LLexfolio

Category: Guides

  • How to Clean Messy Data and Build a Monthly Report in Excel: Step by Step

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: To turn a messy monthly export into a reliable report in Excel, work in this order: keep a raw copy, convert the data to a table, clean text and duplicates on a copy, validate what goes in, bring in rates or names with a lookup, check totals with SUMIFS, then summarise with a PivotTable and a chart. Use an AI assistant for drafting formulas and wording, but check each result against figures you can verify by hand. The steps below use an invented sales sheet as the example.

    Turn this routine into a skill you can show. Excel and AI for Office Work (Rs 299) is a self-paced certificate course on Excel and AI tools for everyday office tasks such as cleaning data and reporting.

    The example we will use

    Imagine a small distributor in Lucknow whose billing software exports a sheet every month with these columns: Invoice No, Date, Customer, City, Zone, Product Code, Quantity, Amount. The Customer column has stray spaces, a few invoices appear twice because the export was run twice on the same day, and the rate list sits in a separate file. This is a typical office situation, and the same method suits attendance sheets, fee registers and stock lists.

    Step 1: Protect the original

    Save the export under a name such as Sales_Oct2026_RAW and never edit it. Copy the sheet into a working file. Microsoft’s own advice before removing duplicates is to copy the original range to another sheet or workbook first, because the command deletes data permanently. Cleaning mistakes cost nothing when you can start again from the raw copy.

    Step 2: Convert the range to a table

    Click inside the data and press Ctrl+T, or use Insert, then Table. Tick the box saying the table has headers. Microsoft recommends giving PivotTable source data one header row of unique, non-blank labels, no merged cells and, ideally, an Excel table format. A table also grows automatically when you paste next month’s rows beneath it, so later formulas and PivotTables stay in step. Give the table a clear name such as Sales on the Table Design tab.

    Step 3: Clean the text

    Add a helper column called Customer_Clean and enter:

    =TRIM(CLEAN([@Customer]))

    TRIM removes extra spaces and CLEAN removes non-printing characters, as shown in Microsoft’s TRIM documentation. If a value still refuses to match, it may contain a non-breaking space (character 160), which TRIM does not remove. Compare the results of LEN on the original and the cleaned cell. If an AI assistant is available, you can describe the problem in words and ask for a formula, for example to replace character 160 with a normal space, but run it on a few rows first.

    If you need to split or recombine text, such as separating a first name from a last name, Flash Fill can do it. Type the first result by hand, start the second, and press Enter to accept the preview, or press Ctrl+E. Microsoft lists Flash Fill as available in Excel for Microsoft 365 and in Excel 2016 and later versions. Always scan the filled column for rows where the pattern broke.

    Step 4: Find and remove duplicates carefully

    First look, then delete. Use conditional formatting to highlight duplicate Invoice Numbers, or filter for unique values, to confirm what Excel considers a duplicate. Remember Microsoft’s note that matching depends on displayed values, so two dates in different formats count as different. Once satisfied, choose Data, Remove Duplicates, and tick only Invoice No. Ticking every column would keep two rows for the same invoice if one of them has a different spelling in the Customer column.

    Write the number of rows before and after in a notes cell. A report that says “212 rows received, 9 duplicate invoices removed, 203 rows used” is far easier to defend.

    Step 5: Stop bad data entering again

    Select the City column, then use Data, Data Validation. On the Settings tab choose List, point to your list of cities, and set an error alert message on the Error Alert tab. Microsoft’s documentation describes this sequence, including the drop-down list option. Data validation is most useful where several people type into the same sheet.

    Step 6: Bring in rates with a lookup

    Suppose the rate list is a table named Rates with columns Code and Rate. To fetch the rate for each row, enter:

    =XLOOKUP([@[Product Code]],Rates[Code],Rates[Rate],"Rate missing")

    XLOOKUP matches exactly by default, and the fourth argument is the text shown when no match is found. Because it is not available in Excel 2016 or Excel 2019, use VLOOKUP with FALSE as the last argument, or INDEX with MATCH, if anyone who will open the file runs those versions. Then filter the column for “Rate missing”. Every such row is a data problem to resolve with the billing team, not a number to guess.

    Step 7: Check totals with SUMIFS

    On a separate sheet, build a check table. For example, for the total quantity of one product code in the North zone:

    =SUMIFS(Sales[Quantity],Sales[Product Code],"P101",Sales[Zone],"North")

    The sum range comes first in SUMIFS, and every criteria range must be the same size as the sum range. A result of zero often means a text criterion was written without quotation marks. Compare the grand total of Amount with the figure on the billing software’s own summary screen. If the two do not agree, find out why before you go further.

    Step 8: Summarise with a PivotTable

    Click inside the table and choose Insert, then PivotTable. Drag City to Rows and Amount to Values; Microsoft notes that numeric fields in Values default to Sum, and text fields to Count. Use the Show Values As tab to display each city as a percentage of the grand total. When you add next month’s rows to the table, right-click the PivotTable and choose Refresh. Forgetting to refresh is the most common reason a PivotTable shows old numbers.

    Add a chart from the PivotTable and give it a title that states the finding, for example “Lucknow contributes the largest share of October sales”, only if the numbers support it.

    Step 9: Use an AI assistant as a reviewer, not as the author

    Depending on your licence and your employer’s policy, Copilot in Excel can generate formulas, summarise data, build charts and PivotTables, and highlight outliers. Microsoft says that it may not be included in your subscription and may be limited by organisation settings. Where it is available:

    • use plan mode or chat mode when you want to see a proposal before anything in the workbook changes;
    • ask it to explain every formula in plain words;
    • test the output on three rows that you can compute by hand;
    • never include columns with phone numbers, bank details or similar personal data unless your employer permits it;
    • record in your notes which parts were drafted with assistance and checked by you.

    Step 10: Hand over a file that explains itself

    • A Notes sheet listing the source, the date, the rows received and used, and what was cleaned.
    • Clear sheet names: RAW, CLEAN, CHECKS, REPORT.
    • A last-updated date on the report sheet.
    • A version number in the file name, not words such as final2.

    Want guided practice? Excel and AI for Office Work (Rs 299) is a self-paced certificate course on Excel and AI tools for office work, finishing with a certificate.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is the quickest way to turn a range into a table?

    Click any cell in the range and press Ctrl+T, then confirm that the table has headers. Excel then treats the data as one named table that grows when you add rows.

    Why does my PivotTable show last month’s numbers?

    The PivotTable has not been refreshed. Right-click it and choose Refresh, or use Refresh All on the PivotTable Analyze tab when you have several.

    Should I use Remove Duplicates or a filter?

    Use a filter or conditional formatting to look first. Remove Duplicates deletes rows permanently, so use it only on a working copy.

    Can I use these steps on Excel 2019?

    Mostly yes, but not XLOOKUP. Use VLOOKUP with exact match or INDEX with MATCH. Flash Fill, PivotTables, SUMIFS and data validation are all available.

    Do I need Copilot to follow this guide?

    No. Every step works with ordinary Excel features. An assistant can speed up drafting, but the checks in steps 4 and 7 are what make the report reliable.

    This article is general information, not legal or other professional advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource. Laws, rates and procedures change, so check the current rule or consult a qualified professional before you act.

  • Business Law Situations Managers Face in India: 6 Illustrations and What to Do

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Business law is easiest to understand when you meet it in a situation. Below are six short, realistic situations that managers in Indian businesses run into, with the legal position and a sensible next step for each. Every scenario here is an invented illustration, not a real case, and the people and companies in them do not exist.

    The position stated is the general rule. Facts, contract wording and the state where you operate can change the answer, so treat each as a starting point for a conversation with your advocate or company secretary.

    Course: Business Law for Managers, Rs 499. A self-paced certificate course on business law for managers, for people who sign, approve and enforce business deals. View the course.

    Illustration 1: The purchase order that was never signed

    A sales manager at a packaging company emails a quotation to a retailer. The retailer replies on email: “Please go ahead, 2,000 boxes at your quoted rate, delivery in two weeks.” The company ships, but the retailer later refuses to pay, saying nothing was signed.

    Position: A contract is formed by offer and absolute acceptance (section 7, Indian Contract Act, 1872), and section 10A of the Information Technology Act, 2000 says a contract is not invalid only because it was formed electronically. The email reply, followed by delivery, is strong evidence of a concluded contract.

    What to do: Preserve the email chain with headers, the delivery challan and proof of receipt. Send a demand for the invoice amount and, in future, attach a standard terms page to every quotation.

    Illustration 2: The supplier who delivered late

    A food processor orders packaging material, with a clause that says “Rs 5 lakh will be deducted for every week of delay”. The supplier is three weeks late. The processor deducts Rs 15 lakh from an invoice of Rs 40 lakh, though its actual loss was a small overtime cost.

    Position: Under section 74, the aggrieved party can claim reasonable compensation not exceeding the sum named. A court will look at what is reasonable, and may not accept the whole sum if it is far above the real loss. Deducting the full amount unilaterally invites a counter claim for the withheld balance.

    What to do: Document the actual loss caused by the delay, give written notice of the deduction with reasons, and pay the undisputed part. Next time, write a liquidated damages figure that you can justify.

    Illustration 3: Raw material prices double

    A garment exporter signed a fixed price contract to supply 10,000 shirts. Cotton prices rise sharply and the exporter writes to the buyer that the contract is “frustrated” and should be cancelled.

    Position: Section 56 of the Contract Act deals with agreements that become impossible to perform. The Supreme Court has long held that a contract is not frustrated merely because it has become more expensive or less profitable (Satyabrata Ghose v. Mugneeram Bangur and Co.). Unless the contract has a price variation or force majeure clause that covers it, the exporter remains bound.

    What to do: Read the contract for price adjustment, force majeure and termination clauses. If none helps, negotiate a revised price rather than cancelling, because wrongful cancellation exposes the exporter to damages under section 73.

    Illustration 4: The sales head who joins a rival

    A software firm’s sales head resigns and joins a competitor. His appointment letter says he will not work for any competitor in India for two years after leaving. The firm threatens legal action against him and the competitor.

    Position: Section 27 of the Contract Act voids agreements in restraint of a lawful profession or trade, and courts have generally refused to enforce post-employment restraints of this kind. What the firm can still protect is its confidential information, client lists and source code, through a suit for breach of confidence or misuse of trade secrets.

    What to do: Do not send threatening notices that rely only on the non-compete. Identify what confidential material the employee actually took or used, and send a targeted notice on that. For future hires, redraft the clause around confidentiality and notice periods.

    Illustration 5: The cheque given as “security”

    A trader gives a distributor a signed cheque for Rs 6 lakh as security for goods supplied on credit. The goods are delivered, the invoice falls due, and the distributor deposits the cheque on the due date. It is returned for insufficient funds.

    Position: A cheque issued as security can still attract section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 if, when it is presented, a legally enforceable debt is actually due. If no debt had become payable, the drawer may have a defence. The notice must be sent within 30 days of the return memo, the drawer gets 15 days to pay, and the complaint must be filed within one month after that.

    What to do: Both sides should keep the invoice, delivery proof and the cheque return memo. The distributor should send the statutory notice for the cheque amount only; the trader should reply in writing within the 15 days if the debt is disputed.

    Illustration 6: Two friends start a business on a handshake

    Two friends begin a trading business, pooling money and agreeing orally to share profits equally. They never register the firm. After eighteen months, one partner stops contributing and the other wants to sue a customer who refuses to pay.

    Position: A partnership can exist without a written deed, since the Indian Partnership Act, 1932 defines it by the relationship and not the paper. But section 69 bars a suit by or on behalf of an unregistered firm against a third party to enforce a contract right, so the unpaid customer can object to the suit. Partners in an ordinary partnership have unlimited, joint liability for the firm’s debts. A limited liability partnership under the Limited Liability Partnership Act, 2008 is a separate legal entity and limits each partner’s liability to the agreed contribution, subject to fraud and other exceptions.

    What to do: Put a partnership deed in writing, register the firm with the Registrar of Firms of the state, and consider whether an LLP or a company suits the risk of the business.

    What these illustrations have in common

    • The outcome usually depended on documents created before the dispute, not on arguments made after it.
    • Time limits (for a cheque notice, for a suit, for responding) were as important as the rights themselves.
    • Specific clauses, such as the penalty, force majeure, confidentiality and dispute resolution, decided who carried the risk.
    • Choosing the right structure and forum at the start, such as LLP versus partnership, avoided procedural obstacles later.

    A simple habit that prevents most of these problems

    Before approving any deal, ask three questions. Is the commitment clear in a document both sides have accepted? What happens if either side fails to perform, and for how much? Where and how will a dispute be resolved? If you can answer all three from the paper in front of you, you are in a far better position than most businesses. The course below teaches these basics for managers who work with contracts and company law every day.

    Course: Business Law for Managers, Rs 499. A self-paced certificate course on business law for managers, for people who sign, approve and enforce business deals. View the course.

    Frequently asked questions

    Are these scenarios real cases?

    No. They are invented illustrations to show how common rules work. Real facts, contract wording and state rules can change the result.

    Can a binding contract be made over WhatsApp?

    It can be, if the messages show an offer and an unqualified acceptance on certain terms, because electronic contracts are not invalid merely for being electronic. Proof and clarity of terms are the practical issues.

    Does a security cheque always lead to a cheque bounce case?

    No. Section 138 requires that a legally enforceable debt is due when the cheque is presented. If no debt had become due, the drawer may defend the case.

    Should small businesses form an LLP instead of a partnership?

    It depends on the risk, tax position and compliance appetite. An LLP gives limited liability and separate legal personality but has its own filings, so take professional advice.

    Can I recover losses if my supplier breaches a contract?

    You may claim compensation for loss that naturally arises from the breach, and reasonable compensation up to the named sum where a penalty clause exists, under sections 73 and 74 of the Contract Act, subject to proof and your duty to reduce loss.

    When should a manager involve a lawyer?

    Before signing anything with high value, long duration or unusual risk, and immediately on receipt of any legal notice, because many responses have fixed time limits.

    This article is general information, not legal advice for any specific case, and the law and rules may change or differ by state. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • Builder Delayed Possession or Cancelled My Flat: Real Buyer Scenarios and What RERA Says

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: Under the RERA Act, 2016, a flat buyer facing a builder dispute usually has a clear route: a written notice, then a complaint to the state RERA Authority (or to the adjudicating officer for compensation), or alternatively a consumer complaint. Which step suits you depends on the problem. The seven scenarios below are illustrations made up for this guide, not real cases, and each one gives the legal position and the practical next step.

    Names, amounts and dates in the illustrations are invented. The legal provisions are real and come from the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 and the Registration Act, 1908. State rules, such as the rate of interest and the complaint form and fee, vary, so read your state’s RERA rules before filing.

    Want the full picture? The Lexfolio Home Buyer’s Legal Course is a self-paced certificate course on the legal side of buying a home in India. Price: Rs 399.

    The remedies at a glance

    ProblemMain provisionWhere to go
    Delay in possessionSection 18(1): refund with interest, or interest for every month of delayRERA Authority (section 31 complaint) or consumer commission
    Advance above 10 per cent without registered agreementSection 13(1)RERA Authority
    False statement in an advertisement or brochureSection 12: compensation, or refund with interest on withdrawalRERA Authority or adjudicating officer, consumer commission
    Structural or other defect within five yearsSection 14(3): fix within 30 days free of charge, else compensationAdjudicating officer (section 71), consumer commission
    Unilateral cancellationSection 11(5)RERA Authority
    No conveyance or documents after occupancy certificateSection 17RERA Authority

    Illustration 1: The tower that is two years late

    Illustration: Meera booked a flat in a registered project with possession due in March 2024. By November 2026 only the structure is up and the builder gives a new date every few months. She has paid 80 per cent of the price.

    Legal position: section 18(1) of the RERA Act gives her a choice. She can withdraw from the project and claim a refund of the amounts paid with interest and compensation, or she can stay and claim interest for every month of delay until possession is handed over. The rate is the one prescribed by state rules, and many states use the State Bank of India’s highest marginal cost of lending rate plus two per cent. What to do: decide first whether she still wants the flat. Then send a written notice stating the choice, wait for a reasonable reply period, and file a complaint with the RERA Authority under section 31. A consumer complaint is also open to her, as the Supreme Court held in Imperia Structures v. Anil Patni (2020), but she cannot sensibly run both for the same relief.

    Illustration 2: The builder who wants 30 per cent on an allotment letter

    Illustration: Arjun is shown a pre-launch project. The sales team says that if he does not pay 30 per cent in two weeks, the price will rise. No agreement for sale is offered, only an allotment letter.

    Legal position: section 13(1) prevents a promoter from taking more than 10 per cent as advance or application fee without a written, registered agreement for sale. What to do: offer to pay up to the permitted amount and ask for the registered agreement before paying more. Check the project registration on the state RERA website. If the builder insists and Arjun has already paid more, he should keep the receipts, write to the builder to request the agreement and, if it is refused, raise the matter with the Authority.

    Illustration 3: The clubhouse that appeared only in the brochure

    Illustration: Kavita bought because the brochure and the video showed a clubhouse and a swimming pool. At possession, the plot reserved for them has been converted into a parking lot.

    Legal position: section 12 of the RERA Act entitles a person who suffers loss because of a false statement in an advertisement, prospectus or model apartment to compensation, and a buyer who withdraws is entitled to a refund with interest. Section 14(2) bars a promoter from changing sanctioned plans, specifications or amenities without the buyer’s prior consent, apart from minor changes recommended by an authorised architect or engineer, with intimation to the buyer. Changes to common areas of a building need the written consent of at least two thirds of the buyers in that building. What to do: compare the brochure, the sanctioned plan on the RERA site and the agreement for sale. Kavita’s position is strongest if the amenity is in the sanctioned plan or the agreement, and weakest if it appears only in a brochure with a disclaimer. She should write to the builder with the comparison and then approach the Authority or the adjudicating officer.

    Illustration 4: Seepage and cracks eight months after possession

    Illustration: Rohit took possession in January. By September, the bedroom ceiling leaks and a crack runs along the load bearing wall. The builder says that the maintenance is now the society’s responsibility.

    Legal position: section 14(3) says that where a structural defect or any other defect in workmanship, quality or provision of services, not in conformity with the agreement, is brought to the promoter’s notice within five years from the date of handing over possession, the promoter must rectify it without further charge within 30 days. If the promoter fails, the affected buyers are entitled to compensation. What to do: photograph the defects, write to the builder by email and speed post with the date of possession, and ask for rectification within 30 days. Keep proof of delivery. If nothing is done, a claim for compensation can go to the adjudicating officer under section 71, who is expected to decide within 60 days.

    Illustration 5: Cancellation after one missed instalment

    Illustration: Sana’s bank loan disbursal was delayed by three weeks, and she missed an instalment. The builder cancels the allotment by an email and forfeits what she has paid.

    Legal position: section 11(5) allows a promoter to cancel an allotment only in the manner and on the grounds stated in the agreement for sale, and says that a buyer can approach the Authority if the cancellation is unilateral and without sufficient cause. A buyer is also expected to pay on time: section 19(6) and 19(7) require payment as per the agreement and interest on late payments at the prescribed rate. What to do: read the cancellation clause and the notice. Offer the overdue amount with the interest and ask for the cancellation to be withdrawn in writing. If the builder refuses, complain to the Authority and attach the agreement, the demand letters and proof of payments. Sana should never ignore a notice or a reminder in the first place.

    Illustration 6: Possession given, but no occupancy certificate and no conveyance

    Illustration: Imran moved into his flat a year ago. The builder keeps saying that the occupancy certificate and the conveyance deed are in process. The electricity connection is temporary, and the bank is asking for the registered conveyance.

    Legal position: section 17(1) says the promoter must execute a registered conveyance deed in favour of the buyer and hand over the common areas within the period provided by local laws, or within three months of the occupancy certificate if there is none. Section 17(2) requires necessary documents and plans to be handed over within 30 days of the occupancy certificate where local law is silent. The buyer, for his part, is to take physical possession within two months of the certificate under section 19(10). What to do: ask the local authority, through the builder or directly through an application, whether an occupancy certificate has been issued. Imran should send a notice demanding the certificate copy and a date for the conveyance, then complain to the Authority if the builder does not respond.

    Illustration 7: A resale flat with a hidden loan

    Illustration: Neha agrees to buy a resale flat from its owner and pays an advance. A week later she learns from a neighbour that the owner took a home loan against it, and the original papers are with the bank.

    Legal position: a resale is a transaction between private parties, so the protections specific to promoters in the RERA Act do not apply in the same way, and the buyer’s safety lies in due diligence and in a properly drafted agreement. A registered document is needed to transfer a right in immovable property worth Rs 100 or more (section 17, Registration Act, 1908). What to do: ask for the loan statement and the bank’s no-objection letter, and structure the payment so that the balance goes to the bank to clear the loan against a written release of the original documents. Do not pay the full price to the seller on the strength of a promise. A lawyer should draft the agreement to say who will clear the loan and when.

    Before you file anything

    • Collect the registered agreement, receipts, demand letters, emails, and the brochure.
    • Send a written notice by speed post and email, and keep the proof of delivery.
    • Check your state’s RERA complaint form and fee on the Authority’s website. The form and fee differ between states.
    • Choose one forum for the same relief. A consumer complaint must be filed within two years of the cause of action under section 69 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, and is filed online on e-Jagriti.
    • Consider whether talks with the builder in writing can resolve it faster, without giving up the right to file.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can I get a refund if the builder is late?

    Yes. Under section 18(1) of the RERA Act, a buyer who withdraws from a delayed project can claim a refund of the amount paid with interest and compensation. The outcome in a particular case depends on the agreement, the facts and the order of the Authority.

    Do I have to go to RERA, or can I go to a consumer commission?

    You can choose. The Supreme Court held in Imperia Structures v. Anil Patni (2020) that the RERA Act does not bar a consumer complaint. Do not claim the same relief twice in two forums.

    Who decides compensation claims under RERA?

    Claims for compensation under sections 12, 14, 18 and 19 are decided by the adjudicating officer appointed under section 71, who is a judicial officer who is or was a District Judge. Other complaints go to the Authority under section 31.

    Is the interest rate the same in all states?

    No. Each state frames its own rules. Many use the State Bank of India’s highest marginal cost of lending rate plus two per cent, but you should read the rule of your own state.

    What documents should I keep for a complaint?

    The agreement for sale, all receipts and bank statements, demand letters, the brochure, advertisements, emails and messages with the builder, photographs of defects and proof of any notice you sent.

    Go beyond this guide. Continue with the Lexfolio Home Buyer’s Legal Course, a self-paced certificate course on the legal side of buying a home in India. Price: Rs 399.

    This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice for a specific case. Laws, rules and fees change and differ by state, so check the current text or consult a lawyer for your situation. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • BRSR and ESG Reporting in India: 8 Myths About Who Must Report and What

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: BRSR is a mandatory annual disclosure only for the top 1000 listed entities by market capitalisation, under regulation 34(2)(f) of the SEBI listing regulations. Everyone else reports voluntarily or because a buyer, bank or investor asks. Beyond that headline, there are many misunderstandings about what ESG reporting covers, how it differs from CSR, and what regulators now expect.

    Below are eight common myths with the correct position. Because SEBI revises BRSR rules often, treat dates and thresholds as a snapshot and confirm them against the latest circular.

    Want a structured view of ESG reporting in India? The Lexfolio ESG and BRSR Reporting in India is a self-paced certificate course on ESG and BRSR reporting in India. Price: Rs 599.

    Myth 1: Every company must file a BRSR

    The Business Responsibility and Sustainability Report is required of the top 1000 listed entities by market capitalisation, and the requirement has been mandatory since FY 2022-23. A company outside that group, a private company or a small business has no BRSR duty under the listing regulations. It may still choose to report using the BRSR format because the format is a ready template that lenders and customers recognise.

    Myth 2: ESG is just another word for CSR

    Corporate social responsibility under section 135 of the Companies Act, 2013 is a spending obligation. It applies to a company with a net worth of Rs 500 crore or more, turnover of Rs 1,000 crore or more, or net profit of Rs 5 crore or more in the preceding financial year. Such a company must spend at least 2 per cent of its average net profit of the three preceding financial years on activities in Schedule VII, and unspent amounts must be handled in the way the section provides, for example by transfer to an unspent CSR account within 30 days after the end of the financial year for ongoing projects.

    ESG reporting is a disclosure framework. It asks how the business manages emissions, water, waste, people, safety, supply chains, ethics and governance, and it asks for numbers. A company can have a strong CSR programme and weak ESG data, or the reverse. The two sit in different laws, apply to different sets of companies and answer different questions.

    Myth 3: BRSR is only about the environment

    BRSR is organised around the nine principles of the National Guidelines on Responsible Business Conduct issued by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs. These cover ethics and transparency, sustainable and safe products, employee well-being, stakeholder responsiveness, human rights, the environment, responsible policy advocacy, inclusive growth and consumer value. The report has three sections: general disclosures (Section A), management and process disclosures (Section B) and principle wise performance (Section C), with essential indicators that must be reported and leadership indicators that are voluntary. A company that can report its emissions but not its workforce safety record has only a partial BRSR.

    Myth 4: BRSR Core means the same assurance for everyone from day one

    BRSR Core is a subset of indicators across nine ESG attributes that must be independently assessed or assured. SEBI phased it in by market capitalisation: the top 150 listed entities from FY 2023-24, the top 250 from FY 2024-25, the top 500 from FY 2025-26 and the top 1000 from FY 2026-27. A company just outside the old cut off may therefore be preparing for assessment for the first time this year. A March 2025 circular also allowed third party assessment as an alternative route. The provider must be independent of conflicts of interest, so the firm that helps compile the report should not be the same firm that verifies it.

    Myth 5: Value chain disclosures are compulsory and apply to all suppliers

    SEBI’s framework asks the largest listed entities to report on their value chain partners, defined by reference to partners that individually make up 2 per cent or more of purchases or sales by value, with an option to cover partners accounting for 75 per cent of the total. A March 2025 circular made value chain disclosure and the related assessment voluntary and shifted the timelines. This does not mean suppliers can ignore the subject. A listed buyer may still ask for data, and a procurement contract may require it. If you are a supplier, read the questionnaire clause before you sign.

    TopicCommon beliefPosition
    BRSR applicabilityAll companiesTop 1000 listed entities by market capitalisation; others voluntary
    CSR and ESGSame thingCSR is a spending duty under section 135; ESG reporting is a disclosure framework
    BRSR Core assuranceApplies equally to all from the startPhased: top 150, 250, 500, then top 1000 in FY 2026-27
    Value chain disclosuresMandatory for all suppliersVoluntary for the listed entity under the 2025 circular; suppliers may still be asked contractually

    Myth 6: Green claims in advertising need no proof

    An environmental claim in a brochure, a label or a social media post is a claim of fact. The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 deals with misleading advertisements, and the Central Consumer Protection Authority issued guidelines on greenwashing and misleading environmental claims in October 2024. Words such as eco friendly, natural, green, sustainable or carbon neutral should be backed by evidence and qualified so that an ordinary consumer is not misled. The Advertising Standards Council of India has its own code on environmental claims. The safe habit is to keep a file of evidence for every claim before it goes public.

    Myth 7: The ESG report is a marketing brochure

    The BRSR is filed with the stock exchanges as part of the annual report cycle, in the prescribed format. It is a regulatory filing, and the numbers must be consistent with the financial statements, the board’s report and other filings. A report that is polished but contains figures that cannot be traced to source records invites questions from the assessor, from investors and from the regulator. A good internal rule is that every number in the report has an owner, a source and a calculation note.

    Myth 8: The Companies Act says nothing about ESG

    Section 166(2) of the Companies Act, 2013 requires a director to act in good faith to promote the objects of the company for the benefit of its members as a whole, and in the best interests of the company, its employees, the shareholders, the community and for the protection of the environment. This duty applies to every company, listed or not. Section 134 requires the board’s report to carry specified disclosures, and for companies covered by section 135 the CSR report. For a director, ESG is therefore not only a market trend. It already sits inside the statutory duties.

    What a sensible company does after clearing the myths

    1. Confirm whether it is within the BRSR net by market capitalisation, and note the year in which BRSR Core assessment starts for it.
    2. Map the nine principles to the departments that hold the data: HR, EHS, finance, procurement, legal and compliance.
    3. Test whether CSR obligations under section 135 are met separately and recorded in the board’s report.
    4. Review every environmental claim in marketing against evidence.
    5. Check customer and lender questionnaires for contractual ESG data obligations.
    6. Appoint an owner for the report with a timetable that finishes before the annual report is approved.

    Even a company that has no legal duty to report benefits from this exercise, because it shows lenders and customers where the data stands before they ask.

    Move from myths to a working reporting process. The Lexfolio ESG and BRSR Reporting in India is a self-paced certificate course on ESG and BRSR reporting in India. Price: Rs 599.

    Frequently asked questions

    Is BRSR mandatory for unlisted companies?

    No. The BRSR requirement under the SEBI listing regulations applies to the top 1000 listed entities by market capitalisation. Unlisted companies may report voluntarily, and many do so because large customers, lenders or investors ask for the same data.

    What is the difference between BRSR and BRSR Core?

    BRSR is the full report. BRSR Core is a smaller set of key performance indicators drawn from it, covering nine ESG attributes, which is subject to assessment or assurance by an independent provider. The coverage of BRSR Core has been phased in by market capitalisation.

    Does BRSR replace the Business Responsibility Report?

    For the top 1000 listed entities, yes. The BRSR replaced the earlier Business Responsibility Report and became mandatory from FY 2022-23, after a period when it was voluntary.

    Can a company be penalised for greenwashing in India?

    Misleading environmental claims in advertising can be treated as a misleading advertisement under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, and the Central Consumer Protection Authority issued guidelines on greenwashing in October 2024. The Advertising Standards Council of India also has its own guidelines on environmental claims.

    Do small suppliers have to provide ESG data to a listed buyer?

    The law does not directly force a small supplier to report, but a listed buyer may ask for data to meet its own value chain disclosures, and a supplier contract may include an obligation to supply it. Read the clause before signing.

    This article is general information, not legal or professional advice for a specific case. SEBI revises BRSR thresholds, formats and assurance timelines often, so check the latest circulars before preparing a report. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • How to Write an AI Use Policy for Your Office in India: Step by Step

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: an AI use policy for an Indian office should do six things: say which tools are approved, sort information into classes and say which class may go into which tool, require a named human to check and own every output, set rules for personal data, say what to do when something goes wrong, and train staff and review the policy regularly. No Indian law prescribes a form for it, but the law you already have (contracts, the IT Act, copyright and, from 13 May 2027, the main duties under the data protection law) is exactly what the policy should translate into daily rules.

    This guide is for a small or medium employer, a department head or an HR or compliance person who has been asked to “write something on ChatGPT”. It is a drafting checklist with a skeleton you can adapt, not a ready made legal document.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI at Work: Using ChatGPT and AI Tools Safely and Legally, a self-paced certificate course on using ChatGPT and other AI tools safely and legally at work. Course price: Rs 299.

    Why a written policy is worth the effort

    Staff are using these tools whether you permit them or not. A policy turns a vague worry into rules people can follow, and it gives the employer something to point to if an employee later breaches confidentiality or passes off unchecked output as fact. It also supports the position that the organisation took “reasonable security practices”, which is the standard section 43A of the IT Act uses today and the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 will use from 13 May 2027 when its main duties are scheduled to apply.

    The India AI Governance Guidelines issued by the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology on 5 November 2025 favour voluntary measures and existing laws over a new AI statute, and encourage organisations that deploy AI to provide accessible grievance redressal. A written policy is the natural way to follow that approach.

    Step 1: Find out what is already being used

    Ask each team, without blame, which tools they use, on what accounts (company or personal), for what tasks and with what kinds of data. Check browser extensions, meeting note takers and tools built into software you already pay for. You cannot write rules for a practice you have not seen.

    Step 2: Classify your information

    A simple four class table is enough for most offices.

    ClassExamplesRule for public AI tools
    ———
    PublicPublished brochures, public rulesAllowed
    InternalDraft emails, internal notes with no personal dataAllowed on approved tools only
    ConfidentialClient contracts, pricing, unpublished results, source code, legal adviceNot allowed unless the tool is approved for it in writing
    Personal or sensitiveEmployee, student, patient or customer data; financial and health dataNot allowed; mask or anonymise first

    Add your own classes where a client or regulator already has one. If your clients’ contracts say that their data must not leave particular systems, those contracts override your internal table.

    Step 3: Approve tools and accounts

    Name the tools staff may use, on company accounts only. For each tool, someone should read the terms on four points: whether inputs are stored, whether they are used to improve the service, where data is processed and who owns the output. Ask for business or enterprise terms where confidential data is involved, and record the date you checked. Put a person in charge of approving new tools so that the question “can I use X?” has a clear answer.

    Step 4: Write the do and do not rules

    Keep them short enough to fit on one page.

    • Do use approved tools for drafting, summarising public material, brainstorming, translation drafts and formula help.
    • Do not enter confidential or personal information into an unapproved tool.
    • Do not present generated text, numbers or legal or medical statements as verified unless a person has checked them.
    • Do not generate or share images, voices or videos of real people without their written consent.
    • Do not use a tool to make or finalise decisions about hiring, pay, discipline or credit without a human reviewer.
    • Do not upload third party copyrighted material that you are not licensed to copy.

    Step 5: Make human review a rule, not a hope

    Name the role that is responsible for each type of output. The person who sends a document, signs an opinion or publishes a post owns it, whichever tool helped draft it. The Supreme Court’s recent remarks about non-existent citations in court filings (17 and 27 February 2026, and again on 5 May 2026) show the standard the system now expects: verification against authentic sources, and no excuse that “the tool made the mistake”. For important work, ask the reviewer to note what was checked and against which source.

    Step 6: Deal with personal data

    If you handle personal data, list which tools touch it and whether the vendor processes it on your behalf. From 13 May 2027 a data fiduciary will have to take reasonable security safeguards (the Rules mention measures such as encryption, masking or tokenisation, access controls, logging and monitoring, and back ups) and have contracts requiring processors to maintain equivalent safeguards. The Rules also provide for breach intimation to the Data Protection Board and to affected persons. Maximum penalties in the Act’s schedule are Rs 250 crore for failure to take reasonable security safeguards and Rs 200 crore for failure to give intimation of a breach. Build these into the policy now: approved tools only for personal data, a record of what is sent, and a clear no for anything not on the list.

    Step 7: Set up incident reporting

    Define what counts as an incident: confidential data pasted into an unapproved tool, an account taken over, a fake generated message used against the company. Give staff one person and one phone number to tell at once. Some events are also reportable outside the company. Under the CERT-In directions of 28 April 2022, listed incidents such as unauthorised access, data breaches and phishing must be reported to CERT-In within six hours of noticing. The directions also expect logs to be kept for 180 days within India.

    Step 8: Cover disclosure and intellectual property

    Decide when staff must say that a tool was used: for example in client work, submissions to authorities, academic or training material, and anything that carries your signature. For authorship, remember that section 2(d)(vi) of the Copyright Act, 1957 treats the person who causes a computer-generated work to be created as its author, but how this applies to text or images produced by a generative tool is not settled by an Indian court judgment, and the DPIIT working paper of 8 December 2025 on generative AI and copyright is only a consultation document. Do not promise clients exclusive ownership of generated material without checking the tool’s terms.

    Step 9: Train people and test the policy

    A one page policy nobody has read does nothing. Run a short session using real examples from your own office, run two or three test cases (for example, “can I paste this client agreement?”) and fix unclear rules. Give staff a place to ask questions without fear of blame.

    Step 10: Review at fixed intervals

    The law and the tools are both moving. The data protection obligations begin on 13 May 2027, the IT Rules were amended in February 2026 to require labelling of synthetic content, and courts and regulators continue to issue directions on AI. Put a review date in the policy, such as every six months, and name who will carry it out.

    A skeleton you can adapt

    1. Purpose and scope. This policy applies to all employees, contractors and interns using generative tools for work.

    2. Approved tools. Only tools on the approved list, used through company accounts.

    3. Information classes. Public, internal, confidential, personal. Confidential and personal information must not be entered into any tool unless approved in writing.

    4. Human responsibility. The person who uses or sends an output is responsible for checking it.

    5. Prohibited uses. Decisions about people without human review; synthetic images or voices of real people without consent; copying third party material without a licence.

    6. Incidents. Report to [name, phone] immediately.

    7. Disclosure. State tool use where a client, contract or rule requires it.

    8. Review. This policy is reviewed every six months.

    Have a lawyer review the final text against your contracts and sector rules before you adopt it.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI at Work: Using ChatGPT and AI Tools Safely and Legally, a self-paced certificate course on using ChatGPT and other AI tools safely and legally at work. Course price: Rs 299.

    Frequently asked questions

    Is an AI use policy legally required in India?

    A: No Indian law requires a stand-alone one at present. But a policy helps show reasonable security practices and responsible governance, and certain contracts and regulators may expect one.

    Can we make employees sign the policy?

    A: Yes. Make acceptance part of onboarding and circulate updates with an acknowledgement. Whether a breach justifies disciplinary action depends on your service rules and the employee contract.

    Should we ban all AI tools instead?

    A: A complete ban is hard to enforce and pushes use onto personal accounts, where you have no visibility. A narrow approved list with clear data rules is usually safer.

    Do small offices need all ten steps?

    A: Not at full scale. A single page covering approved tools, data classes, human review and who to tell about an incident gives most of the protection.

    This article is general information, not legal, financial or tax advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services.

  • Is It Legal? 6 ChatGPT and AI Situations at Work in India

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    “Is it legal?” is the question people ask after they have already used the tool. This guide runs through six everyday workplace situations involving ChatGPT and similar tools, and gives for each the legal position in India and the safer way to proceed. Every person and fact below is an invented illustration, written to show how the rules apply; none is a real case.

    Keep in mind that India has no stand-alone AI statute. The India AI Governance Guidelines issued by the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology on 5 November 2025 prefer voluntary measures and the application of existing laws, so each answer below comes from those existing laws: contracts, the Information Technology Act, 2000 (IT Act), the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), copyright law and the data protection law as it is being phased in.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI at Work: Using ChatGPT and AI Tools Safely and Legally, a self-paced certificate course on using ChatGPT and other AI tools safely and legally at work. Course price: Rs 299.

    Illustration 1: The contract pasted into a chatbot

    Facts (illustration): A junior associate at a consulting firm pastes a client’s draft supply agreement, marked confidential, into a public chatbot to “get a quick summary”.

    Legal position. The client’s agreement and the associate’s employment terms almost certainly contain confidentiality clauses, and sending the text to an outside service is a disclosure to a third party. Breach can lead to a contractual claim against the firm and disciplinary action against the employee. Section 72A of the IT Act punishes disclosure of personal information obtained under a lawful contract with intent to cause wrongful loss or gain (up to three years or a fine up to Rs 5 lakh, or both), but intent is needed, so the usual consequences are contractual and professional. If the agreement included personal data of the client’s staff, section 43A and, from 13 May 2027, the data protection law’s safeguards come into play.

    What to do. Tell the supervisor at once. Check the tool’s terms on storage and training use, delete the conversation if the settings allow, and record what happened. If the client’s contract requires notice of a possible leak, give it. In future use an approved tool or summarise by hand with names removed.

    Illustration 2: The market report with statistics that do not exist

    Facts (illustration): An analyst asks a chatbot for “market size data” for a proposal. The answer includes a precise percentage growth figure and a named industry report. The analyst puts both in a client proposal without checking.

    Legal position. Generative tools can produce confident but false numbers and sources. If a client relies on a false statement made carelessly or knowingly in a proposal, the firm can face a claim under the contract or in tort, and a knowingly false statement made to obtain business could raise questions of cheating (section 318 BNS). The Supreme Court’s remarks on 17 February 2026 about a cited case that does not exist, and its order of 27 February 2026 in Gummadi Usha Rani v. Sure Mallikarjuna Rao, show that Indian courts regard unverified output as a failure of professional diligence, not a technical glitch.

    What to do. Withdraw or correct the proposal as soon as the error is found, and tell the client. Trace each figure to a source you can open. Add a rule that statistics and citations in client documents need a named reviewer.

    Illustration 3: The resume screening tool

    Facts (illustration): A recruiter uses a tool that scores resumes and automatically rejects those below a cut-off. A candidate asks why she was rejected and suspects the tool penalised a career break.

    Legal position. There is no Indian statute specifically on automated hiring tools. Private sector employers have wide freedom in hiring, but constitutional equality norms bind state employers and public bodies, and a decision that is arbitrary or based on irrelevant factors invites challenge and reputational harm. The candidate’s personal data in the resume must be handled lawfully: from 13 May 2027 the data protection law will require, among other things, reasonable security safeguards and notice-based processing. The 2025 governance guidelines also encourage deployers of AI to maintain a grievance redressal route.

    What to do. Treat the tool’s score as an input. Let a human review rejections, keep reasons on record and test the tool on past hiring to see whether it screens out a group unfairly. Tell applicants that a tool is used and give a contact for questions.

    Illustration 4: The meeting note taker on a client call

    Facts (illustration): A project manager adds an automatic note taking bot to a video call with a client, without telling the client. The bot stores a transcript on the vendor’s servers.

    Legal position. India has no single statute that sets out in one place when a participant may record a call to which they are a party, so the answer is found in the contract, the client’s confidentiality terms and general privacy and data rules. A transcript may contain personal data and trade secrets, and storing it on a vendor’s servers is a disclosure to a processor. Secretly recording a client can also destroy trust even where no law is broken. From 13 May 2027, personal data in the transcript will fall under the data protection duties.

    What to do. Announce the bot at the start of the call and get a clear yes. Use only an approved vendor, set a retention period, restrict who can see transcripts and delete them on schedule.

    Illustration 5: The advertisement image that looks like a real person

    Facts (illustration): A small brand uses a generated image of a woman who strongly resembles a well known actor to advertise a skin cream, and posts it on social media without a label.

    Legal position. Using a person’s look or voice to suggest endorsement can mislead consumers and may give the person a claim for misuse of personality, passing off or defamation, depending on the facts. The IT Rules were amended by a notification dated 10 February 2026, effective 20 February 2026, requiring permitted synthetic content to be prominently labelled and providing for faster platform action, so an unlabelled synthetic ad risks takedown. Consumer protection law also deals with misleading advertisements. Do not assume that because a picture was “made by a tool” no one’s rights are touched.

    What to do. Use images of real, consenting people with written releases, or of clearly fictional persons, and label synthetic content. Remove the post if the person objects and keep a record of the removal.

    Illustration 6: The voice that sounded like the director

    Facts (illustration): The accounts manager of a mid sized company gets a phone call from a voice that sounds exactly like the managing director, instructing an urgent transfer of Rs 5 lakh to a vendor “for a confidential deal”. The money is sent. It later emerges that the voice was cloned.

    Legal position. Obtaining money by pretending to be someone else is cheating by personation (section 319 BNS) and, when a computer resource is used, section 66D of the IT Act (up to three years and a fine up to Rs 1 lakh). Because the company’s own officer authorised the transfer, the Reserve Bank of India’s 2017 circular on customer liability for unauthorised transactions is unlikely to help much, which makes speed of reporting more important.

    What to do. Call the bank at once, report on cybercrime.gov.in or the helpline 1930 and file a police complaint. A compromised e-mail or account is a listed incident for CERT-In, to be reported within six hours of noticing. Afterwards adopt a call back rule for any payment instruction: verify using a number from your own records, and require two approvers above a set amount.

    What the six situations have in common

    Each problem began with a tool being used faster than the rules around it. The fixes are modest: approved tools, information classes, a named human reviewer, labelling and consent for synthetic content, and a plain way to report incidents.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI at Work: Using ChatGPT and AI Tools Safely and Legally, a self-paced certificate course on using ChatGPT and other AI tools safely and legally at work. Course price: Rs 299.

    Frequently asked questions

    Is it a crime to use ChatGPT at work?

    A: No. Using a tool is not an offence. Liability arises from what is done with it, such as disclosing confidential data in breach of contract, cheating or impersonating someone.

    Can a company be sued for something an employee generated with a chatbot?

    A: Yes, in the same way as for any employee’s work, depending on the facts and on whether the employee acted within the scope of the job. A clear policy and training help the employer.

    Do I have to label content made with these tools?

    A: There is no blanket duty on every individual. The amended IT Rules require permitted synthetic content on covered platforms to be labelled, and contracts, clients and institutions may have their own disclosure rules. Labelling is the safe habit.

    What should a company do first if it suspects a leak through an AI tool?

    A: Stop further use, preserve logs and chats, tell the person in charge of security or legal, and check whether the incident is of a type that must be reported to CERT-In or to the client under contract.

    This article is general information, not legal, financial or tax advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services.

  • AI at Work in India: 7 Legal Risk Scenarios and What to Do

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: When AI goes wrong at work, there is rarely a special AI statute to point to. Instead, the problem falls under data protection, consumer protection, cyber and criminal law, contract and sector rules. The seven situations below are illustrations invented to show how those laws apply. Names and facts are made up, and real outcomes depend on documents, contracts and the facts of each case. Each one ends with a practical first move.

    Want to handle these situations with a plan? The Lexfolio Certificate Course in AI Law and Governance in India: Compliance for Businesses and Institutions is a self-paced certificate course on AI law and governance in India, written for managers, compliance teams and institutions that use AI tools. Price: Rs 599.

    Illustration 1: The manager who pasted a client contract into a chatbot

    Facts: A senior manager at a consulting firm pastes a client’s draft joint venture agreement into a free public chatbot to get a summary. The agreement contains personal details of the client’s directors.

    Legal position: Two layers apply. The firm almost certainly owes a confidentiality duty under its engagement letter, and sharing the draft with a third party tool may breach it. Separately, the directors’ details are personal data. Under section 8(1) of the DPDP Act the Data Fiduciary remains responsible for processing done through others, and section 8(5) requires reasonable security safeguards. Most business duties under the Rules start on 13 May 2027, but the contractual breach exists today.

    What to do: Stop use, find out what the tool does with inputs, check whether deletion can be requested, tell the client if the engagement letter requires it, and issue a clear rule on approved tools.

    Illustration 2: The CV screening tool that rejects most women applicants

    Facts: A manufacturer buys a tool that ranks applicants. After three months, the HR head notices that candidates with career gaps are being ranked low, and most of them are women who took maternity leave.

    Legal position: India has no single employment AI law, but equality is a constitutional value and discrimination claims, reputational harm and data protection duties all arise. The DPDP Act allows some processing connected with employment, but that does not excuse inaccurate or unfair decisions. The India AI Governance Guidelines list Fairness and Equity among the seven principles and recommend that deployers offer accessible grievance channels. Accountability stays with the employer who adopted the tool, even if the vendor built it.

    What to do: Pause automated rejection, have a person review rejected profiles, ask the vendor how the ranking is produced and how it was tested, record the review, and keep a route for candidates to ask for reconsideration.

    Illustration 3: The advertisement with a celebrity voice that was never recorded

    Facts: A skincare brand’s agency uses a synthetic voice that sounds like a well known actor to promote a cream, with no permission, and claims results in seven days.

    Legal position: There are several problems. Courts have protected personality rights against unauthorised AI use of a person’s persona, as the Delhi High Court did for actor Abhishek Bachchan in September 2025. A misleading claim exposes the advertiser under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, where the Central Consumer Protection Authority can order withdrawal and penalise endorsers up to Rs 10 lakh for a first breach and up to Rs 50 lakh later. If the content is posted on a large platform, the 2026 IT Rules also expect it to be declared and labelled as synthetic.

    What to do: Take the advertisement down, keep the agency’s brief and approvals on record, replace it with licensed content, and add a written permission rule for any real person’s voice or face.

    Illustration 4: The chatbot that promised a refund the company does not give

    Facts: An online retailer’s support chatbot tells a customer that a damaged appliance will be refunded in full within two days. Policy says seven days after inspection. The customer keeps the chat screenshot.

    Legal position: A statement made by a business through its own channel is likely to be treated as the business’s representation. A customer who relies on it and is refused may pursue a complaint for deficiency in service or unfair trade practice under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. Complaints are filed on the e-Jagriti portal, which replaced e-Daakhil from 1 January 2025. A defence that the chatbot made a mistake is unlikely to carry much weight, particularly if the tool was not tested or monitored.

    What to do: Honour the stated refund unless a clear and prominent disclaimer applied, fix the bot’s knowledge source, and log and review chatbot answers on money-related topics.

    Illustration 5: The cloned voice of the finance head

    Facts: An accounts executive receives a call that sounds like the finance director, instructing an urgent transfer of Rs 18 lakh to a new vendor account. The money leaves in thirty minutes.

    Legal position: This is cheating by personation. Section 66D of the IT Act punishes it with imprisonment up to three years and a fine up to Rs 1 lakh, and the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 has its own cheating provisions. The company may also face questions on whether it had reasonable safeguards. Speed matters because banks can sometimes freeze funds if told quickly.

    What to do: Call the bank at once to request a hold, report on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal (cybercrime.gov.in) or through the 1930 helpline, preserve the call log and account details, and then add a rule that payment changes must be confirmed through a second channel.

    Illustration 6: The learning app that watches children

    Facts: A tutoring app uses a model to track how long Class 7 students look at each question and sends parents promotional messages for add-on courses based on weak topics.

    Legal position: Section 9 of the DPDP Act requires verifiable consent of a parent or lawful guardian before processing a child’s data, forbids processing likely to harm a child’s well-being, and bars tracking, behavioural monitoring and targeted advertising directed at children. The Rules provide limited exemptions, including for educational institutions where monitoring serves educational activities or safety, but a commercial promotion is a different purpose. The penalty for breach of the additional children’s obligations can reach Rs 200 crore. Rule 10 on parental consent starts on 13 May 2027, but product design cannot be changed overnight.

    What to do: Separate learning analytics from marketing, stop targeted promotions to children, and design parent verification before the start date.

    Illustration 7: The lender that cannot explain a rejection

    Facts: A small finance company uses a model to approve personal loans. A rejected applicant asks why, and the credit team cannot say.

    Legal position: The model’s inability to explain a decision is itself a governance weakness. The RBI’s FREE-AI committee report of August 2025 sets out recommendations for responsible AI in finance, and the India AI Governance Guidelines list Understandable by Design and Accountability among their principles. Regulated entities should check current RBI directions that apply to them. Under the DPDP Act, the applicant also has rights regarding their personal data once the relevant Rules commence.

    What to do: Keep documentation of inputs and decision factors, ensure that a human credit officer can review and override the outcome, and prepare a plain explanation template for rejected applicants.

    The common thread

    • The organisation that deploys the tool answers for its outputs.
    • Records of what the tool did, who checked it and what was told to customers are the strongest evidence of care.
    • Speed in the first hours, especially in fraud and leak incidents, changes the outcome.

    Learn the laws behind each scenario and build your own response plan. The Lexfolio Certificate Course in AI Law and Governance in India: Compliance for Businesses and Institutions is a self-paced certificate course on AI law and governance in India, written for managers, compliance teams and institutions that use AI tools. Price: Rs 599.

    Frequently asked questions

    Who is liable if an AI tool gives a wrong answer to a customer?

    Usually the business that put the tool in front of the customer, because its statements are treated as its own. It may then have a contractual claim against the vendor, depending on the agreement.

    Can an employer fire someone for using a chatbot with confidential data?

    Possibly, if the policy and employment terms prohibit it and the process is fair. This is why a written, communicated policy matters. Individual cases depend on the contract and the facts.

    What should we do first if a deepfake of our director circulates?

    Preserve evidence, report to the platform for takedown, file on cybercrime.gov.in, tell your bank and legal adviser if payments are involved, and issue a short factual clarification.

    Is there a penalty for using AI generated images in ads?

    The use itself is not penalised, but misleading claims, unlicensed use of a real person’s likeness and unlabelled synthetic content on covered platforms can create liability.

    Does the DPDP Act apply to employee data used by AI tools?

    Yes, employee personal data is personal data, and the Act has specific provisions on processing for employment purposes. Take advice on the lawful ground that fits your use.

    This article is general information, not legal advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource, and a qualified lawyer should be consulted about your own situation.

  • AI for Law Students in India: 6 Situations (Assignments, Moots, Internships)

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Law students now meet AI tools in every part of the degree: assignments, moot memorials, internships, dissertations and exam notes. Nobody has handed them a rulebook that fits every situation. This guide works through six realistic situations and explains what the law and professional practice say about each, and what a careful student would do. All the students, colleges and facts below are invented illustrations; they are not real events.

    Two points apply throughout. First, India has no single statute on student use of AI, so the governing rules are your institution’s policy, the rules of any competition or internship, copyright and plagiarism norms, and the professional duties you will carry as a lawyer. Second, courts are watching: the Supreme Court said on 17 February 2026 that some pleadings seemed to have been prepared with AI platforms without adequate human scrutiny, and in Gummadi Usha Rani v. Sure Mallikarjuna Rao it said on 27 February 2026 that decisions based on non-existent judgments are not mere errors. The habits you form as a student are the habits you will bring to practice.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI for Lawyers and Law Students, a self-paced certificate course on using AI tools in legal research and drafting, for lawyers and law students. Course price: Rs 499.

    Illustration 1: The assignment with the case that does not exist

    Facts (illustration): Aarav, a third year student, asks a chatbot for “leading cases on the doctrine of legitimate expectation” for a seminar paper. It gives six names with years and one line holdings. He pastes them into his bibliography. His teacher cannot find two of them.

    Position. A citation to a case that does not exist is a false statement in an academic work, whoever generated it. Most institutions treat fabricated sources as an academic integrity violation, and the consequences depend on the college’s rules. Aarav cannot say the tool was responsible, since the Supreme Court has already said in 2026 that parties cannot rely on AI-generated material and then apologise.

    What to do. Search for each case on the Supreme Court or High Court website or a law report database, read the judgment, and cite from it. Remove what cannot be found. If a teacher asks, say honestly how the list was produced. Next time use the tool only to suggest search terms.

    Illustration 2: The moot memorial

    Facts (illustration): Meera’s team is preparing a memorial for a national moot. They use a tool to generate headnotes and “key principles” from judgments they have not fully read. The moot rules are silent on tools.

    Position. Moot rules vary, and a silent rule is not a licence. Judges at moots expect that you know the cases cold. If you cannot answer a bench question about a paragraph because your knowledge came from a summary, the memorial’s weakness will show. If a fabricated authority appears in a submission, it can lead to disqualification or a loss of marks under the competition’s rules.

    What to do. Read the rules and ask the organisers in writing whether tools are allowed. Use a tool only to make a list of issues, then read every case yourself and cite paragraph numbers. Keep a verification log with the source for each authority. Assume you will be asked “where is this in the judgment?”

    Illustration 3: The internship memo

    Facts (illustration): During a litigation internship, Kabir is asked by his supervising advocate to prepare a note on limitation in a client’s money recovery matter. He pastes the client’s facts, names and the draft notice into a public chatbot.

    Position. The client’s communications with the advocate are protected by section 132 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, which bars the advocate from disclosing them without the client’s express consent, subject to defined exceptions. The Supreme Court’s judgment of 31 October 2025 held that the privilege extends to litigation and non-litigious advice. An intern who sends client facts to an outside service creates a risk for the client and the advocate, and probably breaches the internship terms. Most chambers expect interns to maintain confidentiality as a condition of the internship.

    What to do. Ask the supervising advocate about the chambers’ rules before using any tool. If tools are allowed, remove names and identifiers. If Kabir has already pasted the facts, he should tell his supervisor right away. Concealing it is worse than the mistake.

    Illustration 4: The dissertation and the similarity report

    Facts (illustration): Ishita, an LL.M. student, uses a chatbot to rewrite two paragraphs of her literature review. Her university runs a plagiarism check and an AI writing check. The reports flag the paragraphs and her guide asks questions.

    Position. Universities set their own rules on plagiarism and on assistance from tools, and many now require a declaration. Using a tool to polish language may be allowed in one college and prohibited in another. What matters is the written policy, whether you disclosed, and whether the ideas and wording are your own and properly attributed. Detection reports are indicators, not proof, and many institutions say that a flag alone does not establish misconduct, but they invite questions that you must be able to answer by showing drafts and sources.

    What to do. Read the dissertation guidelines and ask the guide. Keep your notes, drafts and sources. Write analysis in your own words, quote with page or paragraph references and cite everything. If tools are permitted, make the declaration the policy requires.

    Illustration 5: The exam notes with old sections

    Facts (illustration): Neha prepares for a judiciary exam. She asks a chatbot for a summary of the law on anticipatory bail and arrest and gets section numbers from the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. She memorises them.

    Position. The Code of Criminal Procedure was replaced by the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 from 1 July 2024, and the Indian Penal Code and the Evidence Act were replaced by the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 and the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023. An exam candidate who learns old section numbers for new events loses marks, and in practice a lawyer who cites the wrong Act looks careless. Offences committed before 1 July 2024 are generally still tried under the old law, which makes the date of the offence relevant.

    What to do. Study from the bare Act text and a current commentary. If you use a tool, ask it to compare provisions and then confirm each section number against the Act. Keep a one page table of old to new sections for revision.

    Illustration 6: The translated judgment

    Facts (illustration): Arjun uses a tool to translate a Hindi High Court judgment into English for a research note. The tool renders one key phrase wrongly, reversing the sense of the order.

    Position. Translation tools are useful but make errors, especially with legal terms of art. The Kerala High Court’s policy for its district judiciary, dated 19 July 2025, requires that outputs, including translations, be carefully checked, which reflects a wider professional expectation. A note that misstates what a court held can mislead a reader or a client.

    What to do. Treat machine translation as a first pass. Check key paragraphs against the original, ask a fluent reader to verify the operative portion, and say in your note that the translation is yours and the original controls.

    What to carry into practice

    Every one of these situations is solved by the same four habits: read the original, verify before you cite, protect confidential information, and be honest about how you worked. Those habits are what courts, supervising advocates and examiners are looking for.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI for Lawyers and Law Students, a self-paced certificate course on using AI tools in legal research and drafting, for lawyers and law students. Course price: Rs 499.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can law students use ChatGPT for assignments?

    A: It depends on the college’s policy and the teacher’s instructions. If tools are allowed, you remain responsible for accuracy, originality and attribution. If you are unsure, ask in writing.

    Will I be punished if a detector says my work is AI-written?

    A: A detection score is an indicator, not proof. Institutions differ in how they treat it. Keep drafts, notes and sources to show how you wrote the work.

    Can I paste a client’s facts into a chatbot during an internship?

    A: Not without the supervising advocate’s permission and an approved tool. Client communications are protected by section 132 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, and confidentiality is a core professional duty.

    Are there any rules from the Bar Council of India for students using these tools?

    A: There is no specific rule for students that we could confirm. The Bar Council has told Parliament that advocates are responsible for AI generated fake citations, and the Supreme Court has asked it to form an expert committee, so the position is developing.

    This article is general information, not legal, financial or tax advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services.

  • Advertising Law in India: 8 Myths Marketers and Influencers Believe

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Advertising rules in India are no longer a matter of a few polite guidelines. Since the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 created the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA), brands, agencies and endorsers have faced notices, penalties and bans from endorsing. Yet many marketers still work on assumptions that were never true, or that stopped being true after the 2022 advertising guidelines and the 2023 endorsement and dark pattern rules. This guide takes eight common beliefs and gives the correct position.

    It covers advertisements for goods and services in general. Special sectors, such as medicines, food, financial products and gaming, have extra rules that are not dealt with here.

    Course: Marketing and Advertising Law in India, Rs 499. A self-paced certificate course on marketing and advertising law in India, for marketers, founders and creators. View the course.

    Myth 1: “We have a disclaimer, so the claim is safe”

    The Guidelines for Prevention of Misleading Advertisements and Endorsements for Misleading Advertisements, 2022 (notified on 9 June 2022 under section 18 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019) deal with disclaimers directly. A disclaimer may clarify or expand a claim, but it must not contradict the material claim or the main message, and must not hide material information or be used to correct a misleading claim. It should also be in the same language and font as the claim. A headline that promises “no hidden charges” cannot be rescued by a footnote that lists charges. Reading the headline and the fine print together is the right test.

    Myth 2: “Only the brand is liable, not the influencer or the celebrity”

    Section 21 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 lets the CCPA impose a penalty on a manufacturer or an endorser of up to Rs 10 lakh for a false or misleading advertisement, and up to Rs 50 lakh for a subsequent contravention. It can also prohibit the endorser of a misleading advertisement from endorsing any product or service for up to one year, and up to three years for a subsequent contravention. So an endorser carries direct risk, not only the brand.

    There is also a criminal provision. Section 89 punishes a manufacturer or service provider who causes a false or misleading advertisement prejudicial to the interest of consumers with imprisonment of up to two years and a fine of up to Rs 10 lakh, and for a subsequent offence up to five years and a fine of up to Rs 50 lakh.

    Myth 3: “An endorser can promote what she has not tried”

    The 2022 Guidelines say an endorsement must reflect the genuine, reasonably current opinion of the individual, group or organisation making it, must be based on adequate information about or experience with the identified product or service, and must not otherwise be deceptive. A celebrity who reads a script about a product she has never used is on weak ground. The Department of Consumer Affairs’ “Endorsement Know-hows” guide for celebrities and influencers (20 January 2023) also says endorsers should not promote what they have not themselves used or experienced.

    Myth 4: “Disclosure is only needed when money changes hands”

    The Endorsement Know-hows guide asks for disclosure of any material connection with the advertiser. It lists payments, but also free products, trips, hotel stays, discounts, gifts, and family, personal or employment relationships. The disclosure must be prominent and clear, in simple language, and it can use terms such as “advertisement”, “sponsored” or “paid promotion”. Burying a tag at the end of a long hashtag list, or in a language the audience does not follow, does not meet the spirit of the rule.

    Myth 5: “Free means free once you read the terms”

    The 2022 Guidelines treat free claims strictly. An offer cannot be described as free or without charge if the consumer must pay anything other than the unavoidable cost of responding to the offer or collecting or taking delivery of the item. The extent of any commitment the consumer must make to take advantage of the free offer has to be made clear. A “free” gift that requires a bigger purchase at a quietly increased price, or extra packing and handling charges, invites scrutiny.

    Myth 6: “A low advertised price is just a teaser”

    The Guidelines also define bait advertising, meaning an advertisement offering goods or services at a low price to attract consumers, and set conditions: the advertiser should not use the offer to entice consumers with no reasonable prospect of selling at that price, and should keep adequate supply to meet foreseeable demand. An advertised laptop price with a handful of units in stock, and a redirect to a costlier model, is the classic example.

    Myth 7: “Dark patterns are an app design issue, not a legal one”

    The Guidelines for Prevention and Regulation of Dark Patterns, 2023, notified on 30 November 2023, apply to sellers, advertisers and platforms that systematically offer goods and services in India, including foreign entities that offer them to the Indian market. They list 13 specified dark patterns, among them false urgency, basket sneaking, confirm shaming, forced action, subscription trap, interface interference, bait and switch, drip pricing, disguised advertisement, nagging, trick question, SaaS billing and rogue malwares. A countdown timer that resets, or a pre-ticked donation added to the cart, can therefore be a compliance problem and not just a design choice.

    Myth 8: “Coaching institutes can promise guaranteed selection if the fine print says so”

    The Guidelines for Prevention of Misleading Advertisement in Coaching Sector, 2024 (issued on 13 November 2024) prohibit false claims such as guaranteed selection, and false claims about the number of selections, ranks or success rate, or about course exit and refund policies. Success stories must disclose important information such as the rank secured and the name and duration of the course taken, and whether the course was paid, and must have the candidate’s written consent. Disclaimers must appear prominently in the same font as the claim. They apply to coaching centres with more than fifty students, as defined in the guidelines.

    Summary table

    Common beliefCorrect positionSource
    Disclaimer cures a misleading claimIt cannot contradict, hide or correct the claim2022 Guidelines, disclaimer rules
    Only the brand paysEndorsers can be fined and barred from endorsingConsumer Protection Act, section 21
    Disclosure is for paid posts onlyAny material connection, including free productsEndorsement Know-hows, 2023
    Free needs terms and conditionsNot free if the consumer pays beyond unavoidable costs2022 Guidelines, free claims
    Low price teaser is fineBait advertising conditions apply2022 Guidelines, bait advertisement
    Dark patterns are only design13 specified patterns are regulatedDark Patterns Guidelines, 2023
    Guaranteed selection ads are okProhibited, with disclosure dutiesCoaching Sector Guidelines, 2024

    What about self-regulation?

    The Advertising Standards Council of India (ASCI) runs a self-regulatory code, and many brands follow it and respond to its complaints process. It is a voluntary body, not a statute. A complaint upheld by ASCI is not a court order, but an advertisement that breaches ASCI norms can also be a breach of the Consumer Protection Act, and regulators can act independently. Do not treat ASCI compliance as a complete defence.

    If you handle campaigns, contracts with influencers or consumer facing offers, build a habit of a legal review before launch. The course below is designed to give marketers and founders the working vocabulary to do that.

    Course: Marketing and Advertising Law in India, Rs 499. A self-paced certificate course on marketing and advertising law in India, for marketers, founders and creators. View the course.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can an influencer be penalised for a misleading ad in India?

    Yes. Section 21 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 lets the CCPA impose penalties on endorsers and bar them from endorsing for a period. The amounts and periods are higher for repeat violations.

    What words should influencers use to disclose a paid post?

    The Department of Consumer Affairs’ guide mentions terms such as advertisement, sponsored and paid promotion, shown prominently and in clear language. Disclose free products and other benefits too.

    Are dark patterns illegal in India?

    The 2023 Dark Patterns Guidelines prohibit the 13 specified patterns for sellers, advertisers and platforms. They were notified under the Consumer Protection Act framework, so unfair trade practices can be acted against under it.

    Who enforces misleading advertisement rules?

    The Central Consumer Protection Authority under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 enforces the guidelines, and consumer commissions hear complaints. ASCI separately handles complaints under its own code.

    Is a comparative advertisement allowed?

    Comparison is not banned, but it must not be misleading and must not take unfair advantage of or harm a competitor’s registered trade mark. Trade mark law and the Consumer Protection Act both apply.

    Can a coaching institute use the photos of toppers in ads?

    Only with the candidate’s written consent, and with the rank, course name, duration and whether the course was paid shown, under the 2024 coaching sector guidelines.

    This article is general information, not legal advice for any specific case, and the law and rules may change or differ by state. Lexfolio is a learning resource.