain you.

    Where can I get a lawyer if I cannot afford one?

    Women are entitled to free legal services under section 12 of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987. Approach the District Legal Services Authority.

    Go beyond this guide. Continue with the Lexfolio Women’s Legal Rights in India, a self-paced certificate course on the main legal rights of women in India, from family and property to safety and the workplace. Price: Rs 299.

    This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice for a specific case. Laws, rules and fees change and differ by state, so check the current text or consult a lawyer for your situation. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • What a School Must Do After a POCSO Complaint: Step by Step

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: When a child tells a teacher about sexual abuse, the school should listen without interrogating, make the child safe, and report to the Special Juvenile Police Unit (SJPU) or the local police without waiting for an internal inquiry. The reporting duty comes from section 19 of the POCSO Act, 2012, and a failure to report is punishable under section 21. This guide sets out the sequence in the order events usually happen, so that a principal or designated staff member can follow it under pressure. It does not replace advice from a lawyer or the instructions of the police in a particular case, and procedures can differ in detail between States.

    Setting up a child protection process? The Lexfolio POCSO and Child Protection for Schools and Institutions is a self-paced certificate course on POCSO and child protection duties for schools and other institutions that work with children. Price: Rs 499.

    The sequence at a glance

    StepActionLegal anchor
    1Listen, reassure, note the child’s own wordsGood practice; Act requires simple language when a child reports
    2Secure the child’s immediate safety and healthSection 19(5): police arrange care where needed
    3Tell the head or the designated person at onceInstitution’s duty; section 21(2) for persons in charge
    4Report to the SJPU or local police and get an entry numberSection 19(1) and 19(2)
    5Do not confront the accused or run a parallel investigationProtects the investigation
    6Protect identity and recordsSection 23 and the rules on confidentiality
    7Support the child and cooperate with CWC and the policePOCSO Rules, 2020
    8Review safety and document the learningSchool Safety Guidelines, 2021

    Step 1: Listen, and do not interrogate

    The first adult a child confides in sets the tone for everything that follows. Keep your voice calm, sit at the child’s level, and let the child speak in her own words. Do not ask leading questions, do not ask for details beyond what is needed to understand that the child may be unsafe, and do not promise to keep it a secret. A simple honest statement works: “I am glad you told me. It is not your fault. I need to tell people whose job is to keep you safe.” Write down, as soon as possible, what the child said in the exact words used, the date, time and place, and who was present. Do not ask the child to write a statement or repeat the account to several staff members.

    Step 2: Make sure the child is safe and, if necessary, medically seen

    If the suspected person is a staff member, another student or a transport employee, keep the child away from that person. If the child is injured, in pain or distressed, arrange for the nearest hospital. Under section 19(5), where the police are satisfied that a child needs care and protection, they must record their reasons and arrange for it, including a shelter home or hospital, within twenty-four hours of the report, and under section 19(6) they must report the matter to the Child Welfare Committee (CWC) and the Special Court within twenty-four hours. The POCSO Rules, 2020 also require that where the police receive information and are satisfied that a child needs urgent medical care, the child is taken to the nearest hospital or medical facility within twenty-four hours. A school that acts at once on safety makes this easier for everyone.

    If the child is in immediate danger, call the police first. Childline 1098, the national child helpline, can also help with urgent support, and the CBSE circular asks schools to display it prominently.

    Step 3: Inform the head or designated person, without delay

    Every school should have a named person for child protection. The teacher who received the disclosure should pass it to that person or the principal the same day, in writing, and keep a copy. This is an internal handover, not an approval step. Nobody in the chain has the power to decide that the report will not be made. Remember that section 21(2) puts a person in charge of an institution at risk of up to one year of imprisonment and a fine if an offence by a subordinate is not reported.

    Step 4: Report to the SJPU or local police

    Section 19(1) names the SJPU or the local police as the recipients. Under section 19(2), every report must be given an entry number, recorded in writing, read over to the informant and entered in a book kept by the unit. Ask for the entry number and, once an FIR is registered, a copy of it. The POCSO Rules, 2020 provide that the police must give the informant a free copy of the FIR. Note the name and rank of the officer, the time, and the number you were given.

    What should the report contain? State the child’s name and class, the facts disclosed in the child’s own words, the date and place of the alleged incident if known, the name of the suspected person, and what the school has done to keep the child safe. Do not exaggerate and do not leave out facts because they are uncomfortable. If you are not sure whether something is an offence, report it and let the police decide. A report given in good faith carries no civil or criminal liability under section 19(7). NCPCR’s POCSO e-Box is another route for reports, mentioned in the 2021 school safety Guidelines, but it should supplement, not replace, the report to the police.

    Step 5: Inform the parents carefully

    In most cases the parents should be told promptly and supported. The exception is where the suspected person is a family member or lives in the same household. In that case the police and the CWC need to decide how the child is protected, and telling that parent first can put the child at risk. If you are unsure, ask the police officer who recorded your report how and when the family should be informed. Never ask the parents to “sort it out” with the school or the accused.

    Step 6: Keep the accused away from the child, but do not investigate

    The school should ensure that the accused has no access to the child, and for a staff member, consider whether to remove him or her from duties involving children while the police act. Employment action, such as suspension, is a separate decision, and it should be taken on legal advice so that it does not interfere with the investigation. Do not confront or question the accused about the allegations, do not ask other children to write statements, and do not conduct a parallel inquiry that could contaminate evidence.

    Preserve what might matter: CCTV footage for the relevant dates, attendance and duty rosters, bus logs, complaint box slips, and messages received. Give the police what they ask for, and hand over originals only against a written receipt.

    Step 7: Protect the child’s identity

    Section 23 restricts the media from disclosing the identity of a child, including name, address, photograph, family details and school, unless the Special Court permits it in writing in the child’s interest. Schools are not media, but the same principle should govern staff conduct. Limit knowledge to those who need to know, do not discuss the case in staff groups or with other parents, and do not announce the matter at an assembly. Prepare a short holding statement for enquiries, and refer media to the police.

    Step 8: Support the child and work with the CWC

    Under the POCSO Rules, 2020, the CWC can, with the consent of the child and the parent or guardian, appoint a support person to assist the child through the investigation and trial; the police must inform the Special Court of this within twenty-four hours. Rule 9 deals with compensation: the Special Court may order interim compensation after the FIR is registered, and the State Government pays within thirty days of receiving the order. A school counsellor can help the child return to routine, but should not conduct therapy for the case or discuss details. Offer flexible attendance and exam arrangements. Watch for retaliation or teasing by other students.

    Step 9: Review and strengthen

    When the immediate response is done, review how the incident came to light, whether the complaint box and helpline display worked, and whether any supervision gap allowed it. The Guidelines on School Safety and Security, 2021, which the Supreme Court directed States and Union Territories to implement in September 2024, make school management responsible for child safety. Rule 3 of the POCSO Rules requires institutions that house children or have regular contact with them to organise periodic child safety and protection training. Record the date of each training session and the staff who attended.

    Learn the reporting duty, the Rules and a school protocol in one course. The Lexfolio POCSO and Child Protection for Schools and Institutions is a self-paced certificate course on POCSO and child protection duties for schools and other institutions that work with children. Price: Rs 499.

    Frequently asked questions

    How soon must a school report a POCSO case?

    The Act does not give schools a number of days, but section 19 requires reporting on knowledge or apprehension, and delay can lead to action under section 21. The safe approach is to report the same day.

    Who should the school report to?

    The Special Juvenile Police Unit or the local police under section 19(1). The report must be recorded in writing, given an entry number and read back to the person making it.

    Can the school suspend a staff member who is accused?

    Employment action is separate from the report to the police. Take legal advice first, so that the step is fair and does not interfere with the investigation, and keep the accused away from children in the meantime.

    Is an internal inquiry committee still required?

    A school may have a complaints committee for receiving complaints and supporting students, as the CBSE circular suggests, but it does not replace or delay the report to the police.

    Will the child have to come to court?

    The Special Court conducts the trial under the Act and the Rules provide for support persons and child-friendly procedures. The police and the court decide how and when the child gives evidence.

    This article is general information, not legal advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource, and a qualified lawyer should be consulted about your own situation.

  • How to Verify AI Legal Research and Drafts: Checklist for Indian Lawyers

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: treat everything a language tool gives you as an unverified lead. Before it goes into a notice, a plaint, a written submission or an opinion, each authority must be located on a reliable source, read in the original, checked for quotations and current status, and recorded in a short verification log. This is the workflow a careful Indian advocate or law student can follow for every draft.

    Why now? In 2026 the Supreme Court has repeatedly warned about fabricated citations. On 17 February 2026 it noted pleadings that seemed to have been prepared with AI platforms without adequate human scrutiny. In Gummadi Usha Rani v. Sure Mallikarjuna Rao the Court said on 27 February 2026 that reliance on non-existent judgments is not a mere error, and on 5 May 2026 it said parties cannot rely on AI-generated material and then apologise. It also said it does not seek to prohibit AI. The Bar Council of India has told Parliament that advocates cannot escape professional liability by blaming technology. A repeatable checking routine is therefore part of competent practice.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI for Lawyers and Law Students, a self-paced certificate course on using AI tools in legal research and drafting, for lawyers and law students. Course price: Rs 499.

    The workflow at a glance

    StageWhat you doOutput
    ———
    1Decide what the tool may and may not doTask note
    2Prepare the input without client identifiersSafe prompt
    3Generate, then extract every legal claimClaims list
    4Verify each case on a reliable sourceVerification log
    5Verify each statute and section numberCurrent text checked
    6Check quotations and paragraph numbersVerbatim quotes
    7Check status: overruled, distinguished, stayedGood law check
    8Final human review and sign offSigned draft

    Step 1: Fix the role of the tool before you start

    Write one line saying what you are using the tool for: for example, “list issues and counter arguments”, “turn my notes into a draft chronology”, or “simplify this paragraph”. Do not use it as a source of law and do not use it to decide what the law is. The Kerala High Court’s policy for the district judiciary (19 July 2025) draws a similar line for judges: assistive use only, and no use for decision making or legal reasoning. It is not a rule for advocates, but it shows the principle courts accept.

    Step 2: Protect confidentiality in the input

    Section 132 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 bars an advocate from disclosing professional communications without the client’s express consent, subject to exceptions. The Supreme Court’s judgment of 31 October 2025 on summoning advocates (2025 INSC 1275) treated the privilege as one that belongs to the client and extends to litigation and non-litigious advice. Before you paste anything:

    • remove names, addresses, account numbers, case numbers and anything that identifies the client or the other side
    • replace facts with neutral labels (Party A, Party B, Company X)
    • use only a tool your chambers or firm has approved, on a plan whose terms you have read for storage and training use
    • do not upload the whole file when a three line description of the issue will do

    Step 3: Extract every legal claim from the output

    Read the answer once for sense, then go through it and list each claim that needs a source: every case name, court, year, citation, section number, quotation and legal proposition. Number them. A paragraph that sounds neutral can contain five checkable claims.

    Step 4: Verify each case on a reliable source

    For every case on your list:

    1. Find the judgment itself on the court’s own website, a recognised law report database (SCC Online, Manupatra or a similar subscription service) or a reputable public judgments repository. Do not accept a blog or the tool’s own link as proof.
    2. Match the neutral citation or report citation, court, date and parties. The Supreme Court now uses neutral citations in the form “2025 INSC 1275”.
    3. Read the part that you rely on. Note the paragraph number.
    4. Note the bench strength and whether it is a majority or a minority view.
    5. If you cannot find the case, assume it does not exist and remove it. Do not “fix” the citation by guessing.

    Step 5: Verify statutes and section numbers

    Check the current text on the India Code portal or in the Gazette. For anything involving crime, procedure or evidence, make sure you are using the right Act:

    SubjectLaw from 1 July 2024Replaced
    ———
    OffencesBharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023Indian Penal Code, 1860
    Criminal procedureBharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
    EvidenceBharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023Indian Evidence Act, 1872

    Offences before 1 July 2024 are generally dealt with under the old laws, so the date of the alleged offence matters. Example of a changed section number: cheating is section 318 BNS, and electronic records are proved under section 63 BSA. Also check state amendments and later notifications.

    Step 6: Check every quotation

    Copy quotations only from the judgment or the statute, never from the tool. Put them in quotation marks and add the paragraph number. The Supreme Court noted on 17 February 2026 that some filings cited real rulings but quoted passages that do not appear in them. If you paraphrase, make sure the paraphrase matches what the court actually held, not what it discussed and rejected.

    Step 7: Check that the authority is still good law

    Run the case through a citator and read the later decisions that follow, distinguish or overrule it. Check whether a larger bench has spoken since, whether a review or curative petition has changed the position, and whether the law was amended after the judgment. A pre-2024 decision on the IPC may still state a useful principle, but its section numbers will not match the BNS.

    Step 8: Keep a verification log

    A simple table protects you if a judge or client asks how you checked. Keep it with the file.

    No.AuthorityCourt and dateSource openedParagraphQuote checkedStatus checkedChecked by
    ————————
    1[name and citation][court, date][database or site][para]YesYes[initials, date]
    2[name and citation][court, date][database or site][para]YesYes[initials, date]

    Step 9: Final review and sign off

    The advocate who signs is the one responsible. Read the whole draft again as the opposing counsel would. Make sure every factual statement matches the client’s documents, and that the draft complies with the format and any practice direction of the court where it will be filed. A draft Supreme Court AI policy for courts was released for comments on 3 June 2026; whether and how it or any High Court direction applies to filings is something to check before you file, since the position may change.

    Step 10: Decide what to tell the client and the court

    If a client has asked, or if a court or tribunal requires a declaration, say honestly how the tool was used. Where nothing is required, many lawyers still tell clients in the engagement letter that tools may support drafting but a lawyer reviews all work. Keep the log in case any question arises.

    Illustration of a rejected citation: You ask a tool for authority that a particular clause is unenforceable. It gives a case name, a High Court and a year. You search the High Court’s website and two paid databases and find nothing with that name or neutral citation. Under this workflow, that authority is deleted and the point is researched afresh from the statute and from decisions you can read.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI for Lawyers and Law Students, a self-paced certificate course on using AI tools in legal research and drafting, for lawyers and law students. Course price: Rs 499.

    Frequently asked questions

    Which sources count as reliable for checking a case?

    A: The court’s own website, a recognised subscription law report database, or the printed law report. Use the same source to check the neutral citation, bench and paragraph. A blog post or the tool’s own answer does not count.

    Do I need to disclose AI use to the court?

    A: There is no general rule in force that applies to all advocates in all courts at present. Check the practice directions of the court concerned, because courts and the Bar Council are still developing their positions. If asked, answer honestly.

    Can I use a tool just for drafting and not for research?

    A: Yes, as a drafting aid, but facts, law and citations in the draft remain your responsibility and must be checked. Do not enter confidential material into an unapproved tool.

    How long should verification take?

    A: It depends on the length of the draft and the number of authorities, but the time spent checking should be planned in. If verification would take longer than researching from scratch, research from scratch.

    This article is general information, not legal, financial or tax advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services.

  • Vendor and Customer Contract Disputes in India: 6 Scenarios and What to Do

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: most contract disputes follow a handful of patterns: late delivery, a claim of impossibility, a missed renewal, a doubtful termination, unpaid bills and a change agreed informally. The six scenarios below are illustrations invented to show the legal position and a sensible next step in each. The parties and figures are made up.

    Learn the process behind these outcomes. The Lexfolio Contract Management and Negotiation for Managers is a self-paced certificate course on contract management and negotiation for managers. Price: Rs 499.

    Illustration 1: The customer who cancels a custom order

    Situation. Shreya’s workshop makes made-to-order office furniture. A client paid 30 per cent in advance, and the contract says the advance is non-refundable. Three weeks later, with the timber already cut, the client cancels the order.

    Legal position. The clause is a stipulation of a sum payable on breach, so section 74 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 is the starting point. The party complaining of breach is entitled to reasonable compensation not exceeding the amount named. A court looks at whether keeping the whole advance is reasonable in view of the loss actually likely to follow, and may allow less if the sum is out of proportion. The workshop’s position is far stronger if it can show what it spent: materials bought, labour used and any resale loss.

    What to do. Send a written notice acknowledging the cancellation as a breach by the client, setting out the costs incurred with supporting bills, and stating how much of the advance the workshop retains and why. Offer to refund any balance. In future contracts, link the forfeiture to stages of work, for example 10 per cent before cutting and 30 per cent after.

    Illustration 2: The service provider who switches off the service

    Situation. An IT services firm stops support to Imran’s company because an invoice is 45 days overdue. Imran’s company disputes the invoice, saying part of the work was not delivered. The contract allows suspension for non-payment ‘after written notice’ and says disputed amounts must be raised within 15 days of the invoice.

    Legal position. Whether the suspension is lawful depends on the clause. If the provider gave the required written notice and the dispute was not raised in time, it may be within its rights. If it suspended without notice, or the invoice was properly disputed within the window, the suspension may itself be a breach, exposing the provider to a claim for damages under section 73. The client, for its part, should pay the undisputed part so that it cannot be accused of non-payment.

    What to do. The client should pay the undisputed amount, send a reasoned dispute note on the rest, and ask for restoration of service under the escalation clause. The provider should check its notice and the timing before continuing the suspension. Both should keep a record of losses, since each side must take reasonable steps to reduce them.

    Illustration 3: The software contract that renewed itself

    Situation. A firm signed a two year software licence. The clause said the licence renews automatically for a further year unless either party gives 60 days’ written notice before expiry. The firm’s IT head, who negotiated it, left. Nobody gave notice, and the invoice for a new year arrived.

    Legal position. The renewal clause is part of the contract the firm signed. Unless the vendor agrees to waive, the firm is likely bound for the renewal period, and refusing to pay may be a breach. The point is about contract management more than law: the renewal date was a risk with no owner.

    What to do. Write to the vendor immediately, ask for a waiver or for a shorter renewal as a goodwill gesture, and offer a longer relationship or a different product in return. For future contracts, record renewal dates in a shared calendar with a named owner and a reminder at least three weeks before the notice date.

    Illustration 4: A termination that may itself be a breach

    Situation. A distributor repeatedly misses sales targets. Dev’s company e-mails a ‘termination with immediate effect’ note to the distributor’s general e-mail address. The contract allows termination for material breach only after 30 days’ written notice to cure, sent to the registered office.

    Legal position. A termination that does not follow the contract’s procedure can be challenged as wrongful, and a wrongful termination can expose the terminating party to damages under section 73. The distributor may argue that the e-mail did not comply with the notice clause and that it was given no chance to cure.

    What to do. Withdraw the defective notice without prejudice to rights, issue a proper notice of breach and cure period to the address in the contract, keep records of the missed targets, and calendar the cure date. Terminate only if the breach continues after the cure period.

    Illustration 5: The micro enterprise that has not been paid

    Situation. A micro enterprise in Lucknow supplied components to a large buyer under a contract that said payment in 90 days. The buyer paid after 140 days and refused interest, saying that the contract fixed the period.

    Legal position. The Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 requires a buyer to pay a micro or small supplier within the agreed time, which cannot exceed 45 days from the day of acceptance or deemed acceptance. Where the buyer fails, it is liable to pay compound interest, with monthly rests, at three times the bank rate notified by the Reserve Bank of India. Disputes can be taken to the Micro and Small Enterprise Facilitation Council, which is expected to decide a reference within 90 days. The supplier’s registration status on the date of the contract matters, so check the Udyam registration.

    What to do. Send a written demand for the principal and the statutory interest, file with the Facilitation Council if unpaid, and keep acceptance records. A buyer who appeals against an award must deposit 75 per cent of the amount awarded before the court will entertain an application to set it aside.

    Illustration 6: The rate changed on a chat message

    Situation. An agency’s account manager and a client’s marketing head agree on WhatsApp that the monthly fee will rise by 15 per cent. The master agreement says variations must be in writing signed by both parties’ authorised signatories. Three months later the client’s finance team pays only the old fee.

    Legal position. Parties may alter a contract by agreement under section 62 of the Contract Act, and contracts can be formed by electronic means under section 10A of the Information Technology Act, 2000. The difficulty is the contract’s own variation clause and the authority of the marketing head. The client can argue that the chat did not satisfy the clause. The agency can argue that the client’s conduct showed agreement. The result is uncertain and expensive to prove.

    What to do. The agency should send a formal amendment letter now for signature and invoice the difference with a reasoned note. Next time, treat any change in price as a document needing signatures from authorised people.

    Before any dispute reaches court

    • Collect the contract, amendments, notices and the e-mail trail.
    • List the dates: breach, notices, cure periods and the three year limitation date.
    • Check for an escalation clause and an arbitration clause.
    • For a commercial suit without urgent interim relief, complete pre-institution mediation under section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, which the Supreme Court has held to be mandatory.
    • Weigh cost and time against the amount at stake and the value of the relationship.

    Handle disputes before they become cases. The Lexfolio Contract Management and Negotiation for Managers is a self-paced certificate course on contract management and negotiation for managers. Price: Rs 499.

    Frequently asked questions

    What damages can I claim for breach of contract?

    Section 73 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 allows compensation for loss that naturally arose in the usual course of things from the breach, or that the parties knew when they made the contract to be likely to result from it. Remote and indirect loss is not compensated. The injured party is expected to take reasonable steps to reduce the loss.

    Is a reminder e-mail enough to preserve my rights?

    It helps as evidence, but it does not by itself stop limitation running. Where the contract says notices must be in a particular form, follow it. For a claim near the end of the three year period, take legal advice about filing.

    Should I stop performing if the other side breaches?

    Not automatically. If you stop without a right to do so, you may be in breach yourself. Check the termination, suspension and cure provisions, give the required notice, and keep performing what you must until your right to stop is clear.

    Can I recover legal costs from the other side?

    Courts and arbitral tribunals have power to award costs, and the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 provides a costs regime for commercial suits. The amount depends on the forum and the conduct of the parties, so costs are never certain.

    Where do MSME payment disputes go?

    The Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 provides for reference of delayed payment disputes to the Micro and Small Enterprise Facilitation Council of the state. Suppliers can file through the government’s online portal or in writing.

    The scenarios are invented illustrations, not reports of real cases or real parties, and every real dispute turns on its own wording and facts. This article is general information, not legal advice for a specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • Tenant and Landlord Myths in India: 10 Mistakes and the Correct Law

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: Rent in India is governed by a mix of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, the Registration Act, 1908, your written agreement and, importantly, state rent laws. Many popular beliefs, such as “an 11 month agreement is the legal limit” or “a landlord can lock a tenant out for unpaid rent”, are wrong. Here are ten myths and the correct position.

    One point before we start: rent and tenancy are State subjects. The Centre’s Model Tenancy Act, 2021 is only a model for states to adopt, so what applies to you depends on your state and sometimes on the type of premises. Where a rule is state specific, this guide says so.

    Tenant and Landlord Rights (Rs 299). A self-paced certificate course on tenant and landlord rights. See the course.

    Myth 1: “An 11 month agreement is the maximum the law allows”

    Nothing in law limits a tenancy to 11 months. The practice comes from the Registration Act, 1908: section 17(1)(d) makes a lease from year to year, or for a term exceeding one year, or reserving a yearly rent, compulsorily registrable. A lease of 11 months with monthly rent therefore does not have to be registered, which saves registration cost. Longer leases are possible, but they must be registered and stamped as the state’s stamp law requires. Stamp duty on rent agreements is fixed by each state.

    Myth 2: “Without a written agreement, I have no rights”

    A tenancy can exist without writing, proved by rent receipts, bank transfers, electricity bills in the tenant’s name or conduct. Under section 106 of the Transfer of Property Act, in the absence of a contract to the contrary, a lease for residential or commercial purposes is treated as a month to month tenancy. The Supreme Court has also recognised a month to month tenancy arising from the parties’ conduct where a lease was unregistered. A written agreement is still essential, because it fixes rent, deposit, notice and repairs.

    Myth 3: “The landlord can tell me to leave tomorrow”

    To end a month to month tenancy, section 106 requires a written notice signed by the person giving it, of at least 15 days, expiring at the end of a tenancy month. If your agreement gives a longer notice period, follow the agreement. Even after the notice expires, a landlord generally cannot remove a tenant personally; the remedy is through the Rent Authority, rent court or civil court, depending on the state. State rent control laws, where they apply, may also restrict eviction to specific grounds such as non-payment, subletting or genuine need.

    Myth 4: “A landlord can cut electricity or water to force me out”

    That is a self-help measure and is not a lawful way to recover possession or rent. The Model Tenancy Act, 2021 lets the Rent Authority pass interim orders to restore essential supplies, and the Uttar Pradesh Regulation of Urban Premises Tenancy Act, 2021 contains a similar provision. In states without such a provision, a tenant can seek an injunction from a civil court and complain to the police if there is harassment or criminal intimidation.

    Myth 5: “A landlord can ask for any amount as security deposit”

    In states that follow the Model Tenancy Act (and in Uttar Pradesh under its 2021 Act), the security deposit is capped at two months’ rent for residential premises and six months’ rent for non-residential premises, and is refundable on handing over vacant possession after lawful deductions. In other states, the deposit is a matter of contract. Whatever the amount, ask for a receipt and a clause saying when and how the deposit will be returned.

    Myth 6: “I can stop paying rent for the last two months because my deposit covers it”

    A deposit is security, not advance rent. Unilaterally adjusting it against rent is a frequent source of disputes, and non-payment is a recognised ground for eviction: under the Model Tenancy Act a landlord may seek eviction for non-payment of rent for more than two months. If you want the deposit adjusted, agree in writing before the last month and ask the landlord to confirm.

    Myth 7: “Rent can be increased by any amount at any time”

    During a fixed term, rent can be revised only as the agreement provides. After the term, the landlord can propose a new rent, but many state laws limit increases or set a process. Under the Model Tenancy Act the agreement sets the rent revision terms, and the Rent Authority decides disputes about revision. Always put a revision clause in writing, with a percentage and a date.

    Myth 8: “An unregistered agreement is useless”

    Under section 49 of the Registration Act a document that should have been registered cannot be used as evidence of the transaction it records, but courts allow it for collateral purposes, and a tenancy can still be proved from conduct and receipts. Still, avoid the problem: for any lease of more than one year, register it.

    Myth 9: “A tenant can sublet the room if the landlord is abroad”

    Subletting without the landlord’s consent is usually forbidden by the agreement, and under the Model Tenancy Act parting with possession without written consent is a ground for eviction. If the landlord is away, get consent by e-mail or letter.

    Myth 10: “The landlord can enter whenever he likes”

    Tenancy gives the tenant exclusive possession. Under the Model Tenancy Act the agreement is supposed to state the reasonable causes for which the landlord may enter. Whether notice is needed depends on your agreement. Put a clause such as 24 hours’ prior notice, except for emergencies.

    Bonus myth: “Rent receipts do not matter if I pay by bank transfer”

    Bank transfers are good evidence, but a receipt (or a clear narration in the transfer such as “rent for November”) removes doubt about which month and which premises the payment covers. If you pay in cash, a signed receipt is essential. Receipts also help if you want to claim house rent allowance from an employer, since many employers ask for them; check your employer’s rules and the current income-tax provisions for the conditions.

    Why the myths persist

    Most people learn tenancy law from brokers and neighbours. Brokers handle the agreement, the deposit and the first month, and they have no reason to explain termination, repairs or exit. That is why the clauses that matter most in a dispute (notice, deposit refund date, subletting, revision) are often missing or copied from an old template. A few minutes spent on those four clauses at the start saves months later.

    Quick table: who decides what

    IssueWhere to look firstCommon error
    Notice to end a month to month tenancySection 106, Transfer of Property Act, and your agreementGiving a verbal notice
    Registration of leaseSection 17, Registration Act, and state stamp lawAssuming 11 months is a legal cap
    Deposit capState tenancy law (for example Model Act states, Uttar Pradesh)Assuming one national cap
    EvictionState rent control or tenancy law and civil courtChanging the lock yourself
    Rent revisionAgreement and state lawNo clause in the agreement

    What a safe rent agreement contains

    • Names, addresses and identity details of both parties and the property description
    • Rent, due date, mode of payment and the revision clause
    • Deposit amount, purpose and refund date
    • Term, lock-in (if any), notice period for both sides
    • Who pays maintenance, society charges and utility bills
    • Rules on subletting, repairs and landlord entry
    • Handover inventory and meter readings

    Most disputes are not about complicated law. They are about missing paper: a deposit without a receipt, a verbal notice or a rent hike nobody wrote down.

    Tenant and Landlord Rights (Rs 299). A self-paced certificate course on tenant and landlord rights. See the course.

    Frequently asked questions

    Is a rent agreement valid on plain paper?

    A tenancy is valid whatever the paper, but stamp duty is payable as per state law, and a document without proper stamp may not be admissible in evidence until duty and penalty are paid. Use the stamp paper or e-stamp your state requires.

    Does the Model Tenancy Act apply in my state?

    Only if your state has adopted it, in whole or with changes. A 2023 report said four states (Tamil Nadu, Andhra Pradesh, Assam and Uttar Pradesh) had adopted versions. Check your state government’s website for the current position.

    Can a landlord evict a tenant to sell the property?

    Not by simply giving notice if a state rent law protects the tenant. In a month to month tenancy with no special protection, a valid section 106 notice followed by a court process is needed. The buyer takes the property subject to the existing tenancy.

    How many months’ deposit is legal?

    There is no single national limit. Model Tenancy Act states and Uttar Pradesh cap it at two months’ rent for residential premises; elsewhere it is by agreement.

    Should the tenant register a rent agreement of 11 months?

    It is not compulsory, but registration or notarisation can add comfort, for example as address proof. Check what your state requires.

    This article is general information, not legal advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • Co-Founder Quits, Investor Offers Money: 6 Startup Legal Scenarios in India

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: the legal problems that hurt young companies are rarely exotic. A co-founder leaves, an investor offers money on a few lines of email, an overseas friend wants to invest, a hire is promised options, a designer claims the logo, and a deadline passes unnoticed. Below are six illustrations, each invented to show how the law applies, with the position and a practical next step. They are not real cases and the names are made up.

    Learn the whole path. This is a self-paced certificate course on startup legal basics, from incorporation to funding, aimed at founders who want to handle these situations before they become disputes. The course is Startup Legal Basics: From Incorporation to Funding, priced at Rs 499.

    How to read these illustrations. Each one is a made up situation. Facts matter in law, so a small change in the facts (a written clause, a date, a signature) can change the result. Use them to spot the issue, not to predict your own outcome.

    Illustration 1: A co-founder leaves after six months

    Illustration. Meera and Arjun incorporate a software company with 50 per cent each. There is no founders’ agreement. Six months later Arjun takes a job elsewhere and stops working on the product, but he is still a 50 per cent shareholder and a director.

    Position. Shares allotted to Arjun are his property. Without vesting terms or a leaver clause, the company has no automatic right to take them back, and he can still vote and block decisions that need a special resolution. Meera cannot simply remove him from the register of members. The company can buy back shares only through a process set out in the Companies Act, with conditions, and any transfer to Meera needs a proper instrument of transfer, stamp duty and compliance with the articles.

    What to do. Negotiate a written exit: Arjun sells all or part of his shares to Meera at an agreed price, resigns as director, and signs an assignment of any code or designs he wrote. Check the articles for pre emption rules and board approval for transfers. The lesson for the next company: vesting and leaver terms signed on day one.

    Illustration 2: An angel investor offers Rs 50 lakh on an email

    Illustration. An investor emails a founder: “I will put in Rs 50 lakh for 10 per cent. Share your account number.” The money arrives. Nothing else is signed.

    Position. Money received without an agreed instrument is a legal grey area: is it a loan, an advance against shares, or a gift? A private company can issue shares by private placement under section 42 of the Companies Act, 2013, but only to persons it has identified before the offer, with an offer letter addressed to each, payment through banking channels, and allotment within 60 days of receiving the money. If allotment is not made in that window, the money must be repaid, with interest if the delay continues. The shareholding of 10 per cent exists only once shares are allotted and recorded.

    What to do. Convert the email into a subscription agreement and, if the investor wants rights such as board seat, information or anti dilution, a shareholders’ agreement. Hold a board meeting, pass the required resolutions, allot the shares on time and file the return of allotment. Share valuation is also a tax question, so ask your accountant.

    Illustration 3: A friend in the United States wants to invest

    Illustration. Kabir, a software engineer in California, offers to put in Rs 30 lakh in a friend’s Pune startup, asking to be repaid if the startup does not work out.

    Position. Because Kabir is a non-resident, the inflow is governed by the Foreign Exchange Management (Non-debt Instruments) Rules, 2019. A private company that is a recognised startup can issue a convertible note: an instrument that acknowledges money received initially as debt and that can be repaid or converted into equity within the period the rules allow (stated as not exceeding ten years). The rules set a minimum of Rs 25 lakh in a single tranche for a non-resident buyer, and the issue has to be reported to the Reserve Bank through its portal, generally within 30 days. An informal loan arrangement outside these rules can create a foreign exchange compliance problem for both sides. Also remember the resident director requirement under section 149(3).

    What to do. Decide whether Kabir wants equity or a note, document it under the foreign investment framework, send the money through a bank, collect the bank’s inward remittance advice, and have the filing made on time. Confirm with an authorised dealer bank which forms apply.

    Illustration 4: A new hire is “promised options”

    Illustration. A startup’s offer letter to a senior engineer says she will get “0.5 per cent ESOPs”. There is no plan, no grant letter and no vesting schedule.

    Position. Options are issued under a scheme approved by the company’s members, within section 62(1)(b) of the Companies Act, 2013 and Rule 12 of the Companies (Share Capital and Debentures) Rules, 2014. Rule 12 requires a minimum one year between grant and vesting. A sentence in an offer letter is not a scheme. If the company never creates one, the engineer holds an unclear promise, and a dispute over what “0.5 per cent” meant (of which share count, diluted or not) is likely. Each allotment when options are exercised is filed on Form PAS-3 within 30 days.

    What to do. Adopt a plan with a member resolution, issue a grant letter stating the number of options, exercise price, vesting schedule and leaver rules, and tell the employee that tax arises at exercise and sale and that she should take advice.

    Illustration 5: The freelance designer claims the logo

    Illustration. A company pays a freelance designer Rs 15,000 for a logo. A year later, after the brand becomes popular, the designer asks for a licence fee, saying the logo was never transferred.

    Position. Under the Copyright Act, 1957, the author is generally the first owner of the work, except in situations the Act lists, such as work made in the course of employment under a contract of service. A freelancer is not an employee. A transfer of copyright must be in writing and signed (section 19(1)), and must state the rights, duration and territory (section 19(2)). If the duration is missing, the law presumes five years, and if the territory is missing, India (section 19(5) and 19(6)). The company may therefore find that even a paid for logo is only partly its own.

    What to do. Ask the designer for a signed assignment with the full term and worldwide territory, and a waiver or acknowledgment about the design files. Apply for a trademark in the company’s name. For future work, use a written services agreement that includes an IP clause before work starts.

    Illustration 6: The company is incorporated but the declaration is never filed

    Illustration. A founder incorporates a company in January, signs customer contracts in March, but never files the declaration of commencement of business after the shareholders pay in their capital.

    Position. The Companies Act requires a declaration that every subscriber has paid for the shares agreed, to be filed within 180 days of incorporation. Until it is filed, the company cannot commence business or exercise borrowing powers, and if the Registrar has reason to believe the company is not carrying on business, the Registrar can start the process of removing its name from the register. The founder faces penalties and, more practically, a company that may be struck off while holding customer contracts.

    What to do. Make sure the subscribers’ money is in the bank, file INC-20A at once with any late fee, and diarise the other deadlines: office verification (30 days), the first auditor (30 days from registration, section 139(6)) and annual filings.

    The pattern behind the six illustrations

    • Write it down and sign it: equity, IP, services, investment.
    • Fix the instrument before the money moves, not after.
    • Know the clock: 30, 60 and 180 day periods run whether or not you noticed them.
    • Check who is on the other side of the table: a resident, a non-resident, an employee or a freelancer, because the rules differ.

    Prepare before it happens. The Lexfolio course on startup legal basics covers incorporation to funding as a self-paced certificate course. The course is Startup Legal Basics: From Incorporation to Funding, priced at Rs 499.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can a co-founder be removed from the company without his consent?

    Not automatically. A director can be removed by an ordinary resolution of members under the Companies Act, but shares cannot be taken back without a contractual right or a buyback. Vesting and leaver clauses give that right.

    Is a convertible note better than a share allotment for early funding?

    Neither is better in every case. A note postpones valuation, while shares fix it. For non-resident investors, the foreign exchange rules set conditions for notes. Ask a professional to model both.

    Does the company own the code written by an employee?

    Generally yes, when the work is made in the course of employment under a contract of service, unless the parties agreed otherwise. Contractors and freelancers need a written assignment.

    Are ESOPs taxed when granted?

    Tax arises at later stages such as exercise and sale. The rules differ for DPIIT recognised startups on timing of tax on exercise, so check the provision applicable to the year in question.

    What if an investor wants their money back after sending it?

    If shares have not been allotted within 60 days of receiving the application money, a private placement requires the money to be repaid. If the arrangement is a loan, the loan terms apply. A written agreement avoids this uncertainty.

    This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice for a specific case. The illustrations are invented and facts change outcomes, so consult a qualified professional before acting. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • Startup Legal Mistakes in India: 8 Founder Myths and the Correct Position

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: most early stage legal trouble in Indian startups does not come from a missing licence. It comes from five or six assumptions founders make in the first year: that a verbal understanding between co-founders is enough, that the code or designs they wrote before incorporation already belong to the company, that DPIIT recognition is automatic or compulsory, and that the angel tax rules of earlier years still apply. This guide lists eight such myths and gives the correct position on each, with the law as it stands on 12 November 2026.

    Want the whole founder journey in one place? This is a self-paced certificate course on startup legal basics, from incorporation to funding, written for first time founders and the people who work with them. The course is Startup Legal Basics: From Incorporation to Funding, priced at Rs 499.

    Myth 1: “We are friends, we will sort out equity later”

    A company is a separate legal person, but the people behind it are not. If two or three founders start work before agreeing who holds what, the default position is whatever the records show, and the records usually show nothing. The shares recorded in the register of members after allotment are what count, not what each founder remembers promising. The correct position: agree the split, the roles and the exit terms in writing before the company is incorporated or at the latest at the time of the first allotment, and record them in a founders’ or shareholders’ agreement that matches the articles of association.

    Three clauses do most of the work. Vesting means each founder earns his or her shares over time, so that a founder who leaves in month four does not walk away with a full quarter of the company. Leaver terms say what happens to unvested and vested shares when a founder quits or is removed. Decision rights list the matters that need every founder’s consent, such as raising money or selling the business.

    Myth 2: “The product I built before incorporating belongs to the company”

    It does not, unless someone has transferred it. Under the Copyright Act, 1957, an assignment of copyright is valid only if it is in writing and signed by the assignor (section 19(1)). It must identify the work and state the rights assigned, the duration and the territorial extent (section 19(2)). Two defaults catch founders out: if the period of assignment is not stated, it is deemed to be five years from the date of assignment (section 19(5)), and if the territorial extent is not specified, it is presumed to extend within India (section 19(6)).

    So a one line email saying “the code is yours” can leave the company with rights for five years and only in India. A good founder IP assignment names the code, designs, domain names and trade names, transfers them for the full term of the rights and for the whole world, and is signed by each founder. Investors ask for it in diligence, and a founder who has fallen out has no reason to sign later.

    Myth 3: “If the Registrar approves the company name, the brand is protected”

    Name approval during incorporation is a company law step. It stops two companies from being registered with the same or a very similar name, but it is not a trademark registration. A trademark is registered separately with the Trade Marks Registry, under the Trade Marks Act, 1999, and the registration is valid for ten years and renewable. Someone else may already hold, or later obtain, rights in a similar mark for similar goods or services, whatever the company register says. Search the trademark register before you spend money on packaging, a website and advertising, and apply for the mark in your own or the company’s name.

    Myth 4: “DPIIT recognition is compulsory, or it automatically gives a tax holiday”

    Recognition is voluntary. The Startup India portal describes the application as made through the National Single Window System, and says the Ministry charges no fee for the certificate. Recognition itself is not the tax benefit. The profit linked deduction for three consecutive years within the first ten years (section 80-IAC of the Income-tax Act, 1961, for years governed by that Act) needs a separate application and approval, and the portal says only private limited companies and LLPs incorporated after 1 April 2016 qualify. For tax years from FY 2026-27 the Income-tax Act, 2025 applies, so check the corresponding provision there with your accountant before you plan around the benefit.

    The definition itself was revised by a DPIIT notification dated February 2026. The portal now states that an entity can be recognised if its turnover is below Rs 200 crore in any previous financial year (earlier Rs 100 crore) and it is within 10 years of incorporation, with a separate deep tech category of 20 years and Rs 300 crore. Entities formed by splitting up or reconstructing an existing business do not qualify.

    Myth 5: “Angel tax will tax my funding round”

    This was a real worry for years, so the myth lingers. Section 56(2)(viib) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 taxed the premium a company received on shares above fair market value. The Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024 removed it, and a proviso states it does not apply on or after 1 April 2025. Commentary on the change notes that it is not carried into the Income-tax Act, 2025. The correct position has two parts. First, shares issued in FY 2025-26 or later do not face angel tax, whoever the investor is. Second, older rounds can still be examined if the assessment is open, and the department can separately question the source and genuineness of funds under the unexplained credit provisions.

    Myth 6: “ESOPs can be given to anyone and vest the next day”

    Employee stock option plans are governed by section 62(1)(b) of the Companies Act, 2013 and Rule 12 of the Companies (Share Capital and Debentures) Rules, 2014. Three points correct the common beliefs. There must be a minimum gap of one year between the grant and the first vesting. Independent directors, promoters and persons holding more than 10 per cent of the equity are generally not eligible, although recognised startups get a relaxation of this restriction for a period after incorporation (currently stated as ten years), so check the current rule before granting options to a founder. And each allotment on exercise must be reported to the Registrar on Form PAS-3 within 30 days. An option is only a right to buy until it is exercised and shares are allotted, which the employee should understand before leaving a salary for options.

    Myth 7: “We can raise money from anyone by posting about it”

    For a private company, taking money for shares from the public at large is the one thing the Act does not allow. A private placement under section 42 of the Companies Act, 2013 must be made only to persons whose names the company has recorded before the offer, with each person getting an offer addressed to them. Public advertisements, media, marketing or agents cannot be used to tell the public about the offer. Money must come through banking channels, not cash, into a separate account. Securities must be allotted within 60 days of receiving the money. The number of persons is limited, and if the limit is crossed the offer is treated as a public offer. A friends and family round is fine if you keep to known people and bank transfers.

    Myth 8: “A foreign investor can just wire us the money”

    Foreign investment into an Indian company is regulated by the Foreign Exchange Management (Non-debt Instruments) Rules, 2019. The company must report the issue to the Reserve Bank through its portal, generally within 30 days of issuing the shares, using the prescribed form (the equity issue form is FC-GPR). The same rules allow a recognised startup to issue a convertible note: an instrument that acknowledges money received as debt and is repayable or convertible into equity, for a period not exceeding ten years as the rules stand, and the rules set a minimum of Rs 25 lakh in a single tranche for a non-resident buyer. Sector caps and pricing conditions also apply, so confirm both before accepting an inbound transfer. Related point: every company must have a director who has stayed in India for at least 182 days in the previous calendar year (section 149(3)), so a foreign led startup needs a resident director from day one.

    A quick correction table

    What founders assumeWhat the law says
    Verbal split of equity is enoughShares are what the company records show; put terms and vesting in writing
    Pre incorporation code is the company’sOnly a signed written assignment transfers it (Copyright Act, s.19)
    Name approval equals trademarkTrademark needs separate registration, valid ten years
    DPIIT recognition gives tax holidayTax benefit needs a separate application and approval
    Angel tax applies to new roundsSection 56(2)(viib) does not apply on or after 1 April 2025
    ESOPs vest immediatelyMinimum one year between grant and vesting (Rule 12)
    Raise funds by public postPrivate placement only to named, pre recorded persons
    Wire from abroad is fineReport to the Reserve Bank; follow sector and pricing rules

    A simple pre funding checklist

    1. Founders’ agreement signed, with vesting and leaver terms.
    2. IP assignment from every founder and every contractor who wrote code or designs.
    3. Trademark searched and applied for.
    4. Statutory registers, minutes and filings up to date, including commencement of business and auditor appointment (the first auditor must be appointed by the Board within 30 days of registration under section 139(6)).
    5. Cap table that matches the register of members.

    Take it step by step. The Lexfolio course on startup legal basics walks through the same ground, from incorporation to funding, as a self-paced certificate course. The course is Startup Legal Basics: From Incorporation to Funding, priced at Rs 499.

    Frequently asked questions

    Do I need a founders’ agreement if there are only two of us?

    Yes, and a small team needs it more, because there is no third person to break a deadlock. A short agreement on equity, vesting, roles, IP and exit costs little and avoids a dispute that can end the company.

    Is DPIIT recognition necessary to start a startup in India?

    No. You can incorporate and operate without it. Recognition is optional and is useful mainly if you want to apply for the tax and other schemes that are linked to it.

    Does the 182 day rule mean all directors must live in India?

    No. The requirement in section 149(3) is for at least one director who has stayed in India for 182 days or more in the previous calendar year. Other directors may live abroad.

    Can a startup give ESOPs to its co-founders?

    It depends on the shareholding and the date of incorporation. The Rule 12 restrictions on promoters and 10 per cent holders are relaxed for recognised startups for a stated period, so check the current rule and get a professional to confirm before granting.

    Is angel tax completely gone?

    For shares issued on or after 1 April 2025, section 56(2)(viib) no longer applies. Older years can still be reopened or examined within the limitation periods, and questions about the source of funds can arise separately.

    Who owns the code written by a freelancer for my startup?

    Unless there is a signed written assignment, the freelancer generally remains the first owner. Get an assignment that states the rights, the duration and the territory.

    This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice for a specific case. Laws and thresholds change, so confirm current rules with a qualified professional before acting. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • Over-MRP Complaints, Bounced Cheques and Defective Goods: Shopkeeper Scenarios and What to Do

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: most disputes in a small shop repeat the same few patterns. Below are six illustrations of the kind that come up again and again. Each one is an invented example written to show how the law works. None describes a real person or case, and the real answer in your own matter will depend on its facts, your state and the documents you hold.

    Want to handle problems like these with confidence? Law for Shopkeepers and Small Businesses (Rs 399). It is a self-paced certificate course on the everyday legal basics of running a shop or small business in India.

    Illustration 1: The mixer grinder that stopped working in a week

    What happened: A customer buys a mixer grinder for Rs 3,500. It stops working after a week. The bill says “Goods once sold will not be taken back”. The shopkeeper refuses a refund.

    The legal position: A defective product is covered by the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. The District Commission can direct the seller to remove the defect, replace the goods, refund the price and pay compensation (section 39(1)). A line on the bill does not remove the statutory right. The shop can often recover the cost from the manufacturer or distributor, but that is a separate matter between them.

    What to do: Check the product. If it is defective, repair or replace it, or refund, and ask the distributor for a replacement against the claim. If the customer is only unhappy with the colour or size, you may decline unless you promised an exchange. Record the decision in writing in either case.

    Illustration 2: Rs 10 above MRP on a cold drink

    What happened: A customer notices that a bottled drink with a printed price of Rs 90 is billed at Rs 100 “because the fridge is on”. He objects and threatens to complain.

    The legal position: Rule 18(2) of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011 does not allow a pre-packed commodity to be sold above its retail sale price. Consumer Commissions have ordered refunds, compensation and costs for overcharges as small as Rs 60 (the Thrissur District Commission, in a decision of 27 June 2025, ordered a refund plus Rs 5,000 compensation and Rs 10,000 costs). The “cooling charge” is a common excuse, but the only exception in rule 18(3), the one the Thrissur Commission examined, concerns tax revisions, and the rule says nothing about chilling.

    What to do: Refund the Rs 10, sell at MRP, and if you want to charge for chilling, discuss it with your local Legal Metrology office or your trade association before adopting any practice. Do not adopt a hand-written price above the printed one.

    Illustration 3: A customer’s cheque bounces

    What happened: A regular customer buys goods worth Rs 80,000 on credit and gives a cheque. It is returned with the memo “funds insufficient” on 4 February.

    The legal position: Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 applies. The shop must send a written demand notice within 30 days of receiving the return memo. The drawer has 15 days from receiving the notice to pay. If he does not, a complaint can be filed within one month after those 15 days end. The offence carries imprisonment up to two years, a fine up to twice the cheque amount, or both, and is compoundable.

    What to do: Work out the three dates on a calendar the day the memo arrives. Send the notice by Speed Post with proof of delivery and by e-mail, demanding the cheque amount. Do not file early, do not wait past the deadlines, and keep the original cheque and the memo safe.

    Illustration 4: A wholesaler’s bill unpaid for years

    What happened: A trader supplied goods to a small shop three years and two months ago and was never paid in full. The shop denies owing anything.

    The legal position: For a suit for the price of goods sold and delivered, where no fixed period of credit was agreed, the Limitation Act, 1963 (Article 14) allows three years from the date of delivery. Acknowledging the debt in writing before the period expires can give a fresh start to the period, and part payment can also affect it, but a claim brought late is liable to fail without such an event.

    What to do: Go through the delivery challans and any later letters, messages or part payments to see whether the claim is still in time. The earlier the notice goes, the better. A shop that is on the other side of such a claim should likewise keep proof of payment for at least as long as the limitation period.

    Illustration 5: A helper quits and demands pay the same day

    What happened: A helper working at a general store resigns on the 12th of the month and asks for all wages and an extra “bonus” immediately. The owner says he will pay on the usual date.

    The legal position: Under the Code on Wages, 2019 (in force from 21 November 2025 with the other Labour Codes), wages of an employee who resigns or is removed must be paid within two working days, and monthly wages are otherwise due within seven days after the end of the month. A bonus is a separate matter that depends on the law applicable and the establishment. Minimum wages apply regardless of the sector, at the rates notified by your state.

    What to do: Compute the wages and dues for the days worked, pay within two working days, take a written receipt, and keep a copy. If you are unsure about a bonus or notice pay claim, ask your local labour office or an advocate before refusing.

    Illustration 6: A food stall without FSSAI

    What happened: A shop that has been selling packed snacks and tea for years has no FSSAI registration. A food safety officer visits and asks for the certificate.

    The legal position: Selling food as a business without the required registration or licence is a violation of the food safety law. Under the amendment effective 1 April 2026, annual turnover up to Rs 1.5 crore falls in the registration category, and registrations issued from that date have perpetual validity. The shop can therefore regularise itself without difficulty, but it is better to do so before an inspection, not after.

    What to do: Apply on FoSCoS in the right category, pay the fee and keep the acknowledgement. Meanwhile, be polite with the inspecting officer, ask for any notice in writing, and reply within the time stated.

    What these scenarios have in common

    • Written proof wins: bills, delivery challans, notices, receipts and messages.
    • Deadlines are strict: 30 days and 15 days for cheques, three years for price recovery, two working days for final wages.
    • A printed line on a bill cannot cancel a right given by statute.
    • Small amounts do not mean small consequences, because costs and compensation are added to the claim.

    Turn these scenarios into working knowledge. Law for Shopkeepers and Small Businesses (Rs 399). It is a self-paced certificate course on the everyday legal basics of running a shop or small business in India.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can I send a legal notice myself, or must an advocate send it?

    The law does not require an advocate to send a demand notice, including a section 138 notice. A notice from an advocate is usually taken more seriously and is drafted to include all the points the section needs.

    Is the limitation period for recovering the price of goods always three years?

    Article 14 gives three years from delivery where no fixed credit period was agreed. Other facts, such as a written acknowledgement, a fixed credit period or a different kind of claim, can change the calculation, so check your own papers.

    What if the customer says the cheque was only a security cheque?

    Section 138 applies when a legally enforceable debt was due on the date the cheque was presented. If no debt had become payable, the drawer may have a defence. Keep the invoice or ledger to show the debt.

    Can a small shop be penalised for selling above MRP even once?

    Yes. The rule applies to every sale of a pre-packed commodity above its retail sale price, and a consumer may complain on a single transaction.

    Do these scenarios apply in every state?

    Central laws such as the Consumer Protection Act, the Negotiable Instruments Act and the Limitation Act apply everywhere. Shop registration, trade licences and some wage rules are state specific.

    This article is general information, not legal or tax advice for a specific case, and the law can change or differ by state. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services. For your own situation, consult a qualified advocate or professional.

  • Legal Myths Every Shopkeeper in India Believes (GST, MRP, Bills, FSSAI)

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: most legal trouble for small shops does not come from big crimes. It comes from believing a few comfortable myths: that a small shop is too small for GST rules, that a printed “no return” line ends a customer’s rights, that a rupee or two above MRP is harmless, or that a bounced cheque is only a nuisance. This guide takes eight of these myths and gives the correct position under Indian law as it stands in November 2026.

    Everything below is general. State rules, local body rules and recent amendments matter a great deal for shops, so treat each point as a prompt to check your own state and your own trade, not as a final answer.

    Want the whole picture in one place? Law for Shopkeepers and Small Businesses (Rs 399). It is a self-paced certificate course on the everyday legal basics of running a shop or small business in India.

    Myth 1: “My shop is small, so GST rules do not apply to me”

    Whether you must register for GST depends on your aggregate turnover, not on how big the shop looks. For most states the registration threshold for a supplier of goods is Rs 40 lakh a year, and for a supplier of services it is Rs 20 lakh, with lower limits in some special category states. Below the threshold you generally need not register, but there are situations where registration is compulsory whatever the turnover, so it is wise to confirm your own position before assuming you are exempt, especially if you sell to other states or through an online marketplace.

    The opposite mistake is common too: collecting a “GST” amount on bills without being registered. Collect tax only if you are registered, and show your GSTIN on the invoice.

    If you are registered and trade in goods, the composition scheme may suit you. Under it a trader pays a flat 1 per cent of turnover (0.5 per cent central and 0.5 per cent state), provided aggregate turnover stays within Rs 1.5 crore (Rs 75 lakh in eight special category states). The trade-offs are real: a composition dealer cannot charge GST to customers, cannot claim input tax credit, cannot make outward supplies to other states, and must issue a bill of supply carrying the words “composition taxable person, not eligible to collect tax on supplies”. Choose it knowingly.

    Myth 2: “Udyam registration costs money and needs an agent”

    Udyam registration is the government’s registration for micro, small and medium enterprises. The registration portal states that the process is free of cost and paperless, that an Aadhaar number is the basic requirement, and that no documents need to be uploaded, with PAN and GST details being verified against government databases. Anyone charging you a “government fee” for the certificate itself is charging for their own service.

    Registration is useful (many loan schemes and tenders ask for it), but it does not replace GST, a shop registration under your state law or an FSSAI registration. Think of it as one document in a set, not the licence to trade.

    Myth 3: “Goods once sold will not be taken back”

    This line is printed on countless bills. It cannot take away a right that the law gives the buyer. Under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, a consumer who has received defective goods can ask the Consumer Commission to direct the seller to remove the defect, replace the goods, refund the price, and pay compensation (section 39(1)). A sentence on a cash memo does not override that.

    The fair reading is narrower. If goods are sound and the customer has merely changed their mind, the law does not force every shop to accept a return. What matters is what you promised. A shop that advertises a seven day exchange has to honour it. A shop that says nothing is still answerable for defects, wrong items and false descriptions. A better printed line is “Goods are exchangeable within X days with the bill, subject to condition. Defective goods will be repaired, replaced or refunded as per law.”

    Myth 4: “A rupee or two above MRP is normal”

    For pre-packed goods the maximum retail price is a ceiling. Rule 18(2) of the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011 bars selling a pre-packed commodity at a price above the retail sale price printed on it, and rule 18(6) bars altering the printed price. A narrow exception allows sale above the printed price after a tax revision, but only within the limited period rule 18(3) allows.

    This is not a theoretical risk. In a reported decision of the Thrissur District Consumer Commission (Lenish V.R. v. Managing Director, Kerala State Beverages Corporation Ltd, decided on 27 June 2025), a bottle with an MRP of Rs 740 was billed at Rs 800. The Commission ordered a refund of the Rs 60 excess, Rs 5,000 as compensation, Rs 10,000 as costs and a direction to stop selling above MRP. Notice what happened: a Rs 60 overcharge produced an order many times larger than the overcharge. Bill at or below the printed price, keep the supplier’s revised-price documents if a tax change ever applies, and never cover or overwrite a printed price.

    Myth 5: “FSSAI is only for restaurants and factories”

    Anyone who sells food or drink as a business, including a grocery, a sweet shop, a tea stall or a cloud kitchen, is a food business operator. What changes is the category. By an amendment to the licensing regulations published in the Gazette on 10 March 2026, with an implementation order dated 13 March 2026 applying from 1 April 2026, the registration category now covers annual turnover up to Rs 1.5 crore (earlier Rs 12 lakh), a state licence covers turnover above Rs 1.5 crore up to Rs 50 crore, and a central licence covers turnover above Rs 50 crore. FSSAI states that registrations and licences issued on or after 1 April 2026 have perpetual validity, so they need no renewal, though the hygiene and safety conditions continue to apply. Existing holders were told they can migrate to the new categories on the FoSCoS portal without a fee.

    So a small kirana that thought it needed a state licence may now need only registration, and one that did nothing because it believed “FSSAI is for restaurants” is exposed. Display the certificate at the shop and keep the number handy for your bills.

    Myth 6: “With two or three helpers, I owe them nothing formal”

    Wage law now applies to nearly every employer. The four Labour Codes came into force on 21 November 2025. Under the Code on Wages, 2019 every employee has a right to minimum wages irrespective of the sector, monthly wages must be paid within seven days after the end of the month, and wages on resignation or termination must be paid within two working days. Rates and procedures are set state by state, so check the minimum wage notified for your trade and area.

    Shop and establishment laws are state laws and are changing. In Uttar Pradesh, for instance, an ordinance of 19 November 2025 amending the Uttar Pradesh Dookan Aur Vanijya Adhishthan Adhiniyam, 1962 excused shops and commercial establishments with fewer than twenty employees from several of its requirements and provided for online registration within six months for establishments with twenty or more. A bill to replace the ordinance was reported in early 2026, so confirm the current position with the state labour department before relying on this.

    Myth 7: “A bounced cheque is just paper, and only a civil matter”

    A cheque returned unpaid for insufficient funds is a criminal offence under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, when it was issued for a legally enforceable debt. It is also a deadline game. The payee must send a written demand within 30 days of receiving the bank’s return memo, the drawer then has 15 days from receipt to pay, and the complaint must be filed within one month after those 15 days expire. A shopkeeper who receives a bounced customer cheque and waits “to see if he pays” can lose the right to prosecute. A shopkeeper who issues cheques to suppliers should know that a wholesaler can use the same section against them.

    Myth 8: “A consumer case cannot be filed against a small shop”

    There is no exemption for small sellers. Under the Consumer Protection (Jurisdiction of the District Commission, the State Commission and the National Commission) Rules, 2021, the District Commission hears complaints where the consideration paid is up to Rs 50 lakh, so almost every retail dispute lands there. Complaints are now filed through the e-Jagriti portal, which replaced e-Daakhil from 1 January 2025. Ignoring a notice from a consumer does not make the case go away; the Commission can decide it in your absence.

    The eight myths at a glance

    MythCorrect position
    Small shops are outside GSTRegistration depends on turnover and on specific triggers, not on size
    Udyam needs a paid agentThe portal states the process is free of cost and paperless
    “Goods once sold” ends all rightsStatutory remedies for defective goods stay (Consumer Protection Act, 2019)
    Slightly above MRP is normalSelling above the printed price breaches the Packaged Commodities Rules
    FSSAI is only for restaurantsAny food seller needs registration or a licence, with new turnover bands from 1 April 2026
    Few helpers, few dutiesMinimum wage and wage payment rules apply; state shop rules differ
    Bounced cheque is minorSection 138 is criminal and runs on strict deadlines
    Cannot be sued as a small sellerDistrict Commission hears claims up to Rs 50 lakh

    A short routine protects most shops: keep a clean bill book, register where the law requires, price at or below MRP, and put every promise to a customer or staff member on paper.

    Learn the basics once, use them for years. Law for Shopkeepers and Small Businesses (Rs 399). It is a self-paced certificate course on the everyday legal basics of running a shop or small business in India. It is meant for shop owners and small business founders who want to understand their legal position before a problem arrives.

    Frequently asked questions

    Do I need GST registration if my turnover is below Rs 40 lakh?

    Generally not for a supplier of goods in most states, but some situations require registration whatever the turnover. Confirm your own position, especially if you sell across state lines or online.

    Is Udyam registration the same as a shop licence?

    No. Udyam is a registration for micro, small and medium enterprises. A shop registration under your state’s shops and establishments law, GST registration and an FSSAI registration, where relevant, are separate.

    Can I refuse to refund a defective item because the bill says no returns?

    Not safely. A printed condition does not remove the consumer’s statutory remedy for defective goods, which can include repair, replacement, refund and compensation.

    Can a customer complain about a Rs 5 overcharge?

    Yes. Selling above the printed price breaches the Legal Metrology rules, and a Consumer Commission can order a refund, compensation and costs, as the Thrissur decision shows.

    Where do I check my state’s shop registration rules?

    On your state labour department portal or the municipal body. These are state laws and several states have amended them recently, so a printed guide may be out of date.

    This article is general information, not legal or tax advice for a specific case, and the law can change or differ by state. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services. For your own situation, consult a qualified advocate or professional.

  • SEBI SCORES Complaint Myths: 9 Mistakes Investors Make and the Correct Position

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: Most failed investor complaints fail for avoidable reasons: they are filed late, filed with no documents, filed with the wrong body, or filed in two places at once. The market regulator, SEBI, runs a complaint platform called SCORES, and the stock exchanges run an online dispute resolution portal called Smart ODR. Each has its own rules. This guide separates the common myths from what the published rules actually say.

    Want the full picture of investor protection? Legal Rights of Investors (Rs 349) is a self-paced certificate course on the legal rights of investors in India, for people who put money into shares, mutual funds, deposits and similar products.

    Myth 1: SEBI will get my money back

    SCORES is a grievance redress system, not a recovery agency. When you lodge a complaint, the platform sends it to the regulated entity concerned, such as a broker, a registrar or a listed company, and tracks whether that entity answers within the prescribed time. A reply that explains why the entity thinks it was right still counts as a reply. You may still be dissatisfied, and in that case your options include the dispute resolution route described below, a civil or consumer remedy, or, for fraud, a criminal complaint.

    Think of SCORES as the front door that forces a regulated entity to respond in writing, on a record that the regulator can see. It does not promise any particular outcome.

    Myth 2: There is no deadline to complain

    The SEBI investor website states that a complaint must be lodged “within a period of one year from the date of occurrence of the cause of action”, and that SEBI may reject complaints filed later. If your broker made an unauthorised trade in March, the one year runs from then, not from the day you finally noticed it on your statement. Keep a note of the date of every transaction you dispute.

    Time limits also matter in other forums. A civil suit, a consumer complaint and a criminal complaint each have their own limits, so do not assume that waiting for a reply from the broker stops those clocks.

    Myth 3: Any complaint will be accepted

    SEBI’s page lists matters that SCORES does not treat as complaints. Among them are:

    • matters unrelated to investment in the securities market;
    • anonymous, incomplete or non-specific complaints;
    • allegations without supporting documents;
    • requests for guidance or suggestions, as opposed to a grievance;
    • dissatisfaction with the trading price of a share;
    • companies under a moratorium, winding up, insolvency or liquidation, and companies struck off by the Registrar of Companies;
    • entities regulated by other bodies such as the RBI, IRDAI or PFRDA, and matters under the Ministry of Corporate Affairs;
    • matters pending before a court or a quasi-judicial authority, or under the exchanges’ online dispute resolution.

    The practical lesson is to describe the grievance specifically (what happened, on which date, in which account, for what amount) and to attach proof. Documents are uploaded as PDF files of up to 2 MB each, so scan or compress large statements before you start.

    Myth 4: I can file the same complaint on SCORES and on Smart ODR

    The exchanges’ Smart ODR page says that if you file on the Smart ODR portal while a SCORES complaint on the same matter is pending, the SCORES complaint is treated as disposed of. Once you file on Smart ODR you cannot file the same complaint on SCORES. So the choice of channel is a real decision. The Smart ODR route also expects you to have taken the matter up with the broker or market participant first, and to be dissatisfied with the response or to have received none.

    PointSCORESSmart ODR
    Run bySEBIMarket infrastructure institutions (the stock exchanges and depositories) through a shared portal
    Wherescores.sebi.gov.insmartodr.in
    First response timeEntity to resolve within 21 calendar days, then auto-escalationPre-conciliation stage of 21 calendar days after filing
    Next stagesReview by the designated body within 15 days of the entity’s report, then SEBI review within 15 daysConciliation, which is mandatory before arbitration, then online arbitration
    Same matter in both?No: filing on Smart ODR disposes of the pending SCORES complaintNo

    Court appeals against an arbitration award under Smart ODR are made under section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, according to the exchange’s description of the process.

    Myth 5: I have to chase every level myself

    Under SCORES 2.0 the entity has 21 calendar days, reduced from 30. If the complaint is not resolved in that time it escalates automatically to the designated body, which reviews it within 15 days of getting the entity’s report, and then to SEBI for a further review within 15 days. You still need to keep your registration number and respond if the platform asks for a clarification, but you do not have to re-file at each level.

    Myth 6: The exchange will compensate me for any loss

    Every exchange keeps an Investor Protection Fund. It is meant for specific situations, mainly claims against a trading member that has been declared a defaulter or expelled. It does not insure you against market losses, bad advice or a falling share price. The ceiling is also not a universal number. A news report from August 2024 says the NSE fund raised its limit from Rs 25 lakh to Rs 35 lakh per investor per claim, and other exchanges set their own limits, so check the exchange where your trade was executed.

    Myth 7: Anyone with a big following can give investment advice

    SEBI’s FAQs on investment advisers explain that persons giving investment advice generally need registration, with limited exemptions where advice is incidental to another regulated activity such as a mutual fund distributor selling only mutual funds. Registered advisers must display their registration details on their website, app and client material, and SEBI publishes a list of registered advisers under the recognised intermediaries section of its website. Before paying a Telegram group, YouTube channel or WhatsApp “mentor”, search for the name in that list and keep a record of what was promised.

    Also remember that regulated entities are restricted from promoting products through unregistered influencers. Reports on SEBI’s 2024 amendments say that persons regulated by SEBI, and their agents, may not have any direct or indirect association with people who give securities advice or make return claims without SEBI permission. A broker or fund house that works with such a promoter is itself in difficulty.

    Myth 8: A high-return deposit scheme is fine if the paper looks professional

    The Banning of Unregulated Deposit Schemes Act, 2019 bans unregulated deposit schemes. A summary of the law prepared by PRS Legislative Research explains that all deposit-taking schemes must be registered with the relevant regulator (for example the RBI for non-banking finance companies, SEBI for mutual funds, state authorities for chit funds). Running an unregulated scheme is punishable with imprisonment of 2 to 7 years and a fine, and the Act gives a Competent Authority power to attach property and a Designated Court power to distribute proceeds to depositors. If a scheme promises fixed, unusually high returns, ask which regulator licenses it and look for that licence before you deposit.

    Myth 9: Unclaimed dividends and shares are lost forever

    Dividends and shares that remain unclaimed for seven consecutive years are transferred by the company to the Investor Education and Protection Fund Authority (IEPFA) under section 124 of the Companies Act, 2013, but the investor or the legal heirs can still claim them. The process runs through the web form IEPF-5, with an indemnity bond and documents sent to the company’s nodal officer, after which the Authority processes the refund. A 2025 report notes relaxations for claims up to Rs 5 lakh, with self-attested documents accepted and no succession certificate needed. Rules on these relaxations have been revised before, so read the current instruction kit on the IEPFA portal.

    A short checklist before you complain

    1. Collect contract notes, ledger, statements, screenshots, call or chat records and the dates of each event.
    2. Write to the broker or company in plain language, state the exact relief you want, and keep proof that you sent it.
    3. Diarise one year from the date of the cause of action.
    4. Decide between SCORES and Smart ODR before filing, because filing on one affects the other.
    5. Save the registration number and check the status regularly.
    6. If money was taken by a scheme that is not registered with any regulator, speak to the police as well, because SEBI’s complaint process may not cover it.

    Know your rights before you need them. Legal Rights of Investors (Rs 349) is a self-paced certificate course on investor rights and remedies in India, written for ordinary investors and students.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is the time limit for a SCORES complaint?

    One year from the date of the cause of action, according to SEBI’s investor website. Later complaints may be rejected, so file as early as you can.

    How long does a company or broker have to reply on SCORES?

    Under SCORES 2.0 the entity has 21 calendar days. If it does not resolve the complaint in that time, the complaint is escalated automatically for review.

    Can I use SCORES for a bank, insurance or NBFC complaint?

    Generally no. SEBI’s list of non-complaints excludes entities regulated by other bodies such as the RBI, IRDAI and PFRDA. Use the grievance mechanism of that regulator.

    Do I need a lawyer to complain on SCORES or Smart ODR?

    No. Both are online portals meant to be used by investors directly. A lawyer helps when the amount is large, when a court case is possible, or when you want to draft a precise written complaint.

    What if my complaint was rejected on SCORES?

    Read the reason given. If it was missing documents or a vague description, you may be able to file a fresh and complete complaint, but only within the one year limit. If the reason is that the matter is outside SCORES, take it to the right forum instead.

    Is the Investor Protection Fund guaranteed to pay me?

    No. It applies to defined situations such as a defaulting trading member, and each claim is examined under the exchange’s rules, up to the exchange’s ceiling.

    This article is general information, not legal or financial advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource. Laws, rates and procedures change, so check the current rule or consult a qualified professional before you act.

  • Will, Gift or No Will? Six Property Situations for Senior Citizens in India

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: What happens to an older person’s property depends on three documents or their absence: a will, a registered gift or transfer deed, and the personal law that applies if there is no will. The six situations below are illustrations invented for this guide. Each one states the legal position and the practical step, using the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, the Indian Succession Act, 1925, the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, the Registration Act, 1908 and the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007.

    The illustrations assume the family is Hindu, Buddhist, Jain or Sikh unless stated, because that is the group to which the Hindu Succession Act applies. Muslims, Christians and Parsis follow different succession rules, and a lawyer should be consulted for them. Names and facts below are fictional.

    Want the full picture? The Lexfolio Senior Citizens’ Rights and Estate Planning is a self-paced certificate course on the legal rights of older people in India and on planning and protecting their property. Price: Rs 349.

    Illustration 1: Ramesh dies without a will

    Illustration: Ramesh, a Hindu widower aged 74, owns a house that he bought himself. He has a son and a daughter, and his mother is alive. He never made a will.

    Legal position: when a Hindu dies without a will, his property passes under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 to his heirs in a fixed order. The first group is the Class I heirs: sons, daughters, the widow and the mother, along with the children and widows of predeceased sons and daughters and some further descendants. Class II heirs inherit only if there is no Class I heir. In Ramesh’s case, the son, the daughter and the mother all stand in the first group, so the property is divided among them and not given to the son alone, even if the son lived with Ramesh and looked after him. What to do: if Ramesh wants a different division, he should make a will while he is capable of doing so. If he does not, the family should obtain the legal heir documents the local authority prescribes and divide the property after discussion.

    Illustration 2: A handwritten will with two neighbours as witnesses

    Illustration: Savitri, aged 80, writes on plain paper that her flat shall go to her granddaughter, signs it and gets two neighbours to sign as witnesses. She does not register it. Her son later says that an unregistered will is worthless.

    Legal position: registration of a will is not compulsory, and the Registration Act treats wills differently from other documents, in that a will can be registered at any time and need not be presented within four months. What matters is that the will is the testator’s free act, is signed by her and is attested by two witnesses, as section 63 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 requires for an ordinary will. Because the validity is tested if the will is challenged, the witnesses may have to depose in a court that they saw her sign. Registration does not replace proof of the will, but it gives stronger backing if the will is disputed. What to do: Savitri should choose witnesses who are younger, who are not beneficiaries and who will be reachable later; state in the will that she is of sound mind; and think about registering the will at the Sub-Registrar’s office. A doctor’s note on her capacity at the time of signing can help when the testator is of advanced age.

    Illustration 3: The oral gift of a house

    Illustration: Gopal told his younger son in front of the family, “This house is yours from today.” There is no document. The son has been living in the house, and the elder son now claims a share.

    Legal position: a gift of immovable property must be made by a registered instrument, signed by the donor or on his behalf and attested by at least two witnesses (section 123, Transfer of Property Act, 1882). An oral declaration does not transfer ownership of the house. Gopal remains the owner, and on his death the house passes by his will or by succession law. What to do: if Gopal wants the younger son to have the house, he should execute a registered gift deed or a will. Because a gift made now is hard to reverse, he should read the next illustration before deciding.

    Illustration 4: A registered gift deed and a promise of care

    Illustration: Lata gifted her house to her son by a registered deed after he promised to look after her for life. Within a year, he stopped giving her food and medicines and told her to move to a relative’s house.

    Legal position: section 23 of the 2007 Act applies where a senior citizen has transferred property by gift or otherwise, subject to the condition that the transferee will provide basic amenities and basic physical needs, and the transferee fails to do so. The transfer is then deemed to have been made by fraud, coercion or undue influence, and the Tribunal may declare it void at the senior citizen’s option. In Urmila Dixit v. Sunil Sharan Dixit (2025 INSC 20) the Supreme Court restored a mother’s property in a case where the son had promised care and a same-day document allowed the mother to revoke the gift if he failed. The Court had separately drawn a line with Sudesh Chhikara v. Ramti Devi, where no such condition was pleaded. What to do: Lata should gather the gift deed and any other document or message that records the promise, and apply to the Maintenance Tribunal for the subdivision. In the future, anyone gifting property should write the condition of care into the deed itself.

    Illustration 5: A parent in an old age home and a child who stopped paying

    Illustration: Harbans, aged 70, has a small pension that does not cover his medical costs. His son agreed to pay for his care but has stopped, and now does not answer calls.

    Legal position: Harbans may apply to the Maintenance Tribunal under section 5 of the 2007 Act for a monthly allowance and for interim maintenance. The Tribunal is to decide within 90 days of service of notice, with one extension of up to 30 days. An order can be enforced through a warrant, and a defaulter may be sentenced to up to one month’s imprisonment. If a person in charge of Harbans’s care left him somewhere with the intention of wholly abandoning him, section 24 provides imprisonment of up to three months, a fine of up to Rs 5,000, or both. As another route, section 144 of the BNSS lets a Magistrate order a person with sufficient means to pay maintenance to a parent who cannot maintain himself. What to do: keep the records of the agreement and of the payments that stopped, send a written request by speed post, and then file before the Tribunal. The maximum allowance under the Act is fixed by State rules and cannot exceed Rs 10,000 per month as the Act stands, so check the current law.

    Illustration 6: A childless widow and her nieces

    Illustration: Kamla, aged 78, is a childless Hindu widow with a house and savings. Two nieces visit her often, and a nephew, who rarely visits, has told others that he will inherit everything.

    Legal position: without a will, her property would pass by the rules of succession, and relatives she may not want could inherit. With a will, she can leave her own property to whomever she chooses. In relation to maintenance, a childless senior citizen can apply against a relative who has sufficient means and who holds or would inherit her property, with liability in proportion to the inheritance share (sections 2(g) and 4 of the 2007 Act). What to do: Kamla should make a will naming the nieces, sign it before two witnesses, keep it somewhere safe and tell a trusted person where it is. She can change it later by making a new will.

    A quick guide to the documents

    SituationDocument that worksKey point
    Wants property to pass after death to chosen peopleWillSigned and attested by two witnesses; registration optional but helpful
    Wants to give a house nowRegistered gift deedOral gifts of immovable property do not transfer title
    Gives property on a promise of careGift deed with the condition written inSection 23 of the 2007 Act may allow cancellation if the condition is broken
    Needs monthly supportApplication to the Tribunal or Magistrate90 days for decision under the 2007 Act; interim maintenance available
    Dies with no willSuccession law decidesClass I heirs inherit together under the Hindu Succession Act

    A final caution: the rules differ for property that is joint family or ancestral, for people of other religions, and for property held jointly. Ask a lawyer to look at your actual documents before you decide.

    Frequently asked questions

    Is a will without registration valid?

    Yes, it can be valid. Registration is not compulsory for a will. It must still be signed by the testator and attested by two witnesses, and it may need to be proved in court if challenged.

    Can I cancel a gift deed that I signed for my child?

    Not just because you changed your mind. If the gift was made on the condition that the child provides basic amenities and physical needs and he or she fails to do so, section 23 of the 2007 Act allows you to apply to the Tribunal to declare the transfer void. Otherwise, a lawyer must look at the deed.

    Who inherits if a Hindu dies without a will?

    The Class I heirs under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, such as sons, daughters, the widow and the mother, inherit first and together. Class II heirs inherit only if there is no Class I heir.

    Where can I get help with a maintenance claim?

    Start with the Maintenance Tribunal for your subdivision, through the district administration or the social welfare office, or with a lawyer. Free legal services may be available through the legal services authority if you qualify.

    Should I make a will even if I have only one child?

    A will removes doubt about what you want, even where only one heir exists, and you can use it to provide for others, such as a caregiver or a grandchild. A lawyer can tell you whether your property and family situation call for one.

    Go beyond this guide. Continue with the Lexfolio Senior Citizens’ Rights and Estate Planning, a self-paced certificate course on the legal rights of older people in India and on planning and protecting their property. Price: Rs 349.

    This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice for a specific case. Laws, rules and fees change and differ by state, so check the current text or consult a lawyer for your situation. Lexfolio is a learning resource.