LLexfolio

Category: LL.B. Notes

Subject-wise notes and exam guides for LL.B. students: contracts, torts, constitution, BNS and more.

  • Law of Torts and Consumer Protection Notes for LLB Students

    Tort law in India is largely judge-made (uncodified), supplemented by statute for consumer protection. These notes cover the core doctrines examined in LL.B. courses.

    General Defences to Tort

    Volenti non fit injuria (consent), necessity, plaintiff’s own default (contributory negligence), act of God (vis major), inevitable accident, private defence, and statutory authority are the recognised general defences.

    Negligence

    Negligence requires: a duty of care owed by the defendant to the plaintiff, breach of that duty (judged by the “reasonable man” standard), and damage caused by the breach that is not too remote. Donoghue v. Stevenson (1932) established the modern “neighbour principle” of duty of care, widely followed in Indian tort reasoning.

    Strict and Absolute Liability

    Rylands v. Fletcher (1868) established strict liability for the escape of a dangerous thing brought onto land for non-natural use, subject to exceptions (act of God, plaintiff’s default, consent). The Supreme Court in M.C. Mehta v. Union of India (1987, the Oleum Gas Leak case) went further, holding that enterprises engaged in hazardous activity owe an “absolute” liability with no exceptions, applicable to industries handling hazardous substances in India.

    Defamation

    Libel (written/permanent) and slander (spoken/transient) both exist as civil wrongs in India (unlike some common law jurisdictions that have abolished the distinction); defences include truth (justification), fair comment, and privilege (absolute and qualified).

    Consumer Protection Act, 2019

    The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 (replacing the 1986 Act) created a three-tier redressal system: District Commission (claims up to Rs 50 lakh under the amended pecuniary jurisdiction), State Commission, and National Commission, plus Consumer Mediation Cells and the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) to curb unfair trade practices and misleading advertisements. The Act also covers e-commerce transactions and product liability (Sections 82-87) for the first time.

    Key exam questions to prepare

    • Essentials of negligence as a tort, with case law.
    • Distinguish strict liability (Rylands v. Fletcher) from absolute liability (M.C. Mehta).
    • Structure of consumer redressal under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.

    More: all LL.B. subject notes

  • Family Law Notes for LLB Students (Hindu and Muslim Law Basics)

    Family Law in Indian LL.B. courses is taught as personal law, separate codes govern Hindus, Muslims, Christians and Parsis. These notes cover the Hindu law and Muslim law portions most commonly examined.

    Hindu Law: The Four Codification Acts of 1955-56

    The Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (marriage, divorce, judicial separation, restitution of conjugal rights under Sections 5, 13, 10, 9 respectively); the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (amended 2005 to give daughters equal coparcenary rights in Mitakshara joint family property); the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956; and the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 together codify Hindu personal law for the purposes of these Acts (defined broadly in Section 2 of each to include Sikhs, Jains and Buddhists, and anyone not Muslim, Christian, Parsi or Jewish by religion).

    Grounds for Divorce under Section 13, Hindu Marriage Act

    Adultery, cruelty, desertion for two years, conversion, unsoundness of mind, virulent leprosy (omitted in 2019), venereal disease, renunciation, and presumption of death (seven years) are fault grounds; Section 13-B provides divorce by mutual consent after one year’s statutory separation.

    Muslim Law: Marriage (Nikah) and Divorce

    Marriage under Muslim law is a civil contract requiring offer (ijab), acceptance (qubul), and mahr (dower). Divorce routes include talaq (now subject to the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Act, 2019, which criminalises instant triple talaq/talaq-e-biddat), khula (wife-initiated), mubarat (mutual), and judicial divorce under the Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act, 1939.

    Maintenance

    Section 125, CrPC (now Section 144, BNSS) provides a secular, religion-neutral maintenance remedy available to any wife (including a divorced Muslim wife per Mohd. Ahmed Khan v. Shah Bano Begum, 1985, and the subsequent Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986 as interpreted in Danial Latifi, 2001) alongside the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act and the Muslim Women Act.

    Key exam questions to prepare

    • Grounds for divorce under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
    • Essentials of a valid Muslim marriage (nikah).
    • Maintenance rights of a divorced Muslim woman after Shah Bano and the 1986 Act.

    More: all LL.B. subject notes

  • Constitutional Law Notes for LLB 1st Year Students

    Constitutional Law I covers the framework, fundamental rights and organs of the Indian Constitution. These notes map the core topics for 1st year LL.B. students.

    Preamble and Basic Structure

    The Preamble declares India a “Sovereign Socialist Secular Democratic Republic” (the words “Socialist” and “Secular” added by the 42nd Amendment, 1976). Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973) established the Basic Structure doctrine: Parliament’s constituent power under Article 368 cannot alter the Constitution’s basic structure, even by amendment.

    Fundamental Rights (Part III)

    Article 14 (equality before law and equal protection of laws), Articles 19(1)(a)-(g) (six freedoms, subject to reasonable restrictions under 19(2)-(6)), Article 21 (protection of life and personal liberty, read expansively post-Maneka Gandhi to include the right to live with dignity, privacy (K.S. Puttaswamy, 2017), and a range of unenumerated rights), and Articles 25-28 (freedom of religion) form the core of the fundamental rights examination.

    Directive Principles (Part IV) and Fundamental Duties (Part IVA)

    Article 37 makes DPSPs non-justiciable but “fundamental in the governance of the country.” Article 51A lists eleven fundamental duties added by the 42nd Amendment (1976) and the 86th Amendment (2002, duty regarding child education).

    Writ Jurisdiction

    Article 32 (Supreme Court) and Article 226 (High Courts) empower courts to issue five writs, habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, certiorari, and quo warranto, for enforcement of fundamental rights (and, under Article 226, for “any other purpose” as well, giving High Courts wider writ jurisdiction than the Supreme Court).

    Union and State Executive

    Article 74 makes the President bound by the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers headed by the Prime Minister; Article 163 creates a parallel structure for Governors and state Councils of Ministers.

    Key exam questions to prepare

    • Explain the Basic Structure doctrine with reference to Kesavananda Bharati.
    • Scope of Article 21 after Maneka Gandhi and Puttaswamy.
    • Difference between Article 32 and Article 226 writ jurisdiction.

    More: all LL.B. subject notes

  • Law of Contract Notes for LLB Students (Indian Contract Act, 1872)

    Contract law is the first substantive-law paper most LL.B. students encounter. These notes track the structure of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 as taught across Indian law schools.

    Essentials of a Valid Contract (Section 10)

    A contract requires: offer and acceptance (Sections 2(a)-2(b)), lawful consideration (Section 2(d), 25), capacity to contract (Section 11, not a minor, of sound mind, not disqualified by law), free consent (Sections 13-22), and a lawful object (Section 23). Mohori Bibee v. Dharmodas Ghose (1903) remains the leading authority that an agreement with a minor is void ab initio, not merely voidable.

    Offer and Acceptance

    An offer (Section 2(a)) must be communicated and capable of creating legal relations; an invitation to treat (shop displays, advertisements) is not an offer. Acceptance (Section 2(b)) must be absolute and unqualified and communicated to the offeror, the postal rule under Section 4 makes acceptance complete against the offeror when the letter is posted.

    Free Consent

    Consent is not free when caused by coercion (Section 15), undue influence (Section 16), fraud (Section 17), misrepresentation (Section 18), or mistake (Sections 20-22). Contracts caused by coercion, undue influence, fraud or misrepresentation are voidable at the option of the aggrieved party (Section 19); mistake of fact by both parties as to an essential matter renders the agreement void (Section 20).

    Void Agreements

    Sections 24-30 list agreements void for unlawful consideration/object, agreements in restraint of marriage (Section 26), trade (Section 27), and legal proceedings (Section 28), agreements uncertain in meaning (Section 29), and wagering agreements (Section 30).

    Discharge and Breach of Contract

    Contracts discharge by performance, agreement, impossibility (Section 56, doctrine of frustration), or breach. Remedies for breach include damages (Sections 73-75, compensatory not penal in nature per Hadley v. Baxendale principles as applied in India), specific performance, and injunction under the Specific Relief Act, 1963 (amended 2018).

    Key exam questions to prepare

    • Essentials of a valid contract under Section 10.
    • Distinguish void, voidable and illegal agreements with case law.
    • Doctrine of frustration under Section 56 with examples.

    More: all LL.B. subject notes

  • Indian Legal System Notes for LLB Students

    The Indian Legal System paper introduces the structure, sources and institutions of law in India, essential foundational reading for 1st year LL.B. students.

    Sources of Indian Law

    India follows a common law system inherited from British colonial administration, layered over indigenous Hindu and Muslim personal law traditions. The primary sources are: the Constitution of India (1950), parliamentary and state legislation, subordinate/delegated legislation, judicial precedent, and custom.

    Court Hierarchy

    India has a unified, integrated judiciary: the Supreme Court of India sits at the apex (Article 124), below it 25 High Courts (Article 214) each with territorial jurisdiction over one or more states/UTs, and below that the subordinate civil and criminal courts (District Courts, Sessions Courts, Magistrate Courts) governed by the Code of Civil Procedure and the Code of Criminal Procedure (now BNSS).

    Doctrine of Precedent

    Article 141 makes Supreme Court decisions binding on all courts within India. High Court decisions bind subordinate courts within their own territorial jurisdiction but are only persuasive on other High Courts. “Ratio decidendi” (the binding reasoning) is distinguished from “obiter dicta” (incidental observations, not binding).

    Legal Profession and the Advocates Act, 1961

    The Bar Council of India (BCI) regulates legal education and the legal profession under the Advocates Act, 1961. State Bar Councils enrol advocates; a practitioner must clear the All India Bar Examination (AIBE) after enrolment to receive a Certificate of Practice.

    Alternative Dispute Resolution

    Section 89, CPC empowers courts to refer disputes to arbitration, conciliation, mediation or Lok Adalat. The Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (amended 2015, 2019) governs arbitration in India; the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 establishes Lok Adalats for compromise settlement of pending and pre-litigation disputes.

    Key exam questions to prepare

    • Explain the hierarchy of courts in India with their jurisdiction.
    • What is the doctrine of precedent and how does Article 141 operate?
    • Role of the Bar Council of India in legal education.

    More: all LL.B. subject notes

  • Jurisprudence Notes for LLB 1st Year Students

    Jurisprudence is the theory of law, it asks what law is, where it comes from, and how it relates to morality and society. These notes cover the core schools of jurisprudential thought examined in Indian LL.B. courses.

    Natural Law School

    Natural law theorists (Aristotle, Aquinas, Grotius) argue that law derives its validity from universal moral principles, not merely from the command of a sovereign. An unjust law, on this view, is not truly “law” at all (“lex injusta non est lex”). In Indian constitutional jurisprudence, natural law reasoning surfaces in the Supreme Court’s treatment of Article 21 as embodying substantive due process after Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (1978).

    Analytical Positivism (Austin, Hart, Kelsen)

    John Austin’s command theory defines law as the command of a sovereign backed by sanction. H.L.A. Hart refined this with the “rule of recognition”, a master rule by which a legal system identifies valid laws, distinguishing primary rules (duties) from secondary rules (rules about rules). Hans Kelsen’s Pure Theory of Law proposes a “grundnorm” (basic norm) as the hypothetical foundation validating the entire legal hierarchy below it.

    Historical and Sociological Schools

    Savigny’s historical school holds that law emerges from the customs and spirit (“Volksgeist”) of a people rather than from legislative fiat. The sociological school (Roscoe Pound’s “social engineering”) treats law as a tool for balancing competing interests in society, individual, public and social interests.

    Legal Realism

    American realists (Holmes, Llewellyn) focused on what courts actually do rather than what rules say, “law is what the judges say it is.” This is useful for understanding judicial discretion and precedent-setting in Indian case law.

    Sources of Law in India

    Legislation, precedent (stare decisis under Article 141), and custom remain the three primary sources recognised in Indian jurisprudence, with the Constitution as the grundnorm of the Indian legal system.

    Key exam questions to prepare

    • Distinguish Austin’s command theory from Hart’s rule of recognition.
    • Critically examine Kelsen’s Pure Theory of Law.
    • Natural law vs legal positivism, which better explains Indian constitutional interpretation?

    More: all LL.B. subject notes · certificate courses for law students

  • First-Year LL.B. Guide: What to Expect in Your First Year of Law

    First-year LL.B. students, whether in a 3-year or 5-year course, usually meet foundational subjects such as constitutional law basics, contract, torts and legal methods, though the exact syllabus varies by university. The real challenge is not the subjects but the new skills: reading a bare act, reading a full judgment, briefing a case and writing with citations. You also need to understand attendance rules, plan internships required by the Bar Council of India, and try a moot early.

    PointPosition
    Common first-year subjectsConstitutional law basics, contract, torts, legal methods (varies by university)
    5-year course first yearOften more humanities or commerce or science subjects alongside law
    Core skills to buildReading bare acts and judgments, case briefing, citation
    InternshipsRequired under BCI’s Legal Education Rules 2008; commonly stated as 20 weeks (5-year) and 12 weeks (3-year) across the course
    AttendanceMinimum attendance rules apply under BCI rules and your university’s regulations; check your college’s notice
    MootsTry an intra-college moot in first year
    Right to practiseOnly after the degree and enrolment with a State Bar Council (Advocates Act 1961)

    What you will study in first year

    Syllabi differ between universities and between 3-year and 5-year programmes, so treat this as a general picture. Most first-year law students meet some of these:

    • Constitutional law basics: Preamble, fundamental rights (Article 14 equality, Article 21 life and personal liberty), and the structure of government.
    • Law of contract: offer, acceptance, consideration, capacity and void and voidable agreements under the Indian Contract Act 1872.
    • Law of torts: negligence, nuisance, defamation and the idea of civil wrongs, much of it built on case law.
    • Legal methods or legal reasoning: sources of law, how courts work, precedent, and how to read and cite legal material.

    In a 5-year integrated course (BA LL.B., BBA LL.B., B.Com LL.B.), the first year often has more non-law subjects such as political science, economics, sociology or English. Do not neglect them: they count towards your marks and build reading and writing skills. In a 3-year LL.B., law subjects start from day one, and you will often be in a class with engineers, commerce graduates and working professionals.

    How to read a bare act and a judgment

    Bare act. A bare act is the statute’s text without commentary. Read it in this order:

    1. The long title and preamble: what the Act is for.
    2. The definitions section (usually s.2): many answers sit in definitions.
    3. The structure: chapters and headings, so you know where things are.
    4. The section you need, then any provisos, explanations and illustrations below it.
    5. Amendments: check the year of the last amendment. Criminal law is a good example: BNS, BNSS and BSA replaced IPC, CrPC and the Evidence Act from 1 July 2024, so older notes may cite outdated sections.

    Judgment. A Supreme Court judgment can run to a hundred pages. Do not read it front to back on day one. Instead:

    1. Read the headnote or summary, if available, to know what the case is about.
    2. Read the facts briefly.
    3. Find the issues the court framed.
    4. Read the reasoning on each issue carefully. This is the core.
    5. Read the conclusion and the order.
    6. Note what the court actually decided (the ratio) and what it said in passing (obiter).

    Case briefing: the skill that carries you through law school

    A case brief is a one-page summary of a judgment. Use a fixed structure every time:

    • Citation: case name, year, court.
    • Facts: 4 to 6 lines, only what matters.
    • Issues: the legal questions, written as questions.
    • Arguments: one or two lines for each side.
    • Held: the answer to each issue.
    • Reasoning: why the court decided so.
    • Your note: why the case matters and what later cases did with it.

    Example: Sana, a first-year student in Lucknow, briefs every leading case in her torts and constitutional law syllabus on one page. At exam time she revises from 40 pages instead of 40 judgments.

    Learn this properly, with a certificate. Law School Starter is written for law aspirants and first-year LL.B. students who want a structured start to legal study instead of figuring it out alone in the first semester. Law School Starter, ₹349: self-paced lessons, module quizzes and a 30-question final test; pass at 60% for a verifiable Lexfolio certificate.

    Attendance, internships and moots under BCI rules

    Attendance. Law colleges apply minimum attendance requirements under the Bar Council of India’s Legal Education Rules 2008 and their own university regulations. Courts have recently examined how strictly shortage of attendance can be used to stop students from exams, so read your college’s current notice rather than relying on what seniors say, and keep your own attendance record.

    Internships. BCI’s Legal Education Rules 2008 require LL.B. students to complete internships during the course, commonly stated as a minimum of 20 weeks for the 5-year programme and 12 weeks for the 3-year programme, with placements such as NGOs, trial and appellate advocates, courts, legal aid bodies, law firms and legal regulatory authorities. Your college may set its own year-wise schedule. First-year internships are often with NGOs, legal aid clinics or district court advocates. An online course, however useful, does not count as an internship.

    Moots. A moot court is a simulated appeal: you research a problem, write a memorial and argue before judges. Try an intra-college moot in first year. You will learn research, drafting and public speaking faster than in any classroom.

    Common first-year mistakes

    • Reading only guidebooks. Short notes are useful for revision, not for learning. Read the bare act alongside.
    • Ignoring legal research. Projects, assignments and memorials all need research and correct citation. Learn it early.
    • Using old section numbers. Check whether your material uses IPC or BNS. Use the current law, with the old section in brackets if helpful.
    • Skipping non-law subjects in the 5-year course.
    • Collecting certificates instead of skills. One good research or drafting skill beats ten certificates.
    • Waiting until third year to intern. Start small, with a legal aid clinic or a local advocate, as soon as your college permits.

    For research and citation skills, see Legal Research and Research Paper Writing, ₹499.

    Frequently asked questions

    Are first-year subjects the same in every university?

    No. Syllabi vary. Constitutional law, contract, torts and legal methods are common, but the order and names differ. Follow your university’s syllabus.

    How many weeks of internship does BCI require?

    BCI’s Legal Education Rules 2008 require internships during the course, commonly stated as at least 20 weeks for the 5-year LL.B. and 12 weeks for the 3-year LL.B. Check your college’s schedule for year-wise requirements.

    Should a first-year student take part in moots?

    Yes, at least an intra-college moot. It builds research, writing and speaking skills early.

    Can I count an online course as an internship?

    No. Internships under BCI rules are with advocates, courts, NGOs, legal aid bodies and similar placements. A course is a course.

    Does the Law School Starter certificate add to my degree?

    No. It is a certificate of completion issued by Lexfolio, not part of your university degree. It helps you build skills and show initiative.

    Quick quiz

    Q1. When reading a bare act, which section often answers questions about the meaning of key words?

    1. The last section
    2. The definitions section, usually s.2
    3. The schedule only
    4. The repeal section
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Most Acts define key terms in an early definitions section, usually s.2.

    Q2. In a judgment, the binding legal principle on which the decision rests is called:

    1. Obiter dicta
    2. Headnote
    3. Ratio decidendi
    4. Prayer
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The ratio decidendi is the reason for the decision; obiter dicta are remarks made in passing.

    Q3. Which rules require internships for LL.B. students?

    1. UGC Regulations 2018
    2. BCI’s Legal Education Rules 2008
    3. Advocates Act 1961, s.29
    4. Indian Contract Act 1872
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The Bar Council of India’s Rules of Legal Education 2008 set the internship requirement.

    Start your first year with structure: Law School Starter, ₹349.

    Sources

    • Bar Council of India Rules of Legal Education 2008 (attendance and internship requirements)
    • Advocates Act 1961, ss.24, 29 and 33
    • Constitution of India, Articles 14 and 21
    • Indian Contract Act 1872
    • Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita 2023, Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023, Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam 2023

    This page is for education and general information, not legal advice for a specific case. Law as on 29 October 2026.

  • Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (1978): Case Summary

    Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (1978): Case Summary

    Read this in Hindi: हिंदी में पढ़ें

    Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India, decided by a seven-judge bench of the Supreme Court on 25 January 1978, held that the “procedure established by law” under Article 21 must be fair, just and reasonable, not arbitrary or oppressive. It also held that Articles 14, 19 and 21 are not separate compartments, so a law restricting personal liberty must satisfy all three, and that the right to travel abroad is part of personal liberty.

    Facts of the case

    Maneka Gandhi was issued a passport on 1 June 1976 under the Passports Act, 1967. By a letter dated 2 July 1977, the Regional Passport Officer, Delhi, directed her to surrender her passport within seven days. The passport was impounded under Section 10(3)(c) of the Act, which allows impounding when the authority considers it necessary “in the interests of the general public”.

    She asked for the reasons, as Section 10(5) of the Act normally requires a brief statement of reasons to be supplied. On 6 July 1977, the Ministry of External Affairs refused, stating that it had been decided not to furnish reasons in the interests of the general public. No hearing was given to her before the order was passed.

    She filed a writ petition under Article 32 challenging the impounding order and the validity of Section 10(3)(c). In its affidavit, the government indicated that her presence was likely to be required in connection with proceedings before a Commission of Inquiry.

    The bench

    The case was heard by seven judges: Chief Justice M.H. Beg and Justices Y.V. Chandrachud, P.N. Bhagwati, V.R. Krishna Iyer, N.L. Untwalia, S. Murtaza Fazal Ali and P.S. Kailasam. The leading opinion was written by Justice Bhagwati. It is reported as (1978) 1 SCC 248 and AIR 1978 SC 597.

    Key holdings

    1. Right to travel abroad is part of personal liberty

    Following Satwant Singh Sawhney v. Assistant Passport Officer (1967), the Court confirmed that the expression “personal liberty” in Article 21 is of the widest amplitude and includes the right to go abroad. So the State cannot take it away except according to procedure established by law.

    2. Procedure must be fair, just and reasonable

    This is the core of the case. The Court held that the procedure contemplated by Article 21 cannot be any procedure that a legislature chooses to enact. It must be right, just and fair, and not arbitrary, fanciful or oppressive. A procedure that fails this standard is no procedure at all for the purposes of Article 21. This reading effectively brought a substantive due process element into Indian constitutional law, even though the framers had deliberately chosen the phrase “procedure established by law” instead of “due process of law”.

    3. Articles 14, 19 and 21 form a single scheme

    In A.K. Gopalan v. State of Madras (1950), the majority had treated each fundamental right as an independent code. A preventive detention law, tested under Article 21, did not also have to meet Article 19. Maneka Gandhi rejected this approach, building on R.C. Cooper v. Union of India (1970). A law depriving a person of personal liberty must satisfy Article 21, and if it also affects a freedom under Article 19, it must meet that Article’s test of reasonableness. Since Article 14 strikes at arbitrariness, the procedure must also be non-arbitrary. This is popularly called the “golden triangle” of Articles 14, 19 and 21.

    4. Natural justice applies to administrative action

    The Court held that the rule of audi alteram partem (hear the other side) applies to administrative orders that affect a person’s rights, and not only to judicial or quasi-judicial bodies. Where a statute is silent, a right to be heard can be implied. In urgent cases, a hearing may be given after the order is made, but it must be a genuine and prompt post-decisional hearing.

    5. Reasons cannot be withheld casually

    The power to refuse reasons “in the interests of the general public” is exceptional and must be used sparingly. In this case, the refusal to give reasons was found unjustified.

    6. Section 10(3)(c) was not struck down

    The Court held that the phrase “in the interests of the general public” has a well-understood legal meaning and is not vague. Section 10(3)(c) was read as requiring a hearing and therefore survived.

    7. Travel abroad and Article 19(1)(a)

    The majority did not treat the right to go abroad as itself part of the freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a). But an order that directly and inevitably restricted that freedom could be challenged under Article 19.

    The Attorney General’s statement

    During the hearing, the Attorney General stated that the government would consider any representation Maneka Gandhi made against the impounding and would decide it expeditiously. The Court treated this as curing the natural justice defect in the order, as she would now get a hearing.

    Gopalan vs Maneka: the shift at a glance

    PointA.K. Gopalan (1950)Maneka Gandhi (1978)
    Meaning of “procedure established by law”Any procedure in a validly enacted lawProcedure that is fair, just and reasonable
    Relation between rightsEach right a separate compartmentArticles 14, 19 and 21 read together
    Due processDeliberately excludedBrought in through the requirement of fairness
    Natural justiceNot required by Article 21Part of fair procedure, even in administrative action

    Impact of the case

    Maneka Gandhi opened the door to the expansive reading of Article 21 that followed. Within a few years, the Court recognised speedy trial (Hussainara Khatoon, 1979), the right to live with human dignity (Francis Coralie Mullin, 1981) and the right to livelihood (Olga Tellis, 1985). The nine-judge bench in Puttaswamy (2017) relied heavily on Maneka Gandhi’s approach in recognising privacy as a fundamental right.

    Exam angle

    • Basic facts: CLAT and AIBE ask the year (1978), the bench strength (seven judges), the statute (Passports Act, 1967) and the provision (Section 10(3)(c)).
    • Overruling: Maneka Gandhi departed from the Gopalan approach. Expect “which case was overruled” questions.
    • Golden triangle: Judiciary prelims and UGC NET test the inter-relationship of Articles 14, 19 and 21.
    • Administrative law: For judiciary mains and UGC NET, use the case for audi alteram partem in administrative action and post-decisional hearing.
    • Phrase recall: “Fair, just and reasonable” is the phrase to remember.

    Quick quiz

    Q1. Maneka Gandhi’s passport was impounded under which provision?

    1. Section 6(2) of the Passports Act, 1967
    2. Section 10(5) of the Passports Act, 1967
    3. Section 3 of the Foreigners Act, 1946
    4. Section 10(3)(c) of the Passports Act, 1967
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The order was made under Section 10(3)(c), which allows impounding in the interests of the general public. Section 10(5) deals with recording and supplying reasons.

    Q2. How many judges decided Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India?

    1. Five
    2. Seven
    3. Nine
    4. Thirteen
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A seven-judge bench headed by Chief Justice M.H. Beg decided the case on 25 January 1978.

    Q3. According to Maneka Gandhi, the procedure under Article 21 must be:

    1. Fair, just and reasonable
    2. Laid down by any enacted law, without more
    3. Approved by the President
    4. Identical to American due process
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Court held the procedure must be right, just and fair, and not arbitrary, fanciful or oppressive.

    Q4. Maneka Gandhi departed from the narrow “separate compartments” view taken in:

    1. Kharak Singh v. State of U.P.
    2. Golak Nath v. State of Punjab
    3. A.K. Gopalan v. State of Madras
    4. Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Gopalan (1950) had treated Article 21 as independent of Article 19; Maneka Gandhi read the rights together.

    Q5. On natural justice, Maneka Gandhi held that:

    1. It applies only to courts
    2. It applies only where the statute expressly requires it
    3. It can never be satisfied by a hearing after the order
    4. It applies to administrative action too, and a prompt post-decisional hearing may suffice in urgent cases
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The Court applied audi alteram partem to administrative orders and accepted a post-decisional hearing where urgency justifies it.

    Practise more

    Constitutional law carries the largest share of CLAT PG and judiciary papers. Try the free CLAT PG 2027 mock, read 30 important Supreme Court judgments of 2026, and register for the All India CLAT Open Mock on 15 November.

    Get one law MCQ a day, free, on Telegram

    A daily question for CLAT, AIBE, NET and judiciary with the answer, plus alerts when exam dates, admit cards and new free mocks are released. No spam.

    Join @lexfolio_in on Telegram

    Sources

    • Supreme Court of India: Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India, (1978) 1 SCC 248; AIR 1978 SC 597 (Writ Petition No. 231 of 1977)
    • Passports Act, 1967: Sections 10(3)(c) and 10(5)
    • Constitution of India: Articles 14, 19 and 21
    • Supreme Court of India: A.K. Gopalan v. State of Madras (1950)
  • मेनका गांधी बनाम भारत संघ (1978): केस सारांश हिंदी में

    मेनका गांधी बनाम भारत संघ (1978): केस सारांश हिंदी में

    English में पढ़ें: Read in English

    मेनका गांधी बनाम भारत संघ का निर्णय 25 जनवरी 1978 को सर्वोच्च न्यायालय की सात न्यायाधीशों की पीठ ने दिया। न्यायालय ने कहा कि अनुच्छेद 21 की “विधि द्वारा स्थापित प्रक्रिया” उचित, न्यायसंगत और युक्तियुक्त (Fair, Just and Reasonable) होनी चाहिए, मनमानी या दमनकारी नहीं। साथ ही अनुच्छेद 14, 19 और 21 को अलग खाने न मानकर एक साथ पढ़ा गया, और विदेश यात्रा के अधिकार को व्यक्तिगत स्वतंत्रता का भाग माना गया।

    मामले के तथ्य

    मेनका गांधी को पासपोर्ट अधिनियम, 1967 के तहत 1 जून 1976 को पासपोर्ट जारी हुआ था। 2 जुलाई 1977 के पत्र द्वारा क्षेत्रीय पासपोर्ट अधिकारी, दिल्ली ने उन्हें सात दिन में पासपोर्ट जमा करने को कहा। पासपोर्ट अधिनियम की धारा 10(3)(c) के तहत परिबद्ध (Impound) किया गया, जो “साधारण जनता के हित में” आवश्यक होने पर ऐसा करने की अनुमति देती है।

    उन्होंने कारण पूछे, क्योंकि अधिनियम की धारा 10(5) सामान्यतः कारणों का संक्षिप्त विवरण देने की अपेक्षा करती है। 6 जुलाई 1977 को विदेश मंत्रालय ने यह कहकर मना कर दिया कि साधारण जनता के हित में कारण न देने का निर्णय लिया गया है। आदेश से पहले उन्हें सुनवाई का अवसर भी नहीं दिया गया।

    उन्होंने अनुच्छेद 32 के तहत रिट याचिका दायर कर परिबद्ध करने के आदेश और धारा 10(3)(c) की वैधता को चुनौती दी। सरकार के शपथपत्र से संकेत मिला कि एक जाँच आयोग (Commission of Inquiry) की कार्यवाही के संबंध में उनकी उपस्थिति आवश्यक हो सकती थी।

    पीठ

    मामले की सुनवाई सात न्यायाधीशों ने की: मुख्य न्यायाधीश एम.एच. बेग, और न्यायमूर्ति वाई.वी. चंद्रचूड़, पी.एन. भगवती, वी.आर. कृष्ण अय्यर, एन.एल. उंटवालिया, एस. मुर्तज़ा फ़ज़ल अली तथा पी.एस. कैलासम। प्रमुख मत न्यायमूर्ति भगवती ने लिखा। उद्धरण: (1978) 1 SCC 248 और AIR 1978 SC 597।

    मुख्य निर्णय

    1. विदेश यात्रा व्यक्तिगत स्वतंत्रता का भाग

    सतवंत सिंह साहनी बनाम सहायक पासपोर्ट अधिकारी (1967) का अनुसरण करते हुए न्यायालय ने पुष्टि की कि अनुच्छेद 21 में “व्यक्तिगत स्वतंत्रता” का अर्थ अत्यंत व्यापक है और इसमें विदेश जाने का अधिकार शामिल है। अतः राज्य इसे केवल विधि द्वारा स्थापित प्रक्रिया से ही छीन सकता है।

    2. प्रक्रिया उचित, न्यायसंगत और युक्तियुक्त हो

    यही मामले का केंद्र है। न्यायालय ने कहा कि अनुच्छेद 21 की प्रक्रिया कोई भी ऐसी प्रक्रिया नहीं हो सकती जो विधायिका बना दे। वह सही, न्यायसंगत और उचित होनी चाहिए, मनमानी, काल्पनिक या दमनकारी नहीं। जो प्रक्रिया इस मानक पर खरी न उतरे, वह अनुच्छेद 21 के प्रयोजन के लिए प्रक्रिया ही नहीं है। इस व्याख्या से भारतीय संवैधानिक विधि में सारवान सम्यक प्रक्रिया (Substantive Due Process) का तत्व आ गया, यद्यपि संविधान निर्माताओं ने जानबूझकर “Due Process of Law” के स्थान पर “Procedure Established by Law” चुना था।

    3. अनुच्छेद 14, 19 और 21 एक ही योजना

    ए.के. गोपालन बनाम मद्रास राज्य (1950) में बहुमत ने हर मौलिक अधिकार को स्वतंत्र संहिता माना था; अनुच्छेद 21 पर परखे गए निवारक निरोध कानून को अनुच्छेद 19 पर परखना आवश्यक नहीं था। आर.सी. कूपर बनाम भारत संघ (1970) के आधार पर मेनका गांधी ने यह दृष्टिकोण अस्वीकार किया। व्यक्तिगत स्वतंत्रता छीनने वाले कानून को अनुच्छेद 21 पूरा करना होगा, और यदि वह अनुच्छेद 19 की किसी स्वतंत्रता को प्रभावित करता है, तो उसकी युक्तियुक्तता की कसौटी भी। चूँकि अनुच्छेद 14 मनमानी पर प्रहार करता है, प्रक्रिया गैर-मनमानी भी होनी चाहिए। इसे लोकप्रिय रूप से अनुच्छेद 14, 19 और 21 का “स्वर्ण त्रिभुज” (Golden Triangle) कहा जाता है।

    4. प्रशासनिक कार्य पर भी नैसर्गिक न्याय

    न्यायालय ने कहा कि “दूसरे पक्ष को सुनो” (Audi Alteram Partem) का नियम केवल न्यायिक या अर्ध-न्यायिक निकायों पर नहीं, बल्कि व्यक्ति के अधिकारों को प्रभावित करने वाले प्रशासनिक आदेशों पर भी लागू होता है। कानून मौन हो तो सुनवाई का अधिकार निहित माना जा सकता है। तात्कालिक परिस्थितियों में आदेश के बाद सुनवाई (Post-decisional Hearing) दी जा सकती है, पर वह वास्तविक और शीघ्र होनी चाहिए।

    5. कारण यूँ ही नहीं रोके जा सकते

    “साधारण जनता के हित में” कारण न बताने की शक्ति असाधारण है और इसका प्रयोग संयम से होना चाहिए। इस मामले में कारण न देना उचित नहीं पाया गया।

    6. धारा 10(3)(c) रद्द नहीं हुई

    न्यायालय ने कहा कि “साधारण जनता के हित में” वाक्यांश का विधि में सुस्थापित अर्थ है और यह अस्पष्ट नहीं है। धारा 10(3)(c) को सुनवाई की अपेक्षा सहित पढ़ा गया और वह बनी रही।

    7. विदेश यात्रा और अनुच्छेद 19(1)(a)

    बहुमत ने विदेश जाने के अधिकार को स्वयं अनुच्छेद 19(1)(a) की वाक् और अभिव्यक्ति की स्वतंत्रता का भाग नहीं माना। पर यदि कोई आदेश प्रत्यक्ष और अपरिहार्य रूप से उस स्वतंत्रता को सीमित करे, तो उसे अनुच्छेद 19 के तहत चुनौती दी जा सकती है।

    महान्यायवादी का कथन

    सुनवाई के दौरान महान्यायवादी (Attorney General) ने कहा कि सरकार परिबद्ध करने के विरुद्ध मेनका गांधी के किसी भी अभ्यावेदन पर विचार करेगी और शीघ्र निर्णय लेगी। न्यायालय ने माना कि इससे आदेश का नैसर्गिक न्याय संबंधी दोष दूर हो गया, क्योंकि अब उन्हें सुनवाई मिलेगी।

    गोपालन बनाम मेनका: बदलाव एक नज़र में

    बिंदुए.के. गोपालन (1950)मेनका गांधी (1978)
    “विधि द्वारा स्थापित प्रक्रिया” का अर्थवैध कानून में दी गई कोई भी प्रक्रियाउचित, न्यायसंगत और युक्तियुक्त प्रक्रिया
    अधिकारों का आपसी संबंधहर अधिकार अलग खानाअनुच्छेद 14, 19 और 21 साथ पढ़े जाएँ
    सम्यक प्रक्रियाजानबूझकर बाहरनिष्पक्षता की अपेक्षा से भीतर आई
    नैसर्गिक न्यायअनुच्छेद 21 की अपेक्षा नहींउचित प्रक्रिया का भाग, प्रशासनिक कार्य में भी

    मामले का प्रभाव

    मेनका गांधी ने अनुच्छेद 21 की उस विस्तृत व्याख्या का द्वार खोला जो आगे आई। कुछ ही वर्षों में न्यायालय ने शीघ्र विचारण (हुसैनारा खातून, 1979), मानवीय गरिमा के साथ जीने का अधिकार (फ्रांसिस कोराली मुलिन, 1981) और आजीविका का अधिकार (ओल्गा टेलिस, 1985) मान्य किए। पुट्टस्वामी (2017) में नौ न्यायाधीशों की पीठ ने निजता को मौलिक अधिकार मानते समय मेनका गांधी के दृष्टिकोण पर भरोसा किया।

    परीक्षा की दृष्टि से

    • मूल तथ्य: CLAT और AIBE में वर्ष (1978), पीठ (सात न्यायाधीश), अधिनियम (पासपोर्ट अधिनियम, 1967) और धारा (10(3)(c)) पूछे जाते हैं।
    • पूर्व दृष्टिकोण से विचलन: मेनका गांधी ने गोपालन के दृष्टिकोण को छोड़ा। “कौन सा निर्णय उलटा गया” जैसे प्रश्नों के लिए तैयार रहें।
    • स्वर्ण त्रिभुज: न्यायिक सेवा प्रारंभिक और UGC NET में अनुच्छेद 14, 19 और 21 के आपसी संबंध पर प्रश्न आते हैं।
    • प्रशासनिक विधि: न्यायिक सेवा मुख्य परीक्षा और UGC NET में इस मामले को प्रशासनिक कार्य में “दूसरे पक्ष को सुनो” और आदेश के बाद सुनवाई के लिए उद्धृत करें।
    • मुख्य वाक्यांश: “Fair, just and reasonable” याद रखें।

    त्वरित प्रश्नोत्तरी

    Q1. मेनका गांधी का पासपोर्ट किस प्रावधान के तहत परिबद्ध किया गया?

    1. पासपोर्ट अधिनियम, 1967 की धारा 6(2)
    2. पासपोर्ट अधिनियम, 1967 की धारा 10(3)(c)
    3. पासपोर्ट अधिनियम, 1967 की धारा 10(5)
    4. विदेशी अधिनियम, 1946 की धारा 3
    उत्तर देखें

    उत्तर: B. आदेश धारा 10(3)(c) के तहत था, जो साधारण जनता के हित में परिबद्ध करने की अनुमति देती है। धारा 10(5) कारण दर्ज करने और देने से संबंधित है।

    Q2. मेनका गांधी बनाम भारत संघ का निर्णय कितने न्यायाधीशों ने दिया?

    1. पाँच
    2. नौ
    3. सात
    4. तेरह
    उत्तर देखें

    उत्तर: C. मुख्य न्यायाधीश एम.एच. बेग की अध्यक्षता में सात न्यायाधीशों की पीठ ने 25 जनवरी 1978 को निर्णय दिया।

    Q3. मेनका गांधी के अनुसार अनुच्छेद 21 की प्रक्रिया कैसी होनी चाहिए?

    1. किसी भी पारित कानून में दी गई, बस इतना पर्याप्त
    2. राष्ट्रपति द्वारा अनुमोदित
    3. अमेरिकी सम्यक प्रक्रिया के बिल्कुल समान
    4. उचित, न्यायसंगत और युक्तियुक्त
    उत्तर देखें

    उत्तर: D. न्यायालय ने कहा कि प्रक्रिया सही, न्यायसंगत और उचित हो, मनमानी, काल्पनिक या दमनकारी नहीं।

    Q4. मेनका गांधी ने किस मामले के “अलग खाने” वाले संकीर्ण दृष्टिकोण से विचलन किया?

    1. ए.के. गोपालन बनाम मद्रास राज्य
    2. खड़क सिंह बनाम उत्तर प्रदेश राज्य
    3. गोलकनाथ बनाम पंजाब राज्य
    4. केशवानंद भारती बनाम केरल राज्य
    उत्तर देखें

    उत्तर: A. गोपालन (1950) ने अनुच्छेद 21 को अनुच्छेद 19 से स्वतंत्र माना था; मेनका गांधी ने अधिकारों को साथ पढ़ा।

    Q5. नैसर्गिक न्याय पर मेनका गांधी ने क्या कहा?

    1. यह केवल न्यायालयों पर लागू होता है
    2. प्रशासनिक कार्य पर भी लागू होता है, और तात्कालिक स्थिति में शीघ्र पश्चात्वर्ती सुनवाई पर्याप्त हो सकती है
    3. यह तभी लागू होता है जब कानून स्पष्ट रूप से कहे
    4. आदेश के बाद की सुनवाई से इसकी पूर्ति कभी नहीं होती
    उत्तर देखें

    उत्तर: B. न्यायालय ने “दूसरे पक्ष को सुनो” को प्रशासनिक आदेशों पर लागू किया और तात्कालिकता में आदेश के बाद की सुनवाई स्वीकार की।

    और अभ्यास करें

    CLAT PG और न्यायिक सेवा परीक्षाओं में संवैधानिक कानून का हिस्सा सबसे बड़ा होता है। CLAT PG 2027 का मुफ़्त मॉक टेस्ट दें और 15 नवंबर के ऑल इंडिया CLAT ओपन मॉक के लिए मुफ़्त पंजीकरण करें।

    रोज़ एक कानूनी MCQ, मुफ़्त, Telegram पर

    CLAT, AIBE, NET और न्यायिक सेवा के लिए रोज़ एक प्रश्न उत्तर सहित, साथ में परीक्षा तिथियों, एडमिट कार्ड और नए मुफ़्त मॉक की सूचना।

    Telegram पर @lexfolio_in से जुड़ें

    Sources

    • सर्वोच्च न्यायालय: मेनका गांधी बनाम भारत संघ, (1978) 1 SCC 248; AIR 1978 SC 597 (रिट याचिका संख्या 231/1977)
    • पासपोर्ट अधिनियम, 1967: धारा 10(3)(c) और 10(5)
    • भारत का संविधान: अनुच्छेद 14, 19 और 21
    • सर्वोच्च न्यायालय: ए.के. गोपालन बनाम मद्रास राज्य (1950)
  • Kesavananda Bharati Case (1973): Basic Structure Doctrine

    Kesavananda Bharati Case (1973): Basic Structure Doctrine

    Read this in Hindi: हिंदी में पढ़ें

    Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala, decided on 24 April 1973 by a 13-judge bench of the Supreme Court, held that Parliament can amend any part of the Constitution, including fundamental rights, but cannot alter or destroy its “basic structure”. The verdict was by a 7:6 majority, overruled Golak Nath (1967), and remains the foundation of constitutional review of amendments in India.

    Background: the battle over the amending power

    From the 1950s, Parliament and the Supreme Court were locked in a dispute over land reform and property rights. Parliament kept amending the Constitution to protect land reform laws, and the Court kept examining whether those amendments could cut down fundamental rights.

    In Shankari Prasad (1951) and Sajjan Singh (1965), the Court held that Parliament could amend fundamental rights. Then, in I.C. Golak Nath v. State of Punjab (1967), an 11-judge bench by a 6:5 majority held that a constitutional amendment is “law” under Article 13, so Parliament could not take away or abridge fundamental rights.

    Parliament responded with a series of amendments:

    • 24th Amendment (1971): declared that Article 13 does not apply to amendments made under Article 368, and made clear that Parliament’s power under Article 368 extends to amending any provision.
    • 25th Amendment (1971): replaced “compensation” with “amount” in Article 31(2) and inserted Article 31C, which protected laws giving effect to certain Directive Principles and barred courts from questioning a law that declared it was for that purpose.
    • 29th Amendment (1972): placed two Kerala land reform laws in the Ninth Schedule.

    Facts of the case

    Swami Kesavananda Bharati was the head of the Edneer Mutt in Kasaragod, Kerala. The Mutt’s land was affected by Kerala’s land reform legislation. He challenged the Kerala laws, and the petition grew into a challenge to the validity of the 24th, 25th and 29th Amendments. The petitioners were led by senior advocate N.A. Palkhivala.

    To reconsider Golak Nath, a bench of 13 judges was constituted, the largest in the Court’s history. Hearings ran for 68 days, from 31 October 1972 to 23 March 1973. Judgment was delivered on 24 April 1973. The case is reported as (1973) 4 SCC 225 and AIR 1973 SC 1461.

    The bench and the 7:6 split

    Majority (7)Minority (6)
    S.M. Sikri CJ, J.M. Shelat, K.S. Hegde, A.N. Grover, B. Jaganmohan Reddy, A.K. Mukherjea, H.R. KhannaA.N. Ray, D.G. Palekar, K.K. Mathew, M.H. Beg, S.N. Dwivedi, Y.V. Chandrachud

    The judges wrote several separate opinions. Six judges in the majority found implied limits on the amending power. Six in the minority found none. Justice H.R. Khanna held the balance: he accepted that Parliament could amend every provision, including fundamental rights, but held that the word “amendment” does not include the power to abrogate the Constitution or change its basic structure or framework. His view therefore tipped the majority.

    A short summary titled “View by the majority” was signed by nine of the thirteen judges. Its key line was that Article 368 does not enable Parliament to alter the basic structure or framework of the Constitution.

    What the Court held

    • Golak Nath overruled: a constitutional amendment is not “law” under Article 13. Parliament can amend any part, including Part III.
    • 24th Amendment upheld.
    • 25th Amendment: the change from “compensation” to “amount” was upheld, as was the first part of Article 31C. But the second part of Article 31C, which barred judicial scrutiny of a law merely because it declared that it gave effect to the Directive Principles, was struck down.
    • 29th Amendment upheld.
    • Basic structure limit: the amending power under Article 368 cannot be used to damage or destroy the basic structure of the Constitution.

    What is “basic structure”?

    The phrase does not appear anywhere in the Constitution. The Court did not give a closed list. Different judges in the majority mentioned features such as supremacy of the Constitution, republican and democratic form of government, secular character, separation of powers and federal character. Later decisions have added others, including judicial review, rule of law, free and fair elections, and the limited nature of the amending power itself.

    The Court has always treated the list as open. Whether a feature is basic is decided case by case.

    Aftermath and later development

    Supersession of judges

    Two days after the judgment, on 26 April 1973, Justice A.N. Ray, who was in the minority, was appointed Chief Justice of India. Three senior judges from the majority, Justices Shelat, Hegde and Grover, were superseded. This was widely seen as a reaction to the verdict.

    Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain (1975)

    The basic structure doctrine was applied for the first time to strike down an amendment. The Court invalidated the relevant part of the 39th Amendment, which had tried to put the election of the Prime Minister beyond judicial scrutiny, on the ground that free and fair elections are part of the basic structure.

    The 42nd Amendment and Minerva Mills (1980)

    The 42nd Amendment (1976) inserted clauses (4) and (5) in Article 368 to bar courts from questioning amendments and to declare that there was no limitation on the amending power. In Minerva Mills v. Union of India (31 July 1980), a five-judge bench struck these clauses down. It held that limited amending power is itself a basic feature, and that a limited power cannot be converted into an unlimited one.

    Waman Rao and I.R. Coelho

    The date of the Kesavananda judgment became a legal cut-off. In Waman Rao (1981), the Court used 24 April 1973 as the dividing line for testing Ninth Schedule additions against the basic structure. In I.R. Coelho (2007), a nine-judge bench held that laws placed in the Ninth Schedule after that date can also be examined against the basic structure.

    Exam angle

    • Numbers: 13 judges, 7:6 majority, decided 24 April 1973, 68 days of hearing. Expect these as one-liners in CLAT and AIBE.
    • Amendment outcomes: Judiciary prelims ask which amendments were upheld (24th, 29th) and which part of the 25th (the second part of Article 31C) was struck down.
    • Chronology: Shankari Prasad, Sajjan Singh, Golak Nath, Kesavananda, Indira Gandhi, Minerva Mills, Waman Rao, I.R. Coelho. Order-based questions are common in UGC NET.
    • Khanna J: Know why his opinion is decisive, and do not confuse him with his dissent in ADM Jabalpur (1976).
    • Not in the text: “Basic structure” is a judicial doctrine and is not written in the Constitution.

    Quick quiz

    Q1. How many judges heard Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala?

    1. 11
    2. 9
    3. 13
    4. 7
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A 13-judge bench, the largest ever constituted by the Supreme Court, decided the case.

    Q2. Which earlier decision was overruled in Kesavananda Bharati?

    1. I.C. Golak Nath v. State of Punjab
    2. Shankari Prasad v. Union of India
    3. Sajjan Singh v. State of Rajasthan
    4. A.K. Gopalan v. State of Madras
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Golak Nath (1967) had held that Parliament cannot abridge fundamental rights; Kesavananda overruled that view.

    Q3. Which part of the 25th Amendment was struck down in Kesavananda Bharati?

    1. The substitution of “amount” for “compensation”
    2. The entire Article 31C
    3. The insertion of Article 31A
    4. The second part of Article 31C, which excluded judicial review
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The first part of Article 31C was upheld, but the clause barring courts from examining a law’s declared purpose was invalidated.

    Q4. In which case did the Supreme Court hold that limited amending power is itself a basic feature, striking down Article 368(4) and (5)?

    1. Indira Nehru Gandhi v. Raj Narain
    2. Minerva Mills v. Union of India
    3. Waman Rao v. Union of India
    4. S.R. Bommai v. Union of India
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Minerva Mills (1980) invalidated the clauses inserted by the 42nd Amendment that tried to make the amending power unlimited.

    Q5. Whose opinion is generally regarded as decisive in forming the 7:6 majority in Kesavananda Bharati?

    1. Chief Justice S.M. Sikri
    2. Justice A.N. Ray
    3. Justice Y.V. Chandrachud
    4. Justice H.R. Khanna
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Justice Khanna rejected implied limits on the subject matter of amendment but held that the basic structure cannot be altered, which tipped the balance.

    Practise more

    Constitutional law carries the largest share of CLAT PG and judiciary papers. Try the free CLAT PG 2027 mock, read 30 important Supreme Court judgments of 2026, and register for the All India CLAT Open Mock on 15 November.

    Get one law MCQ a day, free, on Telegram

    A daily question for CLAT, AIBE, NET and judiciary with the answer, plus alerts when exam dates, admit cards and new free mocks are released. No spam.

    Join @lexfolio_in on Telegram

    Sources

    • Supreme Court of India: Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala, (1973) 4 SCC 225; AIR 1973 SC 1461
    • Supreme Court of India: Minerva Mills Ltd. v. Union of India, AIR 1980 SC 1789
    • Constitution of India: Articles 13, 31C and 368; Constitution (Twenty-fourth, Twenty-fifth and Twenty-ninth Amendment) Acts
    • LiveLaw: commentary on the 50th anniversary of the Kesavananda Bharati judgment (April 2023)
  • केशवानंद भारती मामला (1973): मूल ढांचा सिद्धांत

    केशवानंद भारती मामला (1973): मूल ढांचा सिद्धांत

    English में पढ़ें: Read in English

    केशवानंद भारती बनाम केरल राज्य का निर्णय 24 अप्रैल 1973 को सर्वोच्च न्यायालय की 13 न्यायाधीशों की पीठ ने दिया। न्यायालय ने कहा कि संसद मौलिक अधिकारों सहित संविधान के किसी भी भाग में संशोधन कर सकती है, पर संविधान के मूल ढांचे (Basic Structure) को बदल या नष्ट नहीं कर सकती। यह निर्णय 7:6 के बहुमत से हुआ, इसने गोलकनाथ (1967) को उलटा, और आज भी संविधान संशोधनों की न्यायिक समीक्षा की नींव है।

    पृष्ठभूमि: संशोधन शक्ति पर टकराव

    1950 के दशक से भूमि सुधार और संपत्ति के अधिकार को लेकर संसद और सर्वोच्च न्यायालय के बीच खींचतान चल रही थी। संसद भूमि सुधार कानूनों को बचाने के लिए संविधान में संशोधन करती रही, और न्यायालय परखता रहा कि क्या ऐसे संशोधन मौलिक अधिकारों को घटा सकते हैं।

    शंकरी प्रसाद (1951) और सज्जन सिंह (1965) में न्यायालय ने माना कि संसद मौलिक अधिकारों में संशोधन कर सकती है। फिर आई.सी. गोलकनाथ बनाम पंजाब राज्य (1967) में 11 न्यायाधीशों की पीठ ने 6:5 से कहा कि संविधान संशोधन भी अनुच्छेद 13 के अर्थ में “विधि” है, इसलिए संसद मौलिक अधिकार छीन या कम नहीं कर सकती।

    संसद ने इसके जवाब में कई संशोधन किए:

    • 24वाँ संशोधन (1971): घोषित किया कि अनुच्छेद 368 के तहत किए गए संशोधनों पर अनुच्छेद 13 लागू नहीं होता, और संसद किसी भी उपबंध में संशोधन कर सकती है।
    • 25वाँ संशोधन (1971): अनुच्छेद 31(2) में “प्रतिकर” (Compensation) के स्थान पर “राशि” (Amount) शब्द रखा, और अनुच्छेद 31C जोड़ा, जो कुछ नीति निदेशक तत्वों को लागू करने वाले कानूनों को संरक्षण देता था और ऐसी घोषणा वाले कानून पर न्यायालय में प्रश्न उठाने से रोकता था।
    • 29वाँ संशोधन (1972): केरल के दो भूमि सुधार कानूनों को नौवीं अनुसूची में डाला।

    मामले के तथ्य

    स्वामी केशवानंद भारती केरल के कासरगोड स्थित एडनीर मठ के प्रमुख थे। मठ की भूमि केरल के भूमि सुधार कानूनों से प्रभावित हुई। उन्होंने इन कानूनों को चुनौती दी, और याचिका आगे चलकर 24वें, 25वें और 29वें संशोधनों की वैधता की चुनौती बन गई। याचिकाकर्ताओं की ओर से वरिष्ठ अधिवक्ता एन.ए. पालखीवाला ने बहस की।

    गोलकनाथ पर पुनर्विचार के लिए 13 न्यायाधीशों की पीठ बनी, जो न्यायालय के इतिहास में सबसे बड़ी है। सुनवाई 68 दिन चली, 31 अक्टूबर 1972 से 23 मार्च 1973 तक। निर्णय 24 अप्रैल 1973 को आया। उद्धरण: (1973) 4 SCC 225 और AIR 1973 SC 1461।

    पीठ और 7:6 का विभाजन

    बहुमत (7)अल्पमत (6)
    मुख्य न्यायाधीश एस.एम. सीकरी, जे.एम. शेलट, के.एस. हेगड़े, ए.एन. ग्रोवर, बी. जगनमोहन रेड्डी, ए.के. मुखर्जी, एच.आर. खन्नाए.एन. रे, डी.जी. पालेकर, के.के. मैथ्यू, एम.एच. बेग, एस.एन. द्विवेदी, वाई.वी. चंद्रचूड़

    न्यायाधीशों ने कई अलग-अलग मत लिखे। बहुमत के छह न्यायाधीशों ने संशोधन शक्ति पर निहित सीमाएँ (Implied Limitations) मानीं, जबकि अल्पमत के छह ने कोई सीमा नहीं मानी। निर्णायक मत न्यायमूर्ति एच.आर. खन्ना का था: उन्होंने माना कि संसद मौलिक अधिकारों सहित हर उपबंध में संशोधन कर सकती है, पर “संशोधन” शब्द में संविधान को समाप्त करने या उसके मूल ढांचे को बदलने की शक्ति शामिल नहीं है। इसी से बहुमत बना।

    तेरह में से नौ न्यायाधीशों ने “View by the majority” शीर्षक वाले एक संक्षिप्त सारांश पर हस्ताक्षर किए। इसका मुख्य वाक्य था कि अनुच्छेद 368 संसद को संविधान के मूल ढांचे या रूपरेखा को बदलने की शक्ति नहीं देता।

    न्यायालय ने क्या निर्णय दिया

    • गोलकनाथ उलटा गया: संविधान संशोधन अनुच्छेद 13 के अर्थ में “विधि” नहीं है। संसद भाग III सहित किसी भी भाग में संशोधन कर सकती है।
    • 24वाँ संशोधन वैध ठहराया गया।
    • 25वाँ संशोधन: “प्रतिकर” के स्थान पर “राशि” शब्द और अनुच्छेद 31C का पहला भाग वैध रहा। पर 31C का दूसरा भाग, जो केवल इस घोषणा के आधार पर न्यायिक समीक्षा रोकता था कि कानून नीति निदेशक तत्वों को लागू करता है, असंवैधानिक घोषित हुआ।
    • 29वाँ संशोधन वैध ठहराया गया।
    • मूल ढांचे की सीमा: अनुच्छेद 368 की संशोधन शक्ति से संविधान के मूल ढांचे को क्षति या विनाश नहीं पहुँचाया जा सकता।

    “मूल ढांचा” क्या है?

    यह शब्द संविधान में कहीं नहीं लिखा है। न्यायालय ने कोई बंद सूची नहीं दी। बहुमत के अलग-अलग न्यायाधीशों ने संविधान की सर्वोच्चता, गणतंत्रात्मक और लोकतांत्रिक शासन, पंथनिरपेक्षता, शक्तियों का पृथक्करण और संघीय स्वरूप जैसी विशेषताओं का उल्लेख किया। बाद के निर्णयों ने न्यायिक पुनर्विलोकन, विधि का शासन, स्वतंत्र और निष्पक्ष चुनाव तथा स्वयं संशोधन शक्ति की सीमितता जैसी विशेषताएँ जोड़ीं।

    न्यायालय ने इस सूची को सदा खुला माना है। कोई विशेषता मूल है या नहीं, यह मामले-दर-मामले तय होता है।

    निर्णय के बाद

    न्यायाधीशों का अधिक्रमण

    निर्णय के दो दिन बाद, 26 अप्रैल 1973 को, अल्पमत में रहे न्यायमूर्ति ए.एन. रे को भारत का मुख्य न्यायाधीश बनाया गया। बहुमत के तीन वरिष्ठ न्यायाधीशों, शेलट, हेगड़े और ग्रोवर, का अधिक्रमण (Supersession) हुआ। इसे व्यापक रूप से निर्णय की प्रतिक्रिया माना गया।

    इंदिरा नेहरू गांधी बनाम राज नारायण (1975)

    पहली बार मूल ढांचा सिद्धांत से किसी संशोधन को रद्द किया गया। न्यायालय ने 39वें संशोधन के उस भाग को अमान्य किया जो प्रधानमंत्री के चुनाव को न्यायिक जाँच से बाहर करना चाहता था, क्योंकि स्वतंत्र और निष्पक्ष चुनाव मूल ढांचे का भाग हैं।

    42वाँ संशोधन और मिनर्वा मिल्स (1980)

    42वें संशोधन (1976) ने अनुच्छेद 368 में खंड (4) और (5) जोड़कर संशोधनों पर न्यायालयी प्रश्न रोकने और संशोधन शक्ति को असीमित घोषित करने का प्रयास किया। मिनर्वा मिल्स बनाम भारत संघ (31 जुलाई 1980) में पाँच न्यायाधीशों की पीठ ने इन खंडों को रद्द किया और कहा कि सीमित संशोधन शक्ति स्वयं मूल विशेषता है; सीमित शक्ति को असीमित में नहीं बदला जा सकता।

    वामन राव और आई.आर. कोएल्हो

    केशवानंद निर्णय की तिथि एक विधिक विभाजन रेखा बन गई। वामन राव (1981) में न्यायालय ने नौवीं अनुसूची के परिवर्धनों को मूल ढांचे पर परखने के लिए 24 अप्रैल 1973 को विभाजन रेखा माना। आई.आर. कोएल्हो (2007) में नौ न्यायाधीशों की पीठ ने कहा कि इस तिथि के बाद नौवीं अनुसूची में डाले गए कानून भी मूल ढांचे की कसौटी पर परखे जा सकते हैं।

    परीक्षा की दृष्टि से

    • संख्याएँ: 13 न्यायाधीश, 7:6 बहुमत, 24 अप्रैल 1973, 68 दिन की सुनवाई। CLAT और AIBE में ये सीधे प्रश्न बनते हैं।
    • संशोधनों का परिणाम: न्यायिक सेवा प्रारंभिक में पूछा जाता है कि कौन से संशोधन वैध रहे (24वाँ, 29वाँ) और 25वें का कौन सा भाग (अनुच्छेद 31C का दूसरा भाग) रद्द हुआ।
    • कालक्रम: शंकरी प्रसाद, सज्जन सिंह, गोलकनाथ, केशवानंद, इंदिरा गांधी, मिनर्वा मिल्स, वामन राव, आई.आर. कोएल्हो। UGC NET में क्रम आधारित प्रश्न आम हैं।
    • न्यायमूर्ति खन्ना: उनका मत निर्णायक क्यों था, यह समझें, और इसे ए.डी.एम. जबलपुर (1976) की उनकी असहमति से न मिलाएँ।
    • संविधान में नहीं: “मूल ढांचा” न्यायिक सिद्धांत है, संविधान के पाठ में नहीं लिखा।

    त्वरित प्रश्नोत्तरी

    Q1. केशवानंद भारती बनाम केरल राज्य की सुनवाई कितने न्यायाधीशों ने की?

    1. 11
    2. 13
    3. 9
    4. 7
    उत्तर देखें

    उत्तर: B. 13 न्यायाधीशों की पीठ ने यह मामला तय किया, जो सर्वोच्च न्यायालय की अब तक की सबसे बड़ी पीठ है।

    Q2. केशवानंद भारती में कौन सा पूर्व निर्णय उलटा गया?

    1. शंकरी प्रसाद बनाम भारत संघ
    2. सज्जन सिंह बनाम राजस्थान राज्य
    3. ए.के. गोपालन बनाम मद्रास राज्य
    4. आई.सी. गोलकनाथ बनाम पंजाब राज्य
    उत्तर देखें

    उत्तर: D. गोलकनाथ (1967) ने कहा था कि संसद मौलिक अधिकार कम नहीं कर सकती; केशवानंद ने यह मत उलट दिया।

    Q3. केशवानंद भारती में 25वें संशोधन का कौन सा भाग रद्द हुआ?

    1. अनुच्छेद 31C का दूसरा भाग, जो न्यायिक समीक्षा रोकता था
    2. “प्रतिकर” के स्थान पर “राशि” शब्द
    3. पूरा अनुच्छेद 31C
    4. अनुच्छेद 31A का जोड़ा जाना
    उत्तर देखें

    उत्तर: A. अनुच्छेद 31C का पहला भाग वैध रहा, पर कानून के घोषित उद्देश्य की जाँच से न्यायालय को रोकने वाला भाग अमान्य हुआ।

    Q4. किस मामले में कहा गया कि सीमित संशोधन शक्ति स्वयं मूल विशेषता है, और अनुच्छेद 368(4) व (5) रद्द हुए?

    1. इंदिरा नेहरू गांधी बनाम राज नारायण
    2. वामन राव बनाम भारत संघ
    3. मिनर्वा मिल्स बनाम भारत संघ
    4. एस.आर. बोम्मई बनाम भारत संघ
    उत्तर देखें

    उत्तर: C. मिनर्वा मिल्स (1980) ने 42वें संशोधन द्वारा जोड़े गए उन खंडों को अमान्य किया जो संशोधन शक्ति को असीमित बनाना चाहते थे।

    Q5. केशवानंद भारती में 7:6 का बहुमत बनाने में किस न्यायाधीश का मत निर्णायक माना जाता है?

    1. मुख्य न्यायाधीश एस.एम. सीकरी
    2. न्यायमूर्ति एच.आर. खन्ना
    3. न्यायमूर्ति ए.एन. रे
    4. न्यायमूर्ति वाई.वी. चंद्रचूड़
    उत्तर देखें

    उत्तर: B. न्यायमूर्ति खन्ना ने निहित सीमाएँ नहीं मानीं, पर कहा कि मूल ढांचा बदला नहीं जा सकता, और इसी से संतुलन बहुमत की ओर झुका।

    और अभ्यास करें

    CLAT PG और न्यायिक सेवा परीक्षाओं में संवैधानिक कानून का हिस्सा सबसे बड़ा होता है। CLAT PG 2027 का मुफ़्त मॉक टेस्ट दें और 15 नवंबर के ऑल इंडिया CLAT ओपन मॉक के लिए मुफ़्त पंजीकरण करें।

    रोज़ एक कानूनी MCQ, मुफ़्त, Telegram पर

    CLAT, AIBE, NET और न्यायिक सेवा के लिए रोज़ एक प्रश्न उत्तर सहित, साथ में परीक्षा तिथियों, एडमिट कार्ड और नए मुफ़्त मॉक की सूचना।

    Telegram पर @lexfolio_in से जुड़ें

    Sources

    • सर्वोच्च न्यायालय: केशवानंद भारती बनाम केरल राज्य, (1973) 4 SCC 225; AIR 1973 SC 1461
    • सर्वोच्च न्यायालय: मिनर्वा मिल्स लिमिटेड बनाम भारत संघ, AIR 1980 SC 1789
    • भारत का संविधान: अनुच्छेद 13, 31C और 368; संविधान (24वाँ, 25वाँ और 29वाँ संशोधन) अधिनियम
    • LiveLaw: केशवानंद भारती निर्णय की 50वीं वर्षगाँठ पर टिप्पणी (अप्रैल 2023)
  • Article 32 vs Article 226: Writs and Key Differences

    Article 32 vs Article 226: Writs and Key Differences

    Read this in Hindi: हिंदी में पढ़ें

    Article 32 gives every person a fundamental right to move the Supreme Court for enforcement of fundamental rights, while Article 226 empowers High Courts to issue writs for fundamental rights and also “for any other purpose”, meaning ordinary legal rights. Both courts can issue the five writs: habeas corpus, mandamus, prohibition, certiorari and quo warranto. Article 226 is wider in scope; Article 32 is itself a guaranteed fundamental right.

    Why these two Articles matter

    A right without a remedy is only a promise on paper. Articles 32 and 226 turn the rights in the Constitution into enforceable claims. When the State unlawfully detains, refuses to perform a legal duty, or acts beyond its powers, the writ jurisdiction allows a citizen to go straight to a constitutional court.

    In L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India (1997), a seven-judge bench held that the power of judicial review vested in the Supreme Court under Article 32 and in the High Courts under Articles 226 and 227 is part of the basic structure of the Constitution. Parliament cannot take it away even by constitutional amendment.

    Article 32: right to constitutional remedies

    Article 32 is in Part III, so the right to approach the Supreme Court is itself a fundamental right. It has four clauses:

    • Clause (1): guarantees the right to move the Supreme Court “by appropriate proceedings” to enforce Part III rights.
    • Clause (2): empowers the Supreme Court to issue directions, orders or writs, including the five named writs.
    • Clause (3): allows Parliament to empower any other court to exercise these powers within its local limits, without affecting the Supreme Court’s powers.
    • Clause (4): says the right shall not be suspended except as the Constitution provides.

    Draft Article 25, which became Article 32, was debated in the Constituent Assembly on 9 December 1948. Dr B.R. Ambedkar described it as the most important article of the Constitution, calling it “the very soul of the Constitution and the very heart of it”.

    In Romesh Thappar v. State of Madras (1950), the Supreme Court said it is the protector and guarantor of fundamental rights, and it cannot refuse to entertain applications seeking protection against infringement of those rights.

    Article 226: power of High Courts to issue writs

    Article 226 is in Part VI, in the chapter on High Courts. It is not a fundamental right, but it is a constitutional power and, because of L. Chandra Kumar, part of the basic structure. Its key features:

    • A High Court can issue writs to any person or authority, including the government, within its territory.
    • It can do so for enforcement of Part III rights and “for any other purpose”, so ordinary statutory and legal rights are also covered.
    • Under clause (2), a High Court can issue writs even to an authority located outside its territory if the cause of action arises, wholly or in part, within its territory.
    • Relief is discretionary. A High Court may decline, for instance, where an efficacious alternative remedy exists or the petitioner has delayed unreasonably.

    Article 32 vs Article 226: the differences

    PointArticle 32Article 226
    CourtSupreme CourtHigh Courts
    Location in ConstitutionPart III (Fundamental Rights)Part VI (The States: High Courts)
    NatureItself a fundamental rightA constitutional power, not a fundamental right
    ScopeOnly enforcement of fundamental rightsFundamental rights and “any other purpose” (legal rights)
    Territorial reachWhole of IndiaWithin the High Court’s territory, or where the cause of action arises
    DiscretionCourt is under a duty to entertain a petition for enforcement of fundamental rightsDiscretionary remedy
    EmergencyRight to move the court can be suspended for specified rights under Article 359 (but never for Articles 20 and 21)Article 226 itself is not suspended; enforcement of suspended fundamental rights is barred in all courts

    The five writs

    1. Habeas corpus

    Meaning “you may have the body”. It directs a person or authority holding someone in custody to produce that person before the court and justify the detention. If the detention is unlawful, the court orders release. It lies against public authorities as well as private persons, and a relative or friend can file it for the detained person.

    2. Mandamus

    Meaning “we command”. It directs a public official, public body, corporation, lower court or government to perform a public duty it is legally bound to perform but has failed to do. It does not lie against a private individual or private body enforcing a purely private right, nor against the President or the Governor of a State, who are protected from court proceedings for official acts by Article 361.

    3. Prohibition

    Meaning “to forbid”. A higher court issues it to a lower court or tribunal to stop it from continuing proceedings in excess of its jurisdiction or without jurisdiction. It is preventive.

    4. Certiorari

    Meaning “to be certified”. A higher court issues it to quash an order already passed by a lower court, tribunal or authority, for excess or lack of jurisdiction, violation of natural justice or an error of law apparent on the face of the record. It is corrective. Courts have extended it to administrative authorities affecting the rights of individuals.

    A simple way to remember: prohibition stops a proceeding before the decision; certiorari quashes the decision after it is made.

    5. Quo warranto

    Meaning “by what authority”. It asks a person holding a public office to show the legal authority under which he holds it. If the holder is not qualified or the appointment is illegal, the court can oust him. The office must be a substantive public office created by statute or the Constitution, not a private or merely ministerial post. Unlike the other writs, any member of the public may seek it, even without being personally aggrieved.

    Exam angle

    • “Heart and soul”: CLAT and AIBE love the question on which Article Ambedkar called the heart and soul of the Constitution. Answer: Article 32.
    • Scope difference: Article 226 is wider because it covers “any other purpose”. This is the single most tested difference.
    • Writ identification: Judiciary prelims give a fact pattern (illegal detention, illegal appointment, pending case without jurisdiction) and ask which writ fits.
    • Basic structure: UGC NET and judiciary mains ask about L. Chandra Kumar (1997) and the status of judicial review under Articles 32, 226 and 227.
    • Prohibition vs certiorari: Remember the timing test: before decision (prohibition) versus after decision (certiorari).

    Quick quiz

    Q1. Which writ is issued to challenge the legality of a person’s claim to a public office?

    1. Mandamus
    2. Certiorari
    3. Prohibition
    4. Quo warranto
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Quo warranto asks “by what authority” a person holds a public office and can oust an unlawful holder.

    Q2. Why is the writ jurisdiction of High Courts under Article 226 considered wider than that of the Supreme Court under Article 32?

    1. High Courts can issue more than five types of writs
    2. Article 226 covers enforcement of legal rights as well, “for any other purpose”
    3. Article 226 cannot be challenged in appeal
    4. High Courts have nationwide territorial jurisdiction
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Article 32 is confined to fundamental rights, while Article 226 also extends to ordinary legal rights.

    Q3. Which case held that judicial review under Articles 32, 226 and 227 is part of the basic structure?

    1. L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India (1997)
    2. Romesh Thappar v. State of Madras (1950)
    3. A.K. Gopalan v. State of Madras (1950)
    4. Minerva Mills v. Union of India (1980)
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A seven-judge bench in L. Chandra Kumar declared this jurisdiction an essential feature that Parliament cannot exclude.

    Q4. A tribunal is about to decide a matter that is clearly outside its jurisdiction. The proceedings are still pending. The appropriate writ is:

    1. Certiorari
    2. Habeas corpus
    3. Prohibition
    4. Mandamus
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Prohibition is preventive and stops a pending proceeding that lacks or exceeds jurisdiction; certiorari is used after a decision.

    Q5. Which writ can be issued against a private person?

    1. Mandamus
    2. Habeas corpus
    3. Quo warranto
    4. Prohibition
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Habeas corpus lies against anyone, public or private, who holds a person in unlawful custody.

    Practise more

    Constitutional law carries the largest share of CLAT PG and judiciary papers. Try the free CLAT PG 2027 mock, read 30 important Supreme Court judgments of 2026, and register for the All India CLAT Open Mock on 15 November.

    Get one law MCQ a day, free, on Telegram

    A daily question for CLAT, AIBE, NET and judiciary with the answer, plus alerts when exam dates, admit cards and new free mocks are released. No spam.

    Join @lexfolio_in on Telegram

    Sources

    • Constitution of India: Articles 32, 226, 359 and 361 (Legislative Department, Government of India)
    • Constituent Assembly Debates, 9 December 1948 (draft Article 25)
    • Supreme Court of India: Romesh Thappar v. State of Madras (1950)
    • Supreme Court of India: L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India, AIR 1997 SC 1125