Last updated: 12 November 2026
“Is it legal?” is the question people ask after they have already used the tool. This guide runs through six everyday workplace situations involving ChatGPT and similar tools, and gives for each the legal position in India and the safer way to proceed. Every person and fact below is an invented illustration, written to show how the rules apply; none is a real case.
Keep in mind that India has no stand-alone AI statute. The India AI Governance Guidelines issued by the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology on 5 November 2025 prefer voluntary measures and the application of existing laws, so each answer below comes from those existing laws: contracts, the Information Technology Act, 2000 (IT Act), the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), copyright law and the data protection law as it is being phased in.
Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI at Work: Using ChatGPT and AI Tools Safely and Legally, a self-paced certificate course on using ChatGPT and other AI tools safely and legally at work. Course price: Rs 299.
Illustration 1: The contract pasted into a chatbot
Facts (illustration): A junior associate at a consulting firm pastes a client’s draft supply agreement, marked confidential, into a public chatbot to “get a quick summary”.
Legal position. The client’s agreement and the associate’s employment terms almost certainly contain confidentiality clauses, and sending the text to an outside service is a disclosure to a third party. Breach can lead to a contractual claim against the firm and disciplinary action against the employee. Section 72A of the IT Act punishes disclosure of personal information obtained under a lawful contract with intent to cause wrongful loss or gain (up to three years or a fine up to Rs 5 lakh, or both), but intent is needed, so the usual consequences are contractual and professional. If the agreement included personal data of the client’s staff, section 43A and, from 13 May 2027, the data protection law’s safeguards come into play.
What to do. Tell the supervisor at once. Check the tool’s terms on storage and training use, delete the conversation if the settings allow, and record what happened. If the client’s contract requires notice of a possible leak, give it. In future use an approved tool or summarise by hand with names removed.
Illustration 2: The market report with statistics that do not exist
Facts (illustration): An analyst asks a chatbot for “market size data” for a proposal. The answer includes a precise percentage growth figure and a named industry report. The analyst puts both in a client proposal without checking.
Legal position. Generative tools can produce confident but false numbers and sources. If a client relies on a false statement made carelessly or knowingly in a proposal, the firm can face a claim under the contract or in tort, and a knowingly false statement made to obtain business could raise questions of cheating (section 318 BNS). The Supreme Court’s remarks on 17 February 2026 about a cited case that does not exist, and its order of 27 February 2026 in Gummadi Usha Rani v. Sure Mallikarjuna Rao, show that Indian courts regard unverified output as a failure of professional diligence, not a technical glitch.
What to do. Withdraw or correct the proposal as soon as the error is found, and tell the client. Trace each figure to a source you can open. Add a rule that statistics and citations in client documents need a named reviewer.
Illustration 3: The resume screening tool
Facts (illustration): A recruiter uses a tool that scores resumes and automatically rejects those below a cut-off. A candidate asks why she was rejected and suspects the tool penalised a career break.
Legal position. There is no Indian statute specifically on automated hiring tools. Private sector employers have wide freedom in hiring, but constitutional equality norms bind state employers and public bodies, and a decision that is arbitrary or based on irrelevant factors invites challenge and reputational harm. The candidate’s personal data in the resume must be handled lawfully: from 13 May 2027 the data protection law will require, among other things, reasonable security safeguards and notice-based processing. The 2025 governance guidelines also encourage deployers of AI to maintain a grievance redressal route.
What to do. Treat the tool’s score as an input. Let a human review rejections, keep reasons on record and test the tool on past hiring to see whether it screens out a group unfairly. Tell applicants that a tool is used and give a contact for questions.
Illustration 4: The meeting note taker on a client call
Facts (illustration): A project manager adds an automatic note taking bot to a video call with a client, without telling the client. The bot stores a transcript on the vendor’s servers.
Legal position. India has no single statute that sets out in one place when a participant may record a call to which they are a party, so the answer is found in the contract, the client’s confidentiality terms and general privacy and data rules. A transcript may contain personal data and trade secrets, and storing it on a vendor’s servers is a disclosure to a processor. Secretly recording a client can also destroy trust even where no law is broken. From 13 May 2027, personal data in the transcript will fall under the data protection duties.
What to do. Announce the bot at the start of the call and get a clear yes. Use only an approved vendor, set a retention period, restrict who can see transcripts and delete them on schedule.
Illustration 5: The advertisement image that looks like a real person
Facts (illustration): A small brand uses a generated image of a woman who strongly resembles a well known actor to advertise a skin cream, and posts it on social media without a label.
Legal position. Using a person’s look or voice to suggest endorsement can mislead consumers and may give the person a claim for misuse of personality, passing off or defamation, depending on the facts. The IT Rules were amended by a notification dated 10 February 2026, effective 20 February 2026, requiring permitted synthetic content to be prominently labelled and providing for faster platform action, so an unlabelled synthetic ad risks takedown. Consumer protection law also deals with misleading advertisements. Do not assume that because a picture was “made by a tool” no one’s rights are touched.
What to do. Use images of real, consenting people with written releases, or of clearly fictional persons, and label synthetic content. Remove the post if the person objects and keep a record of the removal.
Illustration 6: The voice that sounded like the director
Facts (illustration): The accounts manager of a mid sized company gets a phone call from a voice that sounds exactly like the managing director, instructing an urgent transfer of Rs 5 lakh to a vendor “for a confidential deal”. The money is sent. It later emerges that the voice was cloned.
Legal position. Obtaining money by pretending to be someone else is cheating by personation (section 319 BNS) and, when a computer resource is used, section 66D of the IT Act (up to three years and a fine up to Rs 1 lakh). Because the company’s own officer authorised the transfer, the Reserve Bank of India’s 2017 circular on customer liability for unauthorised transactions is unlikely to help much, which makes speed of reporting more important.
What to do. Call the bank at once, report on cybercrime.gov.in or the helpline 1930 and file a police complaint. A compromised e-mail or account is a listed incident for CERT-In, to be reported within six hours of noticing. Afterwards adopt a call back rule for any payment instruction: verify using a number from your own records, and require two approvers above a set amount.
What the six situations have in common
Each problem began with a tool being used faster than the rules around it. The fixes are modest: approved tools, information classes, a named human reviewer, labelling and consent for synthetic content, and a plain way to report incidents.
Learn this properly. Lexfolio offers AI at Work: Using ChatGPT and AI Tools Safely and Legally, a self-paced certificate course on using ChatGPT and other AI tools safely and legally at work. Course price: Rs 299.
Frequently asked questions
Is it a crime to use ChatGPT at work?
A: No. Using a tool is not an offence. Liability arises from what is done with it, such as disclosing confidential data in breach of contract, cheating or impersonating someone.
Can a company be sued for something an employee generated with a chatbot?
A: Yes, in the same way as for any employee’s work, depending on the facts and on whether the employee acted within the scope of the job. A clear policy and training help the employer.
Do I have to label content made with these tools?
A: There is no blanket duty on every individual. The amended IT Rules require permitted synthetic content on covered platforms to be labelled, and contracts, clients and institutions may have their own disclosure rules. Labelling is the safe habit.
What should a company do first if it suspects a leak through an AI tool?
A: Stop further use, preserve logs and chats, tell the person in charge of security or legal, and check whether the incident is of a type that must be reported to CERT-In or to the client under contract.
This article is general information, not legal, financial or tax advice for any specific case. Lexfolio is a learning resource and does not provide legal services.
Useful books for this topic
- Bare acts of the new criminal laws (BNS, BNSS, BSA)
- Code of Civil Procedure bare act
- Legal drafting and conveyancing books
- Constitution of India (coat pocket edition)
As an Amazon Associate, Lexfolio earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are shown on Amazon.
Learn this properly, with a certificate. Police and FIRs, consumer and bank fraud complaints, property, wills and inheritance, work rights, family law, cyber fraud and RTI, in plain English. Certificate Course in Everyday Law for Every Indian, ₹349: self-paced lessons, module quizzes and a final test; pass at 60% for a verifiable Lexfolio certificate.
Leave a Reply