LLexfolio

Tag: product liability India

  • Defective Product or Warranty Refused? Your Rights to Repair, Replacement and Refund

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: A warranty is a promise you can enforce, but your rights over a defective product do not depend only on it. Under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 you can ask the seller or maker to remove the defect, replace the goods or refund the price, and a Consumer Commission can add interest, compensation and costs. You must file within two years of the cause of action. The practical steps are to document the defect, give the service centre a written chance to fix it, escalate to the National Consumer Helpline on 1915, and then file on e-Jagriti.

    Below, you will see how warranty, guarantee and statutory rights fit together, what to do when a service centre keeps failing, and which warranty conditions are worth challenging.

    Everyday Law for Every Indian: Know Your Rights (Rs 349). A self-paced certificate course on everyday legal rights. See the course.

    Three layers of protection

    LayerSourceWhat it gives you
    Basic quality rightsSale of Goods Act, 1930 (section 16) and the Consumer Protection Act, 2019Goods bought from a seller who deals in them should be of merchantable quality, and fit for a purpose you told the seller about and relied on them for. A defect can be a ground for a complaint even without a warranty card.
    Express warranty or guaranteeThe promise made by the maker or seller, in the card, the invoice or the advertisementRepair or replacement within the stated period and on the stated terms. If the product fails to meet an express warranty and causes harm, the maker can be liable under the product liability chapter (section 84).
    Extended warranty or service planA separate contract, often sold at the shopOnly what the contract says. Read what it excludes before you rely on it.

    In the Sale of Goods Act, a “condition” is a term essential to the main purpose of the contract, and a “warranty” is a collateral term (section 12). Breach of a warranty gives a right to claim damages or reduce the price (section 59), while breach of a condition can let you reject the goods in appropriate cases. In everyday speech people use “warranty” for the maker’s repair promise, which is the sense used in the rest of this guide.

    What counts as a defect, and who answers for it

    The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 defines a “defect” as any fault, imperfection or shortcoming in the quality, quantity, potency, purity or standard of goods, whether required by law or claimed by the trader. A product that stops working soon after purchase, differs from its stated specification or is a reconditioned item sold as new fits this description.

    You can raise the complaint against the seller, the maker or both. For personal injury or property damage caused by a defective product, Chapter VI of the Act (sections 82 to 87) sets out product liability. The maker is liable where there is a manufacturing defect, a design defect, a deviation from specifications, a failure to meet an express warranty, or a lack of adequate instructions or warnings. A seller who is not the maker is liable only in the situations listed in section 86, for example where it gave its own express warranty, altered the product, or the maker cannot be traced.

    Step by step when the product keeps failing

    1. Keep proof. Invoice, warranty card, serial or IMEI number, photos or video of the fault, and every job sheet or service report. Photograph faded thermal bills straight away.
    2. Register the complaint with the brand and get a docket number. A phone call alone is not enough, so follow up by e-mail to the service centre and the seller.
    3. Describe the fault, dates and previous visits. Say what you want: repair within a fixed time, or replacement, or refund.
    4. After repeated failures, ask in writing for replacement or refund and refer to the Consumer Protection Act, 2019. Keep the tone factual.
    5. Use the National Consumer Helpline: 1915, WhatsApp 8800001915, or consumerhelpline.gov.in.
    6. Send a short legal notice if needed giving fifteen days. It is not compulsory.
    7. File on e-Jagriti if the company does not act.

    Filing the complaint: forum, fee, time

    • District Consumer Commission: for goods or services where the consideration paid is up to Rs 50 lakh. You can file where you live or work for gain.
    • Fee: nil up to Rs 5 lakh, Rs 200 above Rs 5 lakh and up to Rs 10 lakh, Rs 400 above Rs 10 lakh and up to Rs 20 lakh, and Rs 1,000 above Rs 20 lakh and up to Rs 50 lakh.
    • Limitation: two years from the date the cause of action arose (section 69). A delayed complaint may be admitted if you show sufficient cause, but do not rely on that.
    • Relief under section 39: removal of the defect, replacement with defect-free goods, refund of the price with interest, compensation for loss or injury caused by negligence, punitive damages where fit, and costs. Where a defect needs expert testing, the Commission can refer the goods to a laboratory (see sections 38 and 39).

    Warranty fine print worth a second look

    Clause you may seeWhat to check
    “Warranty void if the seal is broken or the product was opened”If the fault was there before you opened it, say so in writing with proof. Such a clause is open to challenge where the defect pre-dated the opening.
    “Only the authorised service centre may repair”Using an unauthorised repairer can give the company an argument, so ask the brand in writing before you go elsewhere. If the company has no centre near you or does not respond, it will find it harder to rely on the clause.
    “Parts only, no labour”The warranty card should say so. Hidden charges for labour or “visit fees” in the warranty period are open to challenge if they were not disclosed at the time of sale.
    “No warranty on consumables”This is common, but the maker should say what counts as a consumable. The Department of Consumer Affairs has pressed companies to disclose the average life of such items.
    “Extended warranty starts on purchase date”Work out when the extended period actually begins and what the base warranty already covers, so that you do not pay twice for the same cover.

    The Department of Consumer Affairs launched the Right to Repair portal (righttorepairindia.gov.in) on National Consumer Rights Day 2022 to give repair information for products, starting with sectors such as automobiles, consumer durables, mobile and electronics and farm equipment. In its meetings with industry it has also flagged “exaggerated conditions of warranty” and asked for the difference between guarantee, warranty and extended warranty to be explained clearly and for warranty forms to be standardised. The portal is an information tool. It does not by itself create a legal right to a free repair.

    India has no separate “lemon law” for repeated defects. What you rely on is the Consumer Protection Act, the contract and the warranty terms, which is why the written record of repeated failures matters.

    Illustration (not a real case): The washing machine

    A front-load washing machine fails three times in nine months, and the company fixes the same part each time. The buyer keeps all three job sheets, then asks in writing for a replacement. The company refuses. He files on e-Jagriti with the job sheets and seeks replacement or refund with compensation for the repeated visits.

    Illustration (not a real case): The swollen battery

    A phone battery swells and damages the phone and a table. The buyer stops using it, photographs the damage and writes to the maker and seller. Because there is property damage and a safety risk, he also asks for compensation under the product liability provisions, not only a repair.

    Illustration (not a real case): The laptop and the lapsed warranty

    A laptop screen flickers in month ten of a twelve month warranty. The buyer reports it by e-mail and gets a docket number, but the service centre keeps asking him to wait for a part. The warranty period ends. Because his e-mails and docket show the defect was reported in time, he can rely on them when he sends a notice and, if needed, files within two years of the cause of action.

    Common mistakes and myths

    • “The warranty has expired, so nothing can be done.” A defect that existed at the time of sale can be raised within the two year limitation period, though the warranty terms will matter to what the company must do.
    • Paying for a repair in the warranty period. Pay only under protest and in writing, or you may lose the claim for a refund of the charge.
    • Relying on a verbal promise. If the salesperson promised something, ask for it in the invoice or in an e-mail.
    • Letting the product sit. Keep using a hazardous product only if it is safe. Stop immediately if there is any safety risk.

    What not to do

    • Do not open or repair the product yourself while the dispute is on, unless safety demands it.
    • Do not hand over the only copy of your invoice or warranty card. Give a copy.
    • Do not accept a “full and final settlement” form before checking what you are giving up.
    • Do not post unverified allegations on social media that could invite a defamation complaint.

    Everyday Law for Every Indian: Know Your Rights (Rs 349). A self-paced certificate course on everyday legal rights. See the course.

    Frequently asked questions

    Is a guarantee different from a warranty?

    In everyday use the two are often mixed. What matters is the written promise: what is covered, for how long and who must perform. Ask for the terms in writing.

    Can I claim after the warranty period if the defect existed at purchase?

    You can raise it within the two year limitation period, but the outcome depends on proof that the defect was there from the start.

    Can the seller refuse to help and tell me to go to the brand?

    A seller cannot ignore a complaint of a defective product it sold. You can proceed against the seller, the maker or both, and the Commission decides how to apportion responsibility.

    Do I need a lab report to prove the defect?

    Not always. Service reports, photographs and repeated job sheets often suffice. Where the point is technical, the Commission can refer the product to a laboratory.

    What if the product is refurbished but sold as new?

    That is a case of misrepresentation. Keep the listing, invoice and proof showing the product was used or reconditioned, and ask for a replacement or refund.

    This article is general information, not legal advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource.