LLexfolio

Tag: related party transactions

  • Director Duties and Compliance Problems in India: Real Scenarios and What to Do

    Last updated: 12 November 2026

    Short answer: a director’s exposure depends on what the director knew, what the director did about it, and what the records show. The six scenarios below are illustrations invented to show how the Companies Act, 2013 treats common situations. Names and figures are made up.

    Read each as a pattern. The legal position is stated first, then the sensible next step. If your own facts are close to one of these, get advice before you act.

    Learn to handle these situations with a framework. The Lexfolio Corporate Governance, Compliance and Risk Management is a self-paced certificate course on corporate governance, compliance and risk management. Price: Rs 599.

    Illustration 1: Three years of silence

    Situation. Rhea joined a friend’s start-up as a director in 2022 and signed nothing after incorporation. The company never held an annual general meeting and never filed its financial statements or annual returns for three financial years. A notice from the Registrar arrives.

    Legal position. Section 164(2) disqualifies a person who is or was a director of a company that has not filed financial statements or annual returns for any continuous period of three financial years. The disqualification is for five years and covers appointment in other companies too. How it affects an existing directorship has been argued in commentary, so take advice on the date from which it runs and the consequences for your other boards.

    What to do. Establish exactly which years are overdue. Have the company file the pending financial statements and returns, with the additional fees. Check whether your DIN appears on the published list of disqualified directors. Pause signing any new filings until a company secretary or lawyer has confirmed your status.

    Illustration 2: The cousin’s supplier

    Situation. Karan, a director of a manufacturing company, wants the company to buy packaging from a firm run by his cousin. The price looks market competitive. He asks the other directors to approve it by a quick message.

    Legal position. Section 184 requires Karan to disclose his interest in the cousin’s firm to the board, and an interested director generally does not take part in discussion or vote on the contract. Section 188 requires board approval, and in some cases approval of the members, for specified related party contracts above the prescribed thresholds, unless a statutory exemption applies, such as transactions in the ordinary course of business at arm’s length. Whether a cousin’s firm is a related party depends on the definitions of relative and related party in the Act, so check these.

    What to do. Record Karan’s disclosure, have the independent or disinterested directors review the pricing against quotes from other suppliers, pass the approval at a meeting with Karan out of the discussion, and keep the comparison in the file.

    Illustration 3: The anonymous complaint

    Situation. An employee of a mid sized company writes to the chairman alleging that purchase invoices are being inflated. The writer asks that the name be kept confidential.

    Legal position. Section 177(9) requires a vigil mechanism for listed companies, for companies that accept deposits from the public and for companies that have borrowed money from banks and public financial institutions in excess of Rs 50 crore. Where it applies, the mechanism must give adequate safeguards against victimisation and allow direct access to the chairperson of the audit committee in appropriate cases. A company that is outside those classes still has to deal with the allegation, because an inflated invoice can be a misstatement in the accounts.

    What to do. Acknowledge the complaint, restrict the circle of people who know the name, give the investigation to someone independent of the department concerned, preserve the documents, and record the outcome in a note to the board.

    Illustration 4: Minutes written a year later

    Situation. A lender asks for a certified board resolution approving a loan taken eleven months ago. No such resolution exists. A senior manager suggests preparing minutes now, bearing the earlier date.

    Legal position. A resolution that was not passed cannot be created later with an old date. Creating backdated records can amount to making a false statement or document, and the Act punishes fraud and false statements in the course of its provisions, including sections 447 and 448. The correct route is to put the matter before the board now and ratify the borrowing, recording honestly that the decision is being ratified on the new date and why.

    What to do. Call a meeting with proper notice, place the loan terms and the explanation before the directors, and ratify with the actual date. Tell the lender the true position if asked. Ask whether any statutory filing about the borrowing was missed and file it with additional fees.

    Illustration 5: The auditor’s fraud report

    Situation. During the audit, the statutory auditor finds that a store manager has diverted goods worth about Rs 40 lakh over a year.

    Legal position. Section 143(12) requires an auditor who has reason to believe that an offence involving fraud is being or has been committed against the company by officers or employees to report it. Under the rules made under the section, where the amount involved is Rs 1 crore or more the report goes to the Central Government after informing the board, and for smaller amounts the report goes to the audit committee or the board, and the matter must be disclosed in the board’s report. The amount here is below Rs 1 crore, so the route is to the board or audit committee.

    What to do. Convene the board, take the report on record, give the auditor a reasoned reply within the rule’s time limit, act against the employee through a proper inquiry, and disclose the details in the board’s report as the rules require. The board should not pressure the auditor to drop the matter.

    Illustration 6: A deactivated DIN

    Situation. Meera, a director of two companies, learns that a bank refuses her signature on a form because her DIN shows as deactivated for non filing of KYC.

    Legal position. Director KYC rules changed with effect from 31 March 2026. Routine KYC is now filed once after every three consecutive financial years through the consolidated form DIR-3-KYC-Web, by 30 June of the following financial year, and the form is also used for DIN reactivation. Some cases, such as reactivation, need a certification by a chartered accountant, cost accountant or company secretary. Check which window applies to your DIN, because the transition from the old annual cycle can produce confusion.

    What to do. File the form, pay any fee applicable for reactivation, update the company records, and re-file any document that was rejected because of the status. Set a reminder for the next window and for the 30 day duty to report a change in mobile, e-mail or residential address.

    Illustration 7: The meeting that never happened

    Situation. A company’s last board meeting was in January. It is now September and no meeting has been held. The directors assume that an annual general meeting in September will count.

    Legal position. An annual general meeting is a meeting of members, not of the board. Section 173 requires board meetings at least four times a year with no more than 120 days between two consecutive meetings, unless the company falls in a relaxed category such as a small company, one person company, dormant company or start-up private company, which must meet once in each half of the calendar year with a gap of at least 90 days.

    What to do. Hold a board meeting at once, record the lapse candidly, and fix the calendar for the remaining months. Check whether the company is eligible for the relaxed pattern and document the basis.

    What the illustrations have in common

    • Each problem became serious because nobody acted when the first sign appeared.
    • Each can be solved through honest records: disclosure, a meeting, a filing with fees, or a ratification dated truthfully.
    • A director’s best protection is a paper trail showing questions asked and decisions taken with care.

    Turn these patterns into a working governance routine. The Lexfolio Corporate Governance, Compliance and Risk Management is a self-paced certificate course on corporate governance, compliance and risk management. Price: Rs 599.

    Frequently asked questions

    Is a director personally liable for a company’s debts?

    Generally no. A company is a separate legal person and its debts are its own. Personal liability arises where the Act says so, for example for fraud under section 447, for acts done with consent or connivance, for specific defaults as an officer in default, or where a director gave a personal guarantee.

    What is an officer in default?

    Section 2(60) lists the persons who are treated as officers in default for the purposes of penalties, including whole time directors, key managerial personnel and, where there are none, directors specified by the board. It also reaches a director who knew of the default through board proceedings and did not object, or who consented or connived.

    Can a disqualified director continue to sign filings?

    A person disqualified under section 164 should not act as a director or sign documents as one. The Ministry of Corporate Affairs publishes lists of disqualified directors. Take advice immediately if you find your DIN on such a list.

    Do I need a vigil mechanism in a small private company?

    The Act makes it mandatory for listed companies, for companies accepting deposits from the public and for companies with borrowings from banks and public financial institutions above the prescribed limit. A company outside those classes is not required to have one but a simple written process to receive complaints is good practice.

    When should a director seek independent legal advice?

    When a decision may expose the director to a personal claim, when the board is divided, when a regulator has issued a notice, or when a record seems to have been altered. The company’s lawyer acts for the company, not for each director.

    The scenarios are invented illustrations, not reports of real cases, and every real situation turns on its own facts. This article is general information, not legal or professional advice for a specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource.