LLexfolio

Category: Guides

  • Fake Video Call, Digital Arrest, Morphed Photo: 6 Deepfake Scam Scenarios in India

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: the details differ, but a deepfake or voice clone scam usually follows one pattern: someone you trust (a relative, an officer, a celebrity, a supplier) appears to contact you, creates urgency or fear, and asks for money, secrecy or a private image. In every case the first rule is to break the pattern: stop, verify through a channel you already trust, and report quickly if money has moved. Below are six invented illustrations with the legal position and what to do. They are not real cases.

    Want to be ready for these? This is a self-paced certificate course on deepfake and voice-clone scams for families, built around situations like the ones below. The course is Deepfakes and AI Scams: Protecting Your Family, priced at Rs 199.

    About these illustrations. All the people and events are invented to show how the law and the reporting system work. Real facts decide real cases, so use these as a guide to the issues and talk to an advocate about your own situation.

    Illustration 1: The “nephew” who needs bail money

    Illustration. Sulochana, 67, gets a call at 10 pm. A sobbing voice she takes to be her grandson says he has hit a motorcyclist, he is at a police post and she must send Rs 80,000 by UPI to a “lawyer” immediately and tell no one. The voice is a clone built from a video the grandson posted online.

    Position. This is cheating that dishonestly induces delivery of property, which section 318(4) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 punishes with imprisonment of up to seven years and a fine, and it is also cheating by personation under section 319 (up to five years, or fine, or both). Using a computer resource to cheat by personation also falls within section 66D of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (up to three years and a fine up to Rs 1 lakh).

    What to do. Before paying, hang up and call the grandson on his own number, or his parents. A family code word would settle it in seconds. If Sulochana has already paid, she should call her bank and 1930 immediately, then file on cybercrime.gov.in and with the police, quoting the UPI transaction ID.

    Illustration 2: The “digital arrest” of a retired engineer

    Illustration. Mr Menon, a retired engineer in Kochi, gets a video call from a man in uniform who says a parcel under his Aadhaar contained narcotics. For two days the caller keeps him on camera, tells him he is “under digital arrest” and asks him to move his savings into a “safe account” for verification, which will be refunded after the inquiry.

    Position. Indian criminal procedure has no process of arrest or custody by video call, and no genuine agency asks anyone to transfer money to prove innocence. This is cheating and personation, and the forged documents shown on screen add forgery offences. The Supreme Court has taken up this type of scam on its own motion and the CBI has been asked to investigate such cases, which tells you the pattern is organised and widespread.

    What to do. Disconnect, speak to a family member, and call 1930 at once, even if the transfers were made hours ago. Contact the bank, register on cybercrime.gov.in and the police, and keep the call details and account numbers. The earlier the report reaches the banks, the better the chance that the first receiving accounts can be frozen.

    Illustration 3: The morphed photo and the demand for money

    Illustration. Ananya, a college student, receives a message with a nude image that carries her face, produced by an editing tool. The sender says it will go to her classmates unless she pays Rs 20,000.

    Position. The image is fake, but the threat and the demand are real offences. Threatening to circulate an image to extract money is covered by the extortion and criminal intimidation provisions of the BNS, and publishing sexually explicit material electronically is an offence under section 67A of the IT Act (first conviction up to five years and a fine of up to Rs 10 lakh). A fake of this kind that appears real is also within the “synthetically generated information” brought under the IT Rules by the February 2026 amendment, which requires platforms to take down such content on a government or court order within three hours.

    What to do. Do not pay, because payment usually brings a second demand. Do not delete the messages. Take screenshots, block after saving evidence, and report on cybercrime.gov.in and to the police. Because Ananya is an adult and the image shows her, she can use StopNCII.org, which creates a fingerprint on her own device and shares it with participating platforms to help detect copies. If the person in the image is under 18, report immediately to the police and do not forward or download it. Support from a trusted adult matters more than the legal detail.

    Illustration 4: The famous investor and the “guaranteed returns” group

    Illustration. Vikram sees a video of a well known industrialist praising a trading scheme and clicks to join a messaging group with “tips”. He invests Rs 1 lakh through an app and sees fake profits, then is asked to pay “tax” and “unlock fees” to withdraw.

    Position. The video is a deepfake and the investment is cheating. Fraud of this type usually grows in steps: small genuine looking gains, then bigger deposits, then fees. Offering investment advice or portfolio management in India requires registration with the securities regulator, and the regulator publishes a way to check whether an adviser or intermediary is registered on its website. A promise of “guaranteed” returns on market investments is a warning sign in itself.

    What to do. Stop paying, report on 1930 and cybercrime.gov.in with every bank transaction, and report the group and app to the platform. Check any adviser on the regulator’s website before investing, and tell the platform that the advertisement uses a fake of a real person.

    Illustration 5: The cloned WhatsApp profile of an uncle

    Illustration. Divya receives a message from her uncle’s photo and name, on a new number, saying his phone is broken and he needs Rs 15,000 for a hospital bill, to be returned tomorrow.

    Position. A copied profile picture and name need no hacking, and a taken over account can send the same request from the real number. Either way, using someone else’s identity to ask for money is cheating by personation and attracts section 66C and 66D of the IT Act.

    What to do. Call the uncle on the number saved in the phone, or ask the family. Report the number on WhatsApp and through the Chakshu facility on the Sanchar Saathi portal as a suspected fraud communication. If money has been sent, switch to 1930 and cybercrime.gov.in. If your own account is taken over, warn your contacts from another channel and re-register the number.

    Illustration 6: The shopkeeper and the “supplier” voice note

    Illustration. Imran, who runs a hardware shop, receives a voice note in the voice of his regular supplier: “our bank account has changed, pay today’s invoice of Rs 2.4 lakh to this new account”. He pays. The real supplier calls two days later asking where the money is.

    Position. This is a business payment fraud. The cloned voice, or a hijacked chat, is used to change the beneficiary. Whether Imran can recover anything depends mainly on speed. Because he approved the transfer, the bank may treat it as an authorised transaction, so the Reserve Bank’s 2017 limited liability framework for unauthorised transactions may not help him, and the route is the 1930 system, bank cooperation and the police.

    What to do. Report at once on 1930, tell the bank in writing, file on the portal and with the police. Also tell the real supplier in writing, and preserve the voice note and the chat. For the future, change bank details only after a call back on a known number, and use a second approver for new beneficiaries.

    Common threads

    • Urgency, secrecy and a request for an unusual payment appear in every case.
    • The defence is verification on a channel you already own, not a better ear.
    • Report fast: bank first, then 1930 and cybercrime.gov.in, then the police.
    • Keep the evidence untouched, and do not pay anyone who threatens or promises to “fix” it for a fee.

    Build the habit. The Lexfolio course on protecting your family from deepfake and voice-clone scams is a self-paced certificate course on these scenarios. The course is Deepfakes and AI Scams: Protecting Your Family, priced at Rs 199.

    Frequently asked questions

    Should I pay a blackmailer to stop a morphed photo from spreading?

    Payment usually leads to more demands and does not guarantee deletion. Preserve the evidence, report on cybercrime.gov.in and to the police, and use platform and StopNCII.org tools where they apply.

    Is it illegal to forward a deepfake video as a joke?

    It can be. Depending on the content, forwarding may amount to defamation, publishing obscene or sexually explicit material, or a breach of the platform rules. It also helps the harm spread, so do not forward it.

    Can banks freeze the scammer’s account?

    Banks can place holds on accounts linked to reported cyber fraud through the national reporting system. The Supreme Court has recently directed the central bank to adopt a procedure on temporary debit holds, with a grievance mechanism for account holders affected by freezes.

    How can I tell whether a video is a deepfake?

    There is no reliable test for ordinary users. Odd lip movement, flat expression and blurring can be clues, but good fakes have none. Verify the request through another channel instead of judging the video.

    Where do I report a suspicious call where I lost nothing?

    Use the Chakshu facility on the Sanchar Saathi portal for suspicious calls, SMS and WhatsApp messages. If you have lost money, call 1930 and report on cybercrime.gov.in.

    This article is general information, not legal advice for a specific case. The illustrations are invented and facts change outcomes, so consult an advocate about your own situation. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • Deepfake and Voice Clone Scams in India: 8 Myths That Put Families at Risk

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: a cloned voice or a faked face on a call is now cheap to make, so the old advice, “trust your ears and eyes”, no longer works. The safest habits are to verify by calling back on a number you already have, to agree a family code word, never to pay or share an OTP because of urgency alone, and to report a loss on 1930 or at cybercrime.gov.in as fast as possible. This guide takes eight beliefs that put Indian families at risk and replaces each with the correct position.

    Protect the people at home. This is a self-paced certificate course on spotting deepfake and voice-clone scams and knowing your legal remedies, written for families and not for specialists. The course is Deepfakes and AI Scams: Protecting Your Family, priced at Rs 199.

    Myth 1: “I would know my son’s or my father’s voice anywhere”

    Voice cloning tools can imitate a person from a short recording, such as a social media video or a voice note. A scammer can then phone a parent with a crying, panicked “child” who says there has been an accident or an arrest and money is needed now. The voice may be convincing precisely because panic hides small errors. The correct approach does not depend on your ear. End the call, ring the person back on the number saved in your phone, or call another family member who can check. A family code word that only your household knows is a simple second factor. Ask for it, and if the caller cannot answer, hang up.

    Myth 2: “Scammers only target the rich or the careless”

    The common scams are volume businesses. They go after anyone with a phone and a bank account: a retired couple, a student with an education loan, a shopkeeper who takes UPI. Senior citizens are often targeted because they are alone during the day and trust authority figures. Pressure, secrecy and a deadline work on clever people too, which is why the defence is a procedure (stop, verify, tell someone) and not intelligence.

    Myth 3: “If the number is saved in my phone or looks genuine, the call is genuine”

    Caller identity can be faked. A call can appear to come from a known number, a bank, or even a police station, and a WhatsApp account of a relative can be taken over by someone else. The Department of Telecommunications has itself announced work on a central system to stop spoofed calls, which shows the problem is real. A message that says “I have a new number, send money” should be verified with a call to the old number. If you receive a suspicious call, SMS or WhatsApp message and have not lost money, you can report it through the Chakshu facility on the Sanchar Saathi portal. Chakshu is not for cases where money has already been lost; for those, use 1930 or cybercrime.gov.in.

    Myth 4: “The CBI, police or customs can arrest me on a video call”

    This is the “digital arrest” scam. The caller, often in a uniform or in front of a fake police station set, says that a parcel in your name has drugs, or that your Aadhaar was used in a crime, and orders you to stay on camera and move your money to a “safe account” for verification. The correct position: Indian criminal procedure does not have a process of arrest or custody by video call, and no genuine agency asks you to transfer money to prove innocence. The Supreme Court has taken up these scams on its own motion and has directed the CBI to investigate them, which tells you how widespread they are. Disconnect, do not stay on the call, tell a family member, and report on 1930.

    Myth 5: “If I sent the money myself, nobody can help me”

    Recovery is harder when you made the payment, but it is not hopeless. The national system for reporting financial cyber fraud works through the helpline 1930 and the portal cybercrime.gov.in, which alerts banks so that the money can be traced and held in the accounts it moved to. Speed matters. A published guidance on the “golden hour” advises reporting as early as possible, and one explainer recommends within about four hours, though there is no fixed legal cut off. Also write to your bank immediately, from the branch email address and to customer care, and keep copies.

    Be clear about one limit. The Reserve Bank’s circular on customer protection (6 July 2017) deals with unauthorised electronic transactions. If you report a third party breach within three working days of the bank’s message, your liability is zero, and the bank must credit the amount back within 10 working days of your report. But where you yourself approved the payment or shared your credentials, the bank may treat the transaction as authorised, and the circular places the loss on you until you report it. So the circular does not guarantee a refund in a deepfake scam. Report immediately and ask the bank for a written response.

    Myth 6: “A deepfake is only illegal if it is obscene”

    Several laws apply to a fake that is used for fraud, harassment or defamation, even when nothing obscene is shown.

    • Cheating. Section 318 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023. Cheating that dishonestly induces delivery of property is punishable under section 318(4) with imprisonment of up to seven years and a fine.
    • Cheating by personation. Section 319, punishable with imprisonment of up to five years, or fine, or both. A fake face or voice of a relative or officer is personation.
    • Identity theft and online personation. Sections 66C and 66D of the Information Technology Act, 2000, each punishable with imprisonment of up to three years and a fine of up to Rs 1 lakh.
    • Obscene and sexually explicit content. Sections 67 and 67A of the IT Act. For publishing sexually explicit material, the first conviction can attract up to five years and a fine of up to Rs 10 lakh.

    A fake used to lower someone’s reputation can also be defamation. Which section applies depends on the facts, so the police complaint should describe what actually happened and let the investigating officer apply the sections.

    Myth 7: “Platforms will not act, so reporting is pointless”

    The rules have tightened. The Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021 were amended in February 2026: the amendment was notified on 10 February 2026 and came into force on 20 February 2026. It brings “synthetically generated information” (audio, visual or audio visual content created or altered by a computer resource so that it appears real) within the rules. Platforms that permit such content must label it prominently and embed permanent metadata or provenance markers, and large social media platforms must ask users to declare whether content is synthetic. Intermediaries must act on a government or court order within three hours, down from 36 hours. So a complaint to the platform, and where needed to the police and the courts, has more teeth than before. For intimate images of an adult, including edited or synthetic ones that show you, StopNCII.org creates a digital fingerprint on your own device, so the image itself is not uploaded, and shares it with participating platforms to help detect matching copies. Edited versions may need to be fingerprinted separately.

    Myth 8: “Block the number and delete the chat, then forget it”

    That helps the scammer. Keep everything: screenshots of chats and profiles, the phone number, call logs, UPI or bank transaction IDs and the dates and times, the links or app names, and the bank messages. Do not edit the files. Recordings of calls, where you have them, can be useful. Evidence is what lets the bank and police trace the account holders and what supports a complaint later.

    A one page family safety plan

    HabitWhy it works
    Agree a family code wordDefeats cloned voices and fake video calls
    Call back on the saved numberDefeats spoofed caller IDs
    No money or OTP under time pressureScams depend on urgency
    Tell a second person before payingBreaks secrecy, which scammers rely on
    Save 1930 and bank helplines in every phoneSaves minutes in the first hour
    Lock down social media videos and voice notesLess raw material for cloning

    Practise before it matters. The Lexfolio course for protecting your family from deepfake and voice-clone scams is a self-paced certificate course, covering how these scams work and what to do. The course is Deepfakes and AI Scams: Protecting Your Family, priced at Rs 199.

    Frequently asked questions

    What number do I call if I lose money in an online scam?

    Call 1930, the national cyber crime helpline, and also report at cybercrime.gov.in. Tell your bank at the same time. Speed gives the best chance of the money being held.

    Can the police really not arrest someone by video call?

    Indian criminal procedure does not provide for arrest or custody over a video call. If someone claims to arrest you online and asks for money to verify your innocence, treat it as a scam, disconnect, and report it.

    Is it a crime to make a deepfake of someone?

    It depends on the purpose and content. Using it to cheat, impersonate, defame or circulate sexually explicit content can attract the provisions of the BNS and the IT Act. Parody or satire raises different questions, so legal advice is needed on specific facts.

    How do I stop my voice being cloned?

    You cannot fully prevent it, but you can reduce the risk by keeping voice notes and videos private, avoiding unknown links and using a family code word as a check.

    Should I pay a “fine” or “bail” a caller asks for to clear a family member?

    No. Call the family member directly and a second relative. Real legal processes do not ask for transfers to a personal account or gift cards over a phone call.

    This article is general information, not legal advice for a specific case. Laws, helplines and bank rules change, so confirm them before acting and consult an advocate for your own situation. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • Deepfake or Voice Clone Scam: What to Do in the First Hour in India

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: if you have just paid money to a caller or a video who turned out to be fake, do these in order: stop all further payments and contact with the caller, ring your bank and the payment app to block the account and flag the transaction, call 1930 and register the complaint on cybercrime.gov.in, save every piece of evidence without editing it, lodge a written complaint with the police, and then deal with takedowns, account security and bank follow up. Speed matters most in the first hour, because money that is still sitting in the receiving account can sometimes be held.

    Prefer to be prepared? This is a self-paced certificate course on deepfake and voice-clone scams for families, covering how they work and what to do if one succeeds. The course is Deepfakes and AI Scams: Protecting Your Family, priced at Rs 199.

    Keep this page handy, but act first. If you are reading this during an active scam, call 1930 and your bank now, and come back to the details afterwards.

    Step 1: Stop (first five minutes)

    • Do not send any more money, even a small “release fee” or “verification amount”. Fraud calls usually ask for a second and third payment.
    • Do not argue with the caller or threaten them. Just end the call or the video session.
    • Do not share an OTP, PIN, card number or app screen with anyone, including a person who claims to be from the helpline or the bank.
    • If you installed a screen sharing or remote access app at the caller’s request, uninstall it and switch the phone to flight mode while you call the bank from another phone.
    • Tell a family member nearby. Shame keeps people quiet, and the scammers rely on it.

    Step 2: Call your bank and payment app

    Use the number printed on your card, passbook or the bank’s website, not a number sent in a message. Ask the bank to block the card, UPI or net banking if needed, to record the transaction as fraud, and to try to place a hold on the beneficiary account. Note the complaint number and the name of the person you spoke to. Then send an email to your branch’s email address and to customer care describing what happened, with the transaction details. If you phoned customer care, mention the date, time and duration of the call. Keep the copies, because they may matter later if there is a question about the bank’s liability.

    Step 3: Report on 1930 and cybercrime.gov.in

    The national helpline for financial cyber fraud is 1930, and complaints can be registered online at the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal, cybercrime.gov.in. Reporting through this system lets the authorities alert the banks and payment platforms in the chain so that the money can be traced and, where it is still there, held. Keep these details ready before you call:

    • Your name, phone number and bank account or UPI ID used.
    • Amount, date and time of each transaction, and the transaction reference or UTR number.
    • The beneficiary account number, UPI ID or wallet, and the bank name.
    • The caller’s phone numbers, social media handles, links or app names.
    • A short account in order: what was said, when, and what you did.

    Note the acknowledgement number the system gives you. The portal can also be used to report other cybercrimes, including those involving fake images and videos. The helpline and the portal are meant for incidents where you have lost money or been a victim of cybercrime. For a suspicious call or message where nothing has been lost, the Chakshu facility on the Sanchar Saathi portal is the route.

    Step 4: Preserve the evidence

    KeepHow
    Chats, messages, emailsScreenshots showing the number or handle, date and time, plus the original chat on the phone
    Call detailsCall log screenshots; save any recordings you already have
    Payment proofBank SMS, statement lines, UPI screen with transaction ID, receipts
    The fake contentDo not delete it. Save the link, file and the profile that sent it
    Your deviceKeep the phone. Do not reset or sell it until the police have decided what they need

    Write a timeline while memory is fresh. Do not edit screenshots or crop out dates, and do not forward the fake content to other people “to warn them”, because circulation can spread the harm.

    Step 5: File a written police complaint

    Go to the local police station or the cyber crime police station, or use your state’s online facility, and give a written complaint with the same details. Ask for an acknowledgement and an FIR where a cognizable offence is disclosed. Tell the officer that you have already reported on 1930 and give the acknowledgement number. If the incident happened outside the area of the station you approach, the complaint can be recorded as a Zero FIR and transferred. The Supreme Court, in its proceedings on digital arrest scams, has asked States to adopt an e-Zero FIR mechanism, so online registration may be available in your State.

    You do not have to choose the sections of law yourself, but it helps to know the ones that commonly apply: cheating under section 318 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (section 318(4) carries imprisonment up to seven years and a fine), cheating by personation under section 319 (up to five years, or fine, or both), and identity theft and personation by computer resource under sections 66C and 66D of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (up to three years and a fine of up to Rs 1 lakh each). If sexually explicit material is involved, sections 67 and 67A of the IT Act can apply as well.

    Step 6: Take down the fake content

    • Report to the platform. Use its report tool and its grievance officer, attach the links and say that the content is fake and impersonates you. Platforms covered by the amended IT Rules (notified 10 February 2026 and in force from 20 February 2026) have to label synthetic content and must act on government or court takedown orders within three hours.
    • StopNCII.org for intimate images. If the image shows you, you are an adult, and it is nude or sexual, including a synthetic one, StopNCII.org makes a digital fingerprint on your device (the image is not uploaded) and shares it with participating platforms to detect copies. Altered versions may need separate fingerprints, and it does not remove content from every website.
    • If a child is involved report at once on 1930 and cybercrime.gov.in and to the police. Do not forward or download the material. Seek legal advice immediately.
    • Court order. Where the content keeps spreading, an advocate can seek an injunction and a takedown direction from the competent court.

    Step 7: Secure your accounts

    • Change the passwords of email, banking, UPI and social media accounts, starting with email.
    • Turn on two step verification, including on WhatsApp.
    • Check “linked devices” in WhatsApp and log out sessions you do not recognise.
    • If your phone stopped working or calls dropped suddenly, check with your telecom operator for any SIM change.
    • If your own account was used to cheat others, warn your contacts from a safe channel.

    Step 8: Follow up with the bank, then the Ombudsman

    The Reserve Bank’s 2017 circular on limiting customer liability covers unauthorised electronic transactions. If a transaction was unauthorised and the fault lies elsewhere, not with you or the bank, you have zero liability if you report within three working days of the bank’s communication, and the bank must credit the disputed amount within 10 working days of your notification. Where you shared credentials or approved the payment yourself, the bank may argue that the transaction was authorised, so ask for its written position and the reasons. Customers should register for SMS alerts and report at the earliest.

    If the bank does not respond within 30 days of your complaint, or rejects it, you can approach the RBI Ombudsman through cms.rbi.org.in, within 90 days of the bank’s response deadline or last reply under the scheme in force from 1 July 2026 (older write-ups say one year). The Ombudsman will not take up a complaint that is pending before a court or another forum, so decide the route with an advocate.

    Timeline at a glance

    WhenWhat
    MinutesStop, call bank, call 1930
    The same dayPortal complaint, email to branch and customer care, evidence saved, police complaint
    Within 3 working daysReport to the bank if you rely on the zero liability window for an unauthorised transaction
    Within 10 working daysBank credit expected where the circular applies
    After 30 days without a bank replyComplaint to the RBI Ombudsman
    LaterFollow the police investigation; ask for status regularly

    Know what to do before it happens. The Lexfolio course on protecting your family from deepfake and voice-clone scams is a self-paced certificate course with the reporting routes in one place. The course is Deepfakes and AI Scams: Protecting Your Family, priced at Rs 199.

    Frequently asked questions

    Will I definitely get my money back if I report on 1930?

    No one can promise that. Reporting quickly increases the chance that money still in the receiving account can be held, but if it has already been moved out, recovery may be partial or not possible.

    Do I need an FIR to approach the bank?

    Report to the bank immediately and keep the acknowledgement. An FIR or the portal acknowledgement may be asked for later, so get both, but do not delay the bank call while you wait for either.

    Can I file the complaint online instead of going to the police station?

    Yes, the national portal accepts complaints online, and many States offer online FIR facilities. Keep the acknowledgement number and follow up with the local police.

    What if the scammer is outside India?

    The complaint can still be registered and the money trail traced through Indian banks and wallets. Cross border investigation is slower and depends on cooperation from other countries.

    How long should I wait before escalating to the Ombudsman?

    The scheme requires you to complain to the bank first and wait 30 days for a reply, unless the bank rejects or gives an unsatisfactory reply sooner. Check the current scheme on the RBI portal before filing.

    This article is general information, not legal advice for a specific case. Helplines, portals and bank rules change, so confirm them and consult an advocate for your own situation. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • Cyber Crime Scenarios in Offices and Colleges in India: 6 Situations

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Rules read easily until a Monday morning when the accounts head says a vendor’s bank details changed “last week” and Rs 8 lakh has already gone. This guide walks through six realistic situations that offices, colleges and schools in India face, and for each one sets out the legal position and the sensible first moves. All the people and facts below are invented illustrations; they are not real cases.

    The laws used throughout are the Information Technology Act, 2000 (IT Act), the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) and the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA). Outcomes depend on evidence and on what a court finds, so nothing here predicts how a case will end.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers Cyber Crime Law for Offices and Institutions, a self-paced certificate course on cyber crime law for offices and institutions. Course price: Rs 599.

    Illustration 1: The vendor whose bank details “changed”

    Facts (illustration): A trading firm receives an e-mail that looks like it is from a regular supplier, saying its bank account has changed. The accounts officer pays an invoice of Rs 8 lakh to the new account. The real supplier calls three days later asking about payment.

    Legal position. A person who dishonestly induces delivery of money by deceiving another commits cheating (section 318 BNS), and pretending to be someone else is cheating by personation (section 319 BNS, punishment up to five years or fine or both). Using a computer resource for the personation also attracts section 66D of the IT Act (up to three years and fine up to Rs 1 lakh). Because the firm’s own officer approved the payment, the Reserve Bank of India’s 2017 circular on *unauthorised* electronic transactions is unlikely to give a refund right.

    What to do. Call the bank immediately and ask it to contact the receiving bank to hold the funds, then confirm in writing. Report on cybercrime.gov.in or call 1930 on the same day, and file a police complaint with the e-mail in full header form. A hacked mail account is also a CERT-In listed incident (unauthorised access, phishing), so report within six hours of noticing. Afterwards add a rule that bank detail changes are confirmed by a call to a known number.

    Illustration 2: The departing manager and the client list

    Facts (illustration): A sales manager resigns on a Friday. Logs show that on Thursday night he forwarded the full client database and price lists to a personal e-mail account. On Monday a competitor contacts three of the clients.

    Legal position. Copying data from a computer without the permission of its owner is covered by section 43 of the IT Act, which makes the person liable to pay compensation, and by section 66 where it is done dishonestly or fraudulently (up to three years or fine up to Rs 5 lakh, or both). Disclosure of personal information obtained under a lawful contract, with intent to cause wrongful loss or gain, is separately punishable under section 72A (up to three years or fine up to Rs 5 lakh, or both). The employment contract’s confidentiality clause and any civil remedy for misuse of confidential information sit alongside these. Whether the manager acted dishonestly is a matter of proof, and a court will look at the contract and whether the data was within his authorised access.

    What to do. Do not alter his mailbox or laptop. Image the laptop and keep the mail server logs, which the CERT-In directions already expect covered entities to hold for 180 days. Send a written notice to preserve and return the data, and take legal advice before deciding between a police complaint and a civil injunction. Check whether the client list contains personal data, because that will matter under the data protection regime from 13 May 2027.

    Illustration 3: The fake admission website

    Facts (illustration): A private college learns that a website with a near identical name and its logo is collecting “admission confirmation fees” through a UPI QR code. Parents have started calling the office.

    Legal position. Collecting money by pretending to be the college is cheating by personation and, because it is done through a website, an offence under section 66D of the IT Act. Using the college’s name and logo may also infringe its trade mark and copyright, which are civil and criminal matters under their own Acts. The fraud affects the public, so quick action matters more than a perfect case.

    What to do. Issue a clear public notice on your real website and notice board giving the genuine payment details. Report the fake site to the domain registrar and hosting provider with proof of your rights, and complain on cybercrime.gov.in. Tell affected parents to call 1930 and their banks immediately. Keep dated screenshots with the full web address visible. If a college runs its own servers, check whether the site is hosted on, or links to, anything of yours.

    Illustration 4: The morphed image in a class group

    Facts (illustration): A student circulates a morphed, sexually suggestive image of a classmate in a messaging group. The affected student is a minor.

    Legal position. Publishing or sharing private images or sexually explicit material electronically engages sections 66E, 67 and 67A of the IT Act, and where the material shows a child in a sexually explicit act, section 67B (up to five years on a first conviction). Offences involving a child are also dealt with under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012. The seriousness is much higher where a minor is the subject, even if the sender is also a minor, and the juvenile justice framework will apply to a child accused. An institution should not try to decide such a matter internally.

    What to do. Support the affected child first and inform the parents. Do not forward, print or keep copies of the image yourself, even as “evidence”; secure the device and hand it to the police. Report to the police and the cyber crime portal and follow the school’s child protection procedure. Ask the platform to remove the content through its grievance process. Institutions should know their duties under the POCSO framework before an incident, not during one.

    Illustration 5: The ransomware message on a Sunday

    Facts (illustration): A diagnostic clinic’s reception computers show a message that all files are encrypted and a payment in cryptocurrency is demanded. Patient records are stored on the same server.

    Legal position. Introducing a virus or ransomware into a computer system without permission falls under section 43 of the IT Act and, if dishonest, section 66. Ransomware and data breaches are listed incidents under the CERT-In directions, so the clinic must report within six hours of noticing. The directions say failure to comply can invite action under section 70B(7), which provides imprisonment up to one year or a fine up to Rs 1 lakh, or both. Patient data is sensitive personal data, so section 43A (compensation for negligent security practices) is relevant today, and the DPDP Act breach intimation duties will apply from 13 May 2027.

    What to do. Isolate the server from the network but do not wipe it. Report to CERT-In and the police, note the time of discovery, check whether back ups are intact and offline, and take forensic help before restoring. Paying a ransom guarantees nothing, and the police should be told before any payment is even considered.

    Illustration 6: The “principal” asking for urgent transfers

    Facts (illustration): The finance clerk of a trust receives a WhatsApp message from an unknown number, with the managing trustee’s photograph, asking for Rs 2 lakh to be sent to “a supplier” and a few gift vouchers to be bought.

    Legal position. Pretending to be a known person to obtain money is cheating by personation (section 319 BNS) and section 66D of the IT Act where a computer resource is used. If the clerk transfers the money, it was an authorised transfer from the clerk’s account side, so recovery rests on the speed of the report and the bank’s ability to hold funds.

    What to do. Do not pay. Verify any instruction to pay by calling the person on a number you already hold. Screenshot the profile, number and chat, report the number on WhatsApp, and file a complaint on cybercrime.gov.in. If payment was made, call 1930 at once. Add a written rule that no payment is made on a messaging app request alone.

    Common thread

    In all six situations, three habits decide the outcome: report fast, preserve the original evidence, and know in advance who in the organisation will do what. Where personal data is involved, the legal duties will tighten from 13 May 2027 when the main DPDP obligations are scheduled to apply.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers Cyber Crime Law for Offices and Institutions, a self-paced certificate course on cyber crime law for offices and institutions. Course price: Rs 599.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can an institution be held responsible for what a student or employee does online?

    A: The person who commits the offence is primarily responsible. An institution can face separate consequences if it ignored a reporting duty, failed to keep reasonable security or has specific child protection duties. The answer depends on the facts and the law that applies.

    Should we file an FIR or only a portal complaint?

    A: File the portal complaint for speed, and also follow up with the police station for a formal FIR. For financial fraud call 1930 straight away so the bank can be alerted.

    Do we need to tell the person whose data was stolen?

    A: From 13 May 2027 the DPDP Rules require a data fiduciary to inform each affected person without delay and the Data Protection Board with a detailed report within 72 hours. Before then, there is no single general rule, but sector regulators and contracts may require it, so check yours.

    Is a WhatsApp chat admissible as evidence?

    A: It can be, if proved as an electronic record under section 63 of the BSA with the required certificate. Keep the original device and the chat export, and do not delete anything.

    Can we trace the person behind a fake account ourselves?

    A: No. Leave tracing to the police, who can seek subscriber and log details from the platform and service providers through legal process.

    This article is general information, not legal, financial or tax advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services.

  • Cyber Crime Myths in India: 9 Mistakes Offices and Colleges Make

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Most offices and colleges learn cyber law the hard way: after the money has moved, the server is locked or a student’s photograph is circulating. By then the first hours have been spent on the wrong steps, because of beliefs that sound sensible but are wrong. This guide takes nine of those beliefs one by one and gives the correct position under Indian law as it stands on the date above.

    A quick note on the statutes: the main law is the Information Technology Act, 2000 (the IT Act). Ordinary offences such as cheating are now under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), and police procedure is under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS), both in force since 1 July 2024.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers Cyber Crime Law for Offices and Institutions, a self-paced certificate course on cyber crime law for offices and institutions. Course price: Rs 599.

    Myth 1: “We are too small or too ordinary to be targeted”

    Phishing e-mails, fake invoices and ransomware are sent in bulk, and a small office with weak passwords and one accounts clerk who can release payments is an easy target. The law also does not shrink with the size of the entity. The reporting directions issued by CERT-In (the Indian Computer Emergency Response Team) apply to service providers, intermediaries, data centres, body corporates and government organisations alike, so a private company or a college society that runs its own systems is covered.

    Myth 2: “A cyber incident is only a police matter, so we do not need to report it anywhere else”

    There are at least two separate reporting tracks, and the police track is the one people know. Under the directions issued by CERT-In on 28 April 2022 under section 70B(6) of the IT Act, listed incidents must be reported to CERT-In within six hours of noticing them. The list includes unauthorised access to IT systems or data, data breaches and leaks, ransomware and other malicious code, phishing and identity theft, attacks on e-mail, DNS or database servers, website defacement and unauthorised access to social media accounts. Reports go to incident@cert-in.org.in or the toll free number 1800-11-4949. CERT-In itself says that failing to comply can invite action under section 70B(7), which provides for imprisonment up to one year or a fine up to Rs 1 lakh, or both.

    The police track (a complaint or FIR) is separate. Doing one does not discharge the other.

    Myth 3: “The data law will tell us what to do after a breach, and it is not in force yet, so we can wait”

    Half of this is true and half is dangerous. The Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 and the DPDP Rules, 2025 (published 13 November 2025) are being phased in. Only the first rules (definitions and the provisions on the Data Protection Board) took effect on 13 November 2025. The main duties of a data fiduciary, including security safeguards and breach intimation, are set to apply from 13 May 2027, eighteen months after publication. The Rules require a breach to be intimated to affected persons and to the Data Protection Board, with a detailed report to the Board within 72 hours.

    But “not yet in force” does not mean “no rule today”. Until then section 43A of the IT Act (compensation when a body corporate is negligent in protecting sensitive personal data) continues to apply, and the CERT-In six hour direction applies now. The DPDP Act will omit section 43A only when its section 44(2) comes into force on the same 13 May 2027 date. The DPDP Act’s schedule provides penalties of up to Rs 250 crore for failure to take reasonable security safeguards and up to Rs 200 crore for failure to give intimation of a breach.

    Myth 4: “Deleting the malicious file or wiping the machine solves it”

    It destroys the evidence. Cyber cases are won on logs, headers, device images and timestamps. The CERT-In directions already require service providers, body corporates and others covered to keep logs of all ICT systems for a rolling 180 days, stored within India, and to synchronise system clocks with NIC or NPL time servers or sources traceable to them. If you rebuild a server before the logs are copied, you may lose both the proof and the ability to show compliance. Isolate the machine from the network, do not switch off or wipe it, and copy logs first.

    Myth 5: “A screenshot is enough proof in court”

    A screenshot helps you complain, but electronic records are proved in a particular way. Under section 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA), an electronic record produced as secondary evidence is admissible when accompanied by a certificate in the prescribed form, signed by the person in charge of the device or system and, in Part B, by an expert. The certificate carries a hash value of the record. In Pune Bar Association v. Union of India (22 May 2026) the Supreme Court upheld the section 63(4) certificate requirement as constitutional, describing a hash value as “synonymous with an electronic fingerprint”. The Court also read section 39 BSA as allowing a person with special skill in computer science and cyber forensics to qualify as an expert for the Part B certificate on the material before the court, and left the wider question open. So keep original files, exported logs and the device itself.

    Myth 6: “If we lose money to online fraud, the bank must refund us”

    It depends on how the money left the account. The Reserve Bank of India’s circular of 6 July 2017 on customer liability in unauthorised electronic banking transactions gives zero liability where the fault is the bank’s, and also where a third party breach occurs and the customer reports within three working days of the bank’s communication. If the customer reports after four to seven working days, liability is limited to the transaction value or a cap, whichever is lower. The caps are Rs 5,000 for BSBD accounts, Rs 10,000 for other savings accounts and for MSME and small individual current accounts (average balance or limit up to Rs 25 lakh), and Rs 25,000 for other current accounts. Beyond seven working days it depends on the bank’s board approved policy.

    The important limit: the circular deals with *unauthorised* transactions. If your own accounts officer, believing a fake invoice or a spoofed e-mail from a “vendor”, approved and released a payment, the transaction was authorised from the bank’s side and a refund right is generally much weaker. Report immediately anyway, because speed is what allows a bank to try to freeze the receiving account.

    Myth 7: “A cyber crime complaint is not an FIR, so nothing will happen”

    A complaint on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal (cybercrime.gov.in) or on the helpline 1930 is not by itself an FIR, but it can lead to one. Under section 173 of the BNSS, information about a cognizable offence can be given by electronic communication and is recorded when the informant signs it within three days. For large financial frauds, the Ministry of Home Affairs announced in May 2025 an e-Zero FIR system: complaints on the portal or 1930 with losses above Rs 10 lakh are converted automatically into a Zero FIR, which the complainant then follows up at the relevant cyber police station within three days. It was launched as a pilot in Delhi with plans for other states, so check what applies where you are. Below that threshold, do not wait for automatic conversion: file the portal complaint and also approach the local cyber cell or police station with a written complaint.

    Myth 8: “An employee who copies office data is only a disciplinary problem”

    It can be both a disciplinary and a criminal matter. Section 43 of the IT Act makes a person who, without permission of the owner, accesses, downloads, copies or extracts data from a computer liable to pay compensation. Section 66 turns the same acts into a crime where done dishonestly or fraudulently, with imprisonment up to three years or a fine up to Rs 5 lakh, or both. Section 72A punishes disclosure of personal information obtained under a lawful contract with intent to cause wrongful loss or gain, with imprisonment up to three years or a fine up to Rs 5 lakh, or both. Where an employee entrusted with data dishonestly misuses it, the offence of criminal breach of trust (section 316 BNS) may also be considered. Criminal liability depends on proof of intent, so preserve evidence and take advice before acting.

    Myth 9: “A fake account or photograph is a ‘social media problem’ that only the platform can fix”

    The platform is one route, not the only one. Identity theft using another person’s password or unique identification feature is punishable under section 66C (up to three years and a fine up to Rs 1 lakh). Cheating by personation using a computer resource is punishable under section 66D (up to three years and a fine up to Rs 1 lakh), and the personation limb of cheating also appears in section 319 BNS. Publishing a private image of a person without consent attracts section 66E (up to three years or a fine up to Rs 2 lakh, or both). Material showing children in sexually explicit acts falls under section 67B (up to five years on a first conviction). Use the platform’s grievance process, keep screenshots with URLs and dates, and file the portal complaint.

    What to do next: a one minute checklist

    • Name one person who decides what to do when something goes wrong, and keep the numbers where staff can find them.
    • Keep logs and back ups as the CERT-In directions expect, and know where they are stored.
    • Train staff on the two or three attacks that actually succeed: fake payment instructions, fake log in pages and password reuse.
    • Save the portal address (cybercrime.gov.in), the 1930 helpline and CERT-In’s reporting address in your incident plan.
    • Plan for the DPDP duties that begin on 13 May 2027.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers Cyber Crime Law for Offices and Institutions, a self-paced certificate course on cyber crime law for offices and institutions. Course price: Rs 599.

    Frequently asked questions

    Do we have to report every spam e-mail to CERT-In?

    A: No. The six hour duty relates to the listed types of cyber incidents, such as unauthorised access, data breach, ransomware or compromise of systems. An ordinary spam message that was deleted unopened is not such an incident, but a successful phishing attack that gave an outsider access is.

    Does a college or school have to follow the CERT-In directions?

    A: The directions are addressed to service providers, intermediaries, data centres, body corporates and government organisations. Whether a particular institution falls in one of those categories depends on how it is constituted and what it operates, so confirm for your own entity. Government institutions are generally covered.

    How soon after a fraud should I call 1930?

    A: As soon as you notice it. The helpline exists so that banks and platforms can be alerted quickly to hold the money, and delay reduces the chance of recovery. Also tell your own bank in writing.

    Will the DPDP Act change what we have to do after a breach?

    A: Yes, from 13 May 2027 the data fiduciary duties, including breach intimation to the Data Protection Board and to affected persons, are scheduled to apply. Until then the IT Act and the CERT-In directions are what apply.

    This article is general information, not legal, financial or tax advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services.

  • What to Do After a Cyber Attack or Data Breach at Your Office in India

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: if your office or institution has been hit by ransomware, a hacked mail account, a data leak or a payment fraud, treat the first day as a clock. Contain the problem without destroying evidence, report to CERT-In within six hours of noticing a listed incident, tell your bank at once if money moved, file a complaint with the police or the cyber crime portal, and keep a record of every step. The order below is a working checklist, not a substitute for advice on your own facts.

    This guide covers an organisation (company, firm, college, school, trust or government office) that controls its own systems. If you are an individual who lost money in a scam, the same ideas apply, but the six hour direction is aimed at organisations.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers Cyber Crime Law for Offices and Institutions, a self-paced certificate course on cyber crime law for offices and institutions. Course price: Rs 599.

    The first day at a glance

    StepDo thisRule or source
    ———
    1Contain: isolate affected devices, change credentials, do not wipeEvidence preservation
    2Note the exact time you noticed the incidentCERT-In six hour clock runs from noticing
    3Report to CERT-In if the incident is of a listed typeDirections of 28 April 2022 under section 70B(6), IT Act
    4If money moved, call your bank and the helpline 1930RBI circular of 6 July 2017; National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal
    5File a complaint or FIRSection 173, BNSS
    6Preserve and certify electronic evidenceSection 63, BSA
    7Assess data protection dutiesIT Act section 43A now; DPDP Act and Rules from 13 May 2027
    8Fix, document, learnInternal record

    Step 1: Contain, but do not destroy

    Disconnect the affected computers from the network and the internet (pull the cable or switch off Wi-Fi rather than shutting the machine down, because shutting down can erase information held in memory). Change passwords and revoke access tokens from a clean device, starting with e-mail, banking and administrator accounts. Switch on multi-factor authentication where it was missing.

    Do not reinstall, reformat or delete anything yet. Make a list of devices, accounts and servers involved. If you use a vendor or cloud provider, ask them in writing to preserve logs. The CERT-In directions already expect covered entities to keep logs of all ICT systems for a rolling 180 days, stored within India, so the logs may exist even if the machine itself is rebuilt later.

    Step 2: Write down the time you noticed

    The six hour period under the CERT-In directions runs from the moment the entity notices the incident or is told about it. Record the time, who noticed it and how, in a simple log that you keep adding to. It protects you later if anyone asks when you knew.

    Step 3: Report to CERT-In if the incident is listed

    The directions issued by CERT-In on 28 April 2022 under section 70B(6) of the Information Technology Act, 2000 list incident types in an annexure. Those most relevant to offices and institutions include:

    • unauthorised access to IT systems or data, and compromise of critical systems or information
    • data breaches and data leaks
    • malicious code such as ransomware, spyware and trojans
    • identity theft, spoofing and phishing
    • attacks on mail, DNS or database servers and on network devices
    • website defacement or intrusion
    • unauthorised access to social media accounts
    • attacks affecting digital payment systems or cloud systems

    Report within six hours by e-mail to incident@cert-in.org.in or by phone on 1800-11-4949. The directions ask for the details of the incident as far as known, so send what you have and add more later. Failure to furnish information or comply can invite action under section 70B(7), which provides for imprisonment up to one year or a fine up to Rs 1 lakh, or both.

    Two related duties in the same directions are worth checking today and not on the day of an attack: keep system logs for 180 days within India, and synchronise your system clocks with the NIC or NPL time servers (or sources traceable to them).

    Step 4: If money has moved, act within minutes

    Call your bank’s fraud line and follow up in writing, giving the transaction reference, amount, time and the receiving account. Then report on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal (cybercrime.gov.in) or call the national helpline 1930. Speed matters because the receiving bank may be able to hold the funds only while they have not been moved on.

    Under the Reserve Bank of India’s circular of 6 July 2017, a customer has zero liability for an unauthorised electronic transaction where the fault lies with the bank, or where a third party breach occurs and the customer reports within three working days of the bank’s communication. After four to seven working days the customer’s liability is capped (Rs 5,000, Rs 10,000 or Rs 25,000 depending on the account type) and beyond seven working days it follows the bank’s board approved policy. The banks must credit the disputed amount provisionally within ten working days of notification. These protections concern *unauthorised* transactions. If your own staff released the payment on a fake instruction, expect a harder dispute and tell the bank exactly what happened.

    Step 5: File a complaint or FIR

    Take a written complaint to the cyber crime police station or the local police station, with copies of the evidence. Under section 173 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, information can also be given electronically; it is taken on record when the informant signs it within three days. For large financial frauds, the Ministry of Home Affairs announced in May 2025 an e-Zero FIR process under which complaints on the portal or 1930 involving more than Rs 10 lakh are converted automatically, starting as a pilot in Delhi. Whether it operates in your state may differ, so ask the police desk.

    What to include in the complaint:

    1. A short chronology with dates and times.
    2. Names and designations of the staff involved and what each did.
    3. Account numbers, transaction IDs, phone numbers, e-mail addresses, URLs and IP addresses seen.
    4. The loss, if any, and the date you informed the bank and CERT-In.
    5. A list of the evidence you are handing over or preserving.

    The offences usually considered are in the IT Act (for example sections 43 and 66 for unauthorised access and damage, 66C for identity theft and 66D for cheating by personation using a computer resource) and in the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (for example section 318 for cheating and section 319 for cheating by personation). The police decide which sections apply on the facts.

    Step 6: Preserve and certify the electronic evidence

    Copy, do not move, the originals. For each item note who copied it, when, from which device and with which tool. Keep e-mails in their original format with full headers, not only printed pages.

    In court, electronic records are proved under section 63 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023. A certificate in the prescribed form accompanies the record: Part A is given by the person in charge of the device or computer system and Part B by an expert, and the certificate records the hash value of the record. In Pune Bar Association v. Union of India, decided on 22 May 2026, the Supreme Court upheld the certificate requirement and described a hash value as “synonymous with an electronic fingerprint”. It also read section 39 of the BSA as allowing a person with special skill in computer science and cyber forensics to qualify as an expert for Part B on the material before the court, while leaving the wider question open. A forensic specialist engaged early can save you from a failed certificate later.

    Step 7: Check your data protection position

    Today, section 43A of the IT Act requires a body corporate that handles sensitive personal data to maintain reasonable security practices, failing which it can be liable to pay compensation to the person affected. The Digital Personal Data Protection Rules, 2025 were published on 13 November 2025 and the main obligations, including the duty to intimate a personal data breach, are scheduled to apply from 13 May 2027. Once they do, a data fiduciary will have to inform each affected person without delay, and the Data Protection Board with an initial description followed by a detailed report within 72 hours. The Act’s schedule sets maximum penalties of Rs 250 crore for failure to take reasonable security safeguards and Rs 200 crore for failure to give intimation of a breach.

    If the incident exposed personal data of students, patients, staff or customers, list what data, whose, and how many. You will need that list under any regime.

    Step 8: Close the loop

    • Reset all credentials, patch the entry point and test back ups before bringing systems back.
    • Brief staff in plain language on what happened and what to do next time.
    • Review contracts with IT vendors for incident support and log retention.
    • Keep a single folder with the incident log, reports to CERT-In, bank and police, and evidence certificates.
    • If you have cyber insurance, read the notice period in the policy and inform the insurer in time.

    What not to do: do not pay a ransom or “recovery agent” on the strength of a message alone, do not delete the attacker’s e-mails and do not contact the receiving account holder yourself. Leave contact with suspects to the police.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers Cyber Crime Law for Offices and Institutions, a self-paced certificate course on cyber crime law for offices and institutions. Course price: Rs 599.

    Frequently asked questions

    What if I am not sure whether the incident is “listed” for CERT-In?

    A: The annexure covers most incidents an office is likely to face, including unauthorised access, phishing, ransomware and data leaks. If you are unsure, reporting is the safer course, and you can supplement the report as facts emerge.

    Is a complaint on cybercrime.gov.in enough, or do I also need an FIR?

    A: The portal complaint starts the process, but an FIR is what lets investigation and prosecution proceed formally. Follow up with the cyber crime police station and ask for the FIR number or a written acknowledgement.

    Can we investigate internally before telling anyone?

    A: You can begin internal checks, but the six hour period for listed incidents runs from noticing, and delay can cost recovery of money. Report first and investigate in parallel.

    Does an employee’s mistake, such as clicking a phishing link, make the employer liable?

    A: Liability depends on the facts: what safeguards the organisation had, what the contract with the affected person says and which law applies. Training and reasonable security practices are your best protection.

    This article is general information, not legal, financial or tax advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services.

  • Copyright Myths for YouTubers and Instagram Creators in India

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: in India, giving credit, using “only a few seconds”, or not earning from a video does not make using someone else’s work lawful. Indian copyright law has no “fair use” doctrine and no stopwatch rule. It has a closed list of “fair dealing” situations, and anything outside that list needs the owner’s permission. This guide goes through the copyright myths creators repeat most often and gives the correct position under the Copyright Act, 1957.

    Creating content for a living? Law for Content Creators and Influencers (Rs 399). It is a self-paced certificate course on the legal basics every content creator and influencer in India should know.

    Myth 1: “I gave credit, so it is fine”

    Credit is courtesy, not permission. Copyright gives the owner the exclusive right to copy, publish, adapt and communicate the work to the public (section 14). Using a song, clip, photo or script without the owner’s licence is infringement under section 51 whether or not you name the creator. Moral rights are a separate matter: section 57 gives an author the right to claim authorship and to object to distortion of the work, and crediting someone satisfies only the first of these, not the owner’s economic rights.

    Credit does help in two places: it avoids a claim that you passed the work off as your own, and it is often a term of a licence you obtain. If a creator says “you may use this with credit”, save that message. It is your licence.

    Myth 2: “Under 30 seconds (or 10, or 5) is fair use”

    No such time limit exists in the Indian Act. The number appears in online folklore. A short clip can infringe if it is the heart of the work, and a long extract can fall within an exception if it is used for a protected purpose. What matters is the purpose and the way the work is used.

    Myth 3: “Fair use applies in India”

    “Fair use” is a United States doctrine. India’s section 52 lists specific acts that are not infringement. For a creator the practical entries in section 52(1)(a) are the fair dealing of a work (other than a computer program) for private or personal use including research, for criticism or review, and for reporting current events and current affairs. Each has to be fair, and the courts look at purpose, quantity, effect on the market for the original and whether the use is a substitute for it.

    • Review and criticism: a film review that plays a short scene while discussing it is closer to the exception than a “reaction” that simply replays the whole scene.
    • News reporting: reporting current events is covered, but reusing a news channel’s entire footage as filler is not.
    • Private use: watching a song at home is one thing; uploading it as the soundtrack of your public reel is another.

    When in doubt, ask the owner, or use material that is licensed to you or that you made yourself.

    Myth 4: “I did not earn from it, so no one can object”

    Infringement does not depend on whether you made money. Not earning matters in two limited ways. First, the punishment provision (section 63) imposes imprisonment of six months to three years and a fine of Rs 50,000 to Rs 2 lakh, but a proviso lets the court, for adequate and special reasons recorded in the judgment, impose a lesser sentence where the infringement was not for gain in the course of trade or business. Second, the punishment is only one part of the picture. Neither point makes the use lawful. In a civil case the owner can seek an injunction, damages or an account of profits, and can have the video taken down.

    Myth 5: “The app’s music library covers anything I post”

    Music libraries inside social apps are licensed under the platform’s terms, which may limit the way tracks are used. Terms often differ between personal and business or creator accounts, and between a short reel and a sponsored post. A track that is available for a personal reel is not automatically cleared for a brand’s paid ad. Read the terms of the platform and, for brand work, ask the brand to confirm the music clearance in the contract.

    Myth 6: “I paid the editor, so I own the video”

    Ownership follows the Act and the contract, not payment alone. As a rule the author is the first owner of the copyright (section 17), and a transfer of ownership must be in writing and signed by the person giving it (section 19). Where an editor, animator, voice artist or photographer works for you without a written assignment, you may have only an implied right to use the work as intended, while the copyright stays with them. The fix is simple: a one page agreement that says who owns the final video, the raw files and the thumbnail, and that the person being paid has not used anyone else’s material.

    Myth 7: “Copyright begins when I register it”

    Copyright in an original work arises automatically when the work is created. Registration with the Copyright Office is not a condition of protection, although a certificate can be useful evidence in a dispute. Keep dated drafts, raw footage and project files, which prove authorship just as well in many cases.

    Myth 8: “A strike or claim on my channel means I will be sued”

    A claim or strike is a platform process under the platform’s own policy. It is separate from a case in an Indian court. A claim can reduce reach or earnings, and repeated strikes can end a channel, so respond to it seriously: check the claim, remove or replace the material, or if you have a lawful basis, use the platform’s dispute route. A court case needs the owner to take separate action, usually after a legal notice.

    How to use other people’s work lawfully

    • Ask the owner in writing and keep the reply. Say where, how long and for what purpose you will use the work.
    • Use stock libraries whose licence covers the way you will use the work, and save the licence with the invoice.
    • Commission original music, art and editing under a written agreement that assigns the rights to you or gives you a clear licence.
    • If you rely on criticism or review, use only what you need to make your point and add your own commentary throughout.

    Where creators go wrong most often

    Common practiceWhat to do instead
    Film clips as fillerUse a short extract only for review or criticism, or license the footage
    Songs from a streaming appUse the platform library within its terms, or license or commission music
    Photos from a search engineUse licensed or self-made images and keep the licence
    Unwritten work with editorsSign a short agreement on ownership and clearances
    Brand supplied music or footageAsk for a written clearance in the contract

    Keep a folder per video with the licence, invoices, messages and project files. If a claim arrives, the folder answers it in minutes.

    Know the rules before a brand or a platform tests you. Law for Content Creators and Influencers (Rs 399). It is a self-paced certificate course on the legal basics every content creator and influencer in India should know.

    Frequently asked questions

    Is there fair use under Indian copyright law?

    No. The Copyright Act, 1957 uses a closed list of fair dealing exceptions in section 52. A use outside the list needs permission, however short or non-commercial it is.

    Can I use a movie clip in a review?

    Fair dealing for criticism or review is an exception under section 52(1)(a), but the use must be fair. A short, relevant extract used while you discuss the film is much safer than a long clip played without comment.

    What is the punishment for copyright infringement in India?

    Section 63 provides imprisonment from six months to three years and a fine from Rs 50,000 to Rs 2 lakh, with a proviso allowing lower punishment in some cases where the infringement was not for gain in trade or business.

    Do I need to register my videos to be protected?

    No. Copyright arises on creation. Registration is optional and acts as evidence.

    Who owns a video that my freelance editor made?

    Unless there is a written assignment or an employment relationship that decides otherwise, the editor, as the author, can be the first owner. Put ownership in writing.

    This article is general information, not legal advice for a specific case, and the law can change or differ by state. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services. For your own situation, consult a qualified advocate or professional.

  • Contract Management Mistakes After Signing: 8 Myths in Indian Companies

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: contracts are usually lost after they are signed, not before. A manager accepts late delivery without saying anything, misses the notice window for a renewal, changes a rate by a chat message, or goes to court without a mediation attempt. The eight myths below are about that second half of a contract’s life.

    Manage the whole life of a contract. The Lexfolio Contract Management and Negotiation for Managers is a self-paced certificate course on contract management and negotiation for managers. Price: Rs 499.

    Myth 1: Once the contract is signed, the legal work is finished

    A signed contract is a list of promises with dates. Every one of those dates is a possible loss: delivery milestones, payment dates, insurance renewals, price review windows, renewal notice dates, warranty periods and limitation periods. Build an obligation register at signing. For each obligation record who owes it, to whom, by when, and who in your company is watching it. Review the register monthly. The cost is small compared with a missed date that costs a renewal or a claim.

    Myth 2: Accepting late delivery or part payment keeps all our rights

    Section 55 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 deals with the effect of failure to perform at the time agreed. Where a promisee accepts performance of a promise at any time other than that agreed, the promisee cannot claim compensation for any loss occasioned by the non-performance at the agreed time, unless at the time of acceptance he gives notice to the promisor of his intention to do so. In plain terms, if you take delayed goods without saying anything, you may lose the right to claim delay damages. The habit to build is to send a short written reservation of rights on the day of acceptance: ‘Accepted under reservation of our rights for delay damages as per clause X.’

    Myth 3: A casual message can safely change the contract

    Parties can agree to change a contract, and section 62 of the Contract Act recognises that parties may substitute a new contract, rescind or alter the original. The danger lies in informality. Many contracts say that any variation must be in writing and signed by authorised signatories. If a project manager agrees a new rate on a chat message, the other side may later argue that the change was effective, while your finance team argues that it was not. Whichever side you are on, you want clarity. Prepare a short amendment letter for every material change, signed by the same level of authority that signed the contract.

    Myth 4: Renewal clauses take care of themselves

    Contracts renew in three ways: automatically unless a party gives notice, only if both parties sign, or at the option of one party. An automatic renewal clause that needs 60 or 90 days’ notice to stop is one of the commonest traps for companies. If the window is missed, the company may be tied to another year of fees. Put every renewal notice date in a shared calendar with a reminder at least three weeks before the last date to give notice, and decide a month earlier whether the supplier has performed well enough to keep.

    Myth 5: A termination notice can be sent in any form

    If a contract has a notice clause, it usually says in which form notices must be given, to whom and at which address, and when they are treated as received. Follow it exactly. A notice sent by e-mail to a person not named in the clause, or to an old address, can be argued to be ineffective. A wrongful termination can itself be a breach, exposing the terminating party to a claim for damages under section 73 of the Contract Act. Before terminating, check three things: whether you have a right to terminate under the clause, whether you have followed the notice and cure procedure, and whether you have kept the evidence of the breach.

    Myth 6: A liability cap protects us from everything

    A limit of liability clause is common and is generally respected by courts as part of the bargain, but it is read together with the rest of the contract and the general law. Caps are often negotiated with carve-outs for fraud, wilful misconduct, confidentiality breaches, intellectual property infringement and indemnities. Section 73 and section 74 of the Contract Act also shape what compensation is recoverable. Do not assume that a cap in your favour will survive a case of deliberate wrongdoing, and do not assume the cap in the other side’s favour will be applied to every kind of loss without argument. Read the carve-outs as carefully as the cap.

    Myth 7: We can choose any court we like in the jurisdiction clause

    Parties can agree that disputes will be heard by the courts of a particular place, and courts generally enforce such clauses when more than one court has jurisdiction on the facts. The parties cannot confer jurisdiction on a court that has none under the law. A clause naming a city where neither party carries on business and no part of the cause of action arose may not work as intended. When the contract has an arbitration clause, the seat of arbitration matters as well, since it affects the court that supervises the arbitration.

    Myth 8: When a dispute arises, we can file in court straight away

    Many commercial disputes now require a step before filing. Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 requires a commercial suit that does not contemplate urgent interim relief to go through pre-institution mediation. In its 2022 decision in Patil Automation Private Limited v. Rakheja Engineers Private Limited, the Supreme Court held that the requirement is mandatory, and that non-compliance can lead to rejection of the plaint. The Court also left room for genuine urgent relief, but the word ‘urgent’ is not defined and courts examine it case by case. Check whether your contract has an escalation ladder and an arbitration clause first. If a plaint is to be filed, include the mediation record.

    Limitation: the clock behind every myth

    The general period for a suit for compensation for breach of contract is three years under the Limitation Act, 1963, usually counted from the breach. A written acknowledgment of liability signed by the person liable, made before the period ends, can give a new period under section 18. Do not rely on goodwill or on a promise to pay next month. Where the supplier is a micro or small enterprise, remember also that the Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 requires payment within the agreed time, which cannot exceed 45 days from acceptance, with compound interest at three times the bank rate notified by the Reserve Bank of India for delay.

    StageCommon mistakeBetter habit
    After signingNo obligation registerOne owner, one register, monthly review
    PerformanceAccepting delay silentlyWritten reservation of rights on acceptance
    ChangeRate changed by chat messageSigned amendment letter
    RenewalMissing the notice windowCalendar with early reminders
    TerminationNotice in the wrong formFollow the notice clause, keep proof
    DisputeFiling straight awayEscalate, check arbitration and section 12A mediation

    Contract management is mostly a discipline of small records. A company that keeps the register, the notices and the amendments in order wins more disputes and, more often, avoids them.

    Learn the full contract lifecycle. The Lexfolio Contract Management and Negotiation for Managers is a self-paced certificate course on contract management and negotiation for managers. Price: Rs 499.

    Frequently asked questions

    What is contract management?

    It is the work of running a contract after it is signed: tracking obligations, deadlines, payments, variations, renewals, notices and disputes, and keeping the records that prove what happened.

    Can a contract be changed by e-mail?

    Under section 62 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 parties may agree to alter a contract. Whether an e-mail is enough depends on the contract. Many contracts say that variations must be in writing and signed by both parties, and a manager who ignores that clause creates a dispute about whether the change took effect.

    Does an arbitration clause stop me going to court?

    For a dispute covered by a valid arbitration agreement, the court will generally refer the parties to arbitration if a party applies at the right stage. Courts still have a role for interim protection, appointment of arbitrators and challenges to awards under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

    What is pre-institution mediation?

    Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015 requires a plaintiff in a commercial suit that does not contemplate urgent interim relief to exhaust pre-institution mediation before filing. The Supreme Court held in 2022 that the requirement is mandatory.

    Who should own a contract inside a company?

    One named person, usually the business manager who uses the product or service, should own each contract, supported by legal and finance. Contracts with no owner are the ones whose renewals and notices are missed.

    This article is general information, not legal advice for a specific case. The outcome of a contract dispute depends on the exact wording of the contract and the facts, so take advice from a lawyer before sending a termination notice or filing a case. Lexfolio is a learning resource.

  • Unpaid Brand Deal, Deepfake of You, Betting App Offer: Creator Scenarios and What to Do

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: creators face five or six recurring legal problems: unpaid brand deals, copied content, deepfakes, risky offers, review disputes and disclosure lapses. The six illustrations below are invented, so no person or brand is real, but each one follows a pattern that comes up repeatedly. For each you will find the legal position and a practical next step. Always check the position against the facts in your own case.

    Creating for brands? Law for Content Creators and Influencers (Rs 399). It is a self-paced certificate course on the legal basics every content creator and influencer in India should know.

    Illustration 1: The brand posted your video, then stopped replying

    What happened: A food creator completes a paid reel for Rs 40,000 under an e-mail agreement. The brand uses it in ads for two months and says the invoice is “under process” for the fourth time.

    The legal position: An e-mail exchange that records the work, the price and the acceptance can be a binding contract. Courts treat unpaid agreed fees as a civil debt, generally recoverable within three years of the date the payment fell due under the Limitation Act, 1963. Continued use of the content after non-payment strengthens your case because the brand is using what it has not paid for.

    What to do: Send a written reminder with the invoice and the agreed date. If no payment follows, send a legal notice demanding payment by a stated date and stating that the licence to use the content is conditional on payment. Keep the original e-mails, the post links and the brand’s approval messages.

    Illustration 2: Another page re-uploads your reels

    What happened: A page with 300,000 followers reposts a comedy creator’s reels with its own watermark and gains sponsorships from them.

    The legal position: The original reel is an original work in which the creator owns the copyright (section 17 of the Copyright Act, 1957, subject to any agreement). Reposting without a licence is infringement under section 51. Section 63 provides criminal penalties, and civil remedies include an injunction and damages. The author also has moral rights under section 57, including the right to claim authorship.

    What to do: Collect screenshots with dates and links, report the content using the platform’s copyright process, and send a legal notice to the page owner if the problem continues. Your dated raw files and project files are the best proof that you made it first.

    Illustration 3: A deepfake video circulates

    What happened: A fashion creator finds a video in which her face has been placed on another person’s body and is being shared on social media.

    The legal position: The Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Amendment Rules, 2026, which took effect on 20 February 2026, define synthetically generated information and require prominent labelling of realistic synthetic content. They also shorten takedown deadlines: platforms must act within three hours on a court order or a reasoned government intimation, and within two hours on complaints of non-consensual nudity or morphed imagery. Significant social media intermediaries must ask users to declare whether content is synthetic and take measures to verify it.

    What to do: Save links, usernames and screenshots with timestamps. Report the content on the platform under the “impersonation” or “non-consensual imagery” route and ask for removal. Then consider a complaint on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal (cybercrime.gov.in) and consult an advocate about police and court options. Do not delete your evidence while you wait for the platform to respond.

    Illustration 4: A “gaming app” offers Rs 5 lakh for three stories

    What happened: A cricket page is approached by an app that lets users stake money on predicting match results. The brand offers Rs 5 lakh for three stories and says it is “legal because it is a skill game”.

    The legal position: The Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Act, 2025 bans online money games and prohibits their advertisement. Section 6 forbids making, causing or aiding the advertisement of such a game in any media, and section 9(2) provides imprisonment of up to two years, a fine of up to Rs 50 lakh, or both, for a first offence. Calling the game a “skill game” does not change this if money is staked in the hope of winning money.

    What to do: Decline, and say so in writing. If you are unsure whether a product falls in the banned category, ask an advocate before posting. The fee is not worth the risk of a criminal case.

    Illustration 5: A brand sends a defamation notice after a negative review

    What happened: A tech creator reviews a power bank, shows that it overheated in a test and calls the product “unsafe”. The brand sends a notice demanding deletion and an apology.

    The legal position: Defamation under section 356 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 is punishable with simple imprisonment up to two years, a fine, both, or community service, and it can also found a civil claim for damages. But the section has exceptions, including an imputation that is true and made for the public good, and a good faith opinion on a work or performance submitted to public judgment. A review that is based on facts you can prove, stated fairly and without exaggeration, is on much firmer ground than a vague insult.

    What to do: Do not panic-delete or retaliate. Keep the test footage, the receipt and the raw files. Reply in writing with the facts, offer to correct anything that is inaccurate, and avoid words like “scam” and “fraud” unless you can prove them. If the brand persists, consult an advocate.

    Illustration 6: A sponsored reel without a label

    What happened: A travel creator posts a hotel stay received in return for a reel but writes only “loved this place”. A follower complains to the consumer authority.

    The legal position: Under the Endorsement Know-hows (20 January 2023), a stay received for a post is a material connection and must be disclosed clearly, using terms such as “ad”, “sponsored” or “paid promotion”, inside the video and in the same language. Section 21(2) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 permits a penalty of up to Rs 10 lakh, and up to Rs 50 lakh for repeat violations.

    What to do: Add the label to the video immediately, keep the contract and the hotel’s confirmation, and answer any notice in writing. Next time, put the disclosure on the video itself, not only the caption.

    One thing is easy to miss: several of these problems arise together. A paid post with a copied song, no label and an unsupported claim is four separate issues, and the brand’s contract may leave all of them with you. Read the clauses on clearance, claims and indemnity before you sign.

    Patterns to take away

    • Put the deal in writing before you start, and save every approval.
    • Keep raw files and dates, because they prove ownership.
    • Disclose any benefit clearly, in the video and in the same language.
    • Say no to categories that are barred, whatever the fee.
    • Reply to notices in writing and on time.

    Handle these situations before they happen. Law for Content Creators and Influencers (Rs 399). It is a self-paced certificate course on the legal basics every content creator and influencer in India should know.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can I take legal action if a brand refuses to pay?

    Yes. An agreed fee is a debt recoverable in a civil claim, generally within three years of when payment fell due. Start with a written reminder and a legal notice, and keep your agreement and approval messages.

    How long do platforms have to remove a deepfake in India?

    Under the 2026 amendment to the IT Rules, three hours when a court order or reasoned government intimation is received, and two hours for complaints of non-consensual nudity or morphed imagery. These are timelines for the platform, not a guarantee of how fast removal will happen in your case.

    Is promoting a fantasy or betting app allowed if I add a disclaimer?

    Not if the product is an online money game. The Online Gaming Act, 2025 prohibits advertising such games, and a disclaimer does not remove the prohibition.

    Can I be punished for a negative review?

    A truthful review stated fairly and in good faith is protected by the exceptions to defamation, but false or exaggerated claims can lead to civil and criminal action. Keep proof for every statement of fact.

    Where do I report a deepfake of myself?

    Use the platform’s reporting tool first and then the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal. Consult an advocate for police and court action in your case.

    This article is general information, not legal advice for a specific case, and the law can change or differ by state. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services. For your own situation, consult a qualified advocate or professional.

  • ChatGPT for Legal Research in India: Fake Citations and 7 Other Mistakes

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Using ChatGPT or a similar tool to start legal research is tempting: it is fast, fluent and it sounds sure of itself. In India, that confidence has already cost lawyers and even a trial court dearly. This guide sets out the mistakes that matter most when generative tools are used for legal work, and the correct position under Indian law and court practice as of the date above.

    The short version: these tools can help with structure, plain language summaries and first drafts, but they are not a source of law. Every authority must be found and read in its original form by a human who then signs for it.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI for Lawyers and Law Students, a self-paced certificate course on using AI tools in legal research and drafting, for lawyers and law students. Course price: Rs 499.

    Mistake 1: Citing a case the tool “found”

    Language tools predict plausible text. They do not look up judgments, so they can produce a case name, a court, a year and a neat holding for something that was never decided. This is not a theoretical risk in India. On 17 February 2026 a Supreme Court bench of the Chief Justice of India, Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice B.V. Nagarathna said that it had begun noticing pleadings that seemed to have been prepared with AI platforms without adequate human scrutiny, and Justice Nagarathna referred to a matter citing a precedent called “Mercy vs Mankind” that does not exist. The Chief Justice also said that in proceedings before another judge, the precedents cited had never existed, and that some filings quoted passages from real Supreme Court rulings that do not appear in them.

    In Gummadi Usha Rani v. Sure Mallikarjuna Rao (SLP (C) No. 7575 of 2026), a trial court had relied on four decisions the petitioners said were non-existent and AI generated. On 27 February 2026 the Supreme Court said that a decision based on such fake judgments is not an error in decision making, and that relying on them would be misconduct with legal consequences; it issued notice to the Attorney General, the Solicitor General and the Bar Council of India (BCI) and appointed a senior advocate as amicus curiae. At the hearing reported on 5 May 2026 the Court said that parties cannot rely on AI-generated material and then apologise, and asked the BCI to constitute a committee of experts to examine the issues. It also said it was not seeking to prohibit the use of AI.

    Mistake 2: Trusting a summary of a real case

    A tool may name a genuine case and still misstate it: the wrong bench strength, the wrong outcome, a passage that is not in the judgment, or a proposition the court actually rejected. Read the judgment. Look at who sat, the date, the question decided, the reasoning and the direction. If you intend to quote, copy the words from the judgment itself and give the paragraph number. A summary is a pointer to where to look, never the authority itself.

    Mistake 3: Using old or wrong law

    A tool trained mostly on older text may answer in terms of the Indian Penal Code, the Code of Criminal Procedure or the Evidence Act. Those were replaced from 1 July 2024 by the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) and the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA). Section numbers changed: for example, cheating is section 318 BNS, cheating by personation is section 319 BNS, and the privilege for professional communications with an advocate is section 132 BSA. Other laws have changed too, including the Labour Codes in force from 21 November 2025. Always check the current text of the statute on the India Code portal or the relevant Gazette, and check whether your authority was decided under the old or the new provision.

    Mistake 4: Pasting client material into a public tool

    Advocates owe clients confidentiality, and section 132 of the BSA bars an advocate from disclosing communications made in the course of professional engagement without the client’s express consent, subject to defined exceptions. In Re: Summoning Advocates who give legal opinion or represent parties during investigation (31 October 2025, 2025 INSC 1275) the Supreme Court held that this privilege covers litigation and non-litigious work, and that an investigating officer cannot directly summon an advocate to disclose case details unless an exception under section 132 applies. The same judgment noted that in-house counsel are not “advocates” under the Advocates Act, 1961 and so cannot claim the section 132 privilege, though they may receive some protection under section 134.

    None of this approves or forbids a particular tool. But sending a client’s confidential papers to an outside service is a disclosure that the client has not agreed to, and it may place privileged material outside your control. The safe practice is to use approved tools under written terms, remove names and identifiers, or use no tool at all for the most sensitive files.

    Mistake 5: Letting the tool do the judgment

    The tool can suggest arguments. It cannot weigh the facts of your case, the temperament of the bench or the client’s interests. The Kerala High Court’s policy on the use of AI tools in the district judiciary, issued on 19 July 2025, shows how courts themselves are drawing the line: such tools must not be used for decision making or legal reasoning or to arrive at findings, reliefs or orders, outputs including translations must be carefully checked, and cloud based tools such as ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot and Deepseek are to be avoided unless approved. That policy applies to Kerala’s district judges and their staff, not to advocates, but it is a useful statement of principle for anyone in the system.

    Mistake 6: Thinking there is no rule for lawyers

    There is no AI specific code for advocates yet, but there are rules in force. Professional misconduct under the Advocates Act, 1961 and the Bar Council of India Rules can reach an advocate who files fabricated authorities, whatever the source. The Bar Council of India has told Parliament, as reported in June 2026, that advocates who file AI-generated fake citations, fabricated quotations or non-existent judgments cannot escape professional liability by blaming technology. Courts may also impose costs, call for explanations or refer the matter to the Bar Council.

    Separately, a draft policy on AI use in courts was issued by the Supreme Court’s AI Committee on 3 June 2026 for public comment, with comments invited until 15 July 2026, and would be notified by High Courts if adopted. Check the current status and any High Court practice direction before you file.

    Mistake 7: Not telling the client, or billing as if the tool did not exist

    If a client has asked whether AI is used, or the engagement letter says nothing, be open. Explain what the tool is used for, that a lawyer reviews everything, and that confidential data is protected. Fees should reflect work actually done by you. Clients who find out later that unchecked output went to court will be less forgiving than clients who were told at the start.

    Mistake 8: Skipping the “is it still good law” check

    Even a real, correctly cited judgment may have been overruled, distinguished, or limited by a larger bench, or stayed in review. A language tool will not tell you reliably. Run the authority through a citator in a recognised law report database, read the later cases that cite it and check the date against any statutory change.

    A quick test before you rely on any output

    1. Can I open the judgment or the statute section on an authoritative source?
    2. Have I read the paragraph, not just the headnote or the tool’s summary?
    3. Is the quote verbatim, with a paragraph number?
    4. Was it decided under the old law or the new one?
    5. Is it still good law?
    6. Did I keep client confidences?

    If any answer is no, do not file it.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI for Lawyers and Law Students, a self-paced certificate course on using AI tools in legal research and drafting, for lawyers and law students. Course price: Rs 499.

    Frequently asked questions

    Has the Supreme Court banned the use of AI by lawyers?

    A: No. At the hearing reported on 5 May 2026 it said it was not seeking to prohibit the use of AI, but it made clear that parties cannot rely on AI-generated material and then apologise for errors.

    Can a lawyer be punished for citing a fake case generated by a tool?

    A: Citing a non-existent authority can amount to professional misconduct and can lead to costs and Bar Council proceedings. The Bar Council of India has said responsibility cannot be passed on to technology.

    Is a tool’s summary of a judgment safe to use if the case name is real?

    A: No. A real case name can be paired with a wrong or invented holding or quotation. Read the judgment and quote from it.

    Does privilege protect what I paste into a chatbot?

    A: Section 132 of the BSA protects confidential professional communications from compelled disclosure by the advocate, but a voluntary disclosure to a third party service can create its own risk. Use approved tools and anonymise.

    This article is general information, not legal, financial or tax advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services.

  • Common Excel Mistakes at Work and AI Myths: What Goes Wrong and the Correct Fix

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: Most spreadsheet disasters in an office come from a handful of habits: a lookup that quietly returns the wrong row, cleanup commands that delete data permanently, numbers that are really text, and a file that behaves differently on a colleague’s older version of Excel. Adding an AI assistant helps with drafting formulas and summaries, but it does not remove these risks and it adds new ones about accuracy, licences and confidential data. This guide goes through the common mistakes and myths, and gives the correct position for each, based on Microsoft’s own documentation.

    Build the habits behind clean spreadsheets. Excel and AI for Office Work (Rs 299) is a self-paced certificate course on using Excel, and AI tools alongside it, for everyday office tasks.

    Mistake 1: Leaving VLOOKUP on its default setting

    Microsoft’s documentation for VLOOKUP says that if you leave out the last argument, the function uses an approximate match (TRUE), and that this is the default method. With approximate matching the first column must be sorted, or the formula can return a wrong value without any error. A clerk who types =VLOOKUP(A2,Rates!A:C,3) may get a plausible but incorrect rate for an employee code that is not in the table.

    Correct position: add FALSE (or 0) as the fourth argument when you need an exact match, or use XLOOKUP, which returns exact matches by default, can look to the left of the key column, and lets you set a message to show when nothing is found. Test with a code that you know is missing and check that you see your message and not a nearby value.

    Mistake 2: Assuming XLOOKUP works on every computer

    Microsoft states that XLOOKUP is available in Excel for Microsoft 365, Excel 2024, Excel 2021 and the Excel apps for tablets and phones, and that it is not available in Excel 2016 and Excel 2019. A workbook built in a newer version may contain XLOOKUP formulas that an older version cannot calculate. In an office where some desks still run Excel 2019, that means errors on the colleague’s screen but not on yours.

    Correct position: before sharing a file with a department, ask what version people use. If anyone is on 2016 or 2019, use INDEX with MATCH, or VLOOKUP with FALSE, in the shared file.

    Mistake 3: Running Remove Duplicates on the only copy

    Microsoft warns that removing duplicates permanently deletes the duplicate values, unlike filtering, which only hides them. It also notes that matching is based on what is displayed, so the same date shown in two formats counts as two different values; that data is removed from all columns of a row, not only the column you checked; and that the first occurrence is kept. The advice is to copy the original range to another sheet or workbook first and to test with a filter for unique values.

    Correct position: keep an untouched raw sheet. Do your cleaning on a copy. If the result is wrong, Ctrl+Z may work immediately, but it will not help after you have saved, closed and mailed the file.

    Mistake 4: Trusting TRIM to clean all spaces

    TRIM removes extra spaces and leaves single spaces between words, but Microsoft’s page says it does not remove the non-breaking space (character 32 is the ordinary space; the non-breaking space is character 160) that often arrives when you copy from a web page or some software exports. A name that looks identical in two sheets will then fail to match in a lookup. The page shows TRIM combined with CLEAN, as in =TRIM(CLEAN(B5)), for general cleaning, though a column copied from a web page may still need the non-breaking space replaced separately.

    Correct position: when two values look equal and still do not match, compare their lengths with LEN. A difference tells you there is an invisible character.

    Mistake 5: Storing long identifiers as numbers

    Excel keeps 15 digits of precision for numbers, according to Microsoft’s specifications page. A 16 digit card or account number typed into a cell formatted as a number will have its last digit changed to zero. Codes with leading zeros, such as 00123, also lose the zeros when they are treated as numbers.

    Correct position: format the column as Text before typing or pasting identifiers, or import them as text. Never use such a column in calculations.

    Mistake 6: Building a PivotTable on messy source data

    Microsoft’s guidance says PivotTable source data should be clean, tabular and organised in columns, with a single header row of unique, non-blank labels, no double header rows and no merged cells, preferably formatted as an Excel table. It also says that after adding data to the source you must refresh the PivotTable, and that value fields default to Sum for numbers but to Count for text, so a column of numbers stored as text will be counted and not added.

    Correct position: fix the source first. If a total looks suspiciously like the number of rows, check whether the column holds text.

    Mistake 7: Mixing up SUMIF and SUMIFS arguments

    In SUMIFS the sum range comes first, then pairs of criteria ranges and criteria. In SUMIF the sum range comes third. Microsoft says every criteria range must have the same number of rows and columns as the sum range, and that a result of 0 often means text criteria were not enclosed in quotation marks.

    Correct position: check one total by hand. Filter the table to one region and one month and compare the filtered total with the formula result.

    Myth: “The AI assistant is built into every copy of Excel”

    Microsoft’s Copilot in Excel page says Copilot may not be included in your Microsoft 365 subscription and that your organisation’s settings may restrict it, so you should check your licence or ask your IT administrator. It works on Windows, Mac and the web in edit, chat and plan modes, while phones support chat mode only. If your office has no licence, the Copilot icon will not be there, however confidently a colleague describes it.

    Myth: “AI output in a spreadsheet is always right”

    Microsoft describes edit mode as the default mode in which Copilot can change your workbook directly, and says you can stop it at any time and that plan mode proposes an approach for you to confirm first. That is a design for supervision. A generated formula can be syntactically valid and still point at the wrong column. Treat anything an assistant writes as a draft from a trainee: ask it to explain the formula, test it on three rows you can calculate by hand, and only then fill it down.

    Myth: “Pasting client or employee data into any chatbot is harmless”

    It is not. Two points apply. First, tools differ in what they do with your data, and Microsoft’s own PivotTable page notes that its PivotTable recommendation feature uses AI services as part of its connected experiences and that, if you opt out of those experiences, the feature is unavailable. Read the privacy terms of every tool you use, and use only tools that your employer has approved. Second, India’s Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 and the DPDP Rules, 2025 were notified on 13 November 2025, with the main obligations on data fiduciaries phasing in until 12 May 2027, according to a law firm’s summary of the rollout. A payroll or customer sheet containing names, phone numbers and bank details is personal data. Remove or mask the personal columns before you use an outside tool, and follow your employer’s confidentiality rules, which apply today.

    Myth: “If I use AI, I do not need to learn formulas”

    An assistant is quickest for people who can already tell whether the answer is plausible. Knowing what a lookup, a SUMIFS and a PivotTable do lets you ask a precise question, spot an error and fix it. People who only paste results forward cannot defend their own report when a manager asks where a number came from.

    A short pre-send checklist

    1. Is the raw data saved on its own sheet?
    2. Do lookups use exact match, and did you test a missing key?
    3. Do totals agree with one figure calculated by hand?
    4. Are identifiers stored as text?
    5. Will everyone who opens the file have the functions you used?
    6. Did you remove personal data before using any outside tool?

    Practise these skills properly. Excel and AI for Office Work (Rs 299) is a self-paced certificate course on Excel and AI tools for office work, with a certificate on completion.

    Frequently asked questions

    Is XLOOKUP better than VLOOKUP?

    For most new work, yes: it matches exactly by default, can return values from columns to the left of the key and has a built in not-found message. VLOOKUP is still needed when you must share files with people on Excel 2016 or 2019, where XLOOKUP is not available.

    How many rows can an Excel sheet hold?

    Microsoft’s specifications give 1,048,576 rows and 16,384 columns per worksheet.

    Does Remove Duplicates have an undo after saving?

    Microsoft says deletion is permanent and advises copying the original data first. Ctrl+Z works only in the session where you ran it, so keep a backup copy.

    Can I use an AI assistant for confidential office data?

    Only with tools and settings approved by your employer, and with personal and client data removed or masked wherever possible. Check the tool’s privacy terms.

    Why does my lookup fail when the values look the same?

    Common causes are extra spaces, a non-breaking space that TRIM does not remove, numbers stored as text in one sheet and as numbers in the other, or an approximate match setting.

    This article is general information, not professional advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource. Laws, rates and procedures change, so check the current rule or consult a qualified professional before you act.

  • ChatGPT at Work in India: 8 Legal Mistakes Employees Make

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Using ChatGPT or a similar tool to draft an e-mail, summarise a report or write a formula is now routine in Indian offices. The mistakes that cause trouble are rarely dramatic. They are small habits: pasting a client’s contract into a public chatbot, forwarding an answer without checking it, using a generated picture of a real person. This guide goes through eight common mistakes and gives the correct position under Indian law as of the date above.

    One framing point first. India does not have a single AI statute. The Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology issued the India AI Governance Guidelines on 5 November 2025, which prefer voluntary measures and the use of existing laws over a new Act. That means the rules that already exist (the IT Act, 2000, the data protection law, copyright law, contracts and professional duties) apply to your use of AI tools today.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI at Work: Using ChatGPT and AI Tools Safely and Legally, a self-paced certificate course on using ChatGPT and other AI tools safely and legally at work. Course price: Rs 299.

    Mistake 1: Pasting confidential or personal data into a tool you have not checked

    This is the most common and the most costly mistake. Client contracts, salary sheets, medical details, unpublished results, source code and customer lists often carry a duty of confidence under an employment contract, a non-disclosure agreement or a professional rule. Typing them into an external tool is a disclosure to a third party, whatever the tool’s friendly interface suggests.

    The legal pressure points are these:

    • Contract. Most employment and client contracts forbid sharing confidential information without permission. Breach exposes you or your employer to a claim.
    • Section 72A, IT Act. Disclosing personal information obtained under a lawful contract, with intent to cause wrongful loss or wrongful gain, is punishable with imprisonment up to three years or a fine up to Rs 5 lakh, or both. Intent is the key element, so careless pasting is not automatically a crime, but it is the type of facts from which disputes start.
    • Section 43A, IT Act. A body corporate handling sensitive personal data must keep reasonable security practices, or it may be liable to pay compensation to the person affected. This section continues to apply until section 44(2) of the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023 comes into force on 13 May 2027.
    • DPDP Act, 2023 and Rules, 2025. From 13 May 2027 the main duties of a data fiduciary are scheduled to apply, including reasonable security safeguards and breach intimation. The Act makes the fiduciary responsible for processing done on its behalf, which will include data sent to a vendor’s tool. Penalties in the Act’s schedule go up to Rs 250 crore for failure to take reasonable security safeguards.

    The practical rule: use only tools your employer has approved, check the plan’s terms on whether your inputs are kept or used to improve the service, and mask names, numbers and identifiers when you are unsure.

    Mistake 2: Treating the answer as a verified fact

    Generative tools produce fluent text, not guaranteed truth. They can invent numbers, rules and even court decisions. The Indian courts have already reacted. On 17 February 2026 a Supreme Court bench led by the Chief Justice of India, Surya Kant, remarked that some pleadings appeared to have been drafted with AI platforms without adequate human scrutiny, and it noted a cited precedent (“Mercy vs Mankind”) that does not exist. In the case of Gummadi Usha Rani v. Sure Mallikarjuna Rao the Court said on 27 February 2026 that a decision relying on non-existent, fake judgments is not a mere error in decision making but could be treated as misconduct. The subject there was courts, but the lesson is general: whoever puts a result into a document or a decision answers for it.

    The correct habit is to treat AI output as a first draft by a fast, careless assistant. Check every figure against the source, every legal rule against the bare Act or a trusted database, and every quotation against the original.

    Mistake 3: Believing “there is no law on AI, so anything goes”

    There is no standalone law, but there are many applicable ones. Fake or misleading content can raise issues of cheating (sections 318 and 319 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023), identity theft or personation online (sections 66C and 66D, IT Act), and defamation. Data rules apply to personal data fed to a tool. Consumer protection law applies to misleading claims made to customers, whether a person or a tool wrote them. The 2025 MeitY guidelines also encourage organisations that deploy AI to set up accessible grievance redressal mechanisms.

    Mistake 4: Assuming you automatically own, and may freely use, whatever the tool produces

    Copyright law deals with this unevenly. Section 2(d)(vi) of the Copyright Act, 1957 says that for a computer-generated literary, dramatic, musical or artistic work the author is the person who causes the work to be created. How far that covers text or images produced by a generative tool from a short prompt is not settled by a court judgment in India. The Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT) released a working paper on generative AI and copyright on 8 December 2025 proposing a “hybrid model” for the use of copyrighted works in training; it is a consultation document, not law.

    So: do not assume exclusivity over generated material, do not claim a generated report as wholly your original work where your employer or client expects human authorship, and read the tool’s terms on ownership and permitted commercial use. Never feed in material you are not licensed to copy.

    Mistake 5: Making synthetic images, voices or videos of real people

    A generated photograph of a real person, a cloned voice or a “face swap” can be misleading or harmful even when made as a joke. Depending on the facts, it can fall under section 66E (violation of privacy, up to three years or fine up to Rs 2 lakh), section 66D (cheating by personation), the obscenity sections 67 and 67A, or defamation. The IT Rules were amended by a notification of 10 February 2026, effective 20 February 2026, to require that permitted synthetic content be prominently labelled and to shorten the time in which platforms must act on government or court orders to three hours. Those duties fall mainly on platforms, but a company that publishes unlabelled synthetic content invites a takedown and reputational damage. Get written consent from any real person whose likeness or voice you use.

    Mistake 6: Letting a tool decide about people

    Using software to rank candidates, flag “low performers” or set pay without a human reviewing the output carries two risks. First, errors or bias in the data can lead to unfair decisions that an employee can challenge under the employment contract and service law. Second, the personal data used must be handled in line with the data protection law once it applies. The safe course is to let the tool assist, require a named human to decide, keep a record of the reasons, and tell staff and applicants what the tool does.

    Mistake 7: Using personal accounts for office work

    When employees use private accounts of public tools, the employer has no record of what left the building and cannot prove compliance. The CERT-In directions of 28 April 2022 expect covered entities to retain logs of ICT systems for a rolling 180 days within India and to report listed incidents, including data leaks, within six hours of noticing them. A leak through a personal account is much harder to detect and reconstruct. A company approved route with an access list and logging is better than a ban that staff quietly ignore.

    Mistake 8: Not disclosing AI use where disclosure is expected

    Clients, universities, regulators and employers increasingly ask whether AI was used. If a contract, assignment rule or submission policy requires a declaration and you stay silent, the problem is no longer the tool but the omission. Where no rule exists, a short line such as “first draft prepared with an AI tool and reviewed by me” is often the honest and safe course. For lawyers and other licensed professionals the duty to verify is stricter: the Supreme Court has said parties cannot rely on AI-generated material and then simply apologise, and the Bar Council of India has told Parliament that advocates cannot escape liability by blaming technology.

    A short routine you can use tomorrow

    1. Classify what you are about to paste: public, internal, confidential or personal data.
    2. Check that the tool is approved for that class of information.
    3. Mask names and identifiers where possible.
    4. Verify each fact, number and citation before use.
    5. Record the tool and the checks in the file for important work.
    6. Disclose where a rule or client expects it.

    Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI at Work: Using ChatGPT and AI Tools Safely and Legally, a self-paced certificate course on using ChatGPT and other AI tools safely and legally at work. Course price: Rs 299.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can my employer legally ban ChatGPT at work?

    A: Yes. An employer can set reasonable instructions on which tools may be used and for what, and breach can lead to disciplinary action under the service rules or contract. A written policy makes the rule clear and fair.

    Is it illegal to use ChatGPT to write my assignment, report or article?

    A: There is no general statute against it. What matters is the rule of the institution or client, the duty to be honest about authorship, and copyright in any material the tool reproduces. Check the specific policy.

    Who is responsible if the AI tool gives wrong advice and my company relies on it?

    A: Generally the company that used the output and presented it to others, as the tool provider will usually limit its liability in its terms. Verification and human review are therefore your protection.

    Does the DPDP Act already apply to AI tools?

    A: The Act and Rules were notified in 2025, but the main obligations of data fiduciaries are scheduled to apply from 13 May 2027. Until then, the IT Act (including section 43A) and contractual duties govern, and it is sensible to prepare now.

    This article is general information, not legal, financial or tax advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services.