LLexfolio

Tag: pre-institution mediation

  • Vendor and Customer Contract Disputes in India: 6 Scenarios and What to Do

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: most contract disputes follow a handful of patterns: late delivery, a claim of impossibility, a missed renewal, a doubtful termination, unpaid bills and a change agreed informally. The six scenarios below are illustrations invented to show the legal position and a sensible next step in each. The parties and figures are made up.

    Learn the process behind these outcomes. The Lexfolio Contract Management and Negotiation for Managers is a self-paced certificate course on contract management and negotiation for managers. Price: Rs 499.

    Illustration 1: The customer who cancels a custom order

    Situation. Shreya’s workshop makes made-to-order office furniture. A client paid 30 per cent in advance, and the contract says the advance is non-refundable. Three weeks later, with the timber already cut, the client cancels the order.

    Legal position. The clause is a stipulation of a sum payable on breach, so section 74 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 is the starting point. The party complaining of breach is entitled to reasonable compensation not exceeding the amount named. A court looks at whether keeping the whole advance is reasonable in view of the loss actually likely to follow, and may allow less if the sum is out of proportion. The workshop’s position is far stronger if it can show what it spent: materials bought, labour used and any resale loss.

    What to do. Send a written notice acknowledging the cancellation as a breach by the client, setting out the costs incurred with supporting bills, and stating how much of the advance the workshop retains and why. Offer to refund any balance. In future contracts, link the forfeiture to stages of work, for example 10 per cent before cutting and 30 per cent after.

    Illustration 2: The service provider who switches off the service

    Situation. An IT services firm stops support to Imran’s company because an invoice is 45 days overdue. Imran’s company disputes the invoice, saying part of the work was not delivered. The contract allows suspension for non-payment ‘after written notice’ and says disputed amounts must be raised within 15 days of the invoice.

    Legal position. Whether the suspension is lawful depends on the clause. If the provider gave the required written notice and the dispute was not raised in time, it may be within its rights. If it suspended without notice, or the invoice was properly disputed within the window, the suspension may itself be a breach, exposing the provider to a claim for damages under section 73. The client, for its part, should pay the undisputed part so that it cannot be accused of non-payment.

    What to do. The client should pay the undisputed amount, send a reasoned dispute note on the rest, and ask for restoration of service under the escalation clause. The provider should check its notice and the timing before continuing the suspension. Both should keep a record of losses, since each side must take reasonable steps to reduce them.

    Illustration 3: The software contract that renewed itself

    Situation. A firm signed a two year software licence. The clause said the licence renews automatically for a further year unless either party gives 60 days’ written notice before expiry. The firm’s IT head, who negotiated it, left. Nobody gave notice, and the invoice for a new year arrived.

    Legal position. The renewal clause is part of the contract the firm signed. Unless the vendor agrees to waive, the firm is likely bound for the renewal period, and refusing to pay may be a breach. The point is about contract management more than law: the renewal date was a risk with no owner.

    What to do. Write to the vendor immediately, ask for a waiver or for a shorter renewal as a goodwill gesture, and offer a longer relationship or a different product in return. For future contracts, record renewal dates in a shared calendar with a named owner and a reminder at least three weeks before the notice date.

    Illustration 4: A termination that may itself be a breach

    Situation. A distributor repeatedly misses sales targets. Dev’s company e-mails a ‘termination with immediate effect’ note to the distributor’s general e-mail address. The contract allows termination for material breach only after 30 days’ written notice to cure, sent to the registered office.

    Legal position. A termination that does not follow the contract’s procedure can be challenged as wrongful, and a wrongful termination can expose the terminating party to damages under section 73. The distributor may argue that the e-mail did not comply with the notice clause and that it was given no chance to cure.

    What to do. Withdraw the defective notice without prejudice to rights, issue a proper notice of breach and cure period to the address in the contract, keep records of the missed targets, and calendar the cure date. Terminate only if the breach continues after the cure period.

    Illustration 5: The micro enterprise that has not been paid

    Situation. A micro enterprise in Lucknow supplied components to a large buyer under a contract that said payment in 90 days. The buyer paid after 140 days and refused interest, saying that the contract fixed the period.

    Legal position. The Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 requires a buyer to pay a micro or small supplier within the agreed time, which cannot exceed 45 days from the day of acceptance or deemed acceptance. Where the buyer fails, it is liable to pay compound interest, with monthly rests, at three times the bank rate notified by the Reserve Bank of India. Disputes can be taken to the Micro and Small Enterprise Facilitation Council, which is expected to decide a reference within 90 days. The supplier’s registration status on the date of the contract matters, so check the Udyam registration.

    What to do. Send a written demand for the principal and the statutory interest, file with the Facilitation Council if unpaid, and keep acceptance records. A buyer who appeals against an award must deposit 75 per cent of the amount awarded before the court will entertain an application to set it aside.

    Illustration 6: The rate changed on a chat message

    Situation. An agency’s account manager and a client’s marketing head agree on WhatsApp that the monthly fee will rise by 15 per cent. The master agreement says variations must be in writing signed by both parties’ authorised signatories. Three months later the client’s finance team pays only the old fee.

    Legal position. Parties may alter a contract by agreement under section 62 of the Contract Act, and contracts can be formed by electronic means under section 10A of the Information Technology Act, 2000. The difficulty is the contract’s own variation clause and the authority of the marketing head. The client can argue that the chat did not satisfy the clause. The agency can argue that the client’s conduct showed agreement. The result is uncertain and expensive to prove.

    What to do. The agency should send a formal amendment letter now for signature and invoice the difference with a reasoned note. Next time, treat any change in price as a document needing signatures from authorised people.

    Before any dispute reaches court

    • Collect the contract, amendments, notices and the e-mail trail.
    • List the dates: breach, notices, cure periods and the three year limitation date.
    • Check for an escalation clause and an arbitration clause.
    • For a commercial suit without urgent interim relief, complete pre-institution mediation under section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, which the Supreme Court has held to be mandatory.
    • Weigh cost and time against the amount at stake and the value of the relationship.

    Handle disputes before they become cases. The Lexfolio Contract Management and Negotiation for Managers is a self-paced certificate course on contract management and negotiation for managers. Price: Rs 499.

    Frequently asked questions

    What damages can I claim for breach of contract?

    Section 73 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 allows compensation for loss that naturally arose in the usual course of things from the breach, or that the parties knew when they made the contract to be likely to result from it. Remote and indirect loss is not compensated. The injured party is expected to take reasonable steps to reduce the loss.

    Is a reminder e-mail enough to preserve my rights?

    It helps as evidence, but it does not by itself stop limitation running. Where the contract says notices must be in a particular form, follow it. For a claim near the end of the three year period, take legal advice about filing.

    Should I stop performing if the other side breaches?

    Not automatically. If you stop without a right to do so, you may be in breach yourself. Check the termination, suspension and cure provisions, give the required notice, and keep performing what you must until your right to stop is clear.

    Can I recover legal costs from the other side?

    Courts and arbitral tribunals have power to award costs, and the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 provides a costs regime for commercial suits. The amount depends on the forum and the conduct of the parties, so costs are never certain.

    Where do MSME payment disputes go?

    The Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 provides for reference of delayed payment disputes to the Micro and Small Enterprise Facilitation Council of the state. Suppliers can file through the government’s online portal or in writing.

    The scenarios are invented illustrations, not reports of real cases or real parties, and every real dispute turns on its own wording and facts. This article is general information, not legal advice for a specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • Contract Management Mistakes After Signing: 8 Myths in Indian Companies

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: contracts are usually lost after they are signed, not before. A manager accepts late delivery without saying anything, misses the notice window for a renewal, changes a rate by a chat message, or goes to court without a mediation attempt. The eight myths below are about that second half of a contract’s life.

    Manage the whole life of a contract. The Lexfolio Contract Management and Negotiation for Managers is a self-paced certificate course on contract management and negotiation for managers. Price: Rs 499.

    Myth 1: Once the contract is signed, the legal work is finished

    A signed contract is a list of promises with dates. Every one of those dates is a possible loss: delivery milestones, payment dates, insurance renewals, price review windows, renewal notice dates, warranty periods and limitation periods. Build an obligation register at signing. For each obligation record who owes it, to whom, by when, and who in your company is watching it. Review the register monthly. The cost is small compared with a missed date that costs a renewal or a claim.

    Myth 2: Accepting late delivery or part payment keeps all our rights

    Section 55 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 deals with the effect of failure to perform at the time agreed. Where a promisee accepts performance of a promise at any time other than that agreed, the promisee cannot claim compensation for any loss occasioned by the non-performance at the agreed time, unless at the time of acceptance he gives notice to the promisor of his intention to do so. In plain terms, if you take delayed goods without saying anything, you may lose the right to claim delay damages. The habit to build is to send a short written reservation of rights on the day of acceptance: ‘Accepted under reservation of our rights for delay damages as per clause X.’

    Myth 3: A casual message can safely change the contract

    Parties can agree to change a contract, and section 62 of the Contract Act recognises that parties may substitute a new contract, rescind or alter the original. The danger lies in informality. Many contracts say that any variation must be in writing and signed by authorised signatories. If a project manager agrees a new rate on a chat message, the other side may later argue that the change was effective, while your finance team argues that it was not. Whichever side you are on, you want clarity. Prepare a short amendment letter for every material change, signed by the same level of authority that signed the contract.

    Myth 4: Renewal clauses take care of themselves

    Contracts renew in three ways: automatically unless a party gives notice, only if both parties sign, or at the option of one party. An automatic renewal clause that needs 60 or 90 days’ notice to stop is one of the commonest traps for companies. If the window is missed, the company may be tied to another year of fees. Put every renewal notice date in a shared calendar with a reminder at least three weeks before the last date to give notice, and decide a month earlier whether the supplier has performed well enough to keep.

    Myth 5: A termination notice can be sent in any form

    If a contract has a notice clause, it usually says in which form notices must be given, to whom and at which address, and when they are treated as received. Follow it exactly. A notice sent by e-mail to a person not named in the clause, or to an old address, can be argued to be ineffective. A wrongful termination can itself be a breach, exposing the terminating party to a claim for damages under section 73 of the Contract Act. Before terminating, check three things: whether you have a right to terminate under the clause, whether you have followed the notice and cure procedure, and whether you have kept the evidence of the breach.

    Myth 6: A liability cap protects us from everything

    A limit of liability clause is common and is generally respected by courts as part of the bargain, but it is read together with the rest of the contract and the general law. Caps are often negotiated with carve-outs for fraud, wilful misconduct, confidentiality breaches, intellectual property infringement and indemnities. Section 73 and section 74 of the Contract Act also shape what compensation is recoverable. Do not assume that a cap in your favour will survive a case of deliberate wrongdoing, and do not assume the cap in the other side’s favour will be applied to every kind of loss without argument. Read the carve-outs as carefully as the cap.

    Myth 7: We can choose any court we like in the jurisdiction clause

    Parties can agree that disputes will be heard by the courts of a particular place, and courts generally enforce such clauses when more than one court has jurisdiction on the facts. The parties cannot confer jurisdiction on a court that has none under the law. A clause naming a city where neither party carries on business and no part of the cause of action arose may not work as intended. When the contract has an arbitration clause, the seat of arbitration matters as well, since it affects the court that supervises the arbitration.

    Myth 8: When a dispute arises, we can file in court straight away

    Many commercial disputes now require a step before filing. Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 requires a commercial suit that does not contemplate urgent interim relief to go through pre-institution mediation. In its 2022 decision in Patil Automation Private Limited v. Rakheja Engineers Private Limited, the Supreme Court held that the requirement is mandatory, and that non-compliance can lead to rejection of the plaint. The Court also left room for genuine urgent relief, but the word ‘urgent’ is not defined and courts examine it case by case. Check whether your contract has an escalation ladder and an arbitration clause first. If a plaint is to be filed, include the mediation record.

    Limitation: the clock behind every myth

    The general period for a suit for compensation for breach of contract is three years under the Limitation Act, 1963, usually counted from the breach. A written acknowledgment of liability signed by the person liable, made before the period ends, can give a new period under section 18. Do not rely on goodwill or on a promise to pay next month. Where the supplier is a micro or small enterprise, remember also that the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 requires payment within the agreed time, which cannot exceed 45 days from acceptance, with compound interest at three times the bank rate notified by the Reserve Bank of India for delay.

    StageCommon mistakeBetter habit
    After signingNo obligation registerOne owner, one register, monthly review
    PerformanceAccepting delay silentlyWritten reservation of rights on acceptance
    ChangeRate changed by chat messageSigned amendment letter
    RenewalMissing the notice windowCalendar with early reminders
    TerminationNotice in the wrong formFollow the notice clause, keep proof
    DisputeFiling straight awayEscalate, check arbitration and section 12A mediation

    Contract management is mostly a discipline of small records. A company that keeps the register, the notices and the amendments in order wins more disputes and, more often, avoids them.

    Learn the full contract lifecycle. The Lexfolio Contract Management and Negotiation for Managers is a self-paced certificate course on contract management and negotiation for managers. Price: Rs 499.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is contract management?

    It is the work of running a contract after it is signed: tracking obligations, deadlines, payments, variations, renewals, notices and disputes, and keeping the records that prove what happened.

    Can a contract be changed by e-mail?

    Under section 62 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 parties may agree to alter a contract. Whether an e-mail is enough depends on the contract. Many contracts say that variations must be in writing and signed by both parties, and a manager who ignores that clause creates a dispute about whether the change took effect.

    Does an arbitration clause stop me going to court?

    For a dispute covered by a valid arbitration agreement, the court will generally refer the parties to arbitration if a party applies at the right stage. Courts still have a role for interim protection, appointment of arbitrators and challenges to awards under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

    What is pre-institution mediation?

    Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 requires a plaintiff in a commercial suit that does not contemplate urgent interim relief to exhaust pre-institution mediation before filing. The Supreme Court held in 2022 that the requirement is mandatory.

    Who should own a contract inside a company?

    One named person, usually the business manager who uses the product or service, should own each contract, supported by legal and finance. Contracts with no owner are the ones whose renewals and notices are missed.

    This article is general information, not legal advice for a specific case. The outcome of a contract dispute depends on the exact wording of the contract and the facts, so take advice from a lawyer before sending a termination notice or filing a case. Lexfolio is a learning resource.