B.A. LL.B. (Third Year)
By Atharv Kumar Suneri, B.A. LL.B. (3rd Year)
The Problem
Imagine two accused persons charged under the same provision, in comparable circumstances and with a similar risk of absconding. The court grants both of them bail on a monetary condition. The first can afford the amount and walks out. The second cannot, and stays in custody. The law treated them alike on paper, yet only one of them is free, and the only difference between them is money.
This article asks whether that outcome is consistent with the Constitution, what the Supreme Court has said about it, and whether courts should assess a person’s ability to pay before fixing monetary bail conditions.
When a Bail Order Does Not Secure Liberty
A person may receive a bail order and still remain in jail if they cannot meet its conditions. The harm does not stop with the accused. Their family loses support, a job may be lost, and dependants suffer, all because of the accused’s financial position rather than anything the court found about the case. The problem is therefore wider than it first appears, and it has to be seen in the light of both practical realities and the legal purpose of bail.
The Constitutional Principles
Article 14 guarantees equality before the law and the equal protection of the laws. When two similarly placed accused persons are treated differently in practice only because one can pay and the other cannot, the equal protection of the law is weakened. Courts should therefore consider the circumstances of each accused so that monetary conditions are not excessive or unfair.
Article 21 protects life and personal liberty, which can be taken away only according to procedure established by law. When an accused who has been granted bail remains in custody only because they cannot afford the condition, a serious question of personal liberty arises. The court should ask whether the condition is justified, proportionate and consistent with the law, and the accused’s financial inability should not be ignored in that assessment.
In Hussainara Khatoon v. Home Secretary, State of Bihar, the Supreme Court highlighted the plight of undertrial prisoners kept in jail for long periods and recognised speedy trial as part of Article 21.[1] A bail condition that a poor accused cannot meet creates exactly the kind of avoidable detention the Court warned against.
Moti Ram: The Importance of Individual Circumstances
In Moti Ram v. State of Madhya Pradesh, the Supreme Court criticised the practice of fixing bail amounts and sureties without regard to the accused’s means, and stressed that bail conditions must be fair to the person who has to meet them.[2] The case shows that granting bail is not the end of the court’s task. The court must also ask whether the accused is actually capable of meeting the condition imposed.
Moti Ram does not hold that monetary conditions are unlawful in themselves. Its point is that the court should decide them after considering whether the person can realistically comply. This is an individualised approach to bail.
What the BNSS Says
Section 484 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (earlier Section 440 CrPC) requires the amount of every bond to be fixed with due regard to the circumstances of the case and provides that it shall not be excessive.[3] Read with Moti Ram, this supports careful scrutiny of conditions that are practically impossible for a particular accused to meet.
The legal position will still depend on the type of case. Financial circumstances cannot override statutory restrictions on bail in serious offences or under special laws. But within the framework that applies, the court can ask whether a monetary condition is really needed, or whether a less burdensome alternative would achieve the same legitimate purpose.
The Supreme Court has also acted on this problem directly. In In Re Policy Strategy for Grant of Bail, it directed that if an accused is not released within seven days of a bail order, the jail superintendent must inform the District Legal Services Authority, and that if bail bonds are not furnished within one month, the court may on its own consider whether the conditions need to be modified or relaxed.[4]
Why Ability to Pay Should Matter
Assessing ability to pay does not mean that the court must grant bail to everyone. It means checking whether the person can actually meet the condition imposed. In practice, a court fixing monetary conditions could ask:
- What is the purpose of the condition in this case, and is a monetary condition necessary to achieve it?
- How serious is the alleged offence, what does the statute require, and what is the risk of the accused absconding or influencing witnesses?
- Is there a less burdensome alternative, such as a lower amount, a personal bond or other non-monetary conditions?
- Can this accused realistically pay what is being asked?
These questions cannot guarantee any particular result, but they ensure that financial capacity is treated as a relevant consideration rather than ignored.
The Need for Reasoned Decisions
At present, outcomes vary from court to court, and there is no uniform approach to accused persons who cannot meet monetary conditions. One useful reform would be for courts to record, briefly, why a particular amount was fixed and whether the accused’s means were considered. This would make decisions more consistent and easier to review.
Any inquiry into means should be fair and not intrusive, so that it does not become another burden on poor families. And it must sit alongside the seriousness of the offence and the requirements of any special law: financial capacity should inform the decision where relevant, not replace the other conditions the law requires.
Making the Right to Bail Meaningful
There is a real difference between obtaining a bail order and actually being released. If a person cannot pay, the order does not give them liberty. The reasoning in Moti Ram asks courts to close that gap by making decisions that are genuine and proportionate to the circumstances of each case.
The answer is not to grant bail to everyone who cannot pay. It is to assess each case carefully, so that the conditions imposed serve a legitimate purpose and are proportionate. Personal liberty should not depend on a person’s bank balance when a reasonable and lawful alternative can achieve the same purpose.
Sources
- [1] Hussainara Khatoon v. Home Secretary, State of Bihar, (1980) 1 SCC 81.
- [2] Moti Ram v. State of Madhya Pradesh, (1978) 4 SCC 47.
- [3] Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, s. 484 (earlier s. 440 CrPC).
- [4] In Re Policy Strategy for Grant of Bail, SMWP (Crl.) No. 4 of 2021, order dated 31 January 2023 (Supreme Court of India).
About the author
Atharv Kumar Suneri is a third-year B.A. LL.B. student with academic interests in constitutional law, criminal justice and access to justice.
How to cite this article (OSCOLA)
Atharv Kumar Suneri, ‘When Poverty Becomes a Barrier to Bail: Should Courts Assess an Accused’s Ability to Pay?’ (Lexfolio, 12 November 2026) <https://lexfolio.in/when-poverty-becomes-a-barrier-to-bail-should-courts-assess-an-accuseds-ability-to-pay/>
Certificate of Contribution
Issued to Atharv Kumar Suneri · No. LX-GA-2026-C83T3 · Verify
© 2026 Atharv Kumar Suneri. Published by Lexfolio with the author’s permission; the author retains copyright. This article was substantially edited by the Lexfolio Editorial Team for language and legal accuracy. The views expressed are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect those of Lexfolio. This article is for information and education and is not legal advice. Want to contribute? Write for Lexfolio.
Useful books for this topic
- Bare acts of the new criminal laws (BNS, BNSS, BSA)
- Code of Civil Procedure bare act
- Legal drafting and conveyancing books
- Constitution of India (coat pocket edition)
As an Amazon Associate, Lexfolio earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are shown on Amazon.
Learn this properly, with a certificate. Section-by-section changes from IPC, CrPC and the Evidence Act, with conversion drills. Certificate Course on the New Criminal Laws: BNS, BNSS and BSA, ₹499: self-paced lessons, module quizzes and a final test; pass at 60% for a verifiable Lexfolio certificate.
Want the complete picture? Everyday Law for Every Indian, ₹349 covers all areas of daily life. See all Lexfolio certificate courses
Leave a Reply