LLexfolio

Tag: AI for lawyers

  • How to Verify AI Legal Research and Drafts: Checklist for Indian Lawyers

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: treat everything a language tool gives you as an unverified lead. Before it goes into a notice, a plaint, a written submission or an opinion, each authority must be located on a reliable source, read in the original, checked for quotations and current status, and recorded in a short verification log. This is the workflow a careful Indian advocate or law student can follow for every draft.

    Why now? In 2026 the Supreme Court has repeatedly warned about fabricated citations. On 17 February 2026 it noted pleadings that seemed to have been prepared with AI platforms without adequate human scrutiny. In Gummadi Usha Rani v. Sure Mallikarjuna Rao the Court said on 27 February 2026 that reliance on non-existent judgments is not a mere error, and on 5 May 2026 it said parties cannot rely on AI-generated material and then apologise. It also said it does not seek to prohibit AI. The Bar Council of India has told Parliament that advocates cannot escape professional liability by blaming technology. A repeatable checking routine is therefore part of competent practice.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI for Lawyers and Law Students, a self-paced certificate course on using AI tools in legal research and drafting, for lawyers and law students. Course price: Rs 499.

    The workflow at a glance

    StageWhat you doOutput
    ———
    1Decide what the tool may and may not doTask note
    2Prepare the input without client identifiersSafe prompt
    3Generate, then extract every legal claimClaims list
    4Verify each case on a reliable sourceVerification log
    5Verify each statute and section numberCurrent text checked
    6Check quotations and paragraph numbersVerbatim quotes
    7Check status: overruled, distinguished, stayedGood law check
    8Final human review and sign offSigned draft

    Step 1: Fix the role of the tool before you start

    Write one line saying what you are using the tool for: for example, “list issues and counter arguments”, “turn my notes into a draft chronology”, or “simplify this paragraph”. Do not use it as a source of law and do not use it to decide what the law is. The Kerala High Court’s policy for the district judiciary (19 July 2025) draws a similar line for judges: assistive use only, and no use for decision making or legal reasoning. It is not a rule for advocates, but it shows the principle courts accept.

    Step 2: Protect confidentiality in the input

    Section 132 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 bars an advocate from disclosing professional communications without the client’s express consent, subject to exceptions. The Supreme Court’s judgment of 31 October 2025 on summoning advocates (2025 INSC 1275) treated the privilege as one that belongs to the client and extends to litigation and non-litigious advice. Before you paste anything:

    • remove names, addresses, account numbers, case numbers and anything that identifies the client or the other side
    • replace facts with neutral labels (Party A, Party B, Company X)
    • use only a tool your chambers or firm has approved, on a plan whose terms you have read for storage and training use
    • do not upload the whole file when a three line description of the issue will do

    Step 3: Extract every legal claim from the output

    Read the answer once for sense, then go through it and list each claim that needs a source: every case name, court, year, citation, section number, quotation and legal proposition. Number them. A paragraph that sounds neutral can contain five checkable claims.

    Step 4: Verify each case on a reliable source

    For every case on your list:

    1. Find the judgment itself on the court’s own website, a recognised law report database (SCC Online, Manupatra or a similar subscription service) or a reputable public judgments repository. Do not accept a blog or the tool’s own link as proof.
    2. Match the neutral citation or report citation, court, date and parties. The Supreme Court now uses neutral citations in the form “2025 INSC 1275”.
    3. Read the part that you rely on. Note the paragraph number.
    4. Note the bench strength and whether it is a majority or a minority view.
    5. If you cannot find the case, assume it does not exist and remove it. Do not “fix” the citation by guessing.

    Step 5: Verify statutes and section numbers

    Check the current text on the India Code portal or in the Gazette. For anything involving crime, procedure or evidence, make sure you are using the right Act:

    SubjectLaw from 1 July 2024Replaced
    ———
    OffencesBharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023Indian Penal Code, 1860
    Criminal procedureBharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
    EvidenceBharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023Indian Evidence Act, 1872

    Offences before 1 July 2024 are generally dealt with under the old laws, so the date of the alleged offence matters. Example of a changed section number: cheating is section 318 BNS, and electronic records are proved under section 63 BSA. Also check state amendments and later notifications.

    Step 6: Check every quotation

    Copy quotations only from the judgment or the statute, never from the tool. Put them in quotation marks and add the paragraph number. The Supreme Court noted on 17 February 2026 that some filings cited real rulings but quoted passages that do not appear in them. If you paraphrase, make sure the paraphrase matches what the court actually held, not what it discussed and rejected.

    Step 7: Check that the authority is still good law

    Run the case through a citator and read the later decisions that follow, distinguish or overrule it. Check whether a larger bench has spoken since, whether a review or curative petition has changed the position, and whether the law was amended after the judgment. A pre-2024 decision on the IPC may still state a useful principle, but its section numbers will not match the BNS.

    Step 8: Keep a verification log

    A simple table protects you if a judge or client asks how you checked. Keep it with the file.

    No.AuthorityCourt and dateSource openedParagraphQuote checkedStatus checkedChecked by
    ————————
    1[name and citation][court, date][database or site][para]YesYes[initials, date]
    2[name and citation][court, date][database or site][para]YesYes[initials, date]

    Step 9: Final review and sign off

    The advocate who signs is the one responsible. Read the whole draft again as the opposing counsel would. Make sure every factual statement matches the client’s documents, and that the draft complies with the format and any practice direction of the court where it will be filed. A draft Supreme Court AI policy for courts was released for comments on 3 June 2026; whether and how it or any High Court direction applies to filings is something to check before you file, since the position may change.

    Step 10: Decide what to tell the client and the court

    If a client has asked, or if a court or tribunal requires a declaration, say honestly how the tool was used. Where nothing is required, many lawyers still tell clients in the engagement letter that tools may support drafting but a lawyer reviews all work. Keep the log in case any question arises.

    Illustration of a rejected citation: You ask a tool for authority that a particular clause is unenforceable. It gives a case name, a High Court and a year. You search the High Court’s website and two paid databases and find nothing with that name or neutral citation. Under this workflow, that authority is deleted and the point is researched afresh from the statute and from decisions you can read.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI for Lawyers and Law Students, a self-paced certificate course on using AI tools in legal research and drafting, for lawyers and law students. Course price: Rs 499.

    Frequently asked questions

    Which sources count as reliable for checking a case?

    A: The court’s own website, a recognised subscription law report database, or the printed law report. Use the same source to check the neutral citation, bench and paragraph. A blog post or the tool’s own answer does not count.

    Do I need to disclose AI use to the court?

    A: There is no general rule in force that applies to all advocates in all courts at present. Check the practice directions of the court concerned, because courts and the Bar Council are still developing their positions. If asked, answer honestly.

    Can I use a tool just for drafting and not for research?

    A: Yes, as a drafting aid, but facts, law and citations in the draft remain your responsibility and must be checked. Do not enter confidential material into an unapproved tool.

    How long should verification take?

    A: It depends on the length of the draft and the number of authorities, but the time spent checking should be planned in. If verification would take longer than researching from scratch, research from scratch.

    This article is general information, not legal, financial or tax advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services.

  • ChatGPT for Legal Research in India: Fake Citations and 7 Other Mistakes

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Using ChatGPT or a similar tool to start legal research is tempting: it is fast, fluent and it sounds sure of itself. In India, that confidence has already cost lawyers and even a trial court dearly. This guide sets out the mistakes that matter most when generative tools are used for legal work, and the correct position under Indian law and court practice as of the date above.

    The short version: these tools can help with structure, plain language summaries and first drafts, but they are not a source of law. Every authority must be found and read in its original form by a human who then signs for it.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI for Lawyers and Law Students, a self-paced certificate course on using AI tools in legal research and drafting, for lawyers and law students. Course price: Rs 499.

    Mistake 1: Citing a case the tool “found”

    Language tools predict plausible text. They do not look up judgments, so they can produce a case name, a court, a year and a neat holding for something that was never decided. This is not a theoretical risk in India. On 17 February 2026 a Supreme Court bench of the Chief Justice of India, Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice B.V. Nagarathna said that it had begun noticing pleadings that seemed to have been prepared with AI platforms without adequate human scrutiny, and Justice Nagarathna referred to a matter citing a precedent called “Mercy vs Mankind” that does not exist. The Chief Justice also said that in proceedings before another judge, the precedents cited had never existed, and that some filings quoted passages from real Supreme Court rulings that do not appear in them.

    In Gummadi Usha Rani v. Sure Mallikarjuna Rao (SLP (C) No. 7575 of 2026), a trial court had relied on four decisions the petitioners said were non-existent and AI generated. On 27 February 2026 the Supreme Court said that a decision based on such fake judgments is not an error in decision making, and that relying on them would be misconduct with legal consequences; it issued notice to the Attorney General, the Solicitor General and the Bar Council of India (BCI) and appointed a senior advocate as amicus curiae. At the hearing reported on 5 May 2026 the Court said that parties cannot rely on AI-generated material and then apologise, and asked the BCI to constitute a committee of experts to examine the issues. It also said it was not seeking to prohibit the use of AI.

    Mistake 2: Trusting a summary of a real case

    A tool may name a genuine case and still misstate it: the wrong bench strength, the wrong outcome, a passage that is not in the judgment, or a proposition the court actually rejected. Read the judgment. Look at who sat, the date, the question decided, the reasoning and the direction. If you intend to quote, copy the words from the judgment itself and give the paragraph number. A summary is a pointer to where to look, never the authority itself.

    Mistake 3: Using old or wrong law

    A tool trained mostly on older text may answer in terms of the Indian Penal Code, the Code of Criminal Procedure or the Evidence Act. Those were replaced from 1 July 2024 by the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) and the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA). Section numbers changed: for example, cheating is section 318 BNS, cheating by personation is section 319 BNS, and the privilege for professional communications with an advocate is section 132 BSA. Other laws have changed too, including the Labour Codes in force from 21 November 2025. Always check the current text of the statute on the India Code portal or the relevant Gazette, and check whether your authority was decided under the old or the new provision.

    Mistake 4: Pasting client material into a public tool

    Advocates owe clients confidentiality, and section 132 of the BSA bars an advocate from disclosing communications made in the course of professional engagement without the client’s express consent, subject to defined exceptions. In Re: Summoning Advocates who give legal opinion or represent parties during investigation (31 October 2025, 2025 INSC 1275) the Supreme Court held that this privilege covers litigation and non-litigious work, and that an investigating officer cannot directly summon an advocate to disclose case details unless an exception under section 132 applies. The same judgment noted that in-house counsel are not “advocates” under the Advocates Act, 1961 and so cannot claim the section 132 privilege, though they may receive some protection under section 134.

    None of this approves or forbids a particular tool. But sending a client’s confidential papers to an outside service is a disclosure that the client has not agreed to, and it may place privileged material outside your control. The safe practice is to use approved tools under written terms, remove names and identifiers, or use no tool at all for the most sensitive files.

    Mistake 5: Letting the tool do the judgment

    The tool can suggest arguments. It cannot weigh the facts of your case, the temperament of the bench or the client’s interests. The Kerala High Court’s policy on the use of AI tools in the district judiciary, issued on 19 July 2025, shows how courts themselves are drawing the line: such tools must not be used for decision making or legal reasoning or to arrive at findings, reliefs or orders, outputs including translations must be carefully checked, and cloud based tools such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot and Deepseek are to be avoided unless approved. That policy applies to Kerala’s district judges and their staff, not to advocates, but it is a useful statement of principle for anyone in the system.

    Mistake 6: Thinking there is no rule for lawyers

    There is no AI specific code for advocates yet, but there are rules in force. Professional misconduct under the Advocates Act, 1961 and the Bar Council of India Rules can reach an advocate who files fabricated authorities, whatever the source. The Bar Council of India has told Parliament, as reported in June 2026, that advocates who file AI-generated fake citations, fabricated quotations or non-existent judgments cannot escape professional liability by blaming technology. Courts may also impose costs, call for explanations or refer the matter to the Bar Council.

    Separately, a draft policy on AI use in courts was issued by the Supreme Court’s AI Committee on 3 June 2026 for public comment, with comments invited until 15 July 2026, and would be notified by High Courts if adopted. Check the current status and any High Court practice direction before you file.

    Mistake 7: Not telling the client, or billing as if the tool did not exist

    If a client has asked whether AI is used, or the engagement letter says nothing, be open. Explain what the tool is used for, that a lawyer reviews everything, and that confidential data is protected. Fees should reflect work actually done by you. Clients who find out later that unchecked output went to court will be less forgiving than clients who were told at the start.

    Mistake 8: Skipping the “is it still good law” check

    Even a real, correctly cited judgment may have been overruled, distinguished, or limited by a larger bench, or stayed in review. A language tool will not tell you reliably. Run the authority through a citator in a recognised law report database, read the later cases that cite it and check the date against any statutory change.

    A quick test before you rely on any output

    1. Can I open the judgment or the statute section on an authoritative source?
    2. Have I read the paragraph, not just the headnote or the tool’s summary?
    3. Is the quote verbatim, with a paragraph number?
    4. Was it decided under the old law or the new one?
    5. Is it still good law?
    6. Did I keep client confidences?

    If any answer is no, do not file it.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI for Lawyers and Law Students, a self-paced certificate course on using AI tools in legal research and drafting, for lawyers and law students. Course price: Rs 499.

    Frequently asked questions

    Has the Supreme Court banned the use of AI by lawyers?

    A: No. At the hearing reported on 5 May 2026 it said it was not seeking to prohibit the use of AI, but it made clear that parties cannot rely on AI-generated material and then apologise for errors.

    Can a lawyer be punished for citing a fake case generated by a tool?

    A: Citing a non-existent authority can amount to professional misconduct and can lead to costs and Bar Council proceedings. The Bar Council of India has said responsibility cannot be passed on to technology.

    Is a tool’s summary of a judgment safe to use if the case name is real?

    A: No. A real case name can be paired with a wrong or invented holding or quotation. Read the judgment and quote from it.

    Does privilege protect what I paste into a chatbot?

    A: Section 132 of the BSA protects confidential professional communications from compelled disclosure by the advocate, but a voluntary disclosure to a third party service can create its own risk. Use approved tools and anonymise.

    This article is general information, not legal, financial or tax advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services.