LLexfolio

Tag: founders agreement India

  • Startup Legal Mistakes in India: 8 Founder Myths and the Correct Position

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: most early stage legal trouble in Indian startups does not come from a missing licence. It comes from five or six assumptions founders make in the first year: that a verbal understanding between co-founders is enough, that the code or designs they wrote before incorporation already belong to the company, that DPIIT recognition is automatic or compulsory, and that the angel tax rules of earlier years still apply. This guide lists eight such myths and gives the correct position on each, with the law as it stands on 12 November 2026.

    Want the whole founder journey in one place? This is a self-paced certificate course on startup legal basics, from incorporation to funding, written for first time founders and the people who work with them. The course is Startup Legal Basics: From Incorporation to Funding, priced at Rs 499.

    Myth 1: “We are friends, we will sort out equity later”

    A company is a separate legal person, but the people behind it are not. If two or three founders start work before agreeing who holds what, the default position is whatever the records show, and the records usually show nothing. The shares recorded in the register of members after allotment are what count, not what each founder remembers promising. The correct position: agree the split, the roles and the exit terms in writing before the company is incorporated or at the latest at the time of the first allotment, and record them in a founders’ or shareholders’ agreement that matches the articles of association.

    Three clauses do most of the work. Vesting means each founder earns his or her shares over time, so that a founder who leaves in month four does not walk away with a full quarter of the company. Leaver terms say what happens to unvested and vested shares when a founder quits or is removed. Decision rights list the matters that need every founder’s consent, such as raising money or selling the business.

    Myth 2: “The product I built before incorporating belongs to the company”

    It does not, unless someone has transferred it. Under the Copyright Act, 1957, an assignment of copyright is valid only if it is in writing and signed by the assignor (section 19(1)). It must identify the work and state the rights assigned, the duration and the territorial extent (section 19(2)). Two defaults catch founders out: if the period of assignment is not stated, it is deemed to be five years from the date of assignment (section 19(5)), and if the territorial extent is not specified, it is presumed to extend within India (section 19(6)).

    So a one line email saying “the code is yours” can leave the company with rights for five years and only in India. A good founder IP assignment names the code, designs, domain names and trade names, transfers them for the full term of the rights and for the whole world, and is signed by each founder. Investors ask for it in diligence, and a founder who has fallen out has no reason to sign later.

    Myth 3: “If the Registrar approves the company name, the brand is protected”

    Name approval during incorporation is a company law step. It stops two companies from being registered with the same or a very similar name, but it is not a trademark registration. A trademark is registered separately with the Trade Marks Registry, under the Trade Marks Act, 1999, and the registration is valid for ten years and renewable. Someone else may already hold, or later obtain, rights in a similar mark for similar goods or services, whatever the company register says. Search the trademark register before you spend money on packaging, a website and advertising, and apply for the mark in your own or the company’s name.

    Myth 4: “DPIIT recognition is compulsory, or it automatically gives a tax holiday”

    Recognition is voluntary. The Startup India portal describes the application as made through the National Single Window System, and says the Ministry charges no fee for the certificate. Recognition itself is not the tax benefit. The profit linked deduction for three consecutive years within the first ten years (section 80-IAC of the Income-tax Act, 1961, for years governed by that Act) needs a separate application and approval, and the portal says only private limited companies and LLPs incorporated after 1 April 2016 qualify. For tax years from FY 2026-27 the Income-tax Act, 2025 applies, so check the corresponding provision there with your accountant before you plan around the benefit.

    The definition itself was revised by a DPIIT notification dated February 2026. The portal now states that an entity can be recognised if its turnover is below Rs 200 crore in any previous financial year (earlier Rs 100 crore) and it is within 10 years of incorporation, with a separate deep tech category of 20 years and Rs 300 crore. Entities formed by splitting up or reconstructing an existing business do not qualify.

    Myth 5: “Angel tax will tax my funding round”

    This was a real worry for years, so the myth lingers. Section 56(2)(viib) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 taxed the premium a company received on shares above fair market value. The Finance (No. 2) Act, 2024 removed it, and a proviso states it does not apply on or after 1 April 2025. Commentary on the change notes that it is not carried into the Income-tax Act, 2025. The correct position has two parts. First, shares issued in FY 2025-26 or later do not face angel tax, whoever the investor is. Second, older rounds can still be examined if the assessment is open, and the department can separately question the source and genuineness of funds under the unexplained credit provisions.

    Myth 6: “ESOPs can be given to anyone and vest the next day”

    Employee stock option plans are governed by section 62(1)(b) of the Companies Act, 2013 and Rule 12 of the Companies (Share Capital and Debentures) Rules, 2014. Three points correct the common beliefs. There must be a minimum gap of one year between the grant and the first vesting. Independent directors, promoters and persons holding more than 10 per cent of the equity are generally not eligible, although recognised startups get a relaxation of this restriction for a period after incorporation (currently stated as ten years), so check the current rule before granting options to a founder. And each allotment on exercise must be reported to the Registrar on Form PAS-3 within 30 days. An option is only a right to buy until it is exercised and shares are allotted, which the employee should understand before leaving a salary for options.

    Myth 7: “We can raise money from anyone by posting about it”

    For a private company, taking money for shares from the public at large is the one thing the Act does not allow. A private placement under section 42 of the Companies Act, 2013 must be made only to persons whose names the company has recorded before the offer, with each person getting an offer addressed to them. Public advertisements, media, marketing or agents cannot be used to tell the public about the offer. Money must come through banking channels, not cash, into a separate account. Securities must be allotted within 60 days of receiving the money. The number of persons is limited, and if the limit is crossed the offer is treated as a public offer. A friends and family round is fine if you keep to known people and bank transfers.

    Myth 8: “A foreign investor can just wire us the money”

    Foreign investment into an Indian company is regulated by the Foreign Exchange Management (Non-debt Instruments) Rules, 2019. The company must report the issue to the Reserve Bank through its portal, generally within 30 days of issuing the shares, using the prescribed form (the equity issue form is FC-GPR). The same rules allow a recognised startup to issue a convertible note: an instrument that acknowledges money received as debt and is repayable or convertible into equity, for a period not exceeding ten years as the rules stand, and the rules set a minimum of Rs 25 lakh in a single tranche for a non-resident buyer. Sector caps and pricing conditions also apply, so confirm both before accepting an inbound transfer. Related point: every company must have a director who has stayed in India for at least 182 days in the previous calendar year (section 149(3)), so a foreign led startup needs a resident director from day one.

    A quick correction table

    What founders assumeWhat the law says
    Verbal split of equity is enoughShares are what the company records show; put terms and vesting in writing
    Pre incorporation code is the company’sOnly a signed written assignment transfers it (Copyright Act, s.19)
    Name approval equals trademarkTrademark needs separate registration, valid ten years
    DPIIT recognition gives tax holidayTax benefit needs a separate application and approval
    Angel tax applies to new roundsSection 56(2)(viib) does not apply on or after 1 April 2025
    ESOPs vest immediatelyMinimum one year between grant and vesting (Rule 12)
    Raise funds by public postPrivate placement only to named, pre recorded persons
    Wire from abroad is fineReport to the Reserve Bank; follow sector and pricing rules

    A simple pre funding checklist

    1. Founders’ agreement signed, with vesting and leaver terms.
    2. IP assignment from every founder and every contractor who wrote code or designs.
    3. Trademark searched and applied for.
    4. Statutory registers, minutes and filings up to date, including commencement of business and auditor appointment (the first auditor must be appointed by the Board within 30 days of registration under section 139(6)).
    5. Cap table that matches the register of members.

    Take it step by step. The Lexfolio course on startup legal basics walks through the same ground, from incorporation to funding, as a self-paced certificate course. The course is Startup Legal Basics: From Incorporation to Funding, priced at Rs 499.

    Frequently asked questions

    Do I need a founders’ agreement if there are only two of us?

    Yes, and a small team needs it more, because there is no third person to break a deadlock. A short agreement on equity, vesting, roles, IP and exit costs little and avoids a dispute that can end the company.

    Is DPIIT recognition necessary to start a startup in India?

    No. You can incorporate and operate without it. Recognition is optional and is useful mainly if you want to apply for the tax and other schemes that are linked to it.

    Does the 182 day rule mean all directors must live in India?

    No. The requirement in section 149(3) is for at least one director who has stayed in India for 182 days or more in the previous calendar year. Other directors may live abroad.

    Can a startup give ESOPs to its co-founders?

    It depends on the shareholding and the date of incorporation. The Rule 12 restrictions on promoters and 10 per cent holders are relaxed for recognised startups for a stated period, so check the current rule and get a professional to confirm before granting.

    Is angel tax completely gone?

    For shares issued on or after 1 April 2025, section 56(2)(viib) no longer applies. Older years can still be reopened or examined within the limitation periods, and questions about the source of funds can arise separately.

    Who owns the code written by a freelancer for my startup?

    Unless there is a signed written assignment, the freelancer generally remains the first owner. Get an assignment that states the rights, the duration and the territory.

    This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice for a specific case. Laws and thresholds change, so confirm current rules with a qualified professional before acting. Lexfolio is a learning resource.